跳到正文
Hacker News (official RSS)(youtube.com)·· 9 天前品質評分52

Jonathan Blow 訪談談 AI 寫程式,為何軟體看起來還是沒變好?

Jonathan Blow – If AI solved coding, why is my software still the same? [video]

重點導讀

AI 可以幫忙寫程式,但這是否真的讓大家用的軟體變得更好,是這場訪談要討論的問題。

Jonathan Blow 與 Wolf Tivy 談到軟體愈來愈複雜,也討論現在的 AI 為什麼還不能寫出比人更好的程式,以及如果 AI 真能做到,世界可能會有什麼改變。

AI 伴隨問答

自備 Key 深度分析

針對這篇報導有疑問?可直接點選快捷問題或向 AI 追問背景脈絡與技術細節:

正文

Jonathan Blow — If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software Still the Same? - YouTube

Back [Image 1](https://www.youtube.com/ "YouTube Home") TW

Skip navigation

Search

Search with your voice

[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRK8h67ol7Q)

Sign in

[Image 2](https://www.youtube.com/ "YouTube Home") TW

[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRK8h67ol7Q)

[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRK8h67ol7Q)

[Video 2](blob:https://www.youtube.com/d1bd45aa-4ffb-48ae-9867-c881eb9402e6)

[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRK8h67ol7Q)

[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRK8h67ol7Q)

Jonathan Blow — If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software Still the Same?

[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRK8h67ol7Q)

Tap to unmute

2x

Image 3

Jonathan Blow — If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software Still the Same?

The Students 4,774 views 3h ago

[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRK8h67ol7Q)

Copy link

Info

Shopping

Image 4

Image 5

If playback doesn't begin shortly, try restarting your device.

•

You're signed out

Videos you watch may be added to the TV's watch history and influence TV recommendations. To avoid this, cancel and sign in to YouTube on your computer.

Cancel Confirm

Up next

Live Upcoming

CancelPlay Now

[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRK8h67ol7Q)

Share

[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRK8h67ol7Q "Share link")- [x] Include playlist

An error occurred while retrieving sharing information. Please try again later.

Image 6

0:01

[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRK8h67ol7Q)[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hhVpOvpXUEE)

0:02 / 1:40:55

Live

•Watch full video

•

•

1:00:37 The Downfall of Jensen Huang: NVIDIA’s Greed & Corruption Gamers Nexus 99K • 2h ago Live Playlist ()Mix (50+)23:41 Jensen Huang’s Exit Just Blew Up AI’s Circular Financing Machine House of El: AI 17K • 1h ago Live Playlist ()Mix (50+)1:32:21 Where Is AI Taking Us? | Karl Friston Jon Hernández 4.7K • 15h ago Live Playlist ()Mix (50+)30:10 Gemini 4 Swarm is out of control...Wes Roth 12K • 2h ago Live Playlist ()Mix (50+)54:54 Samo Burja — Even China Can’t Avoid Mass Immigration The Students 17K • 6d ago Live Playlist ()Mix (50+)1:39:44 Why Lisp Thrives In The Age Of AI (with Cameron Barré)Developer Voices 10K • 2d ago Live Playlist ()Mix (50+)10:58 How to Get So Much Done It Feels Like Cheating A Life Engineered 10K • 4h ago Live Playlist ()Mix (50+)10:38 The New AI Security Nightmare: Undetectable LLM Backdoors Internet of Bugs 1.6K • 1h ago Live Playlist ()Mix (50+)1:31:00 Code Matters: Reflections on Rust in the LLM Age — Bryan Cantrill | Rust NYC Rust East Coast 38K • 9d ago Live Playlist ()Mix (50+)37:32 The state of the software engineering industry | Gergely Orosz | LDX3 New York 2026 LeadDev 22K • 3d ago Live Playlist ()Mix (50+)21:29 AI Bubble: 'Circular financing is over' | Ed Zitron The Tech Report 695K • 19h ago Live Playlist ()Mix (50+)1:13:20 Ex-Amazon VP: the RUTHLESS reality of working for Jeff Bezos My First Million 243K • 2w ago Live Playlist ()Mix (50+)

Jonathan Blow — If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software Still the Same?

Image 7: The Students

The Students

The Students

44.3K subscribers

Subscribe

Subscribed

301

Download

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

K

views

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

h ago

4,774 views • Nov 13, 2026

Jonathan Blow and Wolf Tivy discuss the explosion of complexity in software, why today's AI can't produce better code than people, and what the world would look like if it could. …more

more

How this was made

Auto-dubbed

Audio tracks for some languages were automatically generated. Learn more

Transcript

Follow along using the transcript.

Show transcript

Image 8 ### The Students 44.3K subscribers

VideosAbout

Video details

Date

Nov 13, 2026

Views

4,774

Likes

301

Show less

[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRK8h67ol7Q)
# Jonathan Blow — If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software Still the Same?

4,774 views

Nov 13, 2026

301

Download

92 Comments

Sort comments

Sort by

Top Show featured commentsNewest Show recent comments, including potential spam

Image 9: Default profile photo

Add a comment...

Image 10

@42p42p

1 hour ago (edited)

Now that everyone ships 10x code for 2 years now, where are the NEW non-LLM endproducts visible to customers? New non-LLM features? What has become better, cheaper? more secure (due to being coded by LLM)?

Show less Read more

Like

23

Dislike

Reply

11 replies

Hide replies

11 replies

Image 11

@Siger5019

46 minutes ago

AI solved software because the problem was defined as "How can we ship faster?"

Show less Read more

Like

32

Dislike

Reply

5 replies

Hide replies

5 replies

Image 12

@fishshipemployee

27 minutes ago

Microslop employee: Boss, our ai rollout is done, we can fire like 60k people now. November 13th 2026: Hold my beer.

Show less Read more

Like

4

Dislike

Reply

Image 13

@hraughr

40 minutes ago

It did solve coding, you're using the same apps because it didn't solve marketing budgets, so no indie app getting global use anytime ever anyway, but you can homebrew an app for yourself if you have the time to spare. It's not magic, you can tell AI to build an app, but it will have thousands of logistical question that you will need resolving

Show less Read more

Like

Dislike

Reply

3 replies

Hide replies

3 replies

Image 14

@h4rm0n1c

8 minutes ago

I mean... discord just went from seconds of load time as electron garbage to milliseconds as rust based native code. clear example of software improving in a way that was driving people nuts. wouldve taken years to do it before and been very costly.

Show less Read more

Like

Dislike

Reply

2 replies

Hide replies

2 replies

Image 15

@10e999

1 hour ago

8:42 "video games are more complex than medical and space flight software" Jon I like listening to you, and I think your points are great, but when you say stuff like this, it sounds ignorant and hurts your message. Be humble. You have never worked on embedded systems. You don't know.

Show less Read more

Like

12

Dislike

Reply

10 replies

Hide replies

10 replies

Image 16

@TorlessCarraz

3 hours ago

Legendary game programmer Jonathan Muratori

Show less Read more

Like

61

Dislike

Reply

8 replies

Hide replies

8 replies

Image 17

@JesseMaurais

11 minutes ago (edited)

Even before AI was being used in coding I had noted the consistent decline in software quality over the previous 20 year period. The reasons for that were not solved by AI, and if anything they've gotten worse. Just yesterday Microsoft experienced a global outage for their business enterprise services going more than 16 hours at time of writing (by contract any outage over 45 minutes is credited back to the client). They could not locate the cause of the problem for at least 16 hours. Why? Because the majority of their code is generated by LLMs and no single person at the company knows precisely how the system works anymore. We are living in an era of perpetually alpha software.

Show less Read more

Like

3

Dislike

Reply

Image 18

@shalita310

31 minutes ago

Let's talk in five years

Show less Read more

Like

Dislike

Reply

3 replies

Hide replies

3 replies

Image 19

@yizhizhu5154

3 hours ago

I totally did not expect a political philosophy channel gets to interview a game programmer!

Show less Read more

Like

26

Dislike

Reply

3 replies

Hide replies

3 replies

Image 20

@SevenSevenSeven-777

23 minutes ago

We are just now learning how to harness the power of these models. It's like herding cats... really smart cats. So, I reject the premise. The hype is real, it's just on a slower timeline.

Show less Read more

Like

Dislike

Reply

1 reply

Hide replies

1 reply

Image 21

@eternaldarkness-t5u

6 minutes ago

What a silly question. The reason is humans. Humans are slowing it down.

Show less Read more

Like

Dislike

Reply

1 reply

Hide replies

1 reply

Image 22

@lextr3110

17 minutes ago (edited)

We are of the era that all coders should review their own code, push it themselves in production, take responsibility and hope for the best. We, technical leads, will not review your ai coded crap that you yourselves dont even understand.. Companies are crazy putting it all on the technical lead shoulders.. we accepted it in the past but now the limit was crossed .. they should pay us 10x the salary of others minimun..

Show less Read more

Like

2

Dislike

Reply

Image 23

@michaelvision360

13 minutes ago (edited)

Why is my software still the same... Hmmm... I am doing stuff that I only dreamed of doing with an army of engineers. So are my peers. Im a production engineer. I am writing rust, and rails, and elixer to do really hard stuff that was not financially viable 3 years ago. Why can I do it. 30 years of domain knowledge. "Failures so common and mundain" the guest says. What company and sofware is he using? My customers would not stand for that, nor would I. You fix, and you test. Never before has my testing and deployment tooling been more robust. I am just not buying what the guest is selling.

Show less Read more

Like

1

Dislike

Reply

Image 24

@alvih333

46 minutes ago

Genuinely can JBlow actually name 1 task that Fable 5.2 cannot do but a human can?

Show less Read more

Like

5

Dislike

Reply

4 replies

Hide replies

4 replies

Image 25

@MarcoMugnatto

30 minutes ago

Terrible timing for that speech. I replaced my image editor with a vibe-coded app (PhotoCraft), my Lightroom with a vibe-coded app (LightCraft), my DAW with a vibe-coded app (Transit), my spreadsheet with a vibe-coded app (GridCraft), my monitor brightness control I swapped for something I vibe-coded myself, tailored to my needs, and I also vibe-coded the controller for my smart lamps. We are exactly at the beginning of a software revolution.

Show less Read more

Like

2

Dislike

Reply

Image 26

@YuvalLanger

6 minutes ago

15:48 — the archaeological world calls this phenomena "tell". Successive settlements each one living on the debris of the previous one, creating a hill.

Show less Read more

Like

Dislike

Reply

Image 27

@Kaar

34 minutes ago

This is fantastic! I’m so looking forward to hearing more from Jonathan Blow when he comes back after the Christmas break. I’m especially looking forward to the discussions between him and Casey Muratori. Also, Order of the Sinking Star is a next-level game! I used to play the old Sokoban game when I was a kid, and I remember trying to find it again, but I couldn’t remember what it was called. When Jon came out with his game, I finally learned the name and could play it again. I’m almost more thankful that he led me back to my old childhood game than I am for the game he released.

Show less Read more

Like

1

Dislike

Reply

Image 28

@---...---...---...---...

28 minutes ago

AI solved software the same way the steam engine solved the water pumping problem, we have only just begun the improvement.

Show less Read more

Like

Dislike

Reply

Image 29

@averageartist123

37 minutes ago

Is that a Van Huysum in the background? A print I assume?

Show less Read more

Like

2

Dislike

Reply

Comments 92

Top Show featured commentsNewest Show recent comments, including potential spam

In this video

Transcript

Jonathan Blow — If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software Still the Same?

Image 30: The Students

The Students

The Students

301 Likes

4.7K Views

3h Ago

Jonathan Blow and Wolf Tivy discuss the explosion of complexity in software, why today's AI can't produce better code than people, and what the world would look like if it could. ====================================== The Students is sponsored by Zcash: https://z.cash ====================================== Jonathan on Youtube: ‪@jblow888‬ Jonathan on Twitter: https://x.com/Jonathan_Blow Wolf on Twitter: https://x.com/wolftivy Join The Students at our upcoming events: https://luma.com/thestudents…...more

...more Show less

How this was made

Auto-dubbed

Audio tracks for some languages were automatically generated. Learn more

Transcript

Follow along using the transcript.

Show transcript

Image 31 ### The Students 44.3K subscribers

VideosAbout

Video details

Date

Nov 13, 2026

Views

4,774

Likes

301

Transcript

NaN / NaN

Image 32 1:00:37 New

Image 33

The Downfall of Jensen Huang: NVIDIA’s Greed & Corruption

Gamers Nexus

99K 2h ago

Image 34 23:41 New

Image 35

Jensen Huang’s Exit Just Blew Up AI’s Circular Financing Machine

House of El: AI

17K 1h ago

Image 36 1:32:21 New

Image 37

Where Is AI Taking Us? | Karl Friston

Jon Hernández

4.7K 15h ago

Image 38 30:10 New

Image 39

Gemini 4 Swarm is out of control...

Wes Roth

12K 2h ago

Image 40 54:54 New

Image 41

Samo Burja — Even China Can’t Avoid Mass Immigration

The Students

17K 6d ago

Image 42 1:39:44 New

Image 43

Why Lisp Thrives In The Age Of AI (with Cameron Barré)

Developer Voices

10K 2d ago

Image 44 10:58 New

Image 45

How to Get So Much Done It Feels Like Cheating

A Life Engineered

10K 4h ago

Image 46 10:38 New

Image 47

The New AI Security Nightmare: Undetectable LLM Backdoors

Internet of Bugs

1.6K 1h ago

Image 48 1:31:00

Image 49

Code Matters: Reflections on Rust in the LLM Age — Bryan Cantrill | Rust NYC

Rust East Coast

38K 9d ago

Image 50 37:32 New

Image 51

The state of the software engineering industry | Gergely Orosz | LDX3 New York 2026

LeadDev

22K 3d ago

Image 52 21:29 New

Image 53

AI Bubble: 'Circular financing is over' | Ed Zitron

The Tech Report

695K 19h ago

Image 54 1:13:20

Image 55

Ex-Amazon VP: the RUTHLESS reality of working for Jeff Bezos

My First Million

243K 2w ago

Image 56 45:08 New

Image 57

The Rise and Reckoning of Jensen Huang | The Circuit with Emily Chang

Bloomberg Originals

3.6M 1d ago

Image 58 17:32 New

Image 59

Rethinking Claude Code Best Practices —Lydia Hallie, Anthropic

AI Engineer

415K 1d ago

Image 60 18:27 New

Image 61

Even AI Can't Beat This Man at Programming

Turing

294K 2d ago

Image 62 8:06 New

Image 63

Claude Fable 5.2 Model Prolapse

Mark Jivko

2.4K 1h ago

Image 64 1:25:57

Image 65

Image 66

Samo Burja — AI Bureaucracy Will Enable Total Surveillance

The Students and Samo Burja

17K 13d ago

Image 67 2:17:51 New

Image 68

Image 69

Image 70

1 AI Doomer vs 1 AI Enthusiast | Dr Roman Yampolskiy vs Dr Mike Israetel

The Beyond Tomorrow Podcast with Julian Issa and 2 more

103K 1d ago

Image 71 37:33 New

Image 72

Image 73

Image 74

Inside the Downfall of the Most Powerful Man in A.I. | Hard Fork

Hard Fork and 2 more

260K 17h ago

Image 75 1:00:57 New

Image 76

Catherine Liu: Culture Wars, Victimhood and Social Media | Doomscroll

Joshua Citarella

80K 1d ago

Show more

Show more

[](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRK8h67ol7Q)

讀者討論

理性交流 · 即時討論