跳到正文
𝕏 Gary Marcus(x.com)·· 2 天前品質評分54
重點導讀

一項可能解決黎曼猜想的新成果引起討論,但目前還沒有獲得確認。

  • Gary Marcus 認為,如果成果成立,確實非常令人佩服。
  • 他也把這類方法和純大型語言模型區分開來,指出它依靠複雜的符號定理證明技術。他認為,這種專用方法未必能用在日常推理,因此即使成果獲確認,也不會大幅改變生成式 AI 的經濟問題。他並重申,光靠神經符號 AI 的進步,還不足以帶來穩健的智慧。

AI 伴隨問答

自備 Key 深度分析

針對這篇報導有疑問?可直接點選快捷問題或向 AI 追問背景脈絡與技術細節:

Gary Marcus
Gary Marcus@GaryMarcus
·2 天前
𝕏

Hot take on the possible solution to Riemann:

1. The result is incredibly impressive if it holds up.

2. Anyone who is intellectually serious and interested in AI and math should (re)read my essay “AlphaProof, AlphaGeometry, ChatGPT, and why the future of AI is neurosymbolic” from July 2024, which lavished praise on DeepMind for exploring neurosymbolic models that are predecessors to the systems that Alpöge used with Riemann, and explained (correctly) why pure LLMs could not the same. (Pure LLMs still can’t.)

https://t.co/YYGDIrpnCp

If you think the progress on Riemann is a challenge to me rather than a confirmation of what I have argued for 25 years, you have the argument backwards.

3. The new result has not yet been confirmed yet, just to be clear.

4. But even it is confirmed, it wouldn’t much change the problematic economics of generative AI, because the particular techniques that it relies on involve elaborate symbolic theorem proving techniques that aren’t generally applicable to everyday reasoning. (It’s probably;y more like Deep Blue winning in chess in 1997: a special-purpose symbolic system that was wildly impressive but lacked general applicability.)

5. For more, my 2020 article in the The Next Decade in AI explained why advances in neurosymbolic AI alone would not be enough to get to robust intelligence, and I think what I said there still holds.

推文來源 · X (Twitter)在 X 參與討論

讀者討論

理性交流 · 即時討論