讓 AI 助理代替不同的人參與 AI 政策討論,能讓更多人的意見進場,但發言方式也可能改變討論結果。
- 研究團隊讓 AI 助理先訪談一個人,再代表那個人的看法,和其他 AI 助理討論 AI 安全預算。研究發現,訊息寫得較長或比較不合作的 AI 助理,會更能把預算討論拉向委託者的立場。746 位參與者也覺得由 AI 助理代為表達,比只向一個 AI 系統提供意見公平。
- 研究認為,限制訊息長度並訂下共同的行為規則,有助減少強勢發言左右結果。
AI 伴隨問答
針對這篇報導有疑問?可直接點選快捷問題或向 AI 追問背景脈絡與技術細節:
研究比較不同發言方式對 AI 安全預算討論的影響,也調查參與者對公平性的看法,呈現多人意見由 AI 助理代為表達時可能出現的偏差。
New GoogleDeepMind + UChicago paper finds that AI agents speaking for people gained more influence over group policy when told to be wordier or less cooperative.
Public input on AI policy is hard to scale, since people lack time and technical background. Agents that speak for each person could let many more voices into each discussion.
They built pluralistic agents that interview a person, then argue for their views with other agents to set an AI safety budget. They ran thousands of agent deliberations and a preregistered study with 746 people.
Agents pulled budgets toward their person's views, and gained more pull when told to write longer messages or cooperate less. People rated agents fairer than giving input to 1 AI system, recovering 82% of the fairness difference to joining directly.
If you build agent-based deliberation, cap message length and set shared behavior rules, or the most assertive prompts will tilt the outcome.