研究:倫敦咖啡館如何讓更多工匠參與科學
Coffeehouses and the Rise of Science [pdf]
過去的科學交流常靠大學和學者圈子,工匠不容易加入。
- 這項研究整理 17 世紀倫敦各教區的咖啡館、數學實務工作者和科學儀器店資料,比較咖啡館開張前後的變化。研究發現,開出第一家咖啡館後,當地的實用科學工作者和儀器店持續增加。
- 工匠也更常和發展理論的學者建立聯絡,店家開始製作更多實驗用儀器。作者估算,咖啡館在 1650 年代至 1690 年代佔倫敦實用科學工作者的 31%。研究也在歐洲其他城市看到相似變化,但作者將這部分視為相關現象,沒有主張是因果關係。
AI 伴隨問答
針對這篇報導有疑問?可直接點選快捷問題或向 AI 追問背景脈絡與技術細節:
研究追蹤倫敦咖啡館開設前後的科學活動,呈現低門檻的日常交流如何連結工匠與學者,並擴大實用科學的參與。
譯文尚未完整,完整內容請切換至原文。
‗
咖啡館與科學的興起
† ‡
Monir Bounadi Jens Oehlen
*(求職論文)*
[最新版本請見此處] 2026 年 10 月 31 日
摘要
歷史學家長久以來認為,咖啡館是讓不同社會階層的陌生人相聚交談的場所,在科學革命期間促進了科學交流與活動。我們以 17 世紀倫敦為例,檢驗這項主張。我們運用新近完成地理定位的紀錄,並比較各教區分階段開設咖啡館的情況,進行事件研究。結果發現,某教區開設第一家咖啡館後,應用科學家與科學儀器商店的數量持續增加。這種效果主要出現在與牛津和劍橋家族淵源較弱的應用科學家身上。連結工藝技能與理論的社會關係有所增加,新開的商店也開始轉向實驗儀器。在 17 世紀的歐洲城市中,我們也發現,相較於規模與成長情況相近的城市,一座城市開設第一家咖啡館後,應用數學書籍的出版量與科學儀器製造商的數量都會上升。在一個根據教區與城市層級估計結果校準的量化都市模型中,1652 年第一家咖啡館開幕後的半世紀內,倫敦的應用科學家有 31% 可歸因於咖啡館。這些發現顯示,社會制度能藉由擴大正式學術網路之外的知識交流管道,提高知識的產出與應用。
關鍵詞:咖啡館、科學革命、知識擴散、社會網路 JEL 分類碼:N33、N93、O31、O33、D83、R12 ‗ 我們感謝 Torsten Persson、David Schönholzer 和 David Strömberg 的指導。感謝 Mehdi Amani、Alireza Azampour、Sascha O. Becker、Anne Sofie Beck Knudsen、Iacopo Bianchi、Tessa Bold、Konrad Burchardi、Marcel Caesmann、Gregory Clark、David de la Croix、Merve Demirel、Mitch Downey、Vitalia Eliseeva、Valentin Figueroa、Joseph Flavian Gomes、Simon Handreke、Duncan Hay、Brian Higgins、Rebekah Higgitt、Ruixue Jia、Mounir Karadja、Marie Kaul、Martin Koenen、Julius Koschnick、Lukas Leucht、Moritz Lubczyk、Andreas Madestam、Jaakko Meriläinen、Joel Mokyr、Arash Nekoei、J. Peter Nilsson、Artschil Okropiridse、Anders Olofsgård、Casey Petroff、Alessandro Pizzigolotto、Prashant Poddar、Luca Repetto、Jonatan Riberth、Veronica Salazar Restrepo、Theo Serlin、Lina Skoglund、Mara P. Squicciarini、Anna Tompsett、Karine van der Beek、Miriam Venturini、Noam Yuchtman 和 Yves Zenou;也感謝 IIES、牛津、斯德哥爾摩、土魯斯,以及在歐登塞舉行的第 15 屆成長、歷史與發展工作坊、烏普薩拉第 4 屆經濟史工作坊、SUDSWEC 2025、EAYE 2026 年會、RIDGE Forum 2026、SIOE 2026 研討會、Applied Young Economists’ Webinar 2026,以及第 4 屆 Yale-UB HPE 工作坊的與會者,提供寶貴的回饋與協助,更重要的是給予鼓勵。† 斯德哥爾摩大學 IIES。monir.bounadi@iies.su.se·www.monirbounadi.com ‡ 基爾世界經濟研究所。jens.oehlen@ifw-kiel.de·jensoehlen.github.io
1. 緒論
新知的產生,取決於研究人員能取得多少既有知識(Iaria et al.,2018;Mokyr,2002)。雖然許多既有知識都能透過印刷品或網路取得,但前沿知識往往包含難以明確表達的默會成分,因此面對面互動對傳遞這類知識十分重要(Polanyi,1966)。在科學前沿快速變動的時期,默會知識可能尤其重要(例如,Shapin and Schaffer,1985)。此外,能否取得默會知識,取決於能否進入相關社交網路;而文化、地理位置、教育、家庭背景與財富都會影響這些網路的形成(例如,Bourdieu,1986;Glaeser et al.,1992;Jaffe et al.,1993)。制度會形塑哪些人能取得這類資源。一方面,大學等機構會篩選知識交流的參與者,以維持品質,並在專業且協調一致的社群內組織交流。另一方面,這種篩選也會縮小潛在研究人員的範圍。擴大參與機會或許能引進原本會流失的人才儲備,提升知識的產生與運用(例如,Agarwal and Gaule,2020;Bell et al.,2019;Husén,1974;Stephan,1996),尤其是在機構篩選體系之外的人擁有寶貴默會知識時。然而,參與機會的擴大很少是隨機發生的,我們也鮮少有資料能追蹤其長期影響。本文利用英格蘭社會中新興社會機構——咖啡館的興起,克服這些研究困難。咖啡館是十七、十八世紀出現的數種此類機構之一,其他還包括法國沙龍與德國桌會;這些機構被視為近代早期歐洲的變革性發展(例如,Clark,2000;Cowan,2005;Mokyr,2016)。Habermas(1991[1962])將這些機構的出現視為資產階級「公共領域」的起源,並特別指出咖啡館是啟蒙思想的催化劑:這個開放且重視互動的中產階級空間,讓辯論由理性而非社會地位主導。咖啡館「不僅讓人們較不拘形式、更容易進入相關圈子,也涵蓋了更廣泛的中產階級階層,包括工匠與店主」(Habermas,1991 [1962], p. 33)。Mokyr(2005)認為,咖啡館與其他社會機構降低了取得「實用知識」的成本;這類知識以進步為導向,位於科學與技術的交會點。本文探討咖啡館是否藉由擴大參與機會促進了知識進展;若答案是肯定的,又是如何做到的。我們研究十七世紀倫敦的咖啡館與科學。歐洲最早的咖啡館之一於 1652 年在倫敦開業,而倫敦也是科學革命的中心。在當時,許多新興實驗科學仰賴默會知識。實驗需要使用科學儀器,而製作儀器的技藝掌握在工匠手中;他們透過學徒制度習得技藝,卻很少將其記錄下來。咖啡館自 1652 年首間開業後迅速擴散,且各堂區的普及情況並不一致;豐富的歷史紀錄則追蹤了此後數十年間的科學活動。只要花一便士買一杯咖啡,大約相當於一天工資的十分之一,陌生人就能跨越社會階級交談,咖啡館也因此獲得「一便士大學」的著名稱號(Ellis,1956)。以下分析聚焦於咖啡館對數學實務工作者的影響;這些人是當時的應用科學家,史料記載他們教授數學、撰寫數學著作或製作儀器。我們也研究製造、維修與販售這些儀器的店家。他們的工作以尋求理解為目的,同時也受到實際用途形塑,這正是
若不計算應用科學家的人數,多項研究機構與知識的研究會衡量
Stokes(1997)所稱的「應用導向基礎研究」。咖啡館擴大知識取得管道的觀點,可追溯至皇家學會院士 John Houghton(1645–1705)。他曾觀察到(1727[1701],第 132 頁):
咖啡館讓各種人都能自在交談,富人與窮人相聚,博學者與無知者也是如此:咖啡館促進藝術、商業及其他各類知識;在這裡,好奇的人[……]一個晚上所能學到的,可能比一個月讀書還多。
我們將 Houghton 的論點放到歷史紀錄中檢驗。為此,我們利用數位化的 17 世紀地圖與地名錄,逐一手動地理編碼所有留有地址紀錄的咖啡館、數學實務工作者的工作場所,以及科學儀器商店。這讓我們能將這些紀錄定位到倫敦 162 個教區,並建立涵蓋 1600 年代至 1690 年代、以教區和十年為單位的追蹤資料。我們也利用實務工作者的傳記,重建他們之間的社會連結,包括友誼、師徒關係、通訊與諮詢。咖啡館、實務工作者與儀器商店的資料,分別來自三份不同作者根據不同歷史紀錄編纂的資料集,因此我們的結果並非單一著作或作者所造成的產物。我們首先採用分期事件研究設計,估計教區內第一家咖啡館的影響。我們發現,咖啡館開幕後,數學實務工作者與科學儀器商店的數量持續增加。接著,我們追查背後的途徑。影響主要出現在家族與牛津、劍橋關聯較弱的實務工作者身上;具備工藝技能的實務工作者,與能傳授知識並發展理論的人之間,連結有所增加;新開的商店則轉向製作實驗儀器。放眼倫敦以外的地區,相較於規模與成長程度相近的城市,歐洲各城市在第一家咖啡館開幕後,應用數學書籍與科學儀器製作者的數量也有所增加。最後,在一個量化城市模型中,咖啡館可解釋倫敦 1650 年代至 1690 年代應用科學家總數的 31%。這些結果顯示,機構不必編纂知識或篩選成員,也能促進知識產出。開放的交流場所可以擴大正式學術網路以外的人參與知識交流的機會,進而達到這個目的。如圖 1 所示,咖啡館興起之際,實務工作者與儀器商店的數量也開始持續增加。這些趨勢與文化轉向量化的現象同時出現。Kelly 與 Ó Gráda(2022)指出,1650 年代出版的應用數學書籍數量增加了一倍以上,並將此解讀為航海與測量技術廣泛使用後,相關需求隨之上升。同一個十年裡,強調進步的語言也開始增加(Almelhem 等人,
2026). 2 歷史學家同樣記錄了這些變化,並強調咖啡館是促成變化的關鍵因素(例如 Ellis,2006;Jacob,1997),但未提供量化證據。然而,咖啡館在倫敦各教區的分佈時間不一且並不完整,有助於將這些場所的影響,與整體需求上升的影響區分開來。以專利衡量創新也有相關研究(例如 Berkes and Nencka,2026;Cinnirella et al.,2025;Hanlon et al.,2022)。然而,此處無法採用專利資料。在 Berkes et al.(2026) 的資料中,1617–1699 年英格蘭的 365 件專利,有 34 件列出倫敦的專利權人,5 件與儀器或計時器有關;相較之下,我們的倫敦資料記錄了 345 家儀器商店。儀器製作仰賴保密。即使在 1851 年萬國工業博覽會上,英國展出的儀器也只有 10 percent 取得專利(Moser,2013)。附錄圖 D19 將應用數學書籍的出版量及英格蘭的平均進步分數,加入
圖 1。
咖啡館 數學從業者 科學儀器商店 80
0 1600 1620 1640 1660 1680 1700
圖 1.咖啡館與科學
*註:* 圖中呈現 17 世紀倫敦每年營運中的咖啡館、數學從業者及科學儀器商店數量。咖啡館資料來自 Lillywhite(1963,1972),數學從業者資料來自 Taylor(1954),儀器商店資料來自 Clifton(1995) 和 Hay et al.(2025)。[返回第 2、OA-7、OA-81 頁]
倫敦的教區面積不大,162 個教區中有 97 個全在倫敦市城牆內,因此有咖啡館的教區與沒有咖啡館的教區,往往只隔著幾條街。在 162 個教區中,有 101 個在 1700 年前沒有咖啡館的記錄。我們比較首次記錄到咖啡館開張前後的活動變化,以及從未設有咖啡館的教區的變化,並採用 Wooldridge(2023) 提出的分期處理、對異質性穩健的事件研究估計量。我們發現,咖啡館對兩項科學活動指標都帶來顯著且持續的地方影響。首次設有咖啡館的 61 個教區,在咖啡館進駐前十年的數學從業者平均數為 0.62;從進駐當年起算的十年間及其後四十年間,人數大約增加一倍,達到
1.30。科學儀器商店也從 0.33 家增至 1.57 家,接近五倍。儘管資料稀少,這些影響仍能精確估計,且達統計顯著。在成長方面,從 1640 年代到 1690 年代,倫敦增加了 68 名數學從業者和 136 家儀器商店;將 1690 年代各教區的估計影響加總後,相當於前一項增幅的 49 percent,以及後一項增幅的 63 percent。相較於整體活動量,從 1650 年代到 1690 年代,咖啡館開張可解釋數學從業者人年數的 20 percent,以及儀器商店人年數的 46 percent。我們的識別策略面臨若干威脅。咖啡館開張可能與其他地方性衝擊同時發生,或預示當地成長;可能改變哪些從業者會被記錄在歷史資料中;其影響可能僅來自增加一處聚會場所,而非咖啡館本身的特性;也可能外溢至鄰近教區,或吸引科學家離開這些教區。我們將逐一處理這些問題。因此,因果解讀本研究結果的一項潛在挑戰是,咖啡館開張當然並非隨機發生。歷史記錄顯示,咖啡館進駐往往跟隨商業活動,因為業主偏好商業繁盛的地點(Cowan,2005,
第 156–161 頁)。咖啡館經營者雖隸屬於商業網路,與數學實務工作者並無關聯,但納入研究的教區原本就有較多商業活動、實務工作者與儀器商店。教區固定效果可吸收這些既有差異,但咖啡館也可能在科學活動即將興起的地方開張,或與商業及其他地方性衝擊同時發生。然而,在咖啡館首次開張之前,實務工作者與儀器商店的變化趨勢,與沒有咖啡館開張的教區平行,商業活動則成長得更快。檢視安慰劑結果後,我們發現人口密度、奢侈品商店、菁英「共和國文人」圈內非科學界通訊者的書信,以及酒館,都沒有因咖啡館開張而變化;這不支援商業或人口繁榮、富裕人士或既有學者湧入,以及聚會場所普遍增加等解釋。歷史紀錄的儲存情況則帶來另一項疑慮:咖啡館可能讓既有實務工作者更容易出現在紀錄中,例如透過廣告、印記與通訊。然而,反應最大的群體是儀器商店,而這類商店通常透過有簽名的儀器和行會紀錄留存於史料中。此外,依序排除最早見於各類歷史資料(例如日記、貿易代幣與教區紀錄)的咖啡館,以及為受倫敦大火影響的區域設定不同趨勢後,主要估計結果仍然穩健;這些檢驗有助於處理不同地區史料流失程度不一的問題。其他穩健性檢驗也都得到類似結論,包括隨機化推論、Conley 標準誤、倫敦城牆內部的個別趨勢、在各群組內去除趨勢、逐一排除教區的估計,以及替代性的處理時間、地理單位、對照組和估計方法。以較早開張的酒館作為安慰劑處理時,並未出現類似的增加,這不支援咖啡館只是另一種聚會場所的說法。咖啡館的作用也不是因為缺乏其他場所;1652 年以前,有咖啡館的教區平均已有 3.0 間酒館,其他地區則為 0.5 間。此外,我們對最具人脈的實務工作者 Robert Hooke(1635–1703)於 1672–1683 年間所寫日記的轉錄文本進行分析,發現他提到咖啡館後所寫的內容與談論交流有關,提到酒館後所寫的內容則與紅酒和付款有關。咖啡館也可能帶動鄰近對照教區的活動,這會使我們低估估計值。比較 1640 年代至 1690 年代、以邊長 200 公尺的六邊形網格劃分的變化後,我們發現咖啡館開張會帶來正向外溢效果,而且效果集中在所在六邊形及相鄰六邊形。3
另一個疑慮是,堂區層級的估計無法顯示倫敦整體是否增加了科學家,因為咖啡館可能只是把科學家從對照組堂區或倫敦以外吸引過來。三種現象不支援這種解釋。第一,倫敦的從業者佔英格蘭從業者的比例上升,但英格蘭其他地區的從業者人數也增加,因此倫敦的成長並非只以英格蘭其他地區為代價。第二,咖啡館開業地點的鄰近區域增加了科學家;若他們是從附近堂區遷入,鄰近區域的科學家應會減少,而非增加。第三,將資料中首次記錄的從業者與儀器商店,和從倫敦其他地區遷入者分開計算後,我們發現遷入者佔從業者在地效應的 16%
3 短距離或許令人意外。然而,多數相鄰的六角網格都位於處理組堂區,因此堂區估計已涵蓋大部分增幅;而這段距離也與 Hooke 的習慣相去不遠:他日記中有記載地點的咖啡館提及,約四分之三位於他住處 400 公尺內。
和儀器商店在地效應的 38%。探討作用機制時,我們發現證據符合三種途徑。姓氏在牛津與劍橋出現率最低的從業者,受到的影響最強,顯示更多人得以接觸科學。製作者彼此之間,以及製作者與理論家之間的連結增加,讓工藝技術與理論的發展和傳播產生關聯。與此相關的是,Hooke 的日記記載,在同一年、同一星期幾比較下,他造訪咖啡館的日子比其他日子多見了 2 個人(未造訪咖啡館的日子平均見到 3 人);其中約三分之二不屬於「文人共和國」的菁英通訊網路。生產顯微鏡、空氣幫浦等實驗儀器的商店也增加,而且相較於生產測量與導航等實用儀器的商店,增幅比例更大,儘管前者的基數較小;這與製作者逐漸瞭解新興實驗科學的需求相符。除了這三種途徑,我們也發現,咖啡館讓從業者在更廣泛的應用科學生態系中流動。設有咖啡館的堂區有更多著作、更多儀器製作者學徒,也有更多皇家學會院士。倫敦的情況在歐洲其他地區也看得到。我們將一座城市第一家咖啡館的出現視為該城市轉向開放社交、讓知識交流更容易取得的標記,並建立涵蓋 200 座歐洲城市首批咖啡館的新資料。我們發現,與規模和成長相近的城市相比,一座城市開設第一家咖啡館後,應用數學類書目與科學儀器製作者都會增加。在 1700 年以前已有咖啡館的 37 座城市中,書目數增加 4.97,以進入前平均值 5.95 為基準;製作者則增加
平均值為 3.73,數值為 4.89。我們將這些結果解讀為條件相關性,而非因果效果。儘管如此,這些結果既未呈現事前趨勢,也不以倫敦為基礎;此外,這些結果降低了我們對人口遷移的疑慮:活動在倫敦各教區之間轉移很容易想像,但在倫敦、巴黎與慕尼黑之間轉移則不然。為量化咖啡館對倫敦科學發展的整體影響,我們建立了一個包含兩個區塊的量化都市模型。第一個區塊將咖啡館建模為一種促進會面的技術。兩個教區的應用科學家會面頻率會隨彼此距離增加而降低,若任一方所在教區有咖啡館則會提高。第二個區塊中,潛在的科學從業者會根據各教區提供的科學研究報酬,選擇是否投入科學;若選擇投入,也會決定在哪個教區執業。各教區的報酬會透過第一個區塊,隨著咖啡館所帶來的便利而提高。我們證明,第一個區塊可推匯出一個可估計的重力方程式,用以描述文獻記載的各教區從業者之間的連結。第二個區塊則提供兩種彈性:地點選擇彈性,以及投入科學的彈性。我們透過間接推論校準地點選擇彈性,使模型能重現教區事件研究的結果;至於投入科學的彈性,我們無法在倫敦內部識別,因此參考歐洲各城市首次出現咖啡館後科學家人數的增幅進行校準,並假設科學家不會在城市之間遷移。模型接著推論,從 1650 年代到 1690 年代,咖啡館促成了倫敦 31% 的應用科學家;在設有咖啡館的教區中,科學家人數增加的部分有 23% 來自倫敦其他地區,其餘則來自新投入科學的人。*對相關文獻的貢獻。*本文對數個研究領域有所貢獻。首先,咖啡館是否改變了從事科學研究的人,一直是自Houghton (1699)以來的爭論。歷史學家經常將咖啡館與倫敦的科學發展相提並論。Cowan(2005,
第 260 頁)稱其為「由博學之士所形塑的文化世界之產物」,而Stewart
(1999)將特定咖啡館描述為與皇家學會並列的「其他計算中心」。據我們所知,我們運用新資料,首次提出咖啡館促進科學活動的量化因果證據。我們也證明,咖啡館吸引更多正式學術網路以外的人士投入科學,因而擴大了應用科學的參與範圍。這與童年接觸創新會影響誰成為發明家的證據相呼應(Bell et al.,2019)。其次,近期研究指出,英格蘭持續生產力成長最可能始於 17 世紀上半葉(Bouscasse et al.,2025);而進步導向語言則在下半葉興起,並於啟蒙時代觸及科學與政治經濟學的交會點(Almelhem et al.,2026)。我們將咖啡館納入這項研究:這種社會機構於現代經濟成長開始之際的 1652 年進駐倫敦,並在開設據點的地方促進應用科學。第三,擴大實用知識取得管道並降低知識產生阻力的機構,可分為兩類(例如 Dowey,2017;Galofré-Vilà,2023)。有些機構將知識編纂成形並跨地域傳播(例如 Mokyr,2002):印刷機(Dittmar, 2011,2019)、共和國文人通訊網路的郵政系統(Cervellati et al.,2026;Melillo et al.,2026)、工藝與貿易百科全書(Squicciarini and Voigtländer,2015)、1840 年的統一便士郵資制度(Hanlon et al.,2022)、卡內基圖書館(Berkes and Nencka,2026),以及明治日本的國家翻譯計畫(Juhász et al.,2026)。另一些則組織範圍有限的會員之間進行交流:大學與學院(de la Croix et al.,2025;Koschnick,2025b),以及經濟學會(Cinnirella et al.,
2025)。咖啡館並未做到這一點。相反地,它們降低了不同社群之間反覆面對面接觸的成本;這些社群原本只會在各自專門的場域中碰面。現代研究發現,這類接觸帶來的效益很高(例如 Andrews, 2026;Andrews and Lensing, 2024;Atkin et al., 2022;Boudreau et al., 2017;Campos et al., 2018;Catalini, 2018),網路研究也記錄到,效益會外溢至直接接觸者以外的人(Fluegge and Bailey, 2024)。我們記錄到的連結增加,提供了一種解釋,說明都市密度如何提升知識產出(Carlino and Kerr, 2015;Glaeser, 1999);其作用尺度是街道與教區,而非城鎮(Cox and Figueroa,
2025)。這與曼哈頓南部廣告公司的合作效益會隨距離增加而消退(Arzaghi and Henderson, 2008),以及學術研究成果會外溢至鄰近公司的研發活動(Bergeaud et al., 2025)相似。因此,我們的研究結果為 Fleck(1979)與 Mokyr(2016)的觀點提供了實證佐證,也增添了更多細節:科學知識是在個人互動中產生,而非單靠個人創造。第四,資訊科技進步並未讓隱性知識交流失去作用。如今,取得編碼知識的成本持續降低,近來尤其受惠於網際網路(Goldfarb and Tucker, 2019)與前沿 AI(Stanford Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence, 2026);但這些進展對隱性知識助益較少,因為隱性知識是隨人傳遞,而非隨文字傳播(Storper and Venables, 2004)。17 世紀的倫敦已有印刷書籍,但咖啡館仍改變了從事科學研究的人數與參與者。隨著 AI 興起,學術出版物所承載的內容與研究者實際掌握的知識之間,差距正迅速擴大。正如 Tao(2026,第 7 頁)所言,經 AI 潤飾的數學證明可能「讀來容易,學起來卻困難」,因為人類作者留在文字中的阻力,承載了該領域部分隱性知識。因此,隨著 AI 推動知識編碼化,促進隱性知識交流的場域可能更加重要,而非較不重要。最後,究竟是什麼擴大了將科學知識轉化為實務的人數,目前仍未有定論。Zilsel(1942)將早期現代數學的興起歸因於……
實務工作者促使大學學者與工匠之間的界線逐漸模糊;Taylor(1954)探討航海、戰爭與測量的需求,Kelly 與 Ó Gráda(2022)則記錄實用數學的普及程度。相關研究追溯學徒制中的默會技能(de la Croix et al.,2018)、推動工業技術變革的熟練實作者(Meisenzahl and Mokyr,2012),以及後來專業工程師的出現(Hanlon,2025)。許多透過學徒制進行的學習都發生在行會中,行會將成員的技藝視為行業的「奧秘」加以守護(Ogilvie,2019, pp. 571–572)。有些研究者認為,這類技藝將科學革命與第一次工業革命連結起來(Jacob,1997;Kelly et al.,2023;Kelly and Ó Gráda,2022),而 Ó Gráda(2016,
第 235 頁)主張,工業革命背後的人力資本,主要來自工匠的技能,而非牛頓科學。Cormack(2017)聚焦於 1550 年至 1630 年間的倫敦,記錄了商店、講座及商人之間蓬勃發展的實用數學社群,並將後來的咖啡館視為既有社交活動的另一個場所。我們提供因果證據,顯示咖啡館對科學的貢獻不只是為這種社交活動另覓場地。咖啡館將既有知識中心與更廣泛的技術人員連結起來,為那些將英國的社團交往世界與實用知識傳播連結起來的論述,提供了制度層面的依據(Habermas,1991[1962];Clark,2000;Iliffe,1995;Jacob, 1997;Mokyr,2016;Squicciarini and Voigtländer,2015)。人數增加的實務工作者與製作者,正是部分論述認為促成英國後來技術變革的人群(Meisenzahl and Mokyr,2012;Mokyr,2016)。他們只需付一便士入場,不必取得大學入學資格。 *文章架構。*本文安排如下。第 2 節介紹歷史背景。第 3 節說明資料。第 4 節估計咖啡館對倫敦科學發展的在地影響。第 5 節檢視這些影響背後的機制。第 6 節將分析延伸至歐洲,記錄設有咖啡館的城市相較於規模與成長幅度相近的其他城市,科學發展如何興起。第 7 節建立量化都市模型,估算咖啡館對整個倫敦的影響。第 8 節作結。
### 2.背景
本節介紹 17 世紀的倫敦,接著梳理咖啡館的歷史,以及咖啡館與科學的關係。
2.1.17 世紀的倫敦
17 世紀初,倫敦是蓬勃發展的商業樞紐,擁有密集的貿易網路、技藝精湛的工匠,以及與實用科學密切往來的商人和儀器製作者社群(Cormack,2017;Harkness,2007;Shaw-Taylor et al.,2024)。人口從 1600 年的 200,000 人激增至 1670 年的 475,000 人(Wrigley,2010, p. 61),英格蘭也從數百年的停滯轉向持續的生產力成長(Bouscasse et al.,2025)。都市化與薪資勞動的興起提高了可支配所得,帶動對新消費品與異國進口商品的需求(Lake and Pincus,2006)。咖啡就是其中一種進口商品,透過與鄂圖曼帝國的往來傳入倫敦;當地的咖啡館文化自 16 世紀起便已興盛(Hattox,
2014)。英國旅人自 1600 年起便記述這種飲品,而英格蘭最早有飲用咖啡的紀錄可追溯至 1630 年代末期(Cowan,2005, pp. 5, 25)。海外貿易公司的商人,例如成立於 1592 年的黎凡特公司,曾在海外接觸咖啡,但遲遲未在本土銷售。自然哲學家與其他好奇求知的紳士,以 Francis Bacon(1561–1626)為思想先驅;他們是英格蘭最早撰文介紹咖啡、飲用咖啡並推廣咖啡的人(Cowan,2005, pp. 11, 14, 55–56)。
#### 2.2.咖啡館
圖 2。17 世紀的倫敦咖啡館
*註:*這幅由不知名畫家繪製、約作於 1690–1700 年的畫作,呈現倫敦咖啡館內部景象。顧客坐在共用桌旁閱讀、交談與飲用咖啡,女侍則照看吧檯,咖啡侍童穿梭送餐。大英博物館,1931,0613.2。[返回第 8 頁]
1650 年代,英格蘭出現了咖啡館。這是一種新型公共場所,類似酒館、旅店和啤酒館,人們可以在此交談、交流想法並建立信任(圖 2)。知名科學推廣者 Samuel Hartlib(約 1600–1662)在其著作 *Ephemerides*(1654)中,記錄了 Old Exchange 附近一家「咖啡館,或可說是土耳其式啤酒館」開張一事(引自 Cowan,2005 年,第 25–26 頁)。酒館、書店和工匠作坊等其他社交場所,原本也提供交談與交流的空間;咖啡館的特色,在於將熟悉的社交氛圍與咖啡結合。咖啡和葡萄酒、啤酒一樣能促進歡聚,但不同之處在於,咖啡不會讓顧客陷入醉意的迷濛。早在 1650 年代以前,前往東方的旅人及受其啟發的自然哲學家便認為咖啡能使思緒敏銳;隨著咖啡在倫敦普及,醫師、
作家和政治人物開始稱讚咖啡是能提升生產力、又不致醉的提神飲品,也愈來愈常將酒精與混亂失序聯絡在一起。咖啡館因這項承諾而興盛:它提供一種適合清晰思考的社交飲品(Cowan,2005 年,第 18–21、44–46 頁)。這項魅力在 1652 年首次化為實際場所:黎凡特公司商人 Daniel Edwards 的希臘籍僕人 Pasqua Rosée 在倫敦開設了第一家咖啡館。5 為了吸引顧客,Rosée(1652)散發傳單宣傳咖啡的好處,聲稱這種飲品「能振奮精神,使人心情愉悅」,而且「對預防和治療水腫、痛風與壞血病極為有效」。這個概念迅速傳開。到了 1663 年,倫敦城已有 82 家咖啡館(倫敦市治安官,1663 年)。一便士約可買一杯咖啡,按 2025 年價格換算約為 £1.10 或 $1.45;兩便士則足以支付較長時間的停留(Peacham,1677 年)。6 以這樣的價格,菁英階層以外的男性也負擔得起座位,咖啡館於是成為提供新聞與知識交流的清醒公共空間(Cowan,2005 年,第 52、87 頁)。1660 年 12 月 10 日,Samuel Pepys(1633–1703)首次造訪 Cornhill 的一家咖啡館,發現「與各色人等相聚交談,樂趣無窮」(Pepys,1660–1669)。整個 1660 年代,咖啡館逐漸融入城市日常生活;皇家學會會員聚集在 Garraway’s Coffee House,商人則在 Royal Exchange 附近的咖啡館會面。1666 年,咖啡館影響力日益擴大,令 Charles II 深感憂慮,甚至考慮下令取締(Cowan,2005 年,第 194–195 頁)。咖啡館兼具低廉消費與熱烈討論,因此有了「一便士大學」的稱號;詩人 Thomas Jordan(1675)在倫敦街頭傳單《*The Triumphs of London*》中生動寫道:
如此偉大的大學,
我想從來就沒有過;
你可以成為一名學者,
##### 只要花上一便士。
Habermas(1991[1962])進一步闡述這項觀點,將英格蘭咖啡館描繪為近代早期歐洲新興「公共領域」的具體展現;人們在此討論的範圍,從文學、政治到哲學皆有。Mokyr(2005,第 312 頁)也提出相近看法,將咖啡館描述為博學之士與務實人士自然而然的聚會場所,也是學習、文學討論與政治討論的場域。他寫道:「許多有用知識的取得管道改善,都是透過非正式聚會 […],在咖啡館和酒館、臨時演講以及私人沙龍中實現的。」 4 當時也有人懷疑咖啡館是否有助於學習。牛津古物學家 Anthony Wood(1632–1695)於 1678 年詢問,為什麼「扎實而嚴肅的學問」在大學裡日漸衰退,並回答:「因為有咖啡館,他們把所有時間都花在那裡」(Wood,1892,第 2 卷,第 429 頁)。 5 Pasqua Rosée’s Coffee House 常被描述為倫敦第一家咖啡館,有時也被稱為基督教歐洲第一家咖啡館。後一種說法受到其他史料質疑,這些史料認為牛津的一家店才是第一家咖啡館。這些史料引用 Anthony Wood 的日記;他在 1671 年修訂日記時記載,一名名叫 Jacob 的猶太人在牛津的 Angel 附近開了一家咖啡館,後來的編者則將此事定年為 1651 年。咖啡館史學家 Ellis(2004,第 30 頁)對此歸因提出質疑,並指出 Wood 的日記只能證明牛津有販售咖啡,無法證明當地存在面向公眾的咖啡館。 6 價格換算採用 Clark(2026)的零售價格序列。假設每年有 300 個有薪工作日,同一來源的平均薪資序列顯示,一便士約相當於一天薪資的 10%。這是日常消費中一筆不小的金額,足以購買一週份的新聞小冊或一條小黃瓜(Peacham,1677)。
將咖啡館文化與較早期的社會規範並置,最能看出其社會影響。Cowan(2005,第 101–105、112 頁)指出,咖啡館取代以酒精為主的公共酒館,成為菁英交流的重要場所。17 世紀初的英格蘭,博學之士(自然哲學家與學者)通常聚集在貴族宅邸,彼此往來正式而排外。相較之下,咖啡館鼓勵非正式、跨階級的對話,因此挑戰了傳統的知識聲望取得途徑。對較不富裕、志在成為博學之士的人來說,咖啡館讓他們得以空前地接觸資訊與社交網路。這種交流機會比飲品本身更重要。雖然人們主要在咖啡館而非家中飲用咖啡(Withington,2020,第 59 頁),但咖啡供應量並不充裕。1680 年代中期,英格蘭的進口量最多隻能讓約 50,000 人每天喝到半公升,約佔英格蘭 15 歲以上人口的 1.5%(Smith,2001,第 252–253 頁)。無論如何,咖啡館除了提供咖啡的生理作用之外,也提供了一種制度化的場域:容易進入且營運穩定的場所,降低了不同社會背景的理論家、工匠與企業家之間的溝通成本,並促進新的禮節規範與思想開放風氣傳播(Klein,1996)。
2.3.傳播、接受與顧客群
咖啡館的地理分佈,沿著倫敦的商業與制度地理擴充套件(Cowan,2005, pp. 156–161)。早期咖啡館聚集在皇家交易所、艦隊街與法院律師公會附近,位置就在倫敦市西側城牆外,當地有商人、印刷業者與律師工作。之後,咖啡館從這些地區擴充套件至鄰近街區,業者藉此吸引人潮與回頭客。公眾對咖啡館的觀感,既反映了它作為集體討論場所的角色,也反映了它被定位為傳統酒館的清醒替代選擇(Cowan,2005, pp. 45–46)。業者藉由宣揚咖啡有助於促進清醒、理性的討論,形塑顧客對咖啡館的期待。咖啡館匯聚的新聞、意見與傳聞,也在政治不穩定時期引起當局注意;限制咖啡館文化的管制措施,著重於言論傳播,而非飲用咖啡(Cowan,2005, pp. 193–224)。咖啡館的顧客群相當廣泛,不只限於自然哲學家與商人,也涵蓋更廣泛的城市人口,但仍有其界限(Cowan,2005,pp.255–256)。參與其中需要有一定經濟能力、識字能力與對談技巧,因此許多城市貧民無法參與。女性鮮少以顧客身分出現,但有人擔任業者或工作人員(Cowan,2001)。在 1650 年代以前,科學家與商人的往來有限;史料顯示,咖啡館的興起並非由科學或知識生活的變化所推動。 7 因此,咖啡館串連起商業、知識與技術社群。 7 在Taylor(1954)列出的31位數學實務工作者中,依Warren et al.(2016)根據《牛津國家人物傳記辭典》(Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, 2025)推斷其人脈關係,已知活躍期於1650年以前結束者,其562筆人脈紀錄中只有18筆屬於商業往來,且只有9位實務工作者有此類人脈(附錄表A4)。同一部辭典將早期咖啡館業者列入商業人脈網路,且其人物傳記無一提及他們與科學界的連結(附錄A.1)。
2.4.與科學的關係
1684 年 1 月,皇家學會院士 Robert Hooke、Christopher Wren(1632–1723)與 Edmond Halley(1656–1742)在倫敦一家咖啡館碰面,討論使行星維持軌道執行的力之本質(Mount,2021, pp. 145–146)。Hooke 聲稱自己已發現反平方定律,卻沒有提出證明。Wren 懸賞徵求證明,但 Hooke 未能交出。Halley 為了尋求解答,於同年稍晚前往劍橋拜訪 Isaac Newton(1643–1727)。Newton 回答說,他早已解出這道問題,之後還寄給 Halley 一份手稿,成為《*Principia*》(1687)的基礎。咖啡館為這類對話提供了場域,與皇家學會相輔相成,而且更容易進入。Hooke 的日記裡滿是倫敦咖啡館的記載,他平均每三天就有將近兩天造訪咖啡館。正如 Iliffe(1995)所指出,Hooke 利用這些空間建立人脈、交流技術資訊、檢視機械與儀器,也洽談生意。1678 年 8 月 21 日,他在 Man’s Coffee House 與 Wren 會面後,在日記中畫下兩人彼此描述的四種器具,其中包括一具「poysd weather glasse」和他自己的「philosophicall spring scales」(Robinson and Adams,1935, pp. 372–373)。四種器具中有兩種是 Wren 的。另一個例子是 Hooke 與製圖師 John Ogilby(1600–1676)的往來;1673 年 8 月 14 日,他在 Garraway’s Coffee House 為 Ogilby「設計倫敦地圖的圖紙」。兩個月後,他又在那裡「向他展示如何用字母標記地圖,以及如何描繪陰影」(Robinson and Adams,1935, pp. 55, 65)。咖啡館補足了印刷品的不足,而非取而代之。書籍雖然承載數學與技術見解,但這些見解傳到讀者手中需要時間。相較之下,咖啡館裡的訊息與主張每天透過一再交談傳播,人們可以討論、示範,並結合實作經驗(Higgitt et al.,2024;Johns,2006);而反覆會面建立了這類交流所仰賴的信任與社會資本(Shapin,1994)。咖啡館成為蒐集與比對資訊的場所,也就是 Stewart(1999)所稱的「其他計算中心」。這些專業知識散佈於彼此重疊的自然哲學家、數學實務工作者與工匠網路之中;他們在咖啡館、工坊、商店與機構裡工作(Higgitt et al.,2024, pp. 8–9, 19–20)。既然所有人如今只要花一便士就有誘因走進同一個房間,咖啡館便能串連各個網路所掌握的知識。儀器生產大多仍採委託製作:行會學徒制度傳授工藝與商業知識,廣告則讓製造者接觸專業使用者(Bryden,1992;Crawforth,1987;Stewart,2005)。行會本身也在咖啡館集會。鐘錶匠公會(Clockmakers’ Company)於 1672 年在 Ironmonger Lane 的 George 舉辦宴會,直到 1698 年都在那裡舉行例會;其查察法庭則在 Threadneedle Street 的 Angel and Crown,以及 West Smithfield 的 Crown 開庭(Lillywhite,1963, entries 44, 317, 1751)。咖啡館是否創造了技藝姑且不論,它們擴大了參與者的範圍。對於那些技藝
8 三人究竟在哪裡碰面,至今仍無定論。Mount(2021 年,第 145–146 頁)認為,他們是在 Garraway’s Coffee House 會面。9 其他公司也會在咖啡館聚會,其中包括 1677–1678 年在 Cheapside 的 Kiftell’s 聚會的錫器商,以及在 King Street 的 North’s 聚會的鐵器商和籃具製造商(Lillywhite,1963 年,條目 670 和 914)。
知識是透過示範傳授,而非透過書籍。鐘錶匠 Thomas Tompion(1639–1713)是 Bedfordshire 一名鐵匠之子,清楚展現了這一點。他與 Hooke 合作之初,雖然技藝精湛,卻沒有學術人脈。1674 年 6 月 27 日,Hooke 在 Child’s Coffee House 向他介紹新式分度圓規和其他機械裝置。1675 年 3 月 8 日,Hooke 在 Garraway’s Coffee House 示範如何在擺輪內固定雙遊絲。六天後,Tompion 把鐘錶機件帶給 Hooke;4 月 7 日,兩人向 Charles II 展示 Hooke 的新式遊絲懷錶(Robinson and Adams,1935 年,第 109、151–157 頁;附錄圖 A2)。Hooke 提出科學問題與設計,Tompion 則負責製作、測試和修改。這項合作成為技術與技能的雙向交流(Iliffe,1995 年,
第 311 頁),而這也讓 Tompion 踏入科學領域:1676 年,他為位於格林威治的新皇家天文臺製作了兩座可連續走時兩年的時鐘。這段經歷說明,咖啡館聚會如何結合不同技能與背景人士的見解;更廣泛而言,咖啡館也提高了工匠與學者相遇的機會。工匠具備製作新興實驗科學所需儀器的技能,學者則提出科學問題。咖啡館也曾舉辦實驗哲學的辯論。Shapin and Schaffer(1985, pp. 292–293)記載,牛津的 Tillyard’s Coffee House 是實驗團體聚會及化學講座的場所;1662 年的一本小冊子則討論了一場在倫敦咖啡館舉行、針對氣壓計現象的辯論。從他們對實驗知識的論述來看,實驗知識是儀器、可信的見證與溝通共同作用的產物;咖啡館作為一種社交場域,讓科學制度化的過程延伸至公共領域,拓展實驗室與皇家學會以外的空間,而非取代它們。這種交流仰賴倫敦更廣泛的知識經濟。Beeley(2019,
p. 225)描述,倫敦的數學實務工作者組成一個相互依存的社群,成員涵蓋教師、儀器製造者、印刷商、書商、商人,甚至數學社團;當時人們稱他們為「倫敦數學家」,以別於牛津與劍橋的學術同儕。John Collins(1625–1683)便是其中一位倫敦數學家,也是這個社群中牽線者的代表。他傳閱手稿、安排出版、尋找相關專業人才,並將實務問題與數學家及儀器製造者連結起來(Beeley,2017)。Collins 雖未在大學任職,卻能和其他類似人士一樣,透過咖啡館反覆與更密切連結菁英知識網路的人士交流。Hooke 的日記記錄了 1670 年代 Collins 經常出現在咖啡館聚會中。1674 年 4 月 18 日,Hooke 在 Spanish Coffee House 記下:「Collins 給我看了 Kersey 代數學的第三冊」,這是倫敦教師 John Kersey 剛出版的論著(Robinson and Adams,1935, pp. 67, 98, 392)。印刷商 Joseph Moxon(1627–1691)與學術體制的距離更遠。1674 至 1680 年間,Hooke 在 Man’s、Garraway’s 和 Child’s Coffee Houses 與他會面;Moxon 也從印刷業拓展至地球儀、儀器和數學書籍。1678 年,他獲選為皇家學會會員。對一名商人而言,這是罕見的選舉結果(Robinson and Adams,1935, pp. 90, 286–287, 383, 401, 436;Appendix Table A1)。Stewart(1999)更全面地記錄,咖啡館在傳播印刷品的同時,也闢出房間舉辦聚會、講座與討論,成為辯論近期新聞和普遍交流知識的重要場所。有些咖啡館會舉辦自然哲學講座與示範,有時形式相當正式
其影響力可與學校、英國皇家學會或格雷沙姆學院相提並論。與這些機構不同,咖啡館散佈在全城各處,形成去中心化、以面對面交流為基礎的知識交換網路。咖啡館興起前,倫敦並非與科學隔絕:格雷沙姆學院舉辦公開講座;聖保羅教堂墓園周邊有開放的書籍交易;工坊傳授工藝技能;貴族宅邸則連結既有的學者。然而,這些管道往往遠不如咖啡館開放。在咖啡館,只要一便士,就能取得新聞並在公共空間找個座位交談,不需要資格、特許狀或贊助人。歷史研究指出,這類機構在實用知識的交流,以及歐洲轉向現代經濟成長的過程中扮演重要角色(Broman,1998; Jacob,1997;Mokyr,2002,2005,2016;Stewart,1992)。咖啡館時代之前,學術網路也更難加入。最接近咖啡館作為知識交流場所的先例,是 Robert Boyle(1627–1691)在 1640 年代組成的「無形學院」,以及規模更大的「文人共和國」。這些學者網路雖然沒有會址或特許狀,卻不對外人開放,因為加入者必須有書信往來、引薦人脈與學術地位(Mokyr, 2016, p. 186)。同樣地,研究仰賴富有贊助者的資助,或研究者個人的財富(Mokyr,2016, pp. 181, 205–206)。隨著科學從文藝復興時期的保密風氣轉向公開競爭的發現事業(Wootton,2015),自然哲學家、儀器製作者、工匠、商人與中產階級人士反覆在咖啡館碰面;一次次的接觸建立起聲譽與信任,讓知識交流得以進行(Johns,1999;Shapin,1994;Sunderland,2007)。
3.資料
針對倫敦,我們彙整咖啡館、數學從業者與科學儀器商店的紀錄,每筆資料都附有地址和年代。我們將每個地址進行地理編碼,並歸入倫敦 1660 年劃分的 162 個教區之一。 11 我們按教區與年代計算 1600 年代至 1690 年代的紀錄數量。另外兩種資料來源則補充了這份追蹤資料集。對 17 世紀的歐洲城市,我們以每十年為單位蒐集觀察資料,並記錄與倫敦相似的指標,包括各城市第一家咖啡館開業的年份。我們也謄錄 Robert Hooke 的日記;他在 1672 至 1683 年間幾乎每天記述科學、造訪咖啡館等各種生活點滴。 12
*咖啡館。*為了確認倫敦咖啡館的開業地點與時間,我們彙整了*London Signs*(Lillywhite,1972)的資料。該書取材自倫敦市政廳圖書館的第一手與第二手資料,涵蓋 17 至 19 世紀的咖啡館及其他商家。資料包括代幣、店招紀錄、懸賞公告、商業名錄、報紙、廣告、信件、參考資料與日記。Lillywhite(1972)列出各家咖啡館的名稱與最早見載年份,並提供 2,124 家咖啡館(共 2,254 家)的地址。 10 附錄 A.2 將這些事件依年代排列,呈現咖啡、咖啡館與英格蘭科學發展的歷程。 11 這些區域包括倫敦市的 113 個教區(其中 97 個位於城牆內)、西敏市的 9 個教區、密德塞克斯與薩裡郡的 20 個教區,以及 20 個特許自治區或非教區管轄區。後兩者是獨立的管轄區,並非教區;為求簡便,本文也稱之為教區。摘要統計資料見附錄 D.1。
聖保羅大教堂
1650 年代 英格蘭銀行 1660 年代 1670 年代 1680 年代 1690 年代
倫敦橋
3 公里
圖 3。倫敦第一批咖啡館分佈圖
*註:*倫敦地圖顯示各教區最早有紀錄的咖啡館出現年代,並以內嵌圖呈現城牆內的區域。灰色教區表示 17 世紀沒有咖啡館紀錄。紅點標示三處現今地標。[返回第 15 頁]
據我們所知,Lillywhite(1972)仍是關於倫敦歷史咖啡館最完整的資料來源,記載的咖啡館遠多於知名的幾家。 13
較廣為引用的前身著作 Lillywhite(1963)收錄了 Lillywhite(1972)所列 2,254 家咖啡館中的 2,034 家。 14 Ellis(2006)將 Lillywhite(1963)視為*最主要的*參考著作,Pincus(1995,第 809 頁)稱之為「百科全書式的咖啡館名錄」,Cowan(2007,第 1197 頁)則形容它是「極具價值的倫敦咖啡館參考資料彙編」。 15
建立資料集時,我們處理了兩種測量誤差來源。第一,合併重複專案。同一家咖啡館若以多個名稱出現,Lillywhite(1963、1972)會分別列出,並註明專案重疊之處。 16 第二,找出並移除少數為了補足背景資訊而列入 Lillywhite(1963)的非咖啡館類公共酒館。 17 在 1663 年調查(倫敦市治安官,1663 年)及 1690 年代回報資料(Cowan,2005 年)涵蓋的倫敦市各區中,
13 例如,我們的樣本中有 286 家 17 世紀咖啡館,其中 34 家僅能透過商業代幣得知(附錄表 D6)。 14 附錄圖 D2 和 D3 展示了兩份資料的節錄。在 Lillywhite(1972,第 1 頁)中,第 1 至 2,034 項來自 Lillywhite(1963)。 15 Lillywhite 根據倫敦的店招進行研究;1762 年和 1763 年的公告下令拆除懸挑店招,在此之前,這些店招會標示倫敦住家的地址,而 Lillywhite 以咖啡館作為懸掛店招的住家類別之一(Lillywhite,1972 年,第 xv–xvi 頁)。他的部分資料來自郵政史,也就是寄往這些店招地址的信件(Lillywhite,1963 年,第 10 頁)。只要檔案記載店招名稱、地址和年份,他就會收錄該咖啡館,再補上來源中的其他資訊。因此,咖啡館是否列入名錄,並不取決於其顧客群;顧客群資料只會增加條目細節。 16 例如,「The New Bagnio」(第 1845 項)也以「Turk’s Head Bagnio」(第 1957 項)之名出現。一般而言,咖啡館會依據地點(例如「St. Dunstan」)、店招(例如「Turk’s Head」)或經營者(例如「Bowman」)而有不同名稱,Lillywhite(1963)會交叉註明這些名稱變體。例如,「Pope’s Head Tavern」(第 1870 項)「因其地點以及與咖啡館密切相關,故列於此處」(Lillywhite,1963 年,第 724 頁)。
這些紀錄涵蓋 1690 年代統計咖啡館總數的五分之三,也涵蓋 1663 年調查咖啡館的約三分之一至二分之一,與 1666 年倫敦大火造成歷史紀錄大量散失的整體情況一致。整體而言,這份樣本涵蓋 17 世紀倫敦 61 個教區的 286 家咖啡館。圖 3 標出各教區最早有咖啡館紀錄的年代。在納入分析的 61 個教區中,有 49 個位於倫敦市。1650 年代開業的咖啡館集中在倫敦市東側,鄰近金融與知識中心(皇家交易所與格雷欣學院);西側的威斯敏斯特,即王室與政治中心,也形成另一處聚集區。此後,咖啡館逐十年出現在城牆內及周邊郊區,未持續集中於少數教區。
*數學實務工作者。*我們透過計算應用科學家最接近的歷史類比:數學實務工作者,來衡量他們的數量。這些人將數學應用於教學、撰寫數學文本、製作儀器及其他相關技術職業。我們的資料來自Taylor(1954),這是一項開創性的研究,探討近代早期英格蘭的實用數學,並提出「數學實務工作者」這個概念。Taylor(1954)彙編了1507年至1714年間活躍於英格蘭的584位實務工作者的集體傳記,資料取自當時的著作與日記、書目彙編、博物館目錄及檔案手稿。該研究出版後,「幾乎沒有新增實務工作者,而這個分類本身也鮮少受到嚴肅質疑」(Walton,2017, p. 89)。每篇傳記記載姓名、活躍時期(即從事活動的時間)、工作地點、活動型別(例如製作儀器、教學、研究),以及與其他實務工作者的關係。我們將樣本限縮為244位在倫敦工作地點有精確地理編碼,且記錄的活躍時期與1600年至1699年重疊的實務工作者。其中223位在該世紀開始活躍,另有21位更早開始活躍。他們曾在162個教區中的69個工作。每位實務工作者都會列入其記錄的活躍時期所涵蓋的每個十年,以及該十年間其有工作地點的每個教區,因此結果衡量的是活躍實務工作者的存量。Taylor(1954)記載實務工作者之間多種型別、未標註日期的社會與知識關係,從「朋友」和「師傅」到「通訊往來」、「受僱」及「請教」。我們利用Warren et al.(2016)的*Six Degrees of Francis Bacon*資料庫所收錄的*Oxford Dictionary of National Biography*傳記,透過機器學習推斷相同型別的關係,以擴充這個網路;該資料庫涵蓋244位實務工作者中的75位(附錄D.4)。只要任一來源記載兩位實務工作者之間有關係,就視為兩人曾有連結;若兩人曾有連結,且在十年*𝑡*都活躍,便視為他們在十年*𝑡*有連結。所得網路包含204位實務工作者之間的475條無向長期連結,
18 附錄D.11透過同時期行政紀錄與獨立檔案搜尋,評估資料集的完整性。19 附錄圖D4呈現Taylor(1954)的節錄,附錄圖D20則展示不同世代實務工作者的例子。20 對於Taylor(1954)提供出生日期而非活躍時期的65位實務工作者,我們依據Taylor(1954)各篇傳記隱含的年代順序,將活躍期定義為從個人年滿21歲的那一年,延續至死亡年份或最後活躍年份。21 附錄表D7列出244位實務工作者經統一整理的完整職稱。職稱可能重疊:69位歸類為狹義的數學實務工作者、54位為數學教師,130位為科學儀器製作者。
平均每位實務工作者有4.7條連結,中位數為3條。在某個活躍十年間,實務工作者平均有3.1條連結,中位數為2條。在1665年《*Philosophical Transactions*》創刊至1699年間活躍的176位實務工作者中,我們能在該刊中確認其中32人的姓名。
*科學儀器商店。*為了掌握實體資本與人力資本中的科學活動,我們彙整科學儀器商店的資料;這些商店製造、維修並販售儀器。資料取自Hay et al.(2025)、SIMON(1991 年建立的科學儀器製造商電腦化資料庫,由Clifton 24 (1991)彙編),以及其後續出版的摘錄Clifton(1995)。這些資料根據各種實物與文獻辨識製造商,常見的依據包括現存儀器上的簽名、行會紀錄及商業卡片。許多基礎資料是在 1980 年代與 1990 年代於格林威治的國家海事博物館及皇家天文臺蒐集而成。2025 年版透過數位人文專案*Tools of Knowledge: Modelling the Creative Communities of the Scientific Instrument* *Trade, 1500–1914*擴充這項研究。此資料集記錄截至 1690 年代所有已知在倫敦設有地址的科學儀器製造商與商店,包括每位製造商的姓名、商店地址及營業年份 25。這份面板資料涵蓋 17 世紀在 68 個教區經營 345 家商店的 252 位製造商;這些商店中,除了 1 家以外,其餘都是在 26 世紀首次有紀錄。商店會列入其有紀錄的營業年份所跨越的每個十年,因此這項結果呈現的是存量。
*倫敦地址地理編碼。*我們參照數位歷史地圖與地名錄,手動將每個地址標記在現今的大倫敦 Google 地圖上,再將產生的座標與Cummins et al.(2016)提供的 shapefile 進行空間連線;該檔案呈現 1660 年倫敦的教區地理分佈(附錄 D.12)。
22 附錄圖 D21以四個十年為單位繪出網路,以及鐘錶匠 Thomas Tompion 的 14 條連線。23 我們在皇家學會語料庫(Royal Society Corpus)全部 1,325 篇 17 世紀文章的全文中,搜尋 176 人的姓氏及其當時的拼法(Fischer et al.,2020);只有在名字或上下文足以確認身分時,才將該實務工作者計為被提及,因此 32 是下限。兩位語言模型編碼者分別閱讀 1,199 筆出現紀錄,其中 1,195 筆判定一致;我們只計入兩位編碼者及另外兩位讀者都認可的紀錄。Hooke、Newton 和 Halley 佔提及次數的三分之二以上;32 位被提及者中有 9 位是皇家學會院士,而 144 位從未被提及者中也有 9 位是院士。24 我們也直接查閱了已出版的摘錄,主要用來補齊缺漏的地址。附錄圖 D5展示Clifton(1995)的摘錄。25 附錄圖 D17與D18顯示,在典型年份,英倫群島有紀錄的科學儀器製造商約有四分之三在倫敦活動;自 1660 年代起,比例超過 80%。直到 1660 年代,生產仍以分規、比例規及羅盤等實用儀器為主;此後,顯微鏡與氣泵等實驗儀器開始迅速增加。26 在我們從Taylor(1954)納入樣本的 244 位實務工作者中,有 130 位是科學儀器製造商;後來出版的Clifton(1995)則記錄了 252 位製造商,並以Taylor為資料來源之一。兩者的分類方式也不相同:Christopher Wren 在Taylor(1954)中被列為儀器製造商,在Clifton(1995)中則否(附錄圖 D4)。由於Taylor(1954)記錄的是事業興盛年份,而Clifton(1995)記錄的是活動年份與商店營運期間,我們分析科學儀器商店時只採用Hay et al.(2025)與Clifton(1995)的資料。
*歐洲城市層級資料。*第 6 節延伸至歐洲時,我們採用 Bosker et al. (2013) 的 200 個歐洲城市資料;這些城市在 1600 年至少有 10,000 名居民,符合該論文偏好的城市定義,並且在從未受鄂圖曼帝國統治的歐洲地區,留有 1500 年的人口紀錄。我們透過系統性檢視歷史研究,新增了這些城市首間咖啡館的資料,共整理出 27 筆(附錄 D.7)。總計有 37 個城市在 17 世紀留下咖啡館的紀錄(附錄表 D2)。據我們所知,歐洲沒有像 Taylor (1954) 列出英格蘭數學從業者那樣的名單,因此我們改為計算《Universal Short Title Catalogue》[USTC](2026) 中在各城市印行的應用數學書名,並依照 Kelly and Ó Gráda (2022, p. 849) 用來衡量英格蘭實用數學的 14 個主題標目分類。這種替代方式相當自然,因為 Taylor (1954) 通常也會依據這類書名,將更多人納入數學從業者名單。至於科學儀器製作者,我們計算《*Webster* *SignatureDatabase*》(Webster and Webster, 2007)中記錄每十年間在各城市活躍的製作者;該資料庫收錄了曾在科學儀器上簽名、且其作品現藏於世界各地館藏中的製作者。
*Hooke’s Diary, 1672–1683.*To better understand the features of a coffeehouse, we manually transcribe the diary of Robert Hooke, curator of experiments at the Royal Societyandthebest-connectedpractitionerofthecoffeehouseera(AppendixFigureD13). Hooke recorded where he went and whom he met from March 1672 to May 1683 (Henderson,2007;Robinson and Adams,1935), yielding diary entries for 3,464 days, with an average of 49 words per entry (Appendix Table D3). Coffeehouses appear on 2,244 days, other public houses on 337, and neither on 1,122, with 239 days having both. Furthermore, for each person an entry names, we record whether Hooke met them and identify them in the index of the printed editions, which yields 16,325 recorded meetings, counting each person once a day, with 1,426 distinct people. These are the meetings Hooke thought worth writing down, not everyone he saw. For further details and validation, seeAppendix D.6.
*Other.*Additional variables enter the balance comparisons, robustness checks, and mechanism tests.Appendix Ddefines them, each with its source.
4.EFFECTS ON SCIENCE IN LONDON
This section estimates the local effect of coffeehouses on science in London. Using a staggeredeventstudyacrossparishes, wefindthattheopeningofthefirstcoffeehousein a parish is preceded by flat pre-trends and followed by a persistent increase in scientific activity. Robustness checks on changing population density, commercial activity, the survival of records, and more support the identifying assumptions of parallel trends and no anticipation. We then show that earlier tavern openings produce no comparable increase, which speaks against the idea that the coffeehouse was just another meeting place. Finally, we find positive spillovers onto the immediate neighborhood of an 27 A simple validation exercise supports the dates. Cities closer to one of the five ports through which coffee entered Europe opened coffeehouses earlier, by about 3.3 years per 100 kilometers (Appendix Figure D1). The headings are those of the*English Short Title Catalogue*, applied as keyword rules in seven languages;Appendix D.3lists them with the number of titles under each.
opening, and that relocation of scientists already recorded in London accounts for at most two-fifths of the local effect.
4.1.Empirical Strategy
To estimate effects on science in London, we exploit the staggered introduction of coffeehouses across parishes beginning in 1652. Specifically, we employ an event study model that compares changes before and after the first recorded coffeehouse opens in a parish with changes over the same decades in parishes with no coffeehouse. 29 We focus on the first opening because it provides a clean transition from untreated to treated. 30
As a coffeehouse opening bundles the meeting place, coffee, newsprint, debate, and clientele, our estimates are of their joint effect. The historical record suggests that entry followed commerce, not science (Ap- pendix A.1). Proprietors were middle-class merchants and traders (Appendix Table A2) who sold coffee and chose sites for foot traffic and custom. Before the first coffeehouse opened, they were largely unconnected to mathematical practitioners, whose recorded commercial ties were rare (Appendix Table A4), and the coffeehouse clientele stayed broad throughout the century, reaching well beyond scientists to merchants, aristocrats, and politicians (Appendix Figure A1). Of the 145 coffeehouses whose seventeenth- century records mention a use, 11 mention science or learning, against 82 that mention commerce and 60 politics. As descriptive evidence,Appendix Table C1reports normalized differences between parishes with and without a coffeehouse. Treated parishes were poorer in 1582, but similar to controls by 1638 in the share of well-off households (rent of at least £20 a year), and before 1652 in scientific correspondence and in goldsmiths, a proxy for financial capital. They were less densely populated. The largest differences were in socialcapital andcommerce: treatedparishes hadmore tradesmen’s tokens, commercial premises, taverns, and booksellers. They also lay closer to major centers such as the Royal Exchange, Gresham College, and Paternoster Row. Nevertheless, entry need not be random, and treated and control parishes may differ in levels. 31 Instead, identification requires that parishes did not change behavior in anticipation of a first opening, and that without entry, scientific activity in treated parishes would have followed the path observed in never-treated parishes. Concretely, we estimate an unconditional staggered difference-in-differences model with multiple
29 Our unit of analysis is a parish rather than an individual practitioner for three reasons. First, our margin of interest is how many people practiced science. Second, about half of the practitioners, 127 of 244, are observed only briefly, for a decade or two, which leaves little time before and after a coffeehouse opening. Third, coffeehouses may have changed who became a practitioner in the first place, so that being a practitioner is itself an outcome of the treatment. 30 Parishes stay treated from their first coffeehouse on, so the estimates include whatever later openings added.Appendix B.10groups treated parishes by the number of coffeehouses open in the decade of entry and estimates each group against the never-treated. 31 Section 4.3tests whether these differences matter, comparing changes rather than levels before 1652 and reweighting parishes by their estimated probability of receiving a coffeehouse.
time periods that is robust to heterogeneous treatment effects across groups and time:
##### Õ Õ
*𝑦𝑝𝑡*=*𝛼*+ *𝛽𝑔𝑠*1[*𝑠*=*𝑡*]1[*𝑔*=*𝐸𝑝*]+*𝛾𝑝*+*𝛿𝑡*+*𝜖𝑝𝑡.*(1) *𝑔*=1650 *𝑠*=1600 *𝑠*≠*𝑔*−10
Here, *𝑦𝑝𝑡*denotes the number of mathematical practitioners or scientific instrument shops in parish *𝑝* in decade *𝑡*. *𝛾𝑝*and *𝛿𝑡*denote parish and decade fixed effects that control for local time-invariant differences and London-wide shocks and trends. *𝐸𝑝*≥1650 denotes the decade in which the first coffeehouse is recorded in parish *𝑝*. 33
For each cohort *𝑔*, the omitted reference period is the decade before entry, *𝑠*=*𝑔*−10. For *𝑠*≥*𝑔*, *𝛽𝑔𝑠*is the average effect of coffeehouse entry for cohort *𝑔* in decade *𝑠*, relative to decade *𝑔*−10 and to the never-treated counterfactual, *𝐸𝑝*=∞. Earlier coefficients are pre-treatment contrasts, not effects. *𝜖𝑝𝑡*is an error term. Standard errors are clustered by parish. Dynamictreatmenteffectsareourestimandsofinterest. FollowingWooldridge(2023), we estimate equation (1) by OLS and predict outcomes using all estimated coefficients and fixed effects, yielding b*𝑦𝑝𝑡*. We impute the untreated potential outcome, *𝑦𝑝𝑡*(∞), by predicting from equation (1) using only the estimated intercept and fixed effects, yielding b*𝑦𝑝𝑡*(∞). The observation-specific treatment effect is therefore b*𝑝𝑡𝜏* ≡ b*𝑦𝑝𝑡*− b*𝑦𝑝𝑡*(∞). We estimate the dynamic treatment effect by averaging b*𝑝𝑡𝜏* across parishes observed *ℓ* decades after the first coffeehouse opens: <u>1</u> Õ b*ℓ𝜏* ≡ b*𝑝,𝐸𝜏* *𝑝* +10*ℓ,*(2) |*𝑃ℓ*| *𝑝*∈*𝑃ℓ*
where *𝑃ℓ*denotes the set of parishes observed in period *𝐸𝑝*+10*ℓ*. 34 We plot these effects, measured in levels relative to the decade immediately before treatment. Often, we summarize the pre-trends and post-treatment effects with the pre- and post-ATT, <u>1</u> Í −2 <u>1</u> Í₄ respectively, defined as 4 *ℓ*=−5 b*ℓ𝜏* and 5 *ℓ*=0 b*ℓ𝜏*. The resulting dynamic treatment effect estimates and standard errors are numerically equivalent to those from the long-difference estimators ofCallaway and Sant’Anna (2021). We adopt the approach ofWooldridge(2023) because, unlike long differences, its regression form extends to nonlinear models. Both outcomes are counts with many zeros, so as a robustness check we re-estimate the model by Poisson quasi-maximum likelihood with an exponential conditional mean: 35 ! 1690 Õ1690Õ E[*𝑦𝑝𝑡*|*𝑝,𝑡*]=exp *𝛼*+ *𝛽𝑔𝑠*1[*𝑠*=*𝑡*]1[*𝑔*=*𝐸𝑝*]+*𝛾𝑝*+*𝛿𝑡.*(3) *𝑔*=1650 *𝑠*=1600 *𝑠*≠*𝑔*−10 32 This addresses problems arising from treatment effect heterogeneity in staggered adoption designs. In contrast, conventional two-way fixed effects estimators can place non-convex or negative weights on group-time treatment effects, while dynamic two-way fixed effects event study estimators can suffer from contamination across relative periods (Borusyak et al.,2024;de Chaisemartin and D’Haultfoeuille,2020; Goodman-Bacon,2021;Sun and Abraham,2021). 33 Appendix Figure D15shows the rollout of treatment across parishes.Appendix Figure D16shows coffeehouse counts by event time relative to the first coffeehouse entry. 34 Because the panel ends in the 1690s, fewer cohorts contribute at longer horizons: b4*𝜏* is identified from the 10 parishes treated in the 1650s (Appendix Figure D15). The exponential mean rules out negative predictions and avoids the need for transformations such as the inverse hyperbolic sine (Chen and Roth,2024;Roth and Sant’Anna,2023;Wooldridge,2023).
Identification now requires that, absent a coffeehouse, mean outcomes in treated and control parishes would have grown by the same factor, not the same amount.
4.2.Mathematical Practitioners and Scientific Instrument Shops
Figure 4reports the estimated dynamic effects of equation (2), obtained by estimating
equation (1), for both outcomes along with the post-ATT. 36 Flat pre-trends support their validity. 37 Panel A shows a persistent increase in practitioners. The 61 treated parishes averaged 0.62 practitioners in the decade before entry, and the number rises by 0.68 on average over the decade of entry and the four decades after, roughly doubling. 38 Panel B shows a persistent increase in instrument shops, by 1.24 on a baseline of 0.33, a nearly fivefold rise.
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops
3 Post-ATT = 0.68 (s.e. 0.22) 5 Post-ATT = 1.24 (s.e. 0.31)
4 2
| 2 | 3 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | ||||||||
| 1 | |||||||||
| 0 (.62) | 0 (.33) | ||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
Figure 4.Effects on scientific activity
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pages20,31,OA-7,OA-23,OA-106]
Despite data scarcity, the effects are precisely estimated and statistically significant. They are also large. Between the 1640s and the 1690s, London gained 68 mathematical practitioners and 136 instrument shops. Aggregated across treated parishes, the estimatedeffectsinthe1690saccountfor49percent(s.e.18)oftheincreaseinpractitioners and63percent(s.e.16)oftheincreaseininstrumentshops. Relativetototalactivityrather than growth, coffeehouse entry accounts for 20 percent (s.e. 7) of all 502 practitioner- decades and 46 percent (s.e. 10) of all 412 instrument shop-decades recorded between
36 Appendix Figure B1plots the raw annual means in coffeehouse and control parishes. They follow similar trends before the first coffeehouse opened in London in 1652 and diverge afterward, as scientific activity rises in coffeehouse parishes while control parishes stay nearly flat. 37 We fail to reject the null that the pre-treatment contrasts two to five decades before entry are jointly zero (*𝑝*=0*.*99for practitioners and*𝑝*=0*.*29for instrument shops). 38 Because the outcome is a stock, the increase could in principle reflect longer recorded activity per practitioner rather than more practitioners. It does not: practitioners in parishes that ever received a coffeehouseflourishfor25.3yearsperlocationspellagainst22.8inparishesthatneverdid, aninsignificant difference of 2.5 years (s.e. 2.4).
the 1650s and the 1690s. The treatment and the two outcomes come from three separate compilations, as- sembled by different scholars from different archives and for different purposes. The consistent effects are therefore not an artifact of the coverage of one compilation. This also informs us about observability bias, or the concern that those who frequented coffeehouses were more likely to enter the historical record. Though this concern seems relevant for practitioners, who are drawn from a collective biography of notable individuals, it has less force for instrument shops, which are identified from signatures on surviving instruments in museum collections and traced in guild records and trade cards, none of which plausibly depends on the presence of a coffeehouse.
4.3.Robustness
Coffeehouse openings could have coincided with unobserved local shocks to scientific activity. We address this concern in five ways. First, we test for effects on placebo outcomes that coffeehouses should not move, so that our main effects can be cleanly interpreted as due to coffeehouses. Second, we adjust for baseline characteristics that predict where coffeehouses opened, as one might believe parallel trends hold only conditional on them. Third, we compare the estimates against placebo assignments of treatment. Fourth, we check that the results do not depend on how the sources record coffeehouses and scientific activity. Fifth, we vary the remaining ingredients of the design one at a time.Appendix Cdevelops each check in more depth. We begin with outcomes that openings should not move. Population density is a key factor that increases the rate of interaction among people. Baptism and death densities, which proxy for population density where no direct data exist, do not move, and their pre-trends are flat. Luxury shops, catering to an affluent clientele, would have risen had entry coincided with gentrification, i.e., an inflow of the affluent and intellectually inclined who could themselves enter science. They do not move, consistent with what the design assumes, that coffeehouses raised the rate at which potential entrants turned to science rather than their number. Similarly, non-scientific letters would have risen had established elite correspondents within the Republic of Letters arrived with the coffeehouse, in which case the coffeehouse effect could reflect a connection to the Republic of Letters and its scientific exchange. They do not move. The tavern market, at 400 houses in the 1640s, was probably saturated, so one coffeehouse should neither add taverns nor close them; had it done so, the coffeehouse would have coincided with a general increase in meeting places. Taverns do not respond. Commercial premises are the clearest exception: commercial activity was already rising before entry, consistent with coffeehouses following commerce. This pre-trend in commercial activity does not translate into a pre-trend in scientific activity, so it does not threaten parallel trends (Appendix C.3). Coffeehouses opened where commerce was dense (Section 4.1), and the parishes they entered also began with more practitioners and more instrument shops (Appendix Table C1). However, differences in levels threaten parallel trends only when they predict how scientific activity would have evolved without a coffeehouse (Baker et al.,2026). Two checks address this. First, descriptively, both scientific outcomes are balanced
The shares are computed by summing the estimated dynamic effects across treated parishes and post-treatment decades and then dividing by observed activity.
in changes between the 1600s–1610s and the 1630s–1640s, at absolute normalized differences below 0.1, and only taverns and commercial premises exceed 0.25, two placebos already examined above that do not explain the result (Appendix Table C2). Second, reweighting control parishes by their estimated probability of ever having a coffeehouse, based on pre-1652 taverns, tradesmen’s tokens, booksellers, and an indicator for the City, leaves both effects significant and stable (Appendix Figure C3). 40
Adjusting instead for the propensity score in each decade approximately halves the effects, with the effect on practitioners no longer significant. However, this test might be seen as too demanding, as the 13 parishes most likely to receive a coffeehouse have no comparable untreated parish (Appendix Figure C4andAppendix Table C3). We next compare the estimated main effects against a benchmark in which placebo first coffeehouses are randomly assigned across 61 parishes (the size of the treated group), from the 1650s to the 1690s. Across 1,000 such placebo samples, the post- treatment effects based on historical timing lie in the extreme upper tail of the placebo distributions for both outcomes, while the pre-treatment effects are centered near the medians (Appendix Figure C5). Because this benchmark places coffeehouses without regard to where they actually went, we repeat the exercise, drawing placebo locations to match the estimated probability of entry and preserving the observed entry decades. Again, thepost-treatment estimatesremain intheuppertail underthismoredemanding assignment (Appendix Figure C6). Observability bias bears less on instrument shops than on practitioners, but for both, survival and registration may depend on local prosperity. On the outcome side, we therefore restrict the sample to the 175 of 252 instrument makers with a recorded guild, since guilds enrolled makers as apprentices and freemen whatever later became of their shops. We estimate with and without separate trends for parishes exposed to the Great Fire, which destroyed many guild records. On the treatment side, we re-estimate after excluding, in turn, each broad and each finer category of source through which a coffeehouse is first recorded, and the post-entry averages stay between 0.62 and 0.83 practitioners and between 1.26 and 1.50 shops (Appendix Figures C8andC9). The estimates are broadly unchanged throughout (Appendix C.5). As a final exercise, matching the two rosters person by person links 93 of the 244 practitioners to one of the 252 makers, and estimating equation (1) separately on the two disjoint groups and on the overlap yields a positive and significant effect in each (Appendix C.6). This strengthens our statement that the main result is not an artifact of one source. Our last checks vary the design itself. We allow parishes exposed to the Great Fire of 1666, and parishes inside the London Wall, to follow separate nonparametric trends (Appendix C.4). We change how treatment is defined and timed, moving from decades to two-, three-, and five-year intervals, allowing treatment to switch off, and estimating the effect of closures (de Chaisemartin and D’Haultfoeuille,2026), which lower the number of mathematical practitioners (Appendix C.7). We change the unit and the standard errors, re-estimating on a hexagonal partition of the city and computing Conley(1999) standard errors (Appendix C.8). We change the control group and
40 We choose these four as the most direct measures of the commerce and book trade that coffeehouses followed, and with them every control parish scores within the range of the treated parishes. Other choices give similar estimates. Covariates selected by a cross-validated lasso among the 28 pre-1652 measures give 0.59 (s.e. 0.24) and 1.00 (s.e. 0.38), and adding the remaining measures of social capital and commerce with normalized differences above 0.25 (apothecaries, commercial premises, and dissenting meetings) gives 0.53 (s.e. 0.26) and 0.90 (s.e. 0.41).
the estimator, adding not-yet-treated parishes (Callaway and Sant’Anna,2021) and re-estimating under Poisson and inverse hyperbolic sine specifications (Appendix C.9). Finally, we remove differential trends and influential observations, detrending within treatment cohorts (Goodman-Bacon,2021), dropping each of the 162 parishes in turn, and bounding how far parallel trends could fail before the effects lose significance (Rambachan and Roth,2023;Appendix C.10). None changes the conclusion.
4.4.Taverns as a Placebo Treatment
Taverns, like inns and alehouses, had offered food, drink, lodging, and convivial exchange since the Middle Ages (Clark,1983). Coffeehouses, by contrast, were a novel institution. They were comparably low-cost and sociable public venues, but relative to taverns they centered on news, debate, and business, consequently attracting civil, curious, and cosmopolitan customers, including virtuosi engaged in learned discourse (Cowan,2005, p. 89). Scientific activity could and did occur in taverns (Stewart,1992,
p. 143), but historical scholarship more closely associates coffeehouses with the virtuosi and culture of experimental inquiry (Cowan,2005;Ellis,2004). AsCowan(2005,
p. 260) argues, the coffeehouse was “not simply one among many backdrops” like the traditional taverns, but “the product of the cultural world forged by the virtuosi in Britain’s age of scientific revolution.” Hooke’s diary also separates the coffeehouse from the tavern. The words he wrote after naming a coffeehouse characterize it as a place of discourse: against phrases that name no public house, the most overrepresented word pairs are “discoursed about,” “discoursd with,” “told me,” and “shewed his” (Figure 5, Panel A), while those after he named a tavern concern claret and payment (Panel B). On days he visited a coffeehouse, the diary also records mathematical practitioners and men in manual trades far more often than on days at a tavern (Appendix B.8).
(A)Coffeehouse (B)Tavern
Figure 5.What Hooke wrote after naming a coffeehouse or a tavern
*Notes:* Figure shows the word pairs most overrepresented in what Robert Hooke wrote after naming a coffeehouse (Panel A) or a tavern or other public house (Panel B) in his diary, 10 March 1672 to 15 May
1683. Entries are runs of short phrases separated by semicolons and periods. Each passage runs from the phrase naming the house to the end of the entry. The 3,291 coffeehouse passages are compared with the 15,102 phrases outside them that name no public house, using the weighted log-odds ratio ofMonroe et al.(2008); the 261 tavern passages are scored the same way, too few for Panel B to be more than an illustration. Spelling is Hooke’s. Word size increases with the score. Names of people and of public houses are removed. [Return to page23] This distinction motivates a test using new tavern openings as a placebo treatment. If
meeting places alone raised scientific activity, tavern openings should raise it too. Now, as tavern and coffeehouse counts are correlated once coffeehouses appear (Appendix Table C4), we focus on the 1550s–1640s, before coffeehouses existed.Figure 6reports the estimated effects of the first seventeenth-century tavern opening in this time period. Pre-trends are flat for scientific instrument shops but not for mathematical practitioners, whose numbers were already drifting upward where taverns opened, so a causal reading is not warranted there. If anything, as we read the practitioner estimates against the extrapolated pre-trend line, practitioners stop rising at the opening and fall further below the extended path with every decade. Yet instrument shops move the other way, with a positive but insignificant post-ATT of 0.11 (s.e. 0.07). Relative to the baseline mean of 0.11, that is an imprecise doubling that falls short of the precise and nearly fivefold increase over the same horizon after a first coffeehouse. Subtracting the estimated group-specific pre-trends rather than overlaying them gives the same conclusion (Appendix Figure B12). Full-period estimates, with strong pre-trends, are rather uninformative, but suggest no meaningful impact of taverns (Appendix Figure B11). Moreover, coffeehouses do not seem to matter for lack of other meeting places: before 1652, parishes that later received one already had 3.0 taverns on average, against 0.5 in other parishes (Appendix Table C1).
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops
.4 Post-ATT =−0.06 (s.e. 0.09)
.6 Post-ATT = 0.11 (s.e. 0.07)
| .2 | .4 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 (.43) | |||||||||
| .2 | |||||||||
| −.2 | |||||||||
| −.4 | 0 (.11) | ||||||||
| −.6 −5 | −4 −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −.2 −5 | −4 −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first tavern | Decades since first tavern |
Figure 6.Tavern effects on scientific activity
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of the first seventeenth-century tavern opening on scientific activity, with treatment effect heterogeneity restricted to event time. The dashed line extends a least squares fit to the estimates from five decades to one decade before the first tavern. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1550s to the 1640s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before the first tavern opened. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from the opening through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pages24,OA-19]
4.5.Spillovers and Creation versus Relocation
Thus far we have estimated the local effect of a coffeehouse, which leaves two questions on the table. First, coffeehouses may have raised activity in neighboring control parishes, aspeoplecouldreachacoffeehouseonfoot,whichwouldpushourparish-levelestimates downward (Butts,2023). Second, some of the activity we count may not have been created in treated parishes but moved there from elsewhere. To address the question of spillovers, we consider specifications on a partition of London into hexagons 200 meters wide, as parishes are too coarse to locate spillovers at
walking distance. At the level of these hexagons, we then compare the change from the 1640s to the 1690s in the hexagon that receives the coffeehouse, and in each 200-meter ring around it, with the change in hexagons more than 1,000 meters from any opening (Appendix Figure B2andAppendix Table B1). 41 Mathematical practitioners more than double, rising by 0.39 in the opening hexagon and 0.17 in its immediate neighbors on means of 0.24 and 0.08 in the 1640s. Scientific instrument shops rise by 1.20 and
0.12 on means of 0.07 and 0.05. Beyond 200 meters, the estimates are small and jointly indistinguishable from zero. Both series are also flat for five decades before the opening and rise after it (Appendix Figure B4).
42 We find the same range in a second check, which uses neither rings nor distant controls. We rebuild the grid with hexagon cells from 50 to 1,200 meters wide and re-estimate the baseline specification at the level of these cells. The effect per coffeehouse in the cell grows with cell width up to about 400 meters and then stays flat, plausibly because, by that point, a cell already holds everyone the coffeehouse reaches (Appendix Figure B3). Two implications follow. First, the parish-level estimates can understate the total effect of an opening: summed over the opening hexagon and its immediate neighbors, the effect by the 1690s is 0.77 mathematical practitioners and 1.47 scientific instrument shops, and about half of the practitioner response and a fifth of the shop response lie in the neighbors. Since most of those neighbors lie in parishes that the design counts as treated, most of their gain is already in the parish estimates. 43 Second, the aggregate shares inSection 4.2sum only effects within parishes. Hence, they miss the spillovers onto control parishes but count as gains any activity that merely moved into treated parishes from elsewhere in London. To address the question of creation versus relocation, we probe whether coffeehouses created scientific activity or relocated it. Three patterns favor creation. First, scientific activity grew both in London and elsewhere in England over the period, which weighs against London gaining only at the expense of the rest of the country (Appendix Figure D17). Second, if coffeehouses had only drawn activity from their immediate neighborhood, activity next to an opening would have fallen. The spillover estimates above show that it rose. Third, activity at a first recorded London location accounts for 84 percent of the post-ATT for practitioners and 62 percent for shops, and for shops, creation dates from the year a maker is first recorded, so it cannot come from moves between recorded London locations (Appendix Figure B5). 44 Moves from unrecorded locations, or from outside London, would still register as creation.
41 Averaging the baseline over the 1600s to the 1640s, all before the first coffeehouse, gives nearly identical estimates. 42 One shop coefficient beyond the first ring, at 400 to 600 meters, is significant at the 5 percent level on its own. The short range might seem surprising, but it fits the habits of Robert Hooke: 2,233 of the 2,915 located coffeehouse mentions in his diary lie within 400 meters of his lodgings (Appendix Figure B6). 43 The sums add the effect on the first ring of hexagons, weighted by the number of such neighbors per opening hexagon (2.26, that is, 172 neighbors of 76 opening hexagons), with standard errors of 0.25 and
0.31. They are totals per opening hexagon, which holds 3.8 coffeehouses over the century on average. Of these neighbors, 72 percent lie in parishes coded as treated. 44 That split does not count the losses in the parishes that people left. Counted at both ends, moves between recorded London locations account for 12 percent of the effect on practitioners and 15 percent of the effect on shops, since most ran between parishes that both had a coffeehouse (Appendix B.3).
5.MECHANISMS
Historical research points to several channels through which coffeehouses may have stimulated scientific contact and activity. First, the coffeehouses lowered the social costs of entering the public sphere of applied science, which widened access beyond estab- lished elites. Second, as open commercial settings, they brought natural philosophers who needed experimental instruments into geographic proximity with the craftsmen who made them. Third, this contact gave the craftsmen better knowledge of the demand for experimental instruments. In turn, these channels predict larger effects among applied scientists with weak family ties to Oxford and Cambridge, more connections that link craft skill to theory, and new shops that turn toward experimental instruments. We find evidence consistent with each of these predictions. Finally, we show that coffeehouses set practitioners into a wider ecology of applied science, raising their output, training, and institutional reach.
5.1.Lowering Barriers to Entry
Coffeehouses may have raised scientific activity by making knowledge that others already held cheaper to reach (Mokyr,2005, p. 312). They are remembered as “penny universities” (Ellis,1956); before their arrival, scientific interaction took place largely in private houses, from aristocratic great houses to the lodgings of individual gentlemen (Cowan,2005, p. 102;Shapin,1988, pp. 378–381). If coffeehouses relaxed these access constraints, effects should be stronger among practitioners with weaker family ties to elite institutions. FollowingClark and Cummins(2014), we proxy such ties by the baseline relative representation of a practitioner’s surname *𝑠* in the matriculation rolls of the universities of Oxford and Cambridge (Oxbridge):
<u>share of𝑠among Oxbridge matriculants before 1650</u> *𝑧*(*𝑠*)≡*.*(4) share of*𝑠*among English couples married 1538–1649
The denominator proxies the surname share in the adult English population. Higher values of*𝑧*(*𝑠*)indicate stronger ties. Surnames are observed for all 244 practitioners. 45
Figure 7shows the predicted pattern. Average post-treatment effects, measured
relative to the mean in the decade before entry, are concentrated among practitioners below the median of *𝑧*(*𝑠*) and smaller above it, by 0.99 times the pre-entry mean (s.e. 0.51; Panel A). Panel B estimates effects for the bottom *𝑥* percent of practitioners ranked by *𝑧*(*𝑠*), across values of *𝑥*: the effect declines from approximately 5 for the 16 percent of practitioners whose surnames never appear in the Oxbridge matriculation rolls to about
45 We observe paternal occupation, the more direct measure, for only 56 of the 244 practitioners, mostly from the biographies we link through Wikidata (Appendix D.4) and for a few fromTaylor(1954). For 42 more, a linked biography exists but does not give the father’s occupation, and the remaining 146 have no biography beyond Taylor’s brief entry. Paternal background may be of more interest, and *𝑧*(*𝑠*) captures it only in part: being built from surnames rather than from the household characteristics of each practitioner, it measures the elite intellectual background of a surname, and its values vary within paternal occupations.Appendix Figure D22plots the individual values of *𝑧*(*𝑠*) by paternal occupation, including those for whom it is unobserved. Fathers’ occupations track *𝑧*(*𝑠*): of the 20 practitioners whose fathers were gentry, clergymen, barristers, physicians, or magistrates, 17 lie above the median of *𝑧*(*𝑠*), against 19 of the 36 whose fathers had other occupations. However, since biographies are more likely to record the father of a prominent practitioner, and 36 of the 56 lie above the median, this check only speaks to the direction of*𝑧*(*𝑠*).
1.1 once the most represented are included. In shares, the bottom half by *𝑧*(*𝑠*) held 39 percent of the practitioners recorded in treated parishes in the decade before entry but accounts for 61 percent of the post-treatment effect (Appendix Figure B7).
(A)Below and above the median (B)Along the Lorenz curve Below median (0.25) Above median (0.38) 10 1
Δ= 0.99 (s.e. 0.51) 3 8 0.8 Post-ATT (relative) 2 6 0.6 Share of representation 1 4 0.4
0 2 0.2
−1 0 0 Pre Post Pre Post 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Bottom*𝑥*%of practitioners ranked by*𝑧*(*𝑠*)
Figure 7.Effects on mathematical practitioners by Oxbridge representation
*Notes:* Figure shows ATTs and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners, conditional on the relative representation *𝑧*(*𝑠*) of a practitioner’s surname *𝑠* at Oxbridge before 1650, as defined in equation (4). “Pre” and “Post” are the averages of the estimates two to five decades before entry and from entry through four decades after. Panel A splits practitioners by whether *𝑧*(*𝑠*) falls above or below the median. The parenthetical beside each label reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Δ is the difference between the designated post-treatment averages, estimated on the difference of the two relative outcomes. Panel B restricts to practitioners in the bottom *𝑥* percent of the empirical distribution of *𝑧*(*𝑠*); diamonds on the dashed line, read against the right axis, trace the Lorenz curve of Oxbridge representation: the share of summed *𝑧*(*𝑠*) that those practitioners hold. In both panels each outcome is divided by its mean in the decade before treatment. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pages26,28,31,OA-14,OA-15]
5.2.Connecting Theory and Practice
Coffeehouses may also have functioned as a decentralized institution that matched previously segmented knowledge communities: craftsmen trained in the guild system, who held prescriptive knowledge (knowledge how), and natural philosophers coming into science from Oxbridge, who held propositional knowledge (knowledge what). 47
This is the view ofEllis(2006, pp. x–xi), who portrays coffeehouses as spaces where virtuosi conducted business with instrument makers and where the experimental method was debated by the wider public. The second prediction is that coffeehouses increased social connections among practitioners, above all between the makers who produced instruments and the theorists
46 Pre-entry estimates are close to zero except for the bottom 16 and 20 percent, whose activity fell before entry. Net of group-specific trends, their effects are larger (Appendix Figure B8). 47 The distinction between propositional and prescriptive knowledge was made popular byMokyr (2002) and has more recently been studied in the history of science byKoschnick(2025a).
most likely to put them to use. Figure 8divides connections by the two practitioners they join and shows each effect as a multiple of its pre-entry mean. Connections as a whole rise by 1.21 (s.e. 0.62) times their pre-entry mean. Connections between makers and theorists rise by 1.63 times theirs, and connections among makers by more, while connections among theorists rise little and imprecisely, with pre-treatment estimates close to zero for all three. The rise between makers and theorists exceeds the rise among theorists by 1.04 (s.e. 0.48), though not the rise among makers. 50 Read together with the heterogeneity inFigure 7, this pattern is consistent with the matching the second channel predicts, although it does not isolate that channel.
All (2.07) Theorists (0.98) Makers (0.23) Makers–theorists (0.85)
Δ= 1.04 (s.e. 0.48)
−1 Pre Post Pre Post Pre Post Pre Post
Figure 8.Effects on connections by practitioner type
*Notes:* Figure shows ATTs and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on all connections (All) and on connections between two theoretically oriented practitioners (Theorists), between two scientific instrument makers (Makers), and between a maker and a theorist (Makers–theorists). Each connection is counted once in every parish where one of its two practitioners works. “Pre” and “Post” are the averages of the estimates two to five decades before entry and from entry through four decades after. The parenthetical beside each label reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Each outcome is divided by this mean. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Δ is the difference between the post-treatment averages of Makers–theorists and Theorists, estimated on the difference of the two relative outcomes. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pages28,31,OA-15]
Hooke’s diary shows what a coffeehouse day added to the company one practitioner
48 Theorists are the 114 practitioners who are not makers: 41 taught mathematics or navigation, 18 were surveyors, navigators, or hydrographers, and 10 held professorships.Taylor(1954) records study at Oxford or Cambridge for 23 of them, against 2 of the 130 makers (Appendix Table B2). 49 Much of this rise comes with the rise in practitioners: per practitioner working in the parish, connections rise by 0.36 times their pre-entry mean (s.e. 0.40). 50 More makers and theorists bring more connections even at an unchanged propensity to connect. Counting each connection at the end that works in the parish, the gap is 0.96 (s.e. 0.50). Net of the connections the extra makers and theorists would bring at the pre-entry rate per person, it is 0.79 (s.e. 0.41).
wrote down. On days he visited a coffeehouse, Hooke recorded meeting 5.69 people, against 2.92 on other days (Figure 9, Panel A). Comparing days in the same year and on the same weekday, Hooke recorded 2.23 more people on coffeehouse days (s.e. 0.12). Of these, 1.44 (s.e. 0.08), about two-thirds, were outside the Republic of Letters, a long-distance correspondence network of a learned elite (Panel B). On other days, 1.69 of the 2.92 people he recorded, 58 percent, were outside it. The mix changed little. The diary records only the people Hooke thought worth noting, and he wrote more 51 on coffeehouse days. Hooke might have met the extra people anyway, and the diary seldom says where he met them. Still, the company he recorded on coffeehouse days mixed social groups and knowledge communities.
(A)People recorded per day (B)Additional people on a coffeehouse day
8 Outside the network 3 In the network
2.23
6 5.69 2
1.44
4 3.48
2.92
1 0.79 2 1.69
2.21
1.22
0 0 Coffeehouse days Other days All In the network Outside it
Figure 9.Robert Hooke’s recorded company on coffeehouse days
*Notes:* Figure reports the number of people Robert Hooke records meeting on each day of his diary, 10 March 1672 to 15 May 1683: 3,464 days, 2,244 of them coffeehouse days. Panel A gives raw means on coffeehouse days and on other days, each split into people in the Republic of Letters, who sent at least one letter from London in the seventeenth century recorded in*Early Modern Letters Online*(Hotson and Lewis,
2024), and people outside it. Panel B reports the difference between coffeehouse days and other days from a regression with year-by-weekday fixed effects, for all people recorded and separately for those inside and outside the network, with 95 percent confidence intervals from heteroskedasticity-robust standard errors. The diary dates each meeting but seldom places it, so a coffeehouse day counts everyone Hooke records meeting that day, and only those he thought worth noting. [Return to pages29,OA-16,OA-17]
#### 5.3.Experimental Science
Publicly performed experiments stimulated interest in testing and demonstrating scientific theories using the new instruments of experimental inquiry (Shapin and Schaffer,1985;Stewart,1992). If coffeehouses brought theorists and makers into more frequent contact, makers could learn about theorists’ needs and encounter a larger market for instruments that made new phenomena visible and measurable. This yields the third prediction: coffeehouse entry should increase the supply of experimental instruments, not only established practical tools.
Figure 10compares average treatment effects on practical and experimental instru-
ment shops. Both types of shops rise after entry, and by about the same number:
Entries on coffeehouse days average 57 words, against 36 on other days. Per hundred words they still record more meetings, 11.6 against 8.5.
0.61 experimental and 0.54 practical shops per parish. Relative to its smaller base, the increase is larger for experimental instruments, 5.3 against 2.5 times the pre-entry mean, a difference of 2.76 (s.e. 1.18). The pattern is consistent with coffeehouses strengthening the link between experimental inquiry and the craftsmen who supplied its material tools.
Practical (0.21) Experimental (0.11)
Δ= 2.76 (s.e. 1.18) 8
−2 Pre Post Pre Post
Figure 10.Effects on scientific instrument shops by type
*Notes:* Figure shows ATTs and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on practical (mathematical, navigational, and surveying) and experimental (optical and philosophical) instrument shops. Treatment effect heterogeneity is restricted to event time, since with separate effects for each decade of entry, as in equation (1), the standard errors for experimental shops cannot be computed. “Pre” and “Post” are the averages of the estimates two to five decades before entry and from entry through four decades after. The parenthetical beside each label reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Each outcome is divided by this mean. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Δ is the difference between the designated post-treatment averages, estimated on the difference of the two relative outcomes. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pages29,31]
5.4.Putting Practitioners into Circulation
Historical scholarship portrays the coffeehouse as a meeting technology that turned proximity into knowledge exchange (Cowan,2005;Stewart,1999). The coffeehouse did not necessarily create the skills needed to become a “London mathematician,” but raised the chance that a potential entrant transitioned into applied science by placing him in the circulation of knowledge around applied mathematics and the instrument trade. Coffeehouse sociability was open in principle, but implicit norms steered conversation toward rational, polite, and evidence-based discussion (Ellis,2008). Within those norms, coffeehouses circulated codified knowledge, pamphlets and periodicals along with commercial intelligence, while demonstrations and learning from men who already had the relevant skills supplied tacit knowledge (Higgitt et al.,2024;Johns,2006). Figure11gatherstheevidencethatcoffeehousessetpractitionersintoawiderecology of applied science. For comparison, it repeats the main results ofSection 4.2. First,
*Panel A. Scientific activity* Mathematical practitioners Scientific instrument shops *Panel B. Oxbridge representation* Below-median practitioners Above-median practitioners *Panel C. Connections* All connections Between makers and theorists Among makers Among theorists *Panel D. Experimental science* Experimental instrument shops Practical instrument shops *Panel E. Training* Teachers and instrument masters Instrument masters’ apprentices Senior-to-junior connections *Panel F. Output* Dated works Net of the extra practitioners Distinct instrument classes Net of the extra makers *Panel G. Institutional reach* Royal Society fellows *Panel H. Dissemination* Booksellers
−2
*.*09(0*.*36)
3*.*78(0*.*93)
1*.*69(0*.*62)
0*.*70(0*.*26)
1*.*21(0*.*62)
1*.*63(0*.*80)
2*.*33(1*.*38)
0*.*59(0*.*53)
5*.*29(1*.*37)
2*.*53(0*.*89)
3*.*29(0*.*81)
3*.*53(1*.*37)
1*.*37(0*.*54)
2*.*23(0*.*96)
1*.*14(0*.*86)
1*.*62(0*.*33)
−2*.*16(0*.*75)
4*.*37(2*.*33)
0*.*43(0*.*17)
0 2 4 6 8 10
*Baseline mean*
0.62
0.33
0.25
0.38
2.07
0.85
0.23
0.98
0.11
0.21
0.26
0.21
0.93
0.70
0.70
0.28
0.28
0.15
1.79
PrePost
Figure 11.Effects on the wider ecology of applied science
*Notes:* Figure shows ATTs and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on each outcome. Panels A to D repeatFigures 4,7,8, and10. Net rows subtract the pre-entry rate per practitioner or per shop, so zero means a response at the rate of those already there. For experimental shops and fellows, treatment effect heterogeneity is restricted to event time, since with separate effects for each decade of entry their standard errors cannot be computed; practical shops are estimated the same way for comparison. Each outcome is divided by its baseline mean, the sample mean one decade before treatment, and each net row by that of its gross row. “Pre” and “Post” are the averages of the estimates two to five decades before entry and from entry through four decades after. The number beside each Post interval is the Post-ATT and its standard error.Appendix D.3 defines each outcome. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to page30]
practitioners and makers take on successors: teachers and instrument masters rise by 3.3 times their pre-entry mean, apprentices by 3.5 times, and links from senior to junior practitioners rise, suggesting that established practitioners drew younger ones in. Perhaps public experimental science at coffeehouses steered newcomers, bound as apprentices at about fourteen (Wallis,2025), into instrument making. Second, the practitioners’ dated works rise by 2.2 times their pre-entry mean. Per practitioner, dated works rise from 1.12 before entry to 2.29 for those gained after it, but the excess, plotted as the net row in Panel F, cannot be distinguished from zero. 52 In terms of other output, the range of instruments made in a parish grows, measured by the crafts recorded for its makers, because there are more shops rather than more versatile ones. Net of what the extra makers would bring at the pre-entry rate per shop, crafts fall short (−2.16,
s.e. 0.75). 53
Third, the effect reaches beyond practical science. Booksellers rise, 54 and so does the number of Fellows of the Royal Society, which rises the most relative to its own mean, albeit imprecisely. 55
6.EXTENSION TO EUROPE
Coffeehouses marked a shift toward open sociability with easier access in Europe more broadly (Albrecht,1989;Habermas,1991[1962], pp. 30–33). In London, that access clustered applied scientists around the coffeehouse parishes (Section 4). We ask whether the relationship between coffeehouses and applied science found in London extends to European cities, without claiming to identify the causal effect of a coffeehouse. Instead, we take the first coffeehouse in a city as a marker of a critical juncture in social change, as the arrival of the first social institution “where it was possible to establish a bourgeois-oriented public forum” (Albrecht,1989, p. 95). Such a forum may, as in London, have benefited practical science more broadly; in 1690s Hamburg one keeper styled his coffeehouse an “Academy” with “the special character of an assembly of Science” (Robilliard,2024, p. 159). To this end, we use new data on the first coffeehouses in 200 European cities in the seventeenth century, together with existing measures of applied science (Section 3). We focus on the parts of Europe never under Ottoman rule in the sixteenth or seventeenth centuries, where the coffeehouse was a private trade rather than an institution of the <u>ruler.</u> 56
52 Since both series are outcomes, the rate is an association rather than the output of one more practitioner holding everything else fixed. 53 Counting the distinct instruments each maker is recorded as making (Hay et al.,2025) gives the same pattern, a rise of 2.6 times the pre-entry mean (s.e. 1.25) and none net of the extra makers (−1.18, s.e. 0.73), although only 112 of 252 makers have such a record. 54 The rise comes late and from the ten parishes first treated in the 1650s: the estimates are 0.12, 0.11, and 0.15 in the decade of entry and the two after it, and none exceeds 0.17 once those parishes are dropped. 55 Fellows are rare and only observed from the 1660s, when the Royal Society was founded, with 337 records over 1,620 parish-decades, 133 of which contain one. Moreover, the count places a fellow where he died or was buried, as the workplace or residence is rarely known. Hence, the count is noisy and a long-run outcome, since a fellow may have settled near a coffeehouse late in life. 56 In the Ottoman lands the coffeehouse was in the hands of the ruler: building a grand coffeehouse was among the first things he did in a newly conquered city (Ellis,2004, p. 13), and in 1633 Murad IV, fearing the sedition plotted in coffeehouses, had those of Istanbul torn down; they stayed closed for decades (Hattox,2014, p. 102). The institution arrived in lands that were or soon became Ottoman a century earlier: Mecca (1511), Cairo (1532), and Constantinople (1554) against Western Europe in the
| Copenhagen | First coffeehouse | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hamburg | Gdansk | 1650s | ||
| London | Amsterdam | 1660s 1670s | ||
| 1680s | ||||
| Paris | Munich | Vienna | 1690s | |
| Lyon Marseille | Genoa Venice | Population in 1600(thousands) None | ||
| Rome | 10 100 | 300 |
1,000 km
Figure 12.Mapping the first coffeehouses in Europe
*Notes:* Map of Europe showing our sample of 200 cities. These are populated areas with at least 10,000 inhabitants in 1600 and a recorded population in 1500 inBosker et al.(2013). Circle area is population in 1600, and fill is the decade of the first recorded coffeehouse, gray for the 163 cities with no coffeehouse recorded in the seventeenth century. [Return to page32]
Figure 12maps the sample. Of the 200 cities, 37 record a coffeehouse in the
seventeenth century, from London in the 1650s to Paris in the 1670s and Munich in the 1690s. To compare them with the rest in terms of applied science, we take the two London outcomes to the city level (Section 3). Instrument makers recorded in a city stand in directly for instrument shops. Mathematical practitioners have no European counterpart, so applied mathematics titles printed in a city take their place.
Figure 13compares the 37 cities with a coffeehouse to the 163 without, by decade
relative to the first coffeehouse, estimating equation (1) at the city level and controlling for the growth of the city from 1500 to 1600 and its log population in 1600, each with a separate coefficient in every decade. Flat pre-trends support the comparison conditional on size and growth. 57 Panel A shows a persistent rise in applied mathematics titles. The 37 coffeehouse cities averaged 5.95 titles in the decade before entry, and the number is 4.97 (s.e. 2.30) higher over the decade of entry and the three decades after, close to a doubling. Panel B shows a persistent rise in instrument makers, by 4.89 (s.e. 2.97) on a baseline of 3.73, more than a doubling. We interpret these as conditional correlations, andAppendix C.11shows that they are largely stable. The titles difference holds whether the cities whose sources admit more than one entry decade are dated as early or as late as the sources allow, or dropped, at between 4.59 and 5.45 against 4.97 in the main estimate (Appendix Table C6), and it holds within countries, at 4.25 (s.e. 2.38). Nor do the differences rest on London alone. Over the first two decades after entry, the other coffeehouse cities print 2.29 more titles (s.e. 1.29) and record 0.91 more makers (s.e. 0.53), about two-fifths of their pre-entry
1650s (Ellis,2004, p. 259). The restriction removes cities in Bulgaria, Greece, Albania, Cyprus, Hungary, Romania, and the lands of the former Yugoslavia. 57 We fail to reject the null that the differences two to five decades before entry are jointly zero (*𝑝*=0*.*46 for titles and*𝑝*=0*.*33for makers).
(A)Applied mathematics titles (B)Scientific instrument makers
Post-ATT = 4.97 (s.e. 2.30) Post-ATT = 4.89 (s.e. 2.97)
10 10 5 0 (3.73) 0 (5.95)
−5 −10 −5 −4 −3 −2 −1 0 1 2 3 −5 −4 −3 −2 −1 0 1 2 3
| −5 | −4 −3 | −2 −1 | 0 1 | 2 3 | −5 | −4 −3 | −2 −1 | 0 1 | 2 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
Decades since first coffeehouse Decades since first coffeehouse
Figure 13.Coffeehouse cities relative to comparison cities of similar size and growth
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 90 (darker) and 95 (lighter) percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) at the city level. Outcomes are the decadal number of applied mathematics titles printed and scientific instrument makers recorded in a city. Controls added to equation (1) are log population in 1600 and growth from 1500 to 1600, each interacted with decade fixed effects. The window stops at three decades because only London and Rome are observed at four. Sample includes all 200 cities from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is city-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through three decades after. Standard errors clustered by city. [Return to pages 33,OA-21,OA-47]
58 means. If the association reflects coffeehouses drawing new entrants into science, and not just city size, it should be strongest where the new science already had readers. We locate them with the census byGingerich(2002) of every known copy of Copernicus’s*De* *revolutionibus*(1543), the heliocentric treatise conventionally taken to open the Scientific Revolution (Jacob,1988, p. 256). Holding a copy in 1620 has little to do with size: 10 of the 19 coffeehouse cities at or above the median population in 1600 do, against 7 of the 18 below it. Among the large cities, the post-entry difference in titles is 18.20 (s.e. 7.40) where a copy was held and 1.26 (s.e. 1.63) where none was, and among the small neither group shows a rise (Appendix B.11andAppendix Table B3). The association thus appears where a larger stock of potential entrants into science already existed. We take these results as evidence that the London pattern is not peculiar to London. Thesameinstitution, in37citiesacrosstencountries, comeswiththesametwooutcomes moving with entry, with the same timing and magnitudes of the same order. They also bear on the worry that coffeehouses simply relocated scientists: activity shifting between London parishes is easy to imagine, but between London, Paris, and Munich it is harder.
7.AGGREGATE IMPLICATIONS FOR LONDON
The event studies ofSections 4and6measure what a coffeehouse on average did to a London parish or a European city. The parish estimates do not account for moves within London, and the decade fixed effects absorb whatever coffeehouses did for London as a whole. The city estimate gives the average difference after the first coffeehouse in a city, abstracting from London’s coffeehouse geography. To get at what this geography did to
We use the first two decades here because the third rests on the eight cities that opened a coffeehouse by the 1660s, seven once London is left out.Appendix Table C5reports both windows.
London’s science as a whole, we move beyond these estimates with a standard modern quantitative urban model (Redding,2025), calibrated to both sets of estimates and detailed inAppendix E. What we add is a meeting technology behind its agglomeration force, estimated from documented connections and shifted by the coffeehouse. Our model consists of two blocks. The first says how often scientists meet and what a coffeehouse does to that rate. The second says who takes up science and where they work, given what meetings are worth. Formally, the first block conceptualizes the coffeehouse as a meeting technology: each applied scientist in parish *𝑝* meets each in parish *𝑞*, *𝑑𝑝𝑞*kilometers away, at a Poisson rate proportional to *𝑒* *𝜙𝐷𝑝𝑡* *𝑒* −*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞* *𝑒* *𝜙𝐷𝑞𝑡*, with *𝐷𝑝𝑡*=1 if *𝑝* has a coffeehouse in decade *𝑡* (Assumption E.1). Each coffeehouse multiplies the rate by *𝑒* *𝜙* because it puts the scientists of its parish into circulation, drawing them socially and intellectually into a public sphere of knowledge exchange around the new experimental science (Section 5.4). Thus, a coffeehouse at the other end adds to the first rather than competing with it. If each meeting is documented independently of everything else, the number of connections *𝑇𝑝𝑞𝑡*documented between parishes *𝑝* and *𝑞* follows the gravity equation (Theorem E.1)
##### E[𝑇𝑝𝑞𝑡]=exp ln𝑆𝑝𝑡+ln𝑆𝑞𝑡−𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞+𝜙(𝐷𝑝𝑡+𝐷𝑞𝑡)+𝜇𝑡,(5)
with *𝑆𝑝𝑡*parish *𝑝*’s scientists, the combined de-duplicated roster of 403 drawn from the 244 mathematical practitioners and 252 scientific instrument makers ofSection 3, and *𝜇𝑡* a decade fixed effect for how often meetings are documented. Estimating equation (5) by Poisson pseudo-maximum likelihood on the 244 practitioners’ connections gives *𝜙*=0*.*554 and *𝛿*=0*.*277. Thus, a coffeehouse multiplies the rate at which its parish’s scientists meet by 1*.*74, and the rate halves with every 2*.*5 kilometers of distance, which keeps most meetings local. Thesecondblockassumesachoicemodelthatgovernsentryintoscienceandlocation choices of scientists. Scientists locate where the return to practicing is highest, and that return rises with the meetings a parish offers. Entry into science in the first place rises with the expected return the parishes offer together. The two elasticities estimated below, *𝛽*
| for parish location and 𝛽 | for entry into science, measure these responses. | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑃 | 𝑝𝑡 𝑡 𝜀𝑃 1/𝜀 | 𝜙𝐷𝑝𝑡 𝜈 𝑃 | 𝑆 𝑞 −𝛿𝑑 𝜈 𝑝𝜈 | 𝑝𝑡 𝑝𝑞𝜙𝐷𝑞𝑡𝑞𝑡 𝜈 𝜈 | 𝜂 𝑝𝑡 𝑝𝑡 𝑝𝑡 𝑝 𝑝𝑡 𝜈 𝜀𝑃 | −𝛾 𝑝𝑡 𝑝𝜈 |
| 𝑡 | 𝑘 𝑘𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 |
Here, the return to practicing in parish *𝑝* is *𝑅* =*𝜓 𝐾 𝑆*. It rises at elasticity *𝜂* Í with the parish’s access *𝐾* =*𝑒 𝑒 𝑒 𝑆*, proportional to the meetings each scientist there expects, and, conditional on access, falls at elasticity *𝛾* with those already there, who compete for its premises. The fundamental *𝜓* makes the parish attractive apart from access. Given these quantities, (i) whether a potential entrant *𝜈* practices and (ii) where,*𝑝𝜈*, are given by
*𝜈*practices if*𝑉 𝜁₁ > 𝑢𝜁₀, 𝑝* =arg max *𝑅 𝜉* if it does*,*(6)
with *𝑢* the outside trade’s payoff and *𝜉* and (*𝜁₀,𝜁₁*) Fréchet tastes of shapes *𝜀𝑃*and *𝜀𝑆*, respectively (Assumption E.2). Solving backward, the parish choice gives the value Í of practice*𝑉* =( *𝑅*). Parish*𝑝*’s share is*𝜎* ∝*𝑅* (Theorem E.2).
These blocks lead to two equations, for where scientists work and for how many there are, used for estimation and counterfactuals. The first is given by substituting *𝜀* *𝑃*˜ *𝑆𝑝𝑡*=*𝜎𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑡*and *𝐾𝑝𝑡*=*𝜅𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑡*into *𝜎𝑝𝑡*∝*𝑅* *𝑝𝑡* : ln*𝜎𝑝𝑡*=*𝛽𝑃*ln*𝜅𝑝𝑡*+ln*𝜓𝑝𝑡*+*𝑐𝑡*, with *𝜅𝑝𝑡*
*𝜀* *𝑃* /(1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃*) access in shares *𝜎𝑞𝑡 𝑝𝑡*
| , 𝜓˜ =𝜓 | , 𝛽 =𝜀 | 𝜂/(1+𝛾𝜀 | ), and 𝑐 | common to all parishes | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑞𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑃 | 𝑃 | 𝑃 | 𝑡 |
| 𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 𝜂 −𝛾 𝑡 𝑡 | 𝑃 | 𝑡 𝑃 | |||
| 𝑡 𝑡 𝜀𝑆 | 𝑡 | 𝑆 𝑡 | 𝑡 | 𝑡 | 𝑡 𝑝 𝑝𝑡 | 𝛽 𝑝𝑡𝑃1/𝛽𝑃 |
| 𝑆 | 𝑆 | 𝑡 |
*𝑝𝑡 𝑃 𝑃 𝑃 𝑡* (Theorem E.3). The event study’s decade fixed effects absorb *𝑐*, so it sees only shares moving with access at elasticity *𝛽*. Indirect inference picks *𝛽* =0*.*560, at which the event study on the model’s parish counts, built from London’s observed totals and coffeehouses, with each *𝜓*˜ inverted from its 1600–1640 share and frozen, best matches the post-entry coefficients on the combined roster (Appendix Figure E1). The second is given by *𝑉* = *𝐾 𝑆*, which the shares imply, and, with a large pool of potential Í ˜ entrants, *𝑆* ∝*𝑉* : ln*𝑆* =*𝛽* ln*𝐾* + *𝑐*, with *𝐾* =*𝑆* ( *𝜓 𝜅*) London’s average access, *𝛽𝑆*=*𝜀 𝜂*/(1+*𝛾𝜀*), and *𝑐* set by the pool and the outside payoff (Corollary E.1).
250 Observed Charles II ban of 1675 in force Counterfactual, before the ban Counterfactual, under the ban 200 −33%
150 −35%
0 1650s 1660s 1670s 1680s 1690s Decade
Figure 14.London’s applied scientists with and without the ban of 1675
*Notes:* FigureplotsLondon’sobservedappliedscientists,thecombinedrosterofmathematicalpractitioners and scientific instrument makers, by decade and the counterfactual number the model gives with every coffeehouseclosedinthe1680sand1690s,at*𝛽𝑆*=0*.*39,theaverageofthetwocityestimates(ProcedureE.4). The counterfactual equals the observed count until the ban, and the labels give its shortfall under the ban in percent. [Return to page37]
To quantify the aggregate implications, we consider a counterfactual, marked by primes, that changes each decade’s coffeehouse geography but not its fundamentals. Taking a coffeehouse away lowers access in its parish and London’s average access. The first moves scientists out of the parish at elasticity *𝛽𝑃*, and the second lowers entry at elasticity *𝛽𝑆 𝑝𝑡 𝑡*
| . In ratios to the observed decade, 𝜓˜ | and 𝑐 | cancel and the equations | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑆 | 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑡 | |||||
| ′ | ′ | 𝛽𝑃 | ′ | 𝛽𝑆 | |||
| 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑡 𝑡 | 1−𝛽𝑆 | 𝑡 | |
| 𝑝 𝑝𝑡 | ′ 𝑝𝑡 𝑝𝑡 | 𝛽𝑃1/𝛽𝑃 ′𝑝𝑡 | 𝑡 𝑡 | ||||
| 𝑆 | 𝜙 | 𝑃 | 𝑆 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑡 |
become *𝜎* /*𝜎* = *𝜅* /(*𝑀 𝜅*)*,*ln(*𝑆* /*𝑆*)= ln*𝑀,*(7) Í with *𝑀𝑡*=( *𝜎* (*𝜅* /*𝜅*)) the change in *𝐾* /*𝑆*, average access in shares (The- orems E.8andE.10). As *𝜅* depends on the new shares, the first equation is a fixed point, solved uniquely from the observed counts, *𝜙*, *𝛿*, and *𝛽* (Theorem E.5), and the second the total from *𝛽*. No comparison within London sees *𝛽*, but the first coffeehouse in a city can, absent migration between cities. If it reaches the whole city, it multiplies every pair’s rate by *𝑒* at each end and every *𝜅* by *𝑀* =*𝑒²* *𝜙*, so
by (7) the city’s log count rises by 2*𝜙𝛽𝑆*/(1−*𝛽𝑆*). The treated cities ofSection 6rise from a pre-entry mean base to base+*𝑏*, and calibrating the model to these moments, *𝜙𝛽𝑆*/(1−*𝛽𝑆*)=ln([*𝑏*+base]/base), gives *𝛽𝑆*=0*.*35 for applied mathematics titles and
0*.*43for instrument makers. At the average *𝛽𝑆*=0*.*39, removing every coffeehouse in the 1650s to 1690s would have cost London 243 of 797 scientists counted decade by decade, 31 percent (Appendix Table E1). Coffeehouse parishes would have lost 182, 23 percent to other parishes and 77 percent to the outside trade, and the others, losing access too, a net61(Theorem E.11). The implications are illustrated byFigure 14, which shows what would have happened if Charles II’s proclamation of 29 December 1675, forbidding the retail sale of coffee from 10 January 1676, had not been suspended on 8 January (Cowan,2005, pp. 196–198). London would have had 106 scientists in the 1680s and 150 in the 1690s, 35 and 33 percent fewer, respectively, if nothing had replaced the coffeehouses.
### 8.CONCLUSION
This paper examines the effects of coffeehouses on science in seventeenth-century London. Using newly digitized geocoded panel data and a staggered event study across parishes, we find that the first coffeehouse in a parish was followed by a persistent increase in the number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops. Pre-trends, local commercial booms, and the survival of records do not explain the increase. Earlier tavern openings rooted in traditional English sociability produce no comparable increase. Moreover, positive spillovers onto the immediate neighborhood of an opening weigh against simple displacement. Consistent with the London result, across European cities, applied mathematics titles and instrument makers rise after the first coffeehouse. To get at the aggregate implications, we calibrate a quantitative urban model to the reduced-form parish- and city-level estimates and find that coffeehouses account for 31 percent of London’s applied scientists, counted decade by decade. These results inform us about the importance of broadening access to intellectual exchange for the production and use of knowledge. First, effects are largest among practitioners whose surnames were least represented at Oxford and Cambridge, so science drew on a reserve of talent beyond the learned elite. Second, connections between instrument makers and theoretically oriented practitioners rise. Third, shops making experimental instruments rise proportionally faster than practical ones, from a smaller base. These patterns are consistent with coffeehouses drawing science out of purely scholarly circles and into the tacit skills of London’s instrument trade. These results also add to the economic history of England. Arriving in London in 1652, at the onset of modern growth, the coffeehouse raised scientific activity where it opened, and the applied scientists we count are among the skilled implementers that some accounts place at the center of Britain’s later technological change (Meisenzahl and Mokyr,2012;Mokyr,2016). Though our data do not reach that change, they show how coffeehouses turned proximity into exchange across divided knowledge communities when experimental philosophy needed what craftsmen knew. Coffeehouses, then, fell on the fertile ground of the Scientific Revolution, and by making science more open and more connected, accelerated its applied side. More than three centuries later, what lessons can we draw from these results? Key features of the historical context are still with us, as a reserve of talent lies outside formal
academic networks. For example, in the United States, children from below-median- income families become inventors at one-tenth the rate of those from top-1-percent families(Belletal.,2019), andacrosstheglobe, olympiadmathematicianswouldpublish 10 percent more if those from poorer countries matched equally scoring peers from rich ones (Agarwal and Gaule,2020). That figure counts only talent already discovered, whereas, in our model, coffeehouses also added talent that would otherwise have been “lost Newtons.” Furthermore, the exchange that coffeehouses fostered between those who understood the formal theories and those who could build the tools to test them now runs between universities and firms: most patents that cite science directly are held by firms, and most of the papers they cite come from universities (Ahmadpoor and Jones,2017). Geographic proximity has mattered, and still matters, for such connections (e.g.,Andrews,2023;Jaffe et al.,1993;Kantor and Whalley,2019). Social institutions that make it cheaper to learn from others can therefore widen who produces knowledge and increase the number of such fruitful connections. We conclude with three potential extensions of this work and directions for future research. First, we are testing whether coffeehouses changed the content of knowledge. Only 87 of our 244 practitioners have a printed work, too few to compare parishes by what they wrote, so we compare cities. We are focusing on the content of the books printed in each, measured by their titles or full text. Second, the closed societies that arose in the eighteenth century, such as coffeehouses that became private clubs (Ellis,
2004) and Masonic lodges that met in taverns (Lane,1895), could show whether shutting outsiders out reversed what the open coffeehouse did. Third, tracing apprentices, whomHay et al.(2025) record into the nineteenth century, could show whether shops in coffeehouse parishes taught more of the skills of the instrument-making trade that would turn out to be beneficial to later industrialization (Kelly et al.,2023;Meisenzahl and Mokyr,2012). For modern times, the café remains the archetype of whatOldenburg(1989) calls a “third place,” neither home nor work. Sociologists have long studied how such places form social ties (Small and Adler,2019), and a smaller literature links them to innovation (Gagliardi and Roche,2026;Roche,2020). Yet, to the best of our knowledge, no study on contemporary data estimates whether the opening of such a venue changes who enters science. In seventeenth-century London, by our estimates, the coffeehouse drew outsiders into science for a penny.
### REFERENCES
Agarwal, Ruchir and Patrick Gaule(2020) “Invisible Geniuses: Could the Knowledge Frontier Advance Faster?,”*American Economic Review: Insights*, 2 (4), 409–424, 10.125 7/aeri.20190457. [Referenced on pages1and38] Ahmadpoor, Mohammad and Benjamin F. Jones(2017) “The Dual Frontier: Patented Inventions and Prior Scientific Advance,”*Science*, 357 (6351), 583–587, 10.1126/scie nce.aam9527. [Referenced on page38] Albrecht, Peter(1989) “Coffee-Drinking as a Symbol of Social Change in Continental Europe in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,”*Studies in Eighteenth-Century* *Culture*, 18, 91–103. [Referenced on page32] Almelhem, Ali, Murat Iyigun, Austin Kennedy, and Jared Rubin(2026) “Enlightenment Ideals and Belief in Progress in the Run-up to the Industrial Revolution: A Textual
Analysis,”*The Quarterly Journal of Economics*, 141 (1), 263–314, 10.1093/qje/qjaf054. [Referenced on pages2and6] Andrews, Michael(2026) “Bar Talk: Informal Social Networks, Alcohol Prohibition, and Invention,” 10.2139/ssrn.3489466, Working paper, August 2026; SSRN 3489466. [Referenced on page6] Andrews, Michael J.(2023) “How Do Institutions of Higher Education Affect Local Invention? Evidence from the Establishment of US Colleges,”*American Economic* *Journal: Economic Policy*, 15 (2), 1–41, 10.1257/pol.20200320. [Referenced on page 38] Andrews, Michael and Chelsea Lensing(2024) “Cup of Joe and Knowledge Flow: CoffeeShopsandInvention,” https://ssrn.com/abstract=4919452, SSRNworking paper 4919452. [Referenced on page6] Arzaghi, Mohammad and J. Vernon Henderson(2008) “Networking off Madison Avenue,”*Review of Economic Studies*, 75 (4), 1011–1038,10.1111/j.1467-937X.2008
.00499.x. [Referenced on page6]
Atkin, David, M. Keith Chen, and Anton Popov(2022) “The Returns to Face-to-Face Interactions: Knowledge Spillovers in Silicon Valley,” NBER Working Paper 30147, National Bureau of Economic Research,10.3386/w30147. [Referenced on page6] Baker, Andrew, Brantly Callaway, Scott Cunningham, Andrew Goodman-Bacon, and Pedro H. C. Sant’Anna(2026) “Difference-in-Differences Designs: A Practitioner’s Guide,”*Journal of Economic Literature*, 64 (2), 498–557, 10.1257/jel.20251650. [Referenced on page21] Beeley, Philip(2017) “’To the Publike Advancement’: John Collins and the Promotion of MathematicalKnowledgeinRestorationEngland,”*BSHMBulletin: JournaloftheBritish* *Society for the History of Mathematics*, 32 (1), 61–74, 10.1080/17498430.2017.1278829. [Referenced on page12] (2019) “Practical Mathematicians and Mathematical Practice in Later Seven- teenth-Century London,”*The British Journal for the History of Science*, 52 (2), 225–248,
10.1017/S0007087419000207. [Referenced on page12]
Bell, Alex, Raj Chetty, Xavier Jaravel, Neviana Petkova, and John Van Reenen(2019) “Who Becomes an Inventor in America? The Importance of Exposure to Innovation,” *Quarterly Journal of Economics*, 134 (2), 647–713, 10.1093/qje/qjy028. [Referenced on pages1,6, and38] Bergeaud, Antonin, Arthur Guillouzouic, Emeric Henry, and Clément Malgouyres (2025) “From Public Labs to Private Firms: Magnitude and Channels of Local R&D Spillovers,”*Quarterly Journal of Economics*, 140 (4), 3233–3282, 10.1093/qje/qjaf034. [Referenced on page6] Berkes, Enrico, Matthew Lee Chen, and Matteo Tranchero(2026) “300 Years of British Patents,”*Research Policy*, 55 (1), 105347. [Referenced on page2] Berkes, Enrico and Peter Nencka(2026) “Knowledge Access: The Effects of Carnegie Libraries on Innovation,”*The Review of Economics and Statistics*, 108 (4), 967–982,
10.1162/rest_a_01446. [Referenced on pages2and6]
Borusyak, Kirill, Xavier Jaravel, and Jann Spiess(2024) “Revisiting Event-Study Designs: Robust and Efficient Estimation,”*Review of Economic Studies*, 91 (6), 3253– 3285,10.1093/restud/rdae007. [Referenced on page19] Bosker, Maarten, Eltjo Buringh, and Jan Luiten Van Zanden(2013) “From Baghdad to London: Unraveling Urban Development in Europe, the Middle East, and North
Africa, 800–1800,”*Review of Economics and Statistics*, 95 (4), 1418–1437. [Referenced on pages17and33] Boudreau, Kevin J, Tom Brady, Ina Ganguli, Patrick Gaule, Eva Guinan, Anthony Hollenberg, and Karim R Lakhani(2017) “A Field Experiment on Search Costs and the Formation of Scientific Collaborations,”*The Review of Economics and Statistics*, 99
(4), 565–576. [Referenced on page6]
Bourdieu, Pierre(1986) “The Forms of Capital,” in John G. Richardson ed.*Handbook* *of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education*, 241–258, New York: Greenwood. [Referenced on page1] Bouscasse, Paul, Emi Nakamura, and Jón Steinsson(2025) “When Did Growth Begin? New Estimates of Productivity Growth in England from 1250 to 1870,”*The Quarterly* *Journal of Economics*, 140 (2), 835–888, 10.1093/qje/qjae046. [Referenced on pages6 and7] Broman, Thomas(1998) “The Habermasian Public Sphere and “Science in the Enlight- enment”,”*History of Science*, 36 (2), 123–149. [Referenced on page13] Bryden, D. J.(1992) “Evidence from Advertising for Mathematical Instrument Making in London, 1556–1714,”*Annals of Science*, 49 (4), 301–336, 10.1080/00033799200200281. [Referenced on page11] Butts, Kyle(2023) “Difference-in-Differences with Spatial Spillovers,” https://arxiv. org/abs/2105.03737, arXiv preprint 2105.03737. [Referenced on page24] Callaway, Brantly and Pedro H. C. Sant’Anna(2021) “Difference-in-Differences with Multiple Time Periods,”*Journal of Econometrics*, 225 (2), 200–230. [Referenced on pages19and23] Campos, Raquel, Fernanda Leon, and Ben McQuillin(2018) “Lost in the Storm: The Academic Collaborations That Went Missing in Hurricane ISSAC,”*Economic Journal*, 128 (610), 995–1018,10.1111/ecoj.12566. [Referenced on page6] Carlino, Gerald and William R. Kerr(2015) “Agglomeration and Innovation,” in Gilles Duranton, J. Vernon Henderson, and William C. Strange eds.*Handbook of Regional and* *Urban Economics*, Vol. 5, 349–404, Amsterdam: Elsevier, 10.1016/B978-0-444-59517 -1.00006-4. [Referenced on page6] Catalini, Christian(2018) “Microgeography and the Direction of Inventive Activity,” *Management Science*, 64 (9), 4348–4364. [Referenced on page6] Cervellati, Matteo, Sara Lazzaroni, Gianni Marciante, and Paolo Masella(2026) “The Rise of the Knowledge Economy,” CEPR Discussion Paper 21550, Centre for Economic Policy Research. [Referenced on page6] de Chaisemartin, Clément and Xavier D’Haultfoeuille(2020) “Two-Way Fixed Effects Estimators with Heterogeneous Treatment Effects,”*American Economic Review*, 110
(9), 2964–2996,10.1257/aer.20181169. [Referenced on page19] (2026) “Difference-in-Differences Estimators of Intertemporal Treatment Ef- fects,”*Review of Economics and Statistics*, 108 (4), 863–880, 10.1162/rest_a_01414. [Referenced on page22]
Chen, Jiafeng and Jonathan Roth(2024) “Logs with Zeros? Some Problems and Solutions,”*The Quarterly Journal of Economics*, 139 (2), 891–936. [Referenced on page 19] Cinnirella, Francesco, Erik Hornung, and Julius Koschnick(2025) “Flow of Ideas: Economic Societies and the Rise of Useful Knowledge,”*The Economic Journal*, 135 (669), 1496–1535. [Referenced on pages2and6]
City of London Magistrates(1663) “An accompt of Coffee Houses in the severall wards taken in May 1663,” https://layersoflondon.humap.site/map/records/acco unts-of-coffee-houses-in-several-wards-taken-in-may-1663, Accessed 2 February, 2026. [Referenced on pages9and14] Clark, Gregory(2026) “What Were the British Earnings and Prices Then? (New Series),” http://www.measuringworth.com/ukearncpi/,Accessed16June,2026. [Referenced on page9] Clark, Gregory and Neil Cummins(2014) “Surnames and Social Mobility in England, 1170–2012,”*Human Nature*, 25, 517–537. [Referenced on page26] Clark, Peter(1983)*The English Alehouse: A Social History, 1200–1830*, London: Longman. [Referenced on page23] (2000)*British Clubs and Societies 1580–1800: The Origins of an Associational World*, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Referenced on pages1and7] Clifton, Gloria(1991) “Project Simon: A Computer Database of Scientific-Instrument Makers,”*Interdisciplinary Science Reviews*, 16 (1), 16, 10.1179/isr.1991.16.1.16. [Referenced on page16] (1995)*Directory of British Scientific Instrument Makers, 1550–1851*, London: Zwemmer in association with the National Maritime Museum. [Referenced on pages 3and16] Conley, Timothy G(1999) “GMM Estimation with Cross Sectional Dependence,”*Journal* *of Econometrics*, 92 (1), 1–45. [Referenced on page22] Cormack,LesleyB(2017)“MathematicsforSale: MathematicalPractitioners,Instrument Makers, and Communities of Scholars in Sixteenth-Century London,” in Lesley B Cormack, Steven A Walton, and John A Schuster eds.*Mathematical Practitioners and* *the Transformation of Natural Knowledge in Early Modern Europe*, 69–85, Cham: Springer. [Referenced on page7] Cowan, Brian(2001) “What Was Masculine About the Public Sphere? Gender and the Coffeehouse Milieu in Post-Restoration England,”*History Workshop Journal*, 51 (1), 127–157. [Referenced on page10] (2005)*The Social Life of Coffee: The Emergence of the British Coffeehouse*, Yale University Press. [Referenced on pages1,3,5,8,9,10,14,23,26,30, and37] (2007) “Publicity and Privacy in the History of the British Coffeehouse,”*History* *Compass*, 5 (4), 1180–1213. [Referenced on page14] Cox, Gary W. and Valentin Figueroa(2025) “Agglomeration and Creativity in Early Modern Britain,”*Explorations in Economic History*, 95, 101644, 10.1016/j.eeh.2024
.101644. [Referenced on page6]
Crawforth, M. A.(1987) “Instrument Makers in the London Guilds,”*Annals of Science*, 44 (4), 319–377,10.1080/00033798700200261. [Referenced on page11] de la Croix, David, Matthias Doepke, and Joel Mokyr(2018) “Clans, Guilds, and Markets: Apprenticeship Institutions and Growth in the Preindustrial Economy,”*The* *Quarterly Journal of Economics*, 133 (1), 1–70, 10.1093/qje/qjx026. [Referenced on page7] de la Croix, David, Rossana Scebba, and Chiara Zanardello(2025) “Flora, Cosmos, Sal- vatio: Pre-modern Academic Institutions and the Spread of Ideas,” CEPR Discussion Paper 20569, Centre for Economic Policy Research. [Referenced on page6] Cummins, Neil, Morgan Kelly, and Cormac Ó Gráda(2016) “Living Standards and Plague in London, 1560–1665,”*The Economic History Review*, 69 (1), 3–34. [Referenced on page16]
Dittmar, Jeremiah E.(2011) “Information Technology and Economic Change: The Impact of the Printing Press,”*The Quarterly Journal of Economics*, 126 (3), 1133–1172,
10.1093/qje/qjr035. [Referenced on page6] (2019) “The Economic Origins of Modern Science: Technology, Institutions, and Markets,” Unpublished. [Referenced on page6]
Dowey, James(2017)*Mind over Matter: Access to Knowledge and the British Industrial* *Revolution*, Ph.D. dissertation, London School of Economics and Political Science. [Referenced on page6] Ellis, Aytoun(1956)*The Penny Universities: A History of the Coffee-Houses*, London: Secker & Warburg. [Referenced on pages1and26] Ellis, Markman(2004)*The Coffee-House: A Cultural History*, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson. [Referenced on pages9,23,32,33, and38] ed. (2006)*Eighteenth Century Coffee-House Culture*, Vol. 4, London: Pickering & Chatto. [Referenced on pages2,14, and27] (2008) “An Introduction to the Coffee-House: A Discursive Model,”*Language* *& Communication*, 28, 156–164, 10.1016/j.langcom.2008.01.004. [Referenced on page30] Fischer, Stefan, Jörg Knappen, Katrin Menzel, and Elke Teich(2020) “The Royal Society Corpus 6.0: Providing 300+ Years of Scientific Writing for Humanistic Study,” in*Proceedings of the Twelfth Language Resources and Evaluation Conference*, 794–802, Marseille: European Language Resources Association. [Referenced on page16] Fleck, Ludwik(1979)*Genesis and Development of a Scientific Fact*, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, Edited by Thaddeus J. Trenn and Robert K. Merton, translated by Fred Bradley and Thaddeus J. Trenn; first published in German in 1935. [Referenced on page6] Fluegge, Robert B. and Michael Bailey(2024) “Where Do Friends Matter for Founders? The Role of Social Connections in U.S. Entrepreneurship,” 10.2139/ssrn.4910633, SSRN working paper 4910633. [Referenced on page6] Gagliardi, Luisa and Maria P. Roche(2026) “Parks and Invention,” Working Paper26- 052, Harvard Business School. [Referenced on page38] Galofré-Vilà, Gregori(2023) “The Diffusion of Knowledge during the British Industrial Revolution,”*Social Science History*, 47 (2), 167–188. [Referenced on page6] Gingerich, Owen(2002)*An Annotated Census of Copernicus’ De revolutionibus (Nuremberg,* *1543 and Basel, 1566)*, Leiden: Brill. [Referenced on page34] Glaeser, Edward L.(1999) “Learning in Cities,”*Journal of Urban Economics*, 46 (2), 254–277,10.1006/juec.1998.2121. [Referenced on page6] Glaeser, Edward L., Hedi D. Kallal, José A. Scheinkman, and Andrei Shleifer(1992) “Growth in Cities,”*Journal of Political Economy*, 100 (6), 1126–1152. [Referenced on page1] Goldfarb, Avi and Catherine Tucker(2019) “Digital Economics,”*Journal of Economic* *Literature*, 57 (1), 3–43,10.1257/jel.20171452. [Referenced on page6] Goodman-Bacon, Andrew(2021) “Difference-in-Differences with Variation in Treatment Timing,”*Journal of Econometrics*, 225 (2), 254–277. [Referenced on pages19and23] Habermas, Jürgen(1991)*The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: An Inquiry* *into a Category of Bourgeois Society*, Cambridge: MIT Press, Original work published
1962. [Referenced on pages1,7,9, and32]
Hanlon, W. Walker(2025) “The Rise of the Engineer: Inventing the Professional Inventor During the Industrial Revolution,”*The Economic Journal*, 135 (670), 1749– 1781,10.1093/ej/ueaf023. [Referenced on page7] Hanlon, W. Walker, Stephan Heblich, Ferdinando Monte, and Martin B. Schmitz (2022) “A Penny for Your Thoughts,” NBER Working Paper 30076, National Bureau of Economic Research,10.3386/w30076. [Referenced on pages2and6] Harkness, Deborah E(2007)*The Jewel House: Elizabethan London and the Scientific* *Revolution*, New Haven: Yale University Press. [Referenced on page7] Hattox, Ralph S(2014)*Coffee and Coffeehouses: The Origins of a Social Beverage in the* *Medieval Near East*, Seattle: University of Washington Press. [Referenced on pages7 and32] Hay, Duncan, Sarah Middle, Alex Butterworth et al.(2025) “Tools of Knowledge Database,”10.34908/vkmq-hk45. [Referenced on pages3,16,32, and38] Henderson, Felicity(2007) “Unpublished Material from the Memorandum Book of Robert Hooke, Guildhall Library MS 1758,”*Notes and Records of the Royal Society*, 61
(2), 129–175,10.1098/rsnr.2006.0173. [Referenced on page17]
Higgitt, Rebekah, Jasmine Kilburn-Toppin, and Noah Moxham(2024)*Metropolitan* *Science: London Sites and Cultures of Knowledge and Practice, c. 1600–1800*, London: Bloomsbury Academic,10.5040/9781350417069. [Referenced on pages11and30] Hotson, Howard and Miranda Lewis(2024) “Early Modern Letters Online,” http: //emlo.bodleian.ox.ac.uk, Accessed 15 October, 2024. [Referenced on page29] Houghton, John(1699) “A Discourse of Coffee, Read at a Meeting of the Royal Society,” *Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London*, 21 (256), 311–317. [Referenced on page5] (1727)*A Collection for the Improvement of Husbandry and Trade*, Vol. 3: London: Woodman and Lyon, Edited by Richard Bradley. [Referenced on page2] Husén, Torsten(1974)*Talent, Equality and Meritocracy: Availability and Utilization of* *Talent*, The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff. [Referenced on page1] Iaria, Alessandro, Carlo Schwarz, and Fabian Waldinger(2018) “Frontier Knowledge and Scientific Production: Evidence from the Collapse of International Science,” *Quarterly Journal of Economics*, 133 (2), 927–991, 10.1093/qje/qjx046. [Referenced on page1] Iliffe, Rob(1995) “Material Doubts: Hooke, Artisan Culture and the Exchange of Information in 1670s London,”*The British Journal for the History of Science*, 28 (3), 285–318. [Referenced on pages7,11, and12] Jacob, Margaret C.(1988)*The Cultural Meaning of the Scientific Revolution*, Philadelphia: Temple University Press. [Referenced on page34] Jacob, Margaret Candee(1997)*Scientific Culture and the Making of the Industrial West*, New York: Oxford University Press. [Referenced on pages2,7, and13] Jaffe, Adam B., Manuel Trajtenberg, and Rebecca Henderson(1993) “Geographic Localization of Knowledge Spillovers as Evidenced by Patent Citations,”*The Quarterly* *Journal of Economics*, 108 (3), 577–598. [Referenced on pages1and38] Johns, Adrian(1999)“Identity, Practice, andTrustinEarlyModern NaturalPhilosophy,” *The Historical Journal*, 42 (4), 1125–1145. [Referenced on page13] (2006) “Coffeehouses and Print Shops,” in Katharine Park and Lorraine Daston eds.*The Cambridge History of Science, Volume 3: Early Modern Science*, 320–340, Cam- bridge: CambridgeUniversityPress, 10.1017/CHOL9780521572446.016. [Referenced on pages11and30]
Jordan, Thomas(1675)*The Triumphs of London*, London, Civic pageant for the Lord Mayor’s Show. [Referenced on page9] Juhász, Réka, Shogo Sakabe, and David E. Weinstein(2026) “Codification, Technology Absorption, and the Globalization of the Industrial Revolution,”*The Quarterly Journal* *of Economics*, 141 (3), 1965–2023,10.1093/qje/qjag021. [Referenced on page6] Kantor, Shawn and Alexander Whalley(2019) “Research Proximity and Productivity: Long-Term Evidence from Agriculture,”*Journal of Political Economy*, 127 (2), 819–854,
10.1086/701035. [Referenced on page38]
Kelly, Morgan, Joel Mokyr, and Cormac Ó Gráda(2023) “The Mechanics of the Industrial Revolution,”*Journal of Political Economy*, 131 (1), 59–94. [Referenced on pages7and38] Kelly, Morgan and Cormac Ó Gráda(2022) “Connecting the Scientific and Industrial Revolutions: The Role of Practical Mathematics,”*The Journal of Economic History*, 82
(3), 841–873. [Referenced on pages2,7, and17]
Klein, Lawrence E(1996) “Coffeehouse Civility, 1660–1714: An Aspect of Post-Courtly Culture in England,”*Huntington Library Quarterly*, 59 (1), 30–51. [Referenced on page 10] Koschnick, Julius(2025a) “Did a Feedback Mechanism between Propositional and Prescriptive Knowledge Create Modern Growth?”, Working paper, arXiv:2512.16587. [Referenced on page27] (2025b) “Teacher-Directed Scientific Change: The Case of the English Scientific Revolution,” EHES Working Paper 274, European Historical Economics Society. [Referenced on page6] Lake, Peter and Steve Pincus(2006) “Rethinking the Public Sphere in Early Modern England,”*Journal of British Studies*, 45 (2), 270–292. [Referenced on page7] Lane, John(1895)*Masonic Records, 1717–1894*, London: United Grand Lodge of England. [Referenced on page38] Lillywhite, Bryant(1963)*London Coffee Houses: A Reference Book of Coffee Houses of the* *Seventeenth, Eighteenth, and Nineteenth Centuries*, London: George Allen and Unwin. [Referenced on pages3,11, and14] (1972)*London Signs: A Reference Book of London Signs from Earliest Times to About* *the Mid-Nineteenth Century*, London: George Allen and Unwin. [Referenced on pages 3,13, and14] Meisenzahl, Ralf R. and Joel Mokyr(2012) “The Rate and Direction of Invention in the British Industrial Revolution: Incentives and Institutions,” in Josh Lerner and Scott Stern eds.*The Rate and Direction of Inventive Activity Revisited*, 443–479, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 10.7208/chicago/9780226473062.003.0013. [Referenced on pages7,37, and38] Melillo, Andrea, Luigi Pascali, Mounu Prem, and Francesca Asja Trento(2026) “The Republic of Letters and the Rise of the West,” BSE Working Paper 1579, Barcelona School of Economics. [Referenced on page6] Mokyr, Joel(2002)*The Gifts of Athena: Historical Origins of the Knowledge Economy*, Princeton: Princeton University Press. [Referenced on pages1,6,13, and27] (2005) “The Intellectual Origins of Modern Economic Growth,”*The Journal of* *Economic History*, 65 (2), 285–351. [Referenced on pages1,9,13, and26] (2016)*A Culture of Growth: The Origins of the Modern Economy*, Princeton: Princeton University Press. [Referenced on pages1,6,7,13, and37]
Monroe, Burt L., Michael P. Colaresi, and Kevin M. Quinn(2008) “Fightin’ Words: Lexical Feature Selection and Evaluation for Identifying the Content of Political Conflict,”*Political Analysis*, 16 (4), 372–403, 10.1093/pan/mpn018. [Referenced on page23] Moser, Petra(2013)“PatentsandInnovation: EvidencefromEconomicHistory,”*Journal* *of Economic Perspectives*, 27 (1), 23–44. [Referenced on page2] Mount, Toni(2021)*The World of Isaac Newton*, Stroud: Amberley Publishing. [Referenced on page11] Ó Gráda, Cormac(2016) “Did Science Cause the Industrial Revolution?,”*Journal of* *Economic Literature*, 54 (1), 224–239,10.1257/jel.54.1.224. [Referenced on page7] Ogilvie, Sheilagh(2019)*The European Guilds: An Economic Analysis*, Princeton: Princeton University Press. [Referenced on page7] Oldenburg, Ray(1989)*The Great Good Place*, New York: Paragon House. [Referenced on page38] Oxford Dictionary of National Biography(2025) “Oxford Dictionary of National Biography,” https://www.oxforddnb.com/, Online edition, first published 2004. Accessed 12 September 2025. [Referenced on page10] Peacham, Henry(1677)*Worth of a Penny, or, a Caution to Keep Money*, London: Thomas Lee, Enlarged edition. [Referenced on page9] Pepys, Samuel(1660–1669) “The Diary of Samuel Pepys, 1660–1669,” https://www.pe pysdiary.com/, Wheatley edition, retrieved via the Pepys Diary API. Accessed 16 July, 2026. [Referenced on page9] Pincus, Steve(1995) ““Coffee Politicians Does Create”: Coffeehouses and Restoration Political Culture,”*The Journal of Modern History*, 67 (4), 807–834. [Referenced on page 14] Polanyi, Michael(1966)*The Tacit Dimension*, Garden City, NY: Doubleday. [Referenced on page1] Rambachan, Ashesh and Jonathan Roth(2023) “A More Credible Approach to Parallel Trends,”*The Review of Economic Studies*, 90 (5), 2555–2591. [Referenced on page23] Redding, Stephen J.(2025) “Quantitative Urban Economics,” in*Handbook of Regional and* *Urban Economics*, Vol. 6, Chap. 2, 73–141, Amsterdam: Elsevier. [Referenced on page 35] Robilliard, Gabrielle(2024) “Novel, Popular, Fashionable and Partisan: Making Coffeehouses ‘Burgherly’ Spaces in Early Modern Hamburg,”*Urban History*, 51 (1), 146–170. [Referenced on page32] Robinson, Henry W. and Walter Adamseds. (1935)*The Diary of Robert Hooke, M.A.,*
*M.D., F.R.S., 1672–1680*, London: Taylor & Francis. [Referenced on pages11,12, and17]
Roche, Maria P.(2020) “Taking Innovation to the Streets: Microgeography, Physical Structure, and Innovation,”*Review of Economics and Statistics*, 102 (5), 912–928,
10.1162/rest_a_00866. [Referenced on page38]
Rosée, Pasqua(1652) “The Vertue of the Coffee Drink: First Publiquely Made and Sold in England, by Pasqua Rosée,” Broadside handbill, London. [Referenced on page9] Roth, Jonathan and Pedro H. C. Sant’Anna(2023) “When Is Parallel Trends Sensitive to Functional Form?,”*Econometrica*, 91 (2), 737–747. [Referenced on page19] Shapin, Steven(1988) “The House of Experiment in Seventeenth-Century England,” *Isis*, 79 (3), 373–404,10.1086/354773. [Referenced on page26]
(1994)*A Social History of Truth: Civility and Science in Seventeenth-Century* *England*, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. [Referenced on pages11and13] Shapin, Steven and Simon Schaffer(1985)*Leviathan and the Air-Pump: Hobbes, Boyle, and* *the Experimental Life*, Princeton: Princeton University Press. [Referenced on pages1, 12, and29] Shaw-Taylor, L., S. Keibek, M. Satchell, X. You, and M. Lucas-Smith(2024) “Economies Past,” https://www.economiespast.org/, Accessed16November, 2025. [Referenced on page7] Small, Mario L. and Laura Adler(2019) “The Role of Space in the Formation of Social Ties,”*AnnualReviewofSociology*,45,111–132, 10.1146/annurev-soc-073018-022707. [Referenced on page38] Smith, S. D.(2001) “The Early Diffusion of Coffee Drinking in England,” in Michel Tuchscherer ed.*Le Commerce du Café avant l’ère des plantations coloniales : Espaces,* *réseaux, sociétés (XVe–XIXe siècle)*, 245–268, Cairo: Institut français d’archéologie orientale. [Referenced on page10] Squicciarini, Mara P. and Nico Voigtländer(2015) “Human Capital and Industrializa- tion: Evidence from the Age of Enlightenment,”*The Quarterly Journal of Economics*, 130 (4), 1825–1883. [Referenced on pages6and7] Stanford Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence(2026) “The 2026 AI Index Report,” technical report, Stanford University, https://hai.stanford.edu/a i-index/2026-ai-index-report. [Referenced on page6] Stephan, Paula E.(1996) “The Economics of Science,”*Journal of Economic Literature*, 34
(3), 1199–1235. [Referenced on page1]
Stewart,Larry(1992)*TheRiseofPublicScience: Rhetoric,Technology,andNaturalPhilosophy* *inNewtonianBritain, 1660–1750*, Cambridge: CambridgeUniversityPress. [Referenced on pages13,23, and29] (1999) “Other Centres of Calculation, or, Where the Royal Society Didn’t Count: Commerce, Coffee-Houses and Natural Philosophy in Early Modern London,”*The* *British Journal for the History of Science*, 32 (2), 133–153. [Referenced on pages5,11,12, and30] (2005)“Science, Instruments, andGuildsinEarly-ModernBritain,”*EarlyScience* *and Medicine*, 10 (3), 392–410. [Referenced on page11] Stokes, Donald E.(1997)*Pasteur’s Quadrant: Basic Science and Technological Innovation*, Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press. [Referenced on page2] Storper, Michael and Anthony J. Venables(2004) “Buzz: Face-to-Face Contact and the Urban Economy,”*Journal of Economic Geography*, 4 (4), 351–370, 10.1093/jnlecg/lbh
027. [Referenced on page6]
Sun, Liyang and Sarah Abraham(2021) “Estimating Dynamic Treatment Effects in Event Studies with Heterogeneous Treatment Effects,”*Journal of Econometrics*, 225 (2), 175–199. [Referenced on page19] Sunderland, David(2007)*Social Capital, Trust and the Industrial Revolution, 1780–1880*, London: Routledge. [Referenced on page13] Tao, Terence(2026) “Mathematics in the Age of AI,” https://arxiv.org/abs/2608.1 6753, arXiv preprint 2608.16753. [Referenced on page6] Taylor, Eva Germaine Rimington(1954)*The Mathematical Practitioners of Tudor and Stuart* *England*, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Referenced on pages3,7,10,15, 16,17,26, and28]
Universal Short Title Catalogue [USTC](2026) “Universal Short Title Catalogue,” University of St Andrews, Database of books printed in early modern Europe, https://www.ustc.ac.uk/, accessed 3 August 2026. [Referenced on page17] Wallis, Patrick(2025)*The Market for Skill: Apprenticeship and Economic Growth in Early* *Modern England*, Princeton: Princeton University Press. [Referenced on page32] Walton,StevenA(2017)“TechnologiesofPow(d)er: MilitaryMathematicalPractitioners’ Strategies and Self-Presentation,” in Lesley B Cormack, Steven A Walton, and John A Schuster eds.*Mathematical Practitioners and the Transformation of Natural Knowledge in* *Early Modern Europe*, 87–114, Cham: Springer. [Referenced on page15] Warren, Christopher N., Daniel Shore, Jessica Otis, Lawrence Wang, Mike Finegold, and Cosma Shalizi(2016) “Six Degrees of Francis Bacon: A Statistical Method for Reconstructing Large Historical Social Networks,”*DHQ: Digital Humanities Quarterly*, 10 (3). [Referenced on pages10and15] Webster, Roderick S. and Marjorie K. Webster(2007) “Webster Signature Database,” Adler Planetarium and Astronomy Museum, Chicago, Database of makers who signed scientific instruments held in collections worldwide. Archived at https: //web.archive.org/web/20260513013557/https://historydb.adlerplanetari um.org/signatures/about.html, accessed 30 August, 2026. [Referenced on page17] Withington, Phil(2020) “Where Was the Coffee in Early Modern England?,”*The Journal* *of Modern History*, 92 (1), 40–75. [Referenced on page10] Wood, Anthony(1892)*The Life and Times of Anthony Wood, Antiquary, of Oxford, 1632–* *1695, Described by Himself*, Vol. 2, Oxford: Oxford Historical Society, Edited by Andrew Clark. [Referenced on page9] Wooldridge, Jeffrey M.(2023) “Simple Approaches to Nonlinear Difference-in- Differences with Panel Data,”*The Econometrics Journal*, 26 (3), C31–C66. [Referenced on pages3and19] Wootton, David(2015)*The Invention of Science: A New History of the Scientific Revolution*, New York: HarperCollins. [Referenced on page13] Wrigley, E. A.(2010)*Energy and the English Industrial Revolution*, Cambridge University Press,10.1017/CBO9780511779619. [Referenced on page7] Zilsel, Edgar(1942) “The Sociological Roots of Science,”*American Journal of Sociology*, 47 (4), 544–562. [Referenced on page6]
ONLINE APPENDIX
“Coffeehouses and the Rise of Science”
Monir Bounadi & Jens Oehlen
APPENDIX TABLE OF CONTENTS
AHistorical BackgroundOA-1
A.1 Why Coffeehouses Opened....................... .OA-1
A.2 Coffee, Coffeehouses, and Science.................... .OA-2
A.3 Figures................................... .OA-3
A.4 Tables.................................... .OA-4
BAdditional ResultsOA-7
B.1 Raw Means................................. .OA-7
B.2 Spillover Estimation............................ .OA-7
B.3 Creation and Relocation......................... .OA-11
B.4 Hooke’s Coffeehouse Visits Were Local................ .OA-13
B.5 Oxbridge Representation in Shares................... .OA-14
B.6 Oxbridge Representation before Entry................. .OA-15
B.7 Makers and Theorists........................... .OA-15
B.8 Hooke’s Company on Coffeehouse and Tavern Days......... .OA-16
B.9 Tavern Openings over the Full Period.................. .OA-18
B.10 Treatment Intensity............................ .OA-19
B.11 Where the European Association Concentrates............ .OA-20
CRobustness ChecksOA-22
C.1 Covariate Balance and Adjustment................... .OA-22
C.2 Randomization Inference......................... .OA-22
C.3 Placebo Outcomes............................. .OA-23
C.4 Local Confounders: The Great Fire and the London Wall...... .OA-24
C.5 Selection into the Historical Record................... .OA-24
C.6 Overlap between the Outcome Rosters................. .OA-24
C.7 Treatment Definition and Timing.................... .OA-25
C.8 Spatial Aggregation and Inference................... .OA-26
C.9 Control Groups and Estimators..................... .OA-26
C.10 Trends and Influence........................... .OA-26
C.11 European Cities.............................. .OA-27
C.12 Figures................................... .OA-28
C.13 Tables.................................... .OA-43
DData AppendixOA-49
D.1 Summary Statistics............................ .OA-49
D.2 Treatment Variable............................ .OA-50
D.3 Outcome Variables............................ .OA-51
D.4 Practitioner Connections......................... .OA-54
D.5 Covariates................................. .OA-55
D.6 Hooke’s Diary............................... .OA-57
D.7 First Coffeehouses in European Cities................. .OA-59
D.8 Data Sources................................ .OA-62
D.9 Pages of Original Historical Data.................... .OA-64
D.10 Primary and Secondary Sources for Main Variables......... .OA-67
D.11 Data Validation.............................. .OA-72
D.12 Geocoding................................. .OA-75
D.12.1 Procedure............................. .OA-75
D.12.2 Worked Examples......................... .OA-76
D.13 Figures................................... .OA-79
D.14 Tables.................................... .OA-85
EModel AppendixOA-88
E.1 Environment................................ .OA-88
E.2 Meetings and Gravity........................... .OA-89
E.3 The Fréchet Distribution......................... .OA-90
E.4 Choice................................... .OA-92
E.5 Block Recursion.............................. .OA-93
E.6 Equilibrium in Levels........................... .OA-95
E.7 Equilibrium in Changes......................... .OA-97
E.8 Relocation and Creation......................... .OA-101
E.9 Estimation, Simulation, and the Aggregate Effect........... .OA-101
E.10 Figures................................... .OA-106
E.11 Tables.................................... .OA-107
A.HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
A.1.Why Coffeehouses Opened
The identifying assumption inSection 4requires that the timing and location of first coffeehouse openings be unrelated to the trends local scientific activity would have followed absent coffeehouses, and that differential activity between coffeehouse and non-coffeehouse parishes did not respond before openings. One concern, then, is that keepers anticipated scholarly demand and opened where scientific activity was already poised to grow. The documentary record cannot rule out such selection, but it points instead to non-scientific demand. Indeed, as we explain below, every recorded motive is commercial. Moreover,Table A2documents the middling, rather than virtuosic, economic status of coffeehouse keepers, whileTable A4shows that commercial ties among mathematical practitioners were rare before 1650. The first coffeehouse in London illustrates this decision rule. Pasqua Rosée was a Greek servant whom the Smyrna merchant Daniel Edwards brought to London in 1651 to prepare coffee (Cowan,2017;Ellis,2004b). When visitors seeking coffee overran Edwards’s household, Edwards sponsored Rosée in a shed in the churchyard of St. Michael Cornhill because membership in the Levant Company barred Edwards from retailing coffee himself.Rosée(1652) successfully advertised the drink with a handbill invoking Galenic health claims. Because of the increasing popularity of Rosée’s coffeehouse, and because he was not a freeman, alehouse keepers competing for customers petitioned the Lord Mayor to stop Rosée from trading and selling coffee. Rosée and Edwards were able to overcome this obstacle in 1654 by taking in Christopher Bowman, a freeman of the Grocers’ Company who brought no knowledge of coffee but did bring his status as a freeman of the City. In 1656, these partners leased premises for four pounds a year. In sum, the first coffeehouse entered London as a new public house with a supply chain, a licensing problem, a landlord, and competitors. The other documented coffeehouse keepers in the*Oxford Dictionary of National* *Biography*differed only in the commercial niches they served: Thomas Garraway built his Exchange Alley coffeehouse around auctions, share dealing, and commercial news (Cowan,2004a). Edward Lloyd made his coffeehouse the resort of shipbrokers and marine underwriters and began publishing shipping intelligence in 1692 (Palmer,2007). The coffeehouse run by William Urwin attracted the literary wits (Cowan,2004c), while Alexander Man opened a coffeehouse near Charing Cross in 1666 close to the Court (Lillywhite,1963). Even the hard case in terms of association with science confirms the pattern that coffeehouses were established for reasons largely unrelated to science. The Grecian, the coffeehouse most closely associated with the Royal Society, was founded by George Constantine, a Greek immigrant and former mariner who was selling coffee in Threadneedle Street by 1665. Its initial appeal lay in the classical associations of his name and its location beside the Temple (Harris,2000). A Royal Society clientele is documented only from 1709. The uses recorded for the 286 coffeehouses of the panel point the same way (Figure A1): 82 carry a record of commerce, 74 of news and literature, and 60 of politics or a club, against 11 with any indication of a clientele in science or learning, while 141 carry no indication of a specialized clientele. At the scale of the whole of London, which our parish-level specification controls for as long as a shock hits all parishes equally, which is likely given their small size, timing
OA-1
was shaped by non-scientific shocks common to the whole city: bulk imports by the East India Company from 1657 and its first sale in 1660 (Table A3), the Excise Act of 1660, the licensing requirement introduced by the excise reform of 1663, and the Fire of 1666 (Cowan,2005;Ellis,2004a). Unlike the rest, the Fire did not hit parishes alike, and Appendix C.4allows separate trends for the burned area. Attempts by the Crown to suppress coffeehouses, in 1666 and with the proclamation of December 1675, accused them of sedition, never of natural philosophy (Cowan,2004b,2005). The record cannot, however, entirely rule out the idea that coffeehouse keepers and scientists or potential entrants into science co-located. Coffeehouses concentrated in the wards around the Exchange, as did instrument makers and mathematical practitioners (Stewart,1999). Nevertheless, what the historical evidence shows is that keepers did not seem to deliberately target anticipated scientific demand; it does not show whether coffeehouses and scientific activity shared the same commercial geography.Section 4 addresses the latter concern using pre-treatment dynamics, covariate adjustment, randomization inference, and, most importantly, placebo outcomes. Selection into the historical record is also unlikely to explain the aforementioned evidence. The coffeehouses discussed above are famous partly because historians later connected them to science, which makes them the coffeehouses most likely to have been sited on the outcome, yet their documented origins still primarily lie in insurance, auctions, literary custom, and Court trade. The anonymous establishments comprising most of the sample are even less likely to have been founded in response to scholarly demand. This does not deny that the virtuosi shaped the reception of coffee or that coffeehouses later became consequential for science (Cowan,2005;Pincus,1995). Here our narrower claim is that the available evidence identifies non-scientific aspects, such as coffee supply, commercial geography, immigrant expertise, taxation and licensing, and non-scientific clientele, as the main determinants of where and when coffeehouses opened.
A.2.Coffee, Coffeehouses, and Science
Table A1traces coffee, coffeehouses, and science in England from the 1620s to the end of the seventeenth century. English natural philosophers wrote about coffee decades before the first London coffeehouse opened. The previous subsection shows that the main determinants of why coffeehouses opened were commercial. This subsection shows that once the coffeehouses existed and became integrated with social life, what passed through them was not only natural philosophy but mathematical practice and instrument making: designs handed from theorists to clockmakers, calculating devices shown across a table, and printers and makers carried into the Royal Society.
OA-2
A.3.Figures
Unclassified
Commerce
Literary and news
Politics and club Decade first recorded Other 1650s
Dining and leisure 1660s 1670s Medicine 1680s Science and learning 1690s
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 Number of coffeehouses
Figure A1.Recorded uses of coffeehouses by decade of first record
*Notes:* Figure counts the 286 seventeenth-century coffeehouses of the panel by the uses their records mention, with each bar split by the decade in which the coffeehouse is first recorded. Uses are coded from keyword searches of the entries inLillywhite(1963) dated before 1700 and from the activity tags ofMackie (2013) for years before 1700, and grouped into seven categories; science and learning covers records of virtuosi, the Royal Society, experiments, mathematics, and instrument makers. A coffeehouse can carry several uses, so the seven classified bars count 318 uses of 145 coffeehouses. The 141 coffeehouses with no recorded use are unclassified. [Return to pages18,OA-1]
1639• Baptized in Northill, Bedfordshire, the son of a blacksmith. 1671• Joins the Clockmakers’ Company in London. 27 June 1674• “Told him at Childs coffee house of new Dividing compasses screw upon a Rule.” 8 March 1675• “At Garaways [coffee house]. Tompion. I shewd my way of fixing Double Springs to the inside of the Ballance wheel.” 7 April 1675• “With the King and shewd him my new spring watch, Sir J. More and Tompion there [...] commended it far beyond Zulichems.” 1676• Makes two year-going clocks, commissioned by Sir Jonas Moore, for the new Royal Observatory at Greenwich. Figure A2.Coffeehouse meetings joined craft skill to experimental science
*Notes:* Figure sets a 1697 portrait of the clockmaker Thomas Tompion (1639–1713) beside dates from his life (Evans,2008) and three entries that name him in the diary of Robert Hooke (1635–1703) (Robinson and Adams,1935, pp. 109, 151, 157). [Return to page12]
OA-3
A.4.Tables
Table A1—Chronology of coffee, coffeehouses, and science
Coffee becomes an object of scientific inquiry
1623• Francis Bacon, the philosopher of the experimental method, discusses coffee in*Historia Vitae et Mortis*.
1627• Bacon returns to coffee in*Sylva Sylvarum*, classing it with tobacco and opium among intoxicants that “condense and relieve the spirits” and sharpen the mind.
1640• John Parkinson, one of the first of the great English botanists and apothecary to King James I, introduces coffee to English botanical literature in*Theatrum Botanicum*, describing it as the “Turkes berry drinke.”
1650s• William Harvey, who established the circulation of the blood, drinks coffee privately with his merchant brother Eliab “before Coffee-houses were in fashion in London”; the family’s Levant and East India trade was the likely channel.
Coffeehouses become sites of scientific contact and activity
1652• Pasqua Rosée, a Greek servant of the Smyrna merchant Daniel Edwards, opens the first coffeehouse in London near the Old Exchange.
1655• The natural philosopher Robert Boyle’s circle, including Christopher Wren and John Wilkins, meets in the coffee-room of the Oxford apothecary Arthur Tillyard, constituting the earliest documented gathering of natural philosophers in an English coffee-room.
1659• The Rota Club, a debating society founded by the political theorist James Harrington, meets at Miles’s Coffee House at the Turk’s Head. Eleven of its twenty-seven identifiable members later became Fellows of the Royal Society (Hunter,1989).
1660• The Royal Society is founded; the East India Company holds its first official coffee sale; the Excise Act taxes coffee at the keeper.
1663• Samuel Pepys, the naval administrator and diarist, records “good discourse about physique and chymistry” at a coffeehouse, including news of a projector’s design for “an instrument to sink ships.”
1672–1683• Robert Hooke’s diary records visits to 57 London coffeehouses, on nearly two of every three days, where he exchanged information, displayed instruments, and debated scientific questions.
*Continued on next page*
OA-4
*Continued*
1674• Hooke meets the clockmaker Thomas Tompion at Child’s Coffee House and, in October, mathematical practitioners Henry Oldenburg, John Collins, Moses Pitt, and Joseph Moxon, who shows a calculating device made from Napier’s bones.
1678• Joseph Moxon, a printer who moved into globes, instruments, and mathematical authorship through Hooke’s coffeehouse circle, is elected to the Royal Society, an exceptional election for a tradesman.
1684• Hooke, Wren, and Edmond Halley debate planetary motion at a London coffeehouse, prompting Halley’s visit to Newton and the manuscript*De motu corporum in gyrum*, the basis of the*Principia*.
1689• Naturalists begin to club together at the Temple Coffee House, among them Hans Sloane and the apothecary James Petiver, meeting on Friday evenings to exchange specimens and botanical intelligence until about 1706.
1698• John Harris begins lectures on mathematics and natural philosophy at the Marine Coffee House in Birchin Lane.
1699• John Houghton, an apothecary, coffee merchant, and Fellow of the Royal Society, publishes*A Discourse of Coffee*in the*Philosophical* *Transactions*, giving a history of the coffee trade and a natural history of the plant, and concluding that the “coffee-house makes all sorts of people sociable, they improve arts, and merchandize, and all other knowledge.”
1701• Houghton returns to the theme in his*Collection for the Improvement of* *Husbandry and Trade*: an inquisitive man “may find out such coffee-houses, where men frequent, who are studious in such matters as his enquiry tends to,” and there “gain the pith and marrow of the others reading and studies,” getting “more in an evening than he shall by books in a month.”
*Notes:* Table summarizes key dates linking coffee, coffeehouses, natural philosophy, mathematical practice, and instrument making in England and London to the end of the seventeenth century based onClark(2000);Cowan(2005);Ellis(2006a);Lillywhite(1963);Mount(2021);Riley(2006);Shapin and Schaffer(1985), on the diaries of Hooke (Robinson and Adams,1935) andPepys(1660–1669), and on Houghton(1699,1701). [Return to pages12,OA-2]
OA-5
Table A2—Relative wealth in the London victualling trades, 1692–93
| Trade | Individuals | Householders | Mean Rent, £ | Mean Stock, £ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Victuallers | 773 | 768 | 21 | 26 |
| Coffeemen and Women | 137 | 135 | 30 | 20 |
| Vintners | 131 | 123 | 80 | 149 |
| Innholders or Keepers | 91 | 91 | 80 | 74 |
| Tapsters | 23 | 3 | – | – |
| Alehouse-keepers | 10 | 10 | 21 | 25 |
| Strongwater-men | 10 | 10 | 16 | 42 |
| Total | 1,175 | 1,140 |
*Notes:* Data fromCowan(2005, table 7). [Return to pages18,OA-1]
Table A3—Coffee trade of the East India Company, 1650s–80s
| Period | Activity | Pounds avoirdupois |
|---|---|---|
| 1657 | 1st coffee order | 22,400 |
| 1659 | 2nd coffee order | 44,800 |
| 1660 | 1st official coffee sale | – |
| 1660s | Coffee imports | 45,000–56,000 per year |
| 1680s | Coffee imports | 280,000 per year |
*Notes:* Data fromSmith(2001, pp. 264–265). [Return to pageOA- 2]
Table A4—Commercial Connections of Mathematical Practitioners before 1650
<u>Practitioner network size Practitioners With commercial tie Commercial ties / all ties</u> 1–9 ties 7 0 0/36≈0.0% 10–19 ties 15 3 6/197≈3.0% ≥20 ties 9 6 12/348≈3.4% Total 31 9 18/562≈3.2% *Notes:* The sample is the mathematical practitioners whose recorded flourishing ends be- fore 1650. Network size is the number of SDFB relationships touching each practitioner; relationships are treated as undirected. Commercial contacts comprise merchants, traders, mercers, drapers, grocers, haberdashers, clothiers, shopkeepers, innkeepers, tavern keepers, victuallers, vintners, brewers, and publicans. Booksellers, printers, stationers, publishers, bankers, and financiers are excluded. The third column counts practitioners with at least one such contact. Relationships between practitioners in different rows count in both rows, so the denominators sum to 581 rather than the total of 562.
OA-6
B.ADDITIONAL RESULTS
B.1.Raw Means
| (A)Mathematical practitioners | (B)Scientific instrument shops | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.2 | Coffeehouse parishes | 1.2 | Coffeehouse parishes |
| Control parishes | Control parishes | ||
| 1.0 | 1.0 | ||
| 0.8 | 0.8 | ||
| 0.6 | 0.6 | ||
| 0.4 | 0.4 | ||
| 0.2 | 0.2 | ||
| 0.0 1600 | 1620 | 0.0 1600 | 1620 |
1640 1660 1680 1700 1640 1660 1680 1700 Figure B1.Scientific activity in coffeehouse and control parishes
*Notes:* Figure plots the mean number of mathematical practitioners (Panel A) and scientific instrument shops (Panel B) per parish in each year, for the 61 parishes whose first coffeehouse opened before 1700 and the 101 parishes without one. The dashed line marks 1652, when the first coffeehouse in London opened. Outcomes are annual versions of those in the event study ofFigure 4, with each shop counted in the years its address is dated and a maker who moves counted once in the year of the move.Figure 1 dates the same shops by the working dates recorded for their makers, which include years without a dated address, so its levels are higher. [Return to page20]
B.2.Spillover Estimation
Section 4measures spillovers on a partition of London into 2,830 hexagons 200 meters across (Appendix Figure B2). Let *𝑦ℎ𝑡*be the number of mathematical practitioners or scientific instrument shops in hexagon *ℎ* in decade *𝑡*, and *𝑟ℎ*its ring: *𝑟ℎ*=0 if a coffeehouse opens in the hexagon itself, and otherwise the 200-meter band *𝑟ℎ*∈ {200*,*400*,*600*,*800*,*1000} holding the distance to its nearest opening hexagon. *𝐸ℎ*is the decade in which *ℎ* is first exposed, by its own first coffeehouse if *𝑟ℎ*=0 and by the earliest opening within 200 meters if *𝑟ℎ*=200. Hexagons beyond 1,000 meters have no ring,*𝑟ℎ*=*𝐸ℎ*=∞, and serve as controls.
OA-7
Directly affected 0 to 200 m 200 to 400 m 400 to 600 m 600 to 800 m 800 to 1,000 m
Beyond 1,000 m
3 km Figure B2.Spillover rings around first coffeehouse openings
*Notes:* Map of London divided into 2,830 hexagons of 25,981 m² each, 200 meters corner to corner, with black lines for the 162 parish boundaries and an inset of the area inside the wall. Hexagons with a first coffeehouse in the seventeenth century are directly affected. Every other hexagon is assigned to a 200-meter distance ring around its nearest opening hexagon; the 1,906 gray hexagons more than 1,000 meters from any opening serve as controls inAppendix Table B1. [Return to pages25,OA-7,OA-9, OA-11]
Table B1reports the two-period regression ofButts(2023), in which the outcome is the change in each hexagon between the 1640s and the 1690s, Õ E[*𝑦ℎ,*1690−*𝑦ℎ,*1640|*𝑟ℎ*]=Δ*𝜇*+ *𝜏𝑟*1[*𝑟ℎ*=*𝑟*]*,*ℛ={0*,*200*,*400*,*600*,*800*,*1000}*,* *𝑟*∈ℛ (B.1) where Δ*𝜇* is the change common to all hexagons, *𝜏₀* the effect on the hexagon receiving the coffeehouse, and *𝜏𝑟*the effect at distance *𝑟*, both by the 1690s. Identification requires that spillovers are local, so hexagons beyond a kilometer are unaffected, and that absent an opening within a kilometer, hexagons in each ring would have changed as hexagons beyond it did (Butts,2023).
OA-8
Table B1—Direct and spillover effects of coffeehouse openings
<u>Mathematical practitioners Scientific instrument shops</u> Hexagons Mean (1) (2) Mean (3) (4) Opening hexagon 76 0.2370*.*381 ∗∗
0*.*392 ∗∗
0.0661*.*182
∗∗∗
1*.*196 ∗∗∗
(0.157) (0.159) (0.249) (0.250) 0 to 200 m 172 0.0810*.*166 ∗∗∗
0.0520*.*121
∗∗ (0.054) (0.051) 200 to 400 m 121 0.074−0*.*0190.0170*.*048 (0.048) (0.037) 400 to 600 m 172 0.0120*.*0090.0000*.*027 ∗∗ (0.013) (0.013) 600 to 800 m 225 0.0130*.*0110.0040*.*007 (0.014) (0.011) 800 to 1000 m 158 0.0130*.*0100.0000*.*036 (0.012) (0.027) Beyond 1,000 m 1906 0.001 0.001 Hexagons in control group 2754 1906 2754 1906 *𝑅²* 0.038 0.054 0.169 0.173 Hexagons 2830 2830 2830 2830
*Notes:* Table reports estimates from equation (B.1) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity, on the hexagonal partition shown inAppendix Figure B2. Outcomes are the change in the number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a hexagon from the 1640s to the 1690s. Each hexagon is assigned to a 200-meter distance ring around its nearest opening hexagon, followingButts(2023). Columns (1) and (3) omit the ring indicators, so exposed hexagons remain in the control group; columns (2) and (4) estimate the effect on the directly affected hexagon jointly with the effect on each ring. Mean reports the outcome mean in the 1640s. Sample includes all 2,830 hexagons. Unit of observation is hexagon. Standard errors followConley(1999) with a Bartlett kernel and a 1-kilometer cutoff; significance at the 10, 5, and 1 percent levels is denoted by ∗, ∗∗, and ∗∗∗. [Return to pages25,OA-8,OA-9]
Appendix Figure B4estimates the same two effects dynamically. The first stage estimates the fixed effects on the observations not yet exposed, directly or as an immediate neighbor,
##### E[𝑦ℎ𝑡|ℎ,𝑡]=𝛼 for(ℎ,𝑡)with𝑟ℎ,(B.2)
| +𝜇 | >200or𝑡<𝐸 | |
|---|---|---|
| ℎ 𝑡 | ℎ ℎ | 𝑡 |
and imputes the untreated potential outcome b*𝑦ℎ𝑡*(∞)= b*𝛼* + b*𝜇*, as in equation (1). The second stage regresses the imputed deviation on event time,
##### Õ Õ4
E *𝑦ℎ𝑡*− b*𝑦ℎ𝑡*(∞)|*ℎ,𝑡* = *𝜏𝑟,ℓ*1[*𝑟ℎ*=*𝑟*]1[*𝑡*−*𝐸ℎ*=10*ℓ*]*,*(B.3) *𝑟*∈{0*,*200} *ℓ*=−5
where *𝜏₀,ℓ*and *𝜏₂₀₀,ℓ*are *𝜏₀* and *𝜏₂₀₀* indexed by event time. Standard errors are clustered by hexagon in equation (B.3), accounting for first-stage estimation of the fixed effects. Figure B4treats hexagons more than 200 meters from an opening as unexposed, the distance beyond whichTable B1finds no effect. Treating every hexagon within a kilometer of an opening as exposed instead, as the table does, changes the post-opening estimates by at most 0.02 and leaves the pre-opening estimates jointly indistinguishable from zero.
OA-9
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops
.4
.25
.2.3
.15
.2
.1
.05.1
Post-ATT (per coffeehouse) Post-ATT (per coffeehouse) 0 0 50 100 200 400 800 1,200 50 100 200 400 800 1,200 Hexagon width (meters, log scale) Hexagon width (meters, log scale) Figure B3.Effects on scientific activity: size of grid cell
*Notes:* Figure shows average post-treatment effects and 95 percent confidence intervals of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity, divided by the number of coffeehouses in the treated hexagon, across hexagonal partitions of increasing cell width. Each partition is built anew, and every coffeehouse, practitioner, and instrument shop is reassigned to it. The eight estimates therefore come from eight separate panels. Estimation follows equation (1), with never-treated hexagons as controls. Coffeehouses per treated hexagon rise from 2.8 at 50 meters to 19.5 at 1,200 meters. Without the normalization, the effects would confound spillovers absorbed within the cell with treatment intensity. Unit of observation is hexagon-decade. Standard errors clustered by hexagon. [Return to page25]
OA-10
(A)Practitioners, directly affected (B)Practitioners, immediately neighboring
.6
.4
1
.2
0 (.26) 0 (.12)
| 4 | .3 | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | .2 | ||||||||||
| 2 | .1 | ||||||||||
| 1 0 (.12) | 0 (.05) | ||||||||||
| −5 | −4 −3 | −2 −1 | 0 1 | 2 3 | 4 | −5 | −4 −3 | −2 −1 | 0 1 | 2 3 | 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
| −5 −4 −3 | −2 −1 | 0 1 | 2 3 | 4 | −5 | −4 −3 | −2 −1 | 0 1 | 2 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse | |||||||||
| (C)Shops, directly affected | (D)Shops, immediately neighboring |
Figure B4.Effects on scientific activity: direct and spillover effects
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity, from equations (B.2) and (B.3), followingButts(2023), on the hexagonal partition shown inAppendix Figure B2. Hexagon and decade effects are estimated on observations neither directly affected nor within 200 meters of an opening. Exposure begins with the earliest opening within 200 meters. No period is omitted. Pre-treatment decades also enter the first stage, so pre-treatment estimates average close to zero by construction; their slope, not their level, bears on parallel trends. Vertical scales differ across panels. Sample includes 76 directly affected, 172 immediately neighboring, and 2,582 remaining hexagons from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is hexagon-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean in the relevant group one decade before treatment. Standard errors clustered by hexagon. [Return to pages25,OA-9]
B.3.Creation and Relocation
Appendix Figure B5splits the post-ATTs by where activity arrives. Creation counts practitioners at their first recorded London location and shops opening in the year a maker is first recorded, and relocation counts later locations and later shops. Activity at a first recorded London location accounts for 84 percent of the post-ATT for practitioners and 62 percent for shops. However, note that moves can also lower activity in the parishes that people leave, and so this simple split does not count those losses. For this reason, as an alternative exercise, we assign each practitioner to the first London parish on record and each shop to the parish of the first shop of its maker, and re-estimate. The post-ATTs fall by 0.08 practitioners and 0.18 shops, 12 and 15 percent of the effects. Most moves ran between parishes that both had a coffeehouse. In or after the decade of
OA-11
a first opening, 5 of the 11 moves into a coffeehouse parish, and 10 of the 51 later shops opened there, came from parishes that never had one. Of these 51 shops, 37 opened while the first shop of the maker was still recorded, so holding them at the first parish overstates relocation. Nor did openings empty their neighborhoods. Within 400 meters of a first opening, there were on average 5.4 practitioners and 3.7 instrument shops in the decade before, and 7.7 and 6.5 in the decade of the opening, against 4.5 to 5.7 practitioners and 3.1 to 4.7 shops around the centers of the 101 parishes that never had a coffeehouse.
(A)Share of the post-ATT, percent
Mathematical practitioners Scientific instrument shops 100
0 Creation Relocation Creation Relocation
(B)Relative post-ATT
Mathematical practitioners (0.62) Scientific instrument shops (0.33)
Creation Relocation Creation Relocation Figure B5.Effects on scientific activity: creation and relocation
*Notes:* Figure splits post-ATTs from equations (1) and (2) of first coffeehouse opening into creation and relocation. Creation counts practitioners at their first recorded London location and shops opening in the year a maker is first recorded; relocation counts later locations and later shops. Since later shops include second shops as well as moves, relocation overstates moves within London. Post-ATTs average the decade of treatment and the four decades thereafter. Panel A gives each component as a share of the post-ATT, with 95 percent confidence intervals bootstrapped by parish. Panel B divides each component by the outcome mean in the decade before treatment, given in parentheses, with 95 percent confidence intervals. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pages25,OA-11]
OA-12
B.4.Hooke’s Coffeehouse Visits Were Local
1500 Garraway’s 1
.8
1000 Jonathan’s.6
.4
Coffeehouse visits 500
.2 Cumulative share of visits
0 0 0 1 2 3 Distance to lodgings at Gresham College (km)
Coffeehouse visitsCumulative share of visits
Figure B6.Robert Hooke’s coffeehouse visits, 1672–1683
*Notes:* Figure shows the number of visits Robert Hooke made to different coffeehouses between 10 March 1672 and 15 May 1683, by their distance from his lodgings at Gresham College in Bishopsgate. Visits are days on which his diary names the coffeehouse. Circle size is proportional to the share of the 2,915 visits to the 32 coffeehouses thatBrown et al.(2021) locate, and the step function read against the right axis gives the cumulative share of those visits made within a given distance. Of the 2,915 visits, 2,233 were within 400 meters of his lodgings. The diary names 25 further coffeehouses, 182 times, that cannot be located. Locations fromBrown et al.(2021); visits from the diary as described inAppendix D.6. [Return to pages25,OA-58]
OA-13
B.5.Oxbridge Representation in Shares
70%
50%
Share of post-ATT (%) 20% 25
##### Bottomx% byz(s)
Proportional 0
##### 0 25 50 75 100
##### Share of pre-entry base (%)
Figure B7.Shares of the effect and of the base by Oxbridge representation
*Notes:* Figureplots, forgroupsofmathematicalpractitionersfromthebottom20percentofthedistribution of *𝑧*(*𝑠*) upward, the share of the average post-treatment effect on all practitioners (0.68) that each group accounts for against its share of the 38 practitioner-decades recorded in treated parishes in the decade before entry. The dashed line marks equal shares, and the shaded area the excess of the first over the second. Effects are estimated from equation (1) as inFigure 7, without dividing by the pre-entry mean. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. [Return to page27]
OA-14
B.6.Oxbridge Representation before Entry
(A)Figure 7, Panel B, with pre-ATTs (B)Panel A net of group-specific trends
14 14 12 12 10 10 8 Post-ATT (relative) 8 Post-ATT (relative) 6 6 4 4 2 2 0 0 Pre-ATT (relative) Pre-ATT (relative) 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Bottom*𝑥*%of practitioners ranked by*𝑧*(*𝑠*) Bottom*𝑥*%of practitioners ranked by*𝑧*(*𝑠*) Figure B8.Pre- and post-entry effects by Oxbridge representation
*Notes:* Figure adds pre-ATTs, the averages of the estimates five to two decades before entry, to Panel B of
Figure 7. Panel B estimates the same equations on outcomes net of linear trends estimated by treatment
cohort on pre-treatment observations (Goodman-Bacon,2021), as inAppendix Figure C22. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to page27]
B.7.Makers and Theorists
Appendix Table B2compares the makers and theorists whose connectionsFigure 8 divides. Of the 114 theorists, 41 taught mathematics or navigation, 18 were surveyors, navigators, or hydrographers, 10 held professorships, 25 are recorded only as math- ematical practitioners, and 20 had other occupations.Taylor(1954) records study at Oxford or Cambridge for 23 of them, against 2 of the 130 makers. Theorists are also the more visible group in the record, with more entries in the*Oxford Dictionary of National* *Biography*, more printed works, and more connections. Yet their surnames are about as represented at Oxford and Cambridge as those of makers. Where the occupation of the father is known, theorists more often had fathers among the gentry or in a learned profession, but only 56 fathers are known.
OA-15
Table B2—Makers and theorists among the mathematical practitioners
Makers
| Theorists | Difference | |
|---|---|---|
| Practitioners130 Panel A. Career | 114 | |
| Flourishing from, mean year1660 | 1646−14(4) | |
| Years of flourishing, mean26 | 28 | 3(3) |
| Active from 166578 Panel B. Output and recognition | 65−14(6) | |
| At least one printed work17 | 57 | 40(6) |
| Entry in the ODNB16 | 47 | 31(6) |
| Fellow of the Royal Society5 | 13 | 9(4) |
| Named in thePhilosophical Transactions11 | 28 | 18(6) |
| Named in the Royal Society minutes2 Panel C. Connections | 11 | 9(4) |
| Connections, mean3.2 | 4.7 | 1.6(0.7) |
| Connections to makers58 Panel D. Background | 37−21(5) | |
| Studied at Oxford or Cambridge2 | 20 | 19(4) |
| Percentile of𝑧(𝑠)among the 244, mean49 | 51 | 2(4) |
| Father’s occupation known18 | 29 | 11(5) |
| Father gentry or of a learned profession17 | 48 | 31(12) |
*Notes:* Table compares the 130 makers among the 244 mathematical practitioners, those whose recorded occupations place them in the instrument trade, including chart makers, engravers, and lens grinders, with the 114 theorists, all others. Rows are percentages unless marked as means. Difference is theorists minus makers, with standard errors allowing unequal variances in parentheses. Being named requires the first name or the context to confirm the identity in the*Philosophical Transactions*(Fischer et al.,2020), with every reader accepting the occurrence as inSection 3, among the 176 practitioners active from 1665, and the first name or an honorific in the minutes (The Royal Society,2024), among the 182 active from
1660. Connections are those recorded byTaylor(1954) andWarren et al.(2016), and the share to makers is among the 204 practitioners with any. Study at Oxford or Cambridge is asTaylor(1954) records it. *𝑧*(*𝑠*) enters as its percentile among all 244, 50 on average. The father’s occupation is known for 56, mostly from linked biographies. Gentry or learned professions are gentlemen, baronets, clergymen, barristers, physicians, and magistrates. [Return to pages28,OA-15]
#### B.8.Hooke’s Company on Coffeehouse and Tavern Days
Figure B9splits the additional company of a coffeehouse day inFigure 9by occupation.
OA-16
Mathematical practitioners Other manual trades Physicians and mathematicians Book trade, church, law, trade, office, household No occupation recorded
Outside the network 0.220.21 0.310.62 1.44
In the network 0.17 0.50 0.79
0 0.5 1 1.5
Figure B9.Hooke’s additional company on coffeehouse days by occupation
*Notes:* Figure splits the difference in people recorded between coffeehouse days and other days inFigure 9, Panel B, by occupation, for people outside the Republic of Letters and in it. Each segment is the coefficient on a coffeehouse day from a regression of the number of people in that occupation recorded per day on that indicator and year-by-weekday fixed effects, over the 3,464 days of the diary. Mathematical practitioners are the people matched by name toTaylor(1954) or to SIMON; the match is partly circular, since Taylor cites the diary in 58 entries. Other occupations are read from the notes in the index of the printed editions.Appendix D.6describes the data. [Return to pagesOA-16,OA-18]
Coffeehouse days and tavern days brought different company (Figure B10). In one regression per occupation, a coffeehouse day raises the number of mathematical practitioners Hooke records meeting by 79 percent of its rate on days with neither, against 8 percent for a day at a tavern or other drinking house, and the number of men in other manual trades by 109 percent, against 25 percent. For the church, law, trade, and office, the two kinds of day do not differ. 59
59 The*𝑝*-values of the three differences are*<*0*.*001,0*.*002, and0*.*28.
OA-17
Coffeehouse day Drinking-house day
Mathematical practitioners
Other manual trades
Physicians and mathematicians
Book trade
Church, law, trade, and office
No occupation recorded
−1 −0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5
Figure B10.Hooke’s company on coffeehouse and tavern days by occupation
*Notes:* Figure reports, for each occupation, the additional number of people Hooke records meeting on a coffeehouse day and on a day at a tavern or other drinking house, each as a multiple of the number recorded on days with neither, with 95 percent confidence intervals. Both come from one regression per occupation with indicators for the two kinds of day and year-by-weekday fixed effects over the 3,464 days of the diary, with heteroskedasticity-robust standard errors. A day can be both. Occupations are defined as inFigure B9; Hooke’s household is left out. [Return to pageOA-17]
The diary seldom says where a meeting took place. Reading each coffeehouse-day entry, a language model places 2,896 of the 16,325 meetings at the coffeehouse itself (Appendix D.6). These meetings are more often with correspondents than the meetings placed elsewhere, 44 against 39 percent.
B.9.Tavern Openings over the Full Period
Over the full 1550s–1690s sample, strong pre-trends in mathematical practitioners indicate that the placebo design is invalid there (Figure B11). Controlling for group- specificlineartrendsremovesthesepre-trendsandyieldsnegativeeffectsonpractitioners (Figure B12); estimated effects on instrument shops are positive over the full sample but small and insignificant before the 1650s. Over the full sample, instrument shops are
0.21 higher (s.e. 0.05) on average over the decade of entry and the four decades after a first tavern, on a pre-entry mean of 0.09, against 1.24 after a first coffeehouse on a mean of 0.33: rises of 2.2 and 3.8 times the pre-entry means.
OA-18
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops Full·Post-ATT 0.43 (0.23) Full·Post-ATT 2.22 (0.56) Pre-1650s·Post-ATT−0.13 (0.21) Pre-1650s·Post-ATT 1.03 (0.63)
4 0 2
−1 0
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Decades since first tavern | −5 −4 | −3 −2 Decades since first tavern | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
Figure B11.Tavern effects on scientific activity over the full period
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of the first seventeenth-century tavern opening on scientific activity, over the full period, filled markers and shaded intervals, and before the 1650s, hollow markers and outlined intervals. Treatment effect heterogeneity is restricted to event time, as inFigure 6. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Each outcome is divided by its reference mean, i.e., the sample mean of the outcome one decade before the first tavern opened. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1550s to the 1690s (full) or the 1550s to the 1640s (before the 1650s). Unit of observation is parish-decade. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from the opening through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pages24,OA-18]
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops
| 2 | 8 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 6 | ||||||||
| 0 | 4 | ||||||||
| −1 | 2 | ||||||||
| −2 | 0 | ||||||||
| −3 | −2 | ||||||||
| −5 | −4 −3 Decades since first tavern −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 | −4 −3 Decades since first tavern −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| FullPre-1650s | FullPre-1650s | ||||||||
| Full w/ trendPre-1650s w/ trend | Full w/ trendPre-1650s w/ trend |
Figure B12.Tavern effects on scientific activity: group-specific trends
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of the first seventeenth-century tavern opening on scientific activity. Treatment effect heterogeneity is restricted to event time, as inFigure 6. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Each outcome is divided by its reference mean, i.e., the sample mean of the outcome one decade before the first tavern opened. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1550s to the 1690s (full) or the 1550s to the 1640s (before the 1650s). Results “w/ trend” first adjust for group-specific linear trends, following a suggestion inGoodman-Bacon (2021): we estimate a linear outcome trend by treatment cohort using only pre-treatment observations and then subtract the estimated trend from the outcome. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pages24,OA-18]
B.10.Treatment Intensity
Treated parishes differ in how many coffeehouses arrive. When we group them by the number open in the decade of entry and compare each group with the never-treated, both groups roughly double their practitioners, while instrument shops rise by 3.2 times their pre-entry mean in the 40 parishes that begin with one coffeehouse and 4.7 times in
OA-19
the 21 that begin with two or more, from the same pre-entry mean of 0.33 (Figure B13). These are group-specific average effects rather than a dose-response curve. Identifying the response to an additional coffeehouse would require the stronger parallel trends condition that rules out selection on gains into intensity (Callaway et al.,2026), and with 40 parishes at one coffeehouse and five above two, the intensity observed at entry has too little variation to estimate it.
| (A)Mathematical practitioners | (B)Scientific instrument shops | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 1 (n = 40, mean 0.53) | 2+ (n = 21, mean 0.81) | 8 1 (n = 40, mean 0.33) | 2+ (n = 21, mean 0.33) |
| 6 | |||
| 1 | 4 | ||
| 2 | |||
| 0 | |||
| 0 | |||
| −1 Pre | Pre Post | −2 Pre | Pre Post |
Post Post Figure B13.Effects on scientific activity: coffeehouses at entry
*Notes:* Figure shows average effects before and after first coffeehouse opening, with 95 percent confidence intervals, from equations (1) and (2). Treated parishes are grouped by the number of coffeehouses open in the parish in the decade of first entry, and each group is estimated separately against all 101 never-treated parishes. Pre-entry effects average event study estimates from five to two decades before opening; post-entry effects average them from opening through four decades after. Both are divided by the mean of the outcome in that group one decade before entry, which the panel heading reports beside the number of treated parishes in the group,*𝑛*, so 1 denotes a doubling; standard errors are divided by the same constant, so the intervals carry no sampling error in the group mean. Intensity is measured in the decade of entry rather than as the peak over the panel, which is realized after treatment. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-20]
B.11.Where the European Association Concentrates
Gingerich(2002) traces the provenance of every known copy of Copernicus’s*De* *revolutionibus*(1543), so a copy held in a city in 1620 marks early engagement with the new science at large, not with astronomy alone. Read for dated, city-specific provenance, the 593 census entries place a copy in 17 of the 37 coffeehouse cities. In large cities holding a copy, the post-entry difference in applied mathematics titles is 18.20 (s.e. 7.40) on a pre-entry mean of 10.30; in large cities without one it is 1.26 (s.e. 1.63) on a mean of
7.33, and among small cities neither group shows a rise (Table B3). Instrument makers run the same way, 16.68 (s.e. 11.39) against 0.99 (s.e. 0.62), without the precision to carry the point alone. The rise appears where there was already a sizable pool of potential entrants into science, which is what the London mechanism predicts and equally what one expects if coffeehouses and science went to the same cities.
OA-20
Table B3—The post-entry difference by city size and Copernican stock
| Copy recorded | No copy | Copy minus no copy | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Panel A. Applied mathematics titles | |||
| Large cities18.20 Small cities−2.36 | (7.40) [10.30] (1.60) [5.00] | 1.26 (1.63) [7.33] 0.33−2.69 (1.45) [1.45] | 16.94 (7.44) (0.97) |
| Large minus small20.56 Panel B. Scientific instrument makers | (7.55) | 0.93 (0.38) | 19.63 (7.51) |
| Large cities16.68 Small cities0.32 | (11.39) [10.70] (0.58) [0.71] | 0.99 (0.62) [1.33] 0.77−0.45 (0.53) [1.27] | 15.69 (11.40) (0.41) |
| Large minus small16.36 | (11.40) | 0.23 (0.15) | 16.14 (11.40) |
*Notes:* Table reports post-entry differences from equation (1) with the covariates ofFigure 13, averaged over entry through three decades, the horizons every cell is observed at. Coffeehouse cities are split at their median population in 1600 and by whether any entry in the census ofGingerich(2002) places a copy of*De revolutionibus*in the city in 1620 on dated, city-specific provenance: 10 large and 7 small coffeehouse cities hold a copy, and 9 large and 11 small do not. The last column subtracts the no-copy cell from the copy cell, the last row subtracts the small cities from the large, and the corner, the triple difference, is the copy contrast among large cities minus that among small cities. Brackets give the mean of the outcome in the decade before entry. Within a panel all entries share one variance matrix. Sample includes all 200 cities from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is city-decade. Standard errors clustered by city in parentheses. [Return to pages34,OA-20]
OA-21
C.ROBUSTNESS CHECKS
C.1.Covariate Balance and Adjustment
Coffeehouses did not open at random.Table C1andFigure C1compare parishes that ever received a coffeehouse with parishes that never did. Fourteen of twenty-eight pre-1652 measures show normalized differences above the 0.25 threshold ofImbens and Rubin(2015, p. 277). The largest gaps are in taverns, commercial premises, tradesmen’s tokens issued between 1648 and 1651, and booksellers. We start with balance in changes.Table C2reports normalized differences in the change between the 1600s–1610s and the 1630s–1640s, before the first London coffeehouse in 1652, so treatment cannot explain any of these changes. The two outcomes are balanced in changes, at −0.05 and 0.08, although they differ by 0.32 in levels. For booksellers, the normalized difference goes from 0.57 in levels to −0.02 in changes. Only taverns and commercial premises are above 0.25 in changes, and we examine both directly as placebo outcomes below (Figure C7, Panels A and D). Next, we adjust for the observed differences directly. We estimate the propensity score of ever being treated with a probit on pre-1652 taverns, tradesmen’s tokens, booksellers, and an indicator for the City of London. We then weight control parishes by the odds of this score, so that the estimates refer to the treated parishes. This cuts the mean absolute normalized difference from 0.30 to 0.22 (Figure C2). Under this weighting, the effects are 0.56 practitioners (s.e. 0.25) and 0.99 shops (s.e. 0.37) (Figure C3). Interacting the score with decade fixed effects, with slopes estimated on all parishes and decades, including treated parishes after entry, instead lowers them to 0.31 (s.e. 0.24) and 0.64 (s.e. 0.30) (Figure C4). When a bootstrap re-estimates the probit in each draw, the standard errors are 0.23 and 0.30. Much of the fall reflects the 13 treated parishes whose score exceeds that of every control parish. Without them, the effects are 0.46 and 0.85 unadjusted and 0.33 and 0.59 with the score by decade (Table C3). In every specification, the pre-treatment estimates are jointly indistinguishable from zero.
C.2.Randomization Inference
We first compare the estimates against a benchmark in which parish labels and opening decades carry no information. We construct 1,000 placebo samples by randomly assigning treatment to 61 of the 162 parishes and drawing the decade of first entry for each placebo parish from the 1650s to the 1690s, coding the remainder as never treated. Figure C5plots the resulting placebo distributions by event time. For both outcomes, post-treatment effects based on historical timing lie in the extreme upper tail of the placebo distributions, while pre-treatment effects are centered near the medians. However, this benchmark places coffeehouses without regard to where and when they actually opened. Entry was more likely in commercial parishes. It was also bunched in time, since 31 of the 61 treated parishes received their first coffeehouse in the 1660s. We therefore repeat the exercise with a more demanding assignment. Using the propensity score estimated above, we group parishes into quintiles and draw the observed number of treated parishes within each quintile. That is, placebo entry is as likely as observed characteristics imply. Treatment rates across the quintiles range from 0.09 to 0.78. We then assign the observed entry decades at random among the drawn parishes, so the number of parishes contributing at each event time is the same
OA-22
as in the data. Since placebo entry now concentrates where actual entry was most likely, and those parishes gained scientific activity over the century, the placebo distributions center above zero. Even so, across 1,000 draws, the post-treatment averages lie in the upper tail, while the pre-treatment averages sit closer to zero than the typical placebo 60 draw (Figure C6). Note that this assignment reproduces where coffeehouses went and how many arrived each decade, but not the association between the two.
C.3.Placebo Outcomes
Coffeehouse entry should leave a set of observable outcomes unmoved, and each placebo outcome targets a distinct alternative to the causal reading.Figure C7reports each placebo under the linear specification of equation (1). We start with population. If coffeehouses drew residents into a parish, the rise in scientific activity could simply reflect more people. The only measures of population we have by parish and decade are the densities of baptisms and deaths. Neither responds to entry (Figure C7, Panels E and F). Next, we look at taverns, to see whether entry changed the market for public houses and might correlate with simple growth in public meeting places. The number of taverns does not move (Figure C7, Panel A). Luxury shops capture a taste channel. These are the shops selling imported and fashionable goods, like coffee itself (grocers, confectioners, tobacconists, silk traders, and similar trades). Suppose that mathematics flourished wherever people took a growing interest in the wider world, which practitioners served through navigation and trade. Then a coffeehouse would only mark this interest and not cause the rise in science, and luxury shops should increase along with our outcomes. They do not (Figure C7, Panel B). Non-scientific letters test whether elites moved in. We count the letters sent from or received at addresses in each parish. Correspondence within the Republic of Letters ran through networks that took years to build. Hence, even if coffeehouses had a real effect, generalcorrespondenceshouldstayflatoverthedecadesweobserve. Iflettercountsrose shortly after entry, this would instead suggest that established correspondents moved into treated parishes together with the coffeehouse. We see no such rise (Figure C7, Panel C). Commercial premises test whether entry rode, or produced, a quickening of com- merce at large. This is the one placebo that rises after a coffeehouse opening (Figure C7, Panel D). The linear estimates fall below zero before entry, so commercial activity was rising, consistent with coffeehouses following commerce; the scientific outcomes show no corresponding pre-trends (Figure 4), so the commercial drift does not threaten parallel trends. After entry, the linear estimates continue the climb. Read generously, the estimated coffeehouse effect may bundle some general commercial activity.
60 Randomization *𝑝*-values, the share of placebo draws at least as large as the observed estimate, counting the observed assignment in the reference set, are 0.011 for mathematical practitioners and 0.002 for scientific instrument shops.
OA-23
C.4.Local Confounders: The Great Fire and the London Wall
Two features of London’s geography could jointly determine coffeehouse locations and scientific activity. The Great Fire of 1666 reshaped the city’s economic geography, displacingpoorerresidents,concentratingwealthinrebuiltareas,andshiftingcommerce westward toward Westminster (Ager et al.,2025), and the loss of records in the fire may bias observed treatment timing. The London Wall marks a second divide: the guilds controlled nearly all trade within the walls, no guild existed for scientific instrument making (Cormack,2017, p. 79), and residential rents were higher inside (Baer,2010). We additively allow for separate nonparametric time trends in parishes exposed and not exposed to the fire (Figure C10) and for locations inside and outside the wall (Figure C11). The main results are robust to both controls.
C.5.Selection into the Historical Record
Our outcome and treatment measures both depend on survival into the historical record, and coffeehouse activity could affect that survival. On the outcome side, prominent sources such as the diaries of Samuel Pepys and Robert Hooke often mention coffeehouses in connection with leading scientists, reflecting idiosyncratic reporting. Data on mathematical practitioners, which rely largely on diaries and published materials, are more exposed to this concern; data on scientific instrument shops come largelyfrommuseumcatalogsofsignedinstruments,guildrecords,andtradecards. The difference is one of degree, not of kind: survival and registration are not independent of local prosperity either. To address the remaining exposure, we restrict the sample to the 175 of 252 instrument makers for whom a London guild is recorded (Figure C15, Panel A), and, because many guild records were destroyed in the Great Fire of 1666, we additionally allow separate trends for parishes exposed to the fire (Figure C15, Panel B). Record loss in the fire could also bias the estimates directly, in two ways. It thins the outcome records before 1666 where they burned, and it dates entry too late where the record of an early coffeehouse burned. The post-treatment effects stay positive when the sample keeps only the parishes outside the burnt area, 0.50 practitioners (s.e. 0.32) and 1.15 shops (0.32), the first imprecise on 21 treated parishes; when the panel ends in the 1660s, so that every record faced the same loss, 0.44 (0.20) and 0.41 (0.20); and when treated parishes are limited to those with a coffeehouse recorded after the fire,
0.77 (0.24) and 1.34 (0.32) (Figure C16). On the treatment side, the decade in which a coffeehouse is first recorded could depend on the type of source that records it. We therefore re-estimate the baseline after excluding, in turn, coffeehouses first recorded in published or private sources, administrative or official sources, material or visual sources, and sources of unknown type, and again after excluding each detailed source category (Figures C8andC9). The estimates are broadly unchanged throughout.
#### C.6.Overlap between the Outcome Rosters
Practitioners and instrument shops are compiled independently, four decades apart, from different archives, but from overlapping populations, since makers prominent enough forTaylor(1954) are also makers whose signed instruments survive.Section 4.2 argues that the consistent effects across outcomes cannot come from one compilation’s coverage; partitioning the two rosters tests that argument directly. We match the 244 practitioners flourishing in London in the seventeenth century
OA-24
against the 252 instrument makers active in the same century. To find candidate pairs, we use two tools, a zero-shot record linker (Dasanaike,2026) and the language model Claude Opus 5, and then check each proposed pair by hand against the printed entries. We only keep links that pass three tests (the forenames agree, the surnames agree on a spelling that one of the sources prints, and the periods of activity are compatible). Note that the two rosters often date the same person differently, in 80 of the 93 links. We then take the widest window, from the earlier of the two first years of flourishing to the later of the two last years. Similarly, we place each matched person at every address that either roster records. That is, Taylor adds 40 parish assignments not found in SIMON, and SIMON adds 54 not found in Taylor. The match links 93 people. Hence, 151 practitioners have no maker record and 159 makers have no practitioner record (Figure C17). The 93 links are a lower bound, since two of the Taylor entries name a father and son together and cannot be linked one to one. All three series count people, not shops, so that they are built alike. Relative to the pre-entry mean, the effect averages 0.99 (s.e. 0.36) among practitioners with no maker record, 1.62 (0.53) on the overlap, and 5.77 (1.45) among makers with no practitioner record. Pre-treatment estimates are close to zero in all three groups (Figure C18). If we read the name evidence as strictly as possible, and only accept identical forenames and surnames with intersecting windows, 73 links survive. The three effects then average
0.96, 2.00, and 4.18 times the pre-entry mean of each group. Neither compilation thus carries the result alone.
#### C.7.Treatment Definition and Timing
Event timing is based on the first recorded mention of a coffeehouse, which may differ from its actual opening year. The decade-level design absorbs this error, at the cost of coarser aggregation. Re-estimating equation (1) at two-, three-, and five-year intervals shows no evidence of pre-trends and a similar rise after entry (Figure C12). 61 Treatment need not be absorbing: applying the method ofde Chaisemartin and D’Haultfoeuille (2026) to coffeehouse presence rather than first entry, using the variation shown in Panel B ofFigure D15, yields results that closely match the baseline (Figure C20). The same method estimates the effect of losing the last coffeehouse in a parish. If the entry effects reflected differential trends rather than coffeehouses, closures should not reverse them. Twenty-two parishes lose their last coffeehouse inside the panel, ten of them in the 1690s, so few remain exposed at long horizons. Mathematical practitioners decline by 0.17 two decades after closure, against a pre-closure mean of 0.59, while instrument shop estimates are too imprecise to sign; pre-closure contrasts are jointly indistinguishable from zero for both outcomes (Figure C21). We note that closures are estimatedonthose22parishes, whileentryisestimatedonthe61thatgainacoffeehouse. The closure estimate is therefore not simply the entry effect in reverse. But the decline is small compared with the increase at entry. This is consistent with scientific activity staying in the parish after its coffeehouse closed.
61 Annual specifications are infeasible due to limited outcome variation after controlling for parish and year fixed effects.
OA-25
C.8.Spatial Aggregation and Inference
The parish is the natural unit of analysis because many historical addresses identify locations only by their nearest parish church, but many records are finer. Re-estimating equation (1) on a partition of London into 15,351 hexagons of 5,000 m² (Figure C13) leaves the findings qualitatively unchanged (Figure C14). The cell area is small enough that parishes contain several cells: 132 parishes hold more than one hexagon and the median parish holds four. The parish-by-decade specification is therefore identified from contrasts within parishes, and 56 of the 59 parishes containing a hexagon that receives a coffeehouse also contain hexagons that never do. Adding parish-by-decade fixed effects preserves the patterns for instrument shops while reducing the magnitude and significance of the effect on practitioners, plausibly because church-level addresses absorb much of the relevant variation. Because observations are densely clustered in space, we also computeConley(1999) standard errors at cutoffs of 0.25, 0.5, 1, and 2 kilometers. Post-treatment effects are significant at every cutoff from one decade after opening on (Figure C27). The two widest cutoffs link 42 and 69 percent of all pairs of parishes. Note that the spillover analysis inAppendix B.2uses larger hexagons, 200 meters across. Each cell there is about five times the size of a cell here, so the levels of the two analyses cannot be compared.
C.9.Control Groups and Estimators
Equation (1) uses never-treated parishes as controls. The event study design ofCallaway and Sant’Anna(2021), which also draws on not-yet-treated parishes, leaves the main results unchanged (Figure C19). The results are likewise robust to an inverse hyperbolic sinetransformationoftheoutcome(FigureC26). ThePoissonspecificationinequation(3) reproducestheshapeoftheresponseforbothoutcomes, withwiderconfidenceintervals (Figure C25). Effects on mathematical practitioners are significant at the 10 percent level throughout the post-treatment window. For instrument shops, they are significant at the 5 percent level two and three decades after entry. Estimation drops observations more than five decades before first opening, since cohort-decade cells containing no shops otherwise separate the likelihood.
C.10.Trends and Influence
FollowingGoodman-Bacon(2021), we detrend outcomes linearly within treatment cohorts using only pre-treatment observations; the results remain similar in magnitude and significance, with wider confidence intervals (Figure C22). We also re-estimate equation (1) 162 times, excluding one parish at a time. No single parish drives the findings, though the four-decade effect loses significance under some exclusions (Figure C23). Finally, followingRambachan and Roth(2023), we ask how far parallel trends could fail after entry before the average post-treatment effect loses significance. It remains significant at the 5 percent level as long as the decade-to-decade change in the violation after entry is at most 0.8 times the largest such change before entry for practitioners and 1.7 times for shops (Figure C24).
OA-26
C.11.European Cities
Section6reportsconditionalcorrelations.TableC5addscountry-by-decadefixedeffects, removes London, Paris, and every capital, and restricts the panel to France, Germany, the Netherlands, and the UK, which hold 27 of the 37 coffeehouse cities;Table C6 recodes the cities whose sources admit more than one entry decade to the earliest and the latest of them, and drops them. The titles difference holds within countries, at 4.25 (s.e. 2.38), and under every recoding of the dates; the makers difference is smaller and imprecise within countries, at 3.15 (s.e. 3.21), and 1.55 (s.e. 0.69) once London is left out. The association does not rest on London alone. Without London, the post-entry difference is 1.67 titles (s.e. 1.29) and 0.98 makers (s.e. 0.49), roughly a third of the pre-entry mean for titles and two-fifths for makers (Table C5). Over the first two decades after entry, the differences are 2.29 titles (s.e. 1.29) and 0.91 makers (s.e. 0.53). London carries much of the magnitude. Without any of the ten capitals, the differences are smaller, 1.26 titles (s.e. 0.93) and 0.23 makers (s.e. 0.33). But these 27 coffeehouse cities also had fewer titles and makers to begin with, 3.56 titles and 1.56 makers per decade before entry, against 5.95 and 3.73 in the full panel. For titles, the difference is still about a third of the pre-entry level. We conclude that the correlation is substantive and that it keeps its sign in every comparison.
OA-27
C.12.Figures
*Panel A. Demographics* Baptisms, 1600s–1640s Baptisms per km2, 1600s–1640s Deaths, 1600s–1640s Deaths per km2, 1600s–1640s Households, 1638 Households per km2, 1638 *Panel B. Wealth* Median tax paid, 1582 Substantial households (%), 1638 *Panel C. Social capital and commerce* Apothecaries, 1617–1640s Booksellers, 1600s–1640s Clay-pipe finds, 1600s–1640s Commercial premises, 1600s–1640s Dissenting meetings, 1600s–1640s Goldsmiths, 1600–1651 Luxury shops, 1600s–1640s Taverns, 1600s–1640s Theaters, 1600s–1640s Tradesmen’s tokens, 1648–1651 *Panel D. Science before 1652* Instrument shops, 1600s–1640s Non-scientific letters, 1600s–1640s Practitioners, 1600s–1640s Scientific letters, 1600s–1640s *Panel E. Geography* Area (km2) City of London Distance to Gresham College (km) Distance to Paternoster Row (km) Distance to the Royal Exchange (km) Inside the London Wall
−0.75 −0.5 −0.25 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1
Normalized difference
Not tested directlyTested as a placebo outcome
Figure C1.Normalized differences in baseline characteristics
*Notes:* Figure plots the normalized differences in pre-treatment characteristics between ever-treated and never-treated parishes. The shaded region marks absolute differences below 0.25, the threshold suggested byImbens and Rubin(2015, p. 277). Filled markers indicate covariates that also appear as placebo outcomes inFigure C7. Rows and their measurement followTable C1. [Return to pagesOA-22, OA-29]
OA-28
*Panel A. Demographics* Baptisms, 1600s–1640sUnweighted Baptisms per km, 1600s–1640sWeighted Deaths, 1600s–1640s Deaths per km2, 1600s–1640s Households, 1638 Households per km2, 1638
*Panel B. Wealth* Median tax paid, 1582 Substantial households (%), 1638
*Panel C. Social capital and commerce* Apothecaries, 1617–1640s Booksellers, 1600s–1640s Clay-pipe finds, 1600s–1640s Commercial premises, 1600s–1640s Dissenting meetings, 1600s–1640s Goldsmiths, 1600–1651 Luxury shops, 1600s–1640s Taverns, 1600s–1640s Theaters, 1600s–1640s Tradesmen’s tokens, 1648–1651
*Panel D. Science before 1652* Instrument shops, 1600s–1640s Non-scientific letters, 1600s–1640s Practitioners, 1600s–1640s Scientific letters, 1600s–1640s
*Panel E. Geography* Area (km2) City of London Distance to Gresham College (km) Distance to Paternoster Row (km) Distance to the Royal Exchange (km) Inside the London Wall
−1 −0.75 −0.5 −0.25 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1
Normalized difference
Figure C2.Normalized differences before and after weighting
*Notes:* Figure plots the normalized differences ofFigure C1without weights and with the inverse- probability weights (IPWs) ofFigure C3. The shaded region marks absolute differences below 0.25. Rows and their measurement followTable C1. [Return to pageOA-22]
OA-29
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops Baseline·Post-ATT 0.68 (0.22) Baseline·Post-ATT 1.24 (0.31) IPW·Post-ATT 0.56 (0.25) IPW·Post-ATT 0.99 (0.37)
| 2 | 3 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | ||||||||
| 1 | |||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
0 (.62) 0 (.33)
Figure C3.Effects on scientific activity: IPW adjustment
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity, from the baseline specification in equations (1) and (2), filled markers and shaded intervals, and the same equation weighted with inverse-probability weights (IPWs), hollow markers and outlined intervals. The IPWs are based on a probit-estimated propensity score for ever being treated, using pre-1652 taverns, tradesmen’s tokens (1648–1651), and booksellers, together with an indicator for the City of London. Control parishes are weighted by the odds of the score, so that the estimates refer to the treated parishes; weights are not trimmed. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pages22,OA-22,OA-29,OA-30]
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops
5 3 Baseline·Post-ATT 0.68 (0.22) Baseline·Post-ATT 1.24 (0.31) Score by decade·Post-ATT 0.31 (0.24) Score by decade·Post-ATT 0.64 (0.30) 4
| 2 | 3 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | ||||||||
| 1 | |||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
0 (.62) 0 (.33)
Figure C4.Effects on scientific activity: propensity score by decade
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity, from the baseline specification in equations (1) and (2), filled markers and shaded intervals, and the same equation with the propensity score ofFigure C3interacted with decade fixed effects, hollow markers and outlined intervals. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pages22,OA-22]
OA-30
| (A)Mathematical practitioners | (B)Scientific instrument shops | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | 3 | ||
| 2 | 2 | ||
| 1 | 1 | ||
| 0 (.62) | 0 (.33) | ||
| −1 | −1 | ||
| −2 −5−4−3−2−101234 | Decades since first coffeehouse | −2 | −5−4−3−2−101234 |
Decades since first coffeehouse Figure C5.Effects on scientific activity: randomization inference
*Notes:* Figure shows violin plots of 1,000 placebo estimates of equations (1) and (2) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. In each placebo dataset, we randomly assign the timing of the first coffeehouse opening to one of the decades from the 1650s to the 1690s for 61 of the 162 parishes. Violin plots show the distribution of placebo treatment effects by event time, with dots indicating the actual event study estimates. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. [Return to pages22,OA-22]
| (A)Mathematical practitioners | (B)Scientific instrument shops | |
|---|---|---|
| 4 | 5 | |
| 3 | 4 | |
| 2 | 3 | |
| 2 | ||
| 1 | ||
| 1 | ||
| 0 (.62) | 0 (.33) | |
| −1 | −1 | |
| −5−4−3−2−101234 | Decades since first coffeehouse | −5−4−3−2−101234 |
Decades since first coffeehouse Figure C6.Effects on scientific activity: conditional randomization inference
*Notes:* Figure shows violin plots of 1,000 placebo estimates of equations (1) and (2) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. In each placebo dataset, treated parishes are drawn without replacement within quintiles of the propensity score of ever receiving a coffeehouse, estimated by probit on pre-1652 taverns, tradesmen’s tokens, and booksellers, together with an indicator for the City of London, preserving the number treated in each quintile, and the observed decades of first entry are then assigned at random among the drawn parishes. Violin plots show the distribution of placebo treatment effects by event time, with dots indicating the actual event study estimates. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. [Return to pages22,OA-23]
OA-31
(A)Taverns (B)Luxury shops
Post-ATT =−0.40 (s.e. 0.46).4 Post-ATT = 0.01 (s.e. 0.11)
| 2 | .2 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 (.36) | |||||||||
| 0 (4.93) | |||||||||
| −.2 | |||||||||
| −2 | −.4 | ||||||||
| −4 | −.6 | ||||||||
| −5 | −4 −3 | −2 −1 | 0 1 | 2 3 | −5 | −4 −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse | ||||||||
| (C)Non-scientific letters | (D)Commercial premises | ||||||||
| 10 Post-ATT = 1.07 (s.e. 1.42) | 10 Post-ATT = 2.49 (s.e. 0.85) |
5 5
0 (1.16) 0 (2.52)
−5 −5 −5 −4 −3 −2 −1 0 1 2 3 4 −5 −4 −3 −2 −1 0 1 2 3 4
| −5 | −4 −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 | −5 | −4 −3 | −2 −1 | 0 1 | 2 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse | |||||||||
| (E)Baptisms per km² | (F)Deaths per km² | |||||||||
| 100 Post-ATT =−69 (s.e. 69) | 400 | Post-ATT =−16 (s.e. 91) | ||||||||
| 0 (530) | 200 | |||||||||
| −100 | 0 (781) | |||||||||
| −200 | −200 | |||||||||
| −300 | −400 | |||||||||
| −5 | −4 −3 | −2 | −1 | 0 | −5 | −4 −3 | −2 −1 | 0 1 | 2 3 | 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
Decades since first coffeehouse Decades since first coffeehouse
Figure C7.Effects on placebo outcomes
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on outcomes it should leave unmoved. Outcomes are the decadal number in a parish of taverns (Panel A), luxury shops (Panel B), non-scientific letters (Panel C), and commercial premises (Panel D, signed premises other than drinking houses), and the decadal number of baptisms and deaths per square kilometer (Panels E and F). Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s, except for baptisms, 130 of 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1660s, and deaths, 116 of 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s; deaths are recorded in 119 parishes, but three of them are observed in a single decade and drop out of a design with parish and decade effects. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after (for baptisms, the two decades observed). Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pagesOA-22, OA-23,OA-28]
OA-32
(A)Mathematical practitioners(B)Scientific instrument shops
Baseline
*Excluding coffeehouses sourced from*
Published and private
Administrative and official
Material and visual
Unknown
| .5 | 1 | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| PrePost |
−.5 0 1.5 0.5 1 1.5 2
Figure C8.Effects on scientific activity: dropping coffeehouse source categories
*Notes:* Figure reports average pre-treatment and post-treatment effects, with 95 percent confidence intervals, from equations (1) and (2), on mathematical practitioners (Panel A) and scientific instrument shops (Panel B). In each alternative specification, we exclude coffeehouses first recorded in the indicated source category. Pre-treatment effects are averages of event study estimates from five to two decades before opening; post-treatment effects are averages from opening through four decades after. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pages22,OA-24]
(A)Practitioners(B)Instrument shops
Baseline *Excluding coffeehouses sourced from* Trade tokens Parish, civic, and local records Newspapers and periodicals No source, unidentified, or unclear Printed books, pamphlets, and literary works Maps, views, inscriptions, and topographical evidence Secondary histories and reference works Company, commercial, and financial records State, legal, and court records Diaries, memoirs, and personal writings Advertisements, notices, and ephemera Manuscripts and private papers Catalogues, sales, and auctions
| −.5 0 | .5 1 | 1.5 | 0 .5 | 1 1.5 | 2 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PrePost |
Figure C9.Effects on scientific activity: dropping detailed coffeehouse source categories
*Notes:* Figure reports average pre-treatment and post-treatment effects, with 95 percent confidence intervals, from equations (1) and (2), on mathematical practitioners (Panel A) and scientific instrument shops (Panel B). In each alternative specification, we exclude coffeehouses first recorded in the indicated detailed source category. Pre-treatment effects are averages of event study estimates from five to two decades before opening; post-treatment effects are averages from opening through four decades after. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pages22,OA-24]
OA-33
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops Baseline·Post-ATT 0.68 (0.22) Baseline·Post-ATT 1.24 (0.31) Great Fire trends·Post-ATT 0.68 (0.22) Great Fire trends·Post-ATT 1.25 (0.31)
| 2 | 3 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | ||||||||
| 1 | |||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
0 (.62) 0 (.33)
Figure C10.Effects on scientific activity: control for exposure to the Great Fire
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity, from the baseline specification in equations (1) and (2), filled markers and shaded intervals, and the same equation including fixed effects for the interaction between an indicator for exposure to the Great Fire and each decade, hollow markers and outlined intervals. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-24]
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops
5 3 Baseline·Post-ATT 0.68 (0.22) Baseline·Post-ATT 1.24 (0.31) London Wall trends·Post-ATT 0.68 (0.22) London Wall trends·Post-ATT 1.24 (0.31) 4
| 2 | 3 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | ||||||||
| 1 | |||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
0 (.62) 0 (.33)
Figure C11.Effects on scientific activity: control for location within the London Wall
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity, from the baseline specification in equations (1) and (2), filled markersandshadedintervals, andthesameequationincludingfixedeffectsfortheinteractionbetweenan indicator for whether a parish lies within the London Wall and each decade, hollow markers and outlined intervals. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-24]
OA-34
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops 10·Post-ATT 0.68 (0.22) 10·Post-ATT 1.24 (0.31)
6 2 4 0 (.62) 2
−2 0 (.33) −50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20 30 40 50 −50 −40 −30 −20 −10 0 10 20 30 40 50 Years since first coffeehouse Years since first coffeehouse
Figure C12.Effects on scientific activity by time-frame length
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity. Outcomes are the number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. For instrument shops at three and two years, effects vary by event time but not by cohort, since equation (1) leaves their standard errors uncomputable. Sample includes all 162 parishes from 1600 to 1699. Unit of observation is parish-period, with periods of ten, five, three, or two years. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT, shown for ten-year periods only, is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after. Averages over shorter periods are not comparable with it, since counts per period fall with period length and their window ends 40 years after entry, whereas the last decadal estimate runs to 49 years after the start of the decade of entry. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-25]
3 km Figure C13.Hexagonal partition of London
*Notes:* Map of London divided into 15,351 hexagons of 5,000 m² each, with white lines for hexagon boundaries and black lines for the 162 parish boundaries. [Return to pagesOA-26,OA-36]
OA-35
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops Baseline Baseline Parish-by-decade FE Parish-by-decade FE
| .5 | 1.5 | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||||||
| .5 0 (.07) | ||||||||||
| −.5 | −.5 | |||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 | −4 −3 | −2 −1 | 0 1 | 2 3 | 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
0 (.12)
Figure C14.Effects on scientific activity: grid cell level
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity, without and with parish-by-decade fixed effects. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a 5,000 m² hexagon. Sample includes all 15,351 hexagons (seeFigure C13) from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is hexagon-decade. The parish-by-decade specification drops the 593 hexagons whose centroid falls outside every parish, none of them treated; 155 of the 162 parishes contain at least one hexagon. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-26]
(A)All shops and guild-linked shops (B)Guild-linked shops
5 All shops·Post-ATT 1.24 (0.31) Baseline·Post-ATT 0.99 (0.25) Guild-linked shops·Post-ATT 0.99 (0.25) Great Fire trends·Post-ATT 0.99 (0.24) 4 3
3 2 2 1 1
0 0 (.26)
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
Figure C15.Effects on guild-linked scientific instrument shops
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific instrument shops. Panel A counts all shops, filled markers and shaded intervals, and only those operated by instrument makers for whom a guild is recorded, hollow markers and outlined intervals; the sample mean one decade before treatment is 0.33 for all shops and 0.26 for guild-linked shops. Panel B counts guild-linked shops, without controls, filled markers and shaded intervals, and including fixed effects for the interaction between an indicator for exposure to the Great Fire and each decade, hollow markers and outlined intervals; the parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-24]
OA-36
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops Pre Pre Post Post
| Post | 5 Post | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 4 | ||||
| 3 | |||||
| 2 | |||||
| 0 | 1 | ||||
| 0 | |||||
| −1 | −1 | ||||
| Baseline | Unburnt Before 1666 | Attested | Baseline | Unburnt Before 1666 | Attested |
| (0.62) | (1.00) | (0.66) | (0.33) | (0.52) | (0.34) |
(0.49) (0.29) Figure C16.Effects on scientific activity: records lost in the Great Fire
*Notes:* Figure reports average pre-treatment and post-treatment effects of first coffeehouse opening, with 95 percent confidence intervals, from equations (1) and (2), each divided by the mean of the outcome among treated parishes one decade before treatment in its own sample, which the parenthetical under each label reports. Baseline uses all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unburnt keeps the 67 parishes outside the area burnt in the Great Fire of 1666. Before 1666 ends the panel in the 1660s; parishes first treated from the 1670s serve as controls there. Attested drops the five treated parishes with no coffeehouse recorded after 1666 and keeps the other 56 at their baseline entry dates. Pre-treatment effects are averages of event study estimates from five to two decades before opening; post-treatment effects are averages from opening through four decades after. The dotted line marks the baseline post-treatment effect. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-24]
Mathematical practitioners Scientific instrument makers
People
151 93 159
Post-ATT (relative) 0.99 1.62 5.77 (Standard error) (0.36) (0.53) (1.45)
Figure C17.Overlap between the outcome rosters
*Notes:* Figure shows a Venn diagram of the two outcome rosters: the 244 mathematical practitioners of Taylor(1954) in the London sample described inSection 3(left), the 252 scientific instrument makers recorded in SIMON and active in the same century (right), and the 93 people matched across the two (intersection), as described inAppendix C.6. Beneath each count is the post-ATT from equation (1), averaging the decade of treatment and the four decades thereafter, estimated on that region alone and divided by its mean one decade before treatment. Regions count people rather than shops. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors, in parentheses, clustered by parish. [Return to pagesOA-25,OA-38]
OA-37
(A)Event study (B)Pre- and post-entry averages
Practitioners only Practitioners onlyBothMakers only Both 20 Makers only
| 15 | 6 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 4 | ||||||
| 5 | 2 | ||||||
| 0 | 0 | ||||||
| −5 | −4 −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | |||
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Pre | Pre Post | Pre Post |
Post
Figure C18.Effects by cell of the roster partition
*Notes:* Figure shows the effect of first coffeehouse opening from equation (1) estimated separately on each region of the partition inFigure C17: practitioners recorded only byTaylor(1954) (Practitioners only), people recorded in both rosters (Both), and instrument makers recorded only by SIMON (Makers only). The three regions start from pre-entry means of 0.36, 0.36, and 0.11, so both panels are expressed relative to the pre-entry mean of the region they belong to. Panel A divides each event study estimate and interval by that mean. Panel B divides the outcome itself by that mean before estimation, and then averages the coefficients over the pre-entry and post-entry windows. Whiskers and shaded intervals are 95 percent intervals. Every region counts people, not shops. Hence, a person enters once per parish-decade, and the maker series differs from the shop count used in the main text. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-25]
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops
5 3 Baseline·Post-ATT 0.68 (0.22) Baseline·Post-ATT 1.24 (0.31) Not-yet-treated·Post-ATT 0.67 (0.22) Not-yet-treated·Post-ATT 1.23 (0.30) 4
| 2 | 3 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | ||||||||
| 1 | |||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
0 (.62) 0 (.33)
Figure C19.Effects on scientific activity: never- and not-yet-treated controls
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals from the baseline specification in equations (1) and (2), filled markers and shaded intervals, and the estimator ofCallaway and Sant’Anna(2021), hollow markers and outlined intervals, where the control group consists of both never- and not-yet-treated parishes. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-26]
OA-38
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops Baseline·Post-ATT 0.68 (0.22) Baseline·Post-ATT 1.24 (0.31) Non-absorbing·Post-ATT 0.67 (0.23) Non-absorbing·Post-ATT 1.23 (0.31)
2
| 2 | 3 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | ||||||||
| 1 | |||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
0 (.62) 0 (.33)
Figure C20.Effects on scientific activity: non-absorbing treatment
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals from the baseline specifi- cation in equations (1) and (2), filled markers and shaded intervals, and the estimator ofde Chaisemartin and D’Haultfoeuille(2026) for the effect of coffeehouse presence on scientific activity, hollow markers and outlined intervals. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-25]
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops
.8 1 Post-ATT =−0.11 (s.e. 0.07) Post-ATT =−0.21 (s.e. 0.16)
.6
.5
.4
.2 0 (.82)
0 (.59) −.5 −.2 −.4 −1 −5 −4 −3 −2 −1 0 1 2 3 −5 −4 −3 −2 −1 0 1 2 3
| −5 | −4 −3 | −2 −1 | 0 1 | 2 3 | −5 | −4 −3 | −2 −1 | 0 1 | 2 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Decades since last coffeehouse closed | Decades since last coffeehouse closed |
Figure C21.Effects on scientific activity: closing down the last coffeehouse
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals based onde Chaisemartin and D’Haultfoeuille(2026) for the effect of closing the last coffeehouse on scientific activity. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before closure. The label in the upper left of each panel reports the average of the four dynamic effects, with its standard error. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-25]
OA-39
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops Baseline·Post-ATT 0.68 (0.22) Baseline·Post-ATT 1.24 (0.31) Group-specific trends·Post-ATT 0.61 (0.22) Group-specific trends·Post-ATT 1.15 (0.31)
| 2 | 3 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | ||||||||
| 1 | |||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
0 (.62) 0 (.33)
Figure C22.Effects on scientific activity: group-specific trends
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity, from the baseline specification in equations (1) and (2), filled markers and shaded intervals, and the same equation on outcomes net of linear trends estimated by treatment cohort on pre-treatment observations (Goodman-Bacon,2021), hollow markers and outlined intervals. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample mean of the unadjusted outcome one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pagesOA-15,OA-26]
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops
4 Lower 95% limit 6 Lower 95% limit Estimate Estimate 3 Upper 95% limit Upper 95% limit 4 2 Post-ATT = 0.68 (s.e. 0.22) Post-ATT = 1.24 (s.e. 0.31)
| 1 | 2 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 (.62) | |||||||||
| −1 | |||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
0 (.33)
Figure C23.Effects on scientific activity: leave-one-out sensitivity check
*Notes:* Figure shows boxplots, including outliers, of event study estimates and their 95 percent confidence limits from equations (1) and (2) for the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. The boxplots use 162 samples from the 1600s to the 1690s, with each parish omitted once. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the full-sample average of the estimates from entry through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-26]
OA-40
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops Baseline 95 percent interval Baseline 95 percent interval Robust 95 percent interval Robust 95 percent interval
2 3
| 2 | 3 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | ||||||
| 0 | 1 | ||||||
| −1 | 0 | ||||||
| −2 | −1 | ||||||
| Baseline | 0 0.5 | 1 1.5 𝑀 | 2 2.5 3 | Baseline | 0 0.5 | 1 1.5 𝑀 | 2 2.5 3 |
Figure C24.Effects on scientific activity: violations of parallel trends
*Notes:* Figureshows95percentconfidenceintervalsfortheaveragepost-treatmenteffectoffirstcoffeehouse opening from equations (1) and (2) that allow parallel trends to fail, followingRambachan and Roth (2023). Under their relative-magnitudes restriction, the change in the violation of parallel trends from one decade to the next after entry is at most *𝑀*times the largest such change before entry; the intervals use their conditional least-favorable hybrid. The interval labeled “Baseline” is the conventional one, with its point estimate, and the vertical line marks *𝑀*=1. Post-treatment effects are averages of event study estimates from opening through four decades after. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to page OA-26]
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops
3 Baseline·Post-ATT 0.68 (0.22) Baseline·Post-ATT 1.24 (0.31) 5 Poisson·Post-ATT 0.59 (0.26) Poisson·Post-ATT 0.98 (0.36) 4
| 2 | 3 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | ||||||||
| 1 | |||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
0 (.62) 0 (.33)
Figure C25.Effects on scientific activity: Poisson specification
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity, from the baseline linear specification in equations (1) and (2), filled markers and shaded intervals, and the Poisson specification in equation (3), hollow markers and outlined intervals. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Poisson estimates are average differences in predicted counts. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-26]
OA-41
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops
1.5 Post-ATT = 0.33 (s.e. 0.11) Post-ATT = 0.56 (s.e. 0.11)
| 1 | 1.5 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | |||||||||
| .5 | |||||||||
| .5 | |||||||||
| 0 (.4) | 0 (.25) | ||||||||
| −.5 | −.5 | ||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
Figure C26.Effects on scientific activity: inverse hyperbolic sine
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals for the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity, obtained by estimating equations (1) and (2) with the inverse hyperbolic sine of the outcome. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after, on the inverse hyperbolic sine scale. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to pageOA-26]
(A)Mathematical practitioners (B)Scientific instrument shops
5 3 Post-ATT = 0.68 (s.e. 0.22, 0.22, 0.20, 0.18) Post-ATT = 1.24 (s.e. 0.29, 0.29, 0.28, 0.26)
0.25 km 0.25 km
4
0.5 km 0.5 km
2 1 km 3 1 km 2 km 2 km 2
| 1 | 2 | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | |||||||||
| −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 | −5 −4 | −3 −2 | −1 0 | 1 2 | 3 4 |
| Decades since first coffeehouse | Decades since first coffeehouse |
0 (.62) 0 (.33)
Figure C27.Effects on scientific activity:Conley(1999) standard errors
*Notes:* Figure shows event study estimates and 95 percent confidence intervals from equations (1) and (2) of the effect of first coffeehouse opening on scientific activity. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. Unit of observation is parish-decade. The parenthetical next to 0 on the vertical axis reports the sample outcome mean one decade before treatment. Standard errors follow Conley(1999): they allow for heteroskedasticity, for correlation between any two decades of the same parish, and for correlation within a decade between parishes whose centroids lie within the cutoff, with weights declining linearly in distance; the cutoffs are 0.25, 0.5, 1, and 2 kilometers. At 2 kilometers the estimated variance matrix is not positive semidefinite, and the interval two decades before opening cannot be computed. Post-ATT is the average of the estimates from entry through four decades after, with its standard error under each distance cutoff, in the order of the legend. [Return to pageOA-26]
OA-42
C.13.Tables
Table C1—Balance of pre-treatment levels
| Parishes | Normalized | |
|---|---|---|
| Panel A. Demographics | Treatment | difference |
| Baptisms, 1600s–1640s130 | 84.72(120.74)57.44(113.62)0.23 | |
| Baptisms per km², 1600s–1640s130 | 493.76(349.55)634.63(503.77) | −0.32 |
| Deaths, 1600s–1640s110 | 117.25(174.38)86.08(159.55)0.19 | |
| Deaths per km², 1600s–1640s110 | 740.21(564.89)872.94(665.37) | −0.22 |
| Households, 1638107 | 249.00(329.67)157.87(255.37)0.31 | |
| Households per km², 1638107 Panel B. Wealth | 3419.34(1368.22)4114.09(2010.83) | −0.40 |
| Median tax paid, 158298 | 93.20(87.91)124.53(132.58) | −0.28 |
| Substantial households (%), 163892 Panel C. Social capital and commerce | 26.45(15.99)25.97(20.17)0.03 | |
| Apothecaries, 1617–1640s162 | 0.12(0.32)0.03(0.11)0.39 | |
| Booksellers, 1600s–1640s162 | 1.53(3.29)0.19(0.37)0.57 | |
| Clay-pipe finds, 1600s–1640s162 | 0.50(2.50)0.39(1.98)0.05 | |
| Commercial premises, 1600s–1640s162 | 0.50(0.90)0.06(0.18)0.68 | |
| Dissenting meetings, 1600s–1640s162 | 0.33(0.85)0.06(0.34)0.41 | |
| Goldsmiths, 1600–1651162 | 0.18(1.18)0.05(0.41)0.15 | |
| Luxury shops, 1600s–1640s162 | 0.07(0.20)0.05(0.17)0.13 | |
| Taverns, 1600s–1640s162 | 3.01(3.63)0.53(1.21)0.92 | |
| Theaters, 1600s–1640s162 | 0.08(0.23)0.04(0.19)0.15 | |
| Tradesmen’s tokens, 1648–1651162 Panel D. Science before 1652 | 1.16(1.88)0.23(1.02)0.62 | |
| Instrument shops, 1600s–1640s162 | 0.15(0.40)0.05(0.20)0.32 | |
| Non-scientific letters, 1600s–1640s162 | 3.87(10.41)1.09(3.98)0.35 | |
| Practitioners, 1600s–1640s162 | 0.40(0.95)0.16(0.48)0.32 | |
| Scientific letters, 1600s–1640s162 Panel E. Geography | 0.38(1.08)0.23(1.38)0.12 | |
| Area (km²)162 | 0.99(4.23)1.28(4.37) | −0.07 |
| City of London162 | 0.80(0.40)0.63(0.48)0.38 | |
| Distance to Gresham College (km)162 | 1.18(1.02)1.37(1.20) | −0.18 |
| Distance to Paternoster Row (km)162 | 1.01(0.88)1.24(1.12) | −0.24 |
| Distance to the Royal Exchange (km) | 1.01(1.01)1.22(1.21) | −0.19 |
| Inside the London Wall162 | 0.66(0.48)0.56(0.50)0.19 | |
| Parishes162 with parishes with no recorded coffeehouse (control). All characteristics predate the first London coffeehouse opening in 1652. The nonmissing column reports the number of parishes with a nonmissing value. Treatment and control columns report means, with standard deviations in parentheses. Values labeled 1600s–1640s are averages of observed decadal counts from 1600 through 1640, except scientific letters, non-scientific letters, and dissenting meetings, which are period totals. Normalized differences are the difference between the treatment and control means divided by the square root of the average sample variance. [Return to pages18,21,24,OA-22,OA-28,OA-29,OA-44,OA-55] | 61 |
Notes:TablecomparesLondonparisheswithrecordedcoffeehousesintheseventeenthcentury(treatment)
Nonmissing Control
OA-43
Table C2—Balance of pre-treatment changes
Observed Treatment Control Normalized parishes parishes parishes difference *Panel A. Demographics* Baptisms130 31*.*49(73*.*83)17*.*93(76*.*60)0*.*18 Baptisms per km² 130 104*.*57(196*.*59)107*.*73(239*.*48) −0*.*01 Deaths91 26*.*44(100*.*91)7*.*08(83*.*22)0*.*21 Deaths per km² 91 10*.*61(183*.*58)37*.*26(286*.*36) −0*.*11 *Panel B. Social capital and commerce* Booksellers162−0*.*04(2*.*15) −0*.*01(0*.*56) −0*.*02 Clay-pipe finds162 0*.*16(0*.*91)0*.*26(1*.*28) −0*.*09 Commercial premises162 0*.*50(1*.*02)0*.*10(0*.*37)0*.*52 Dissenting meetings162 0*.*08(0*.*41)0*.*03(0*.*17)0*.*17 Luxury shops162 0*.*11(0*.*33)0*.*09(0*.*37)0*.*06 Taverns162 4*.*16(4*.*67)0*.*67(1*.*63)1*.*00 Theaters162 0*.*02(0*.*24) −0*.*03(0*.*16)0*.*25 *Panel C. Scientific activity before 1652* Instrument shops162 0*.*09(0*.*32)0*.*06(0*.*36)0*.*08 Non-scientific letters162 0*.*68(2*.*52)0*.*24(1*.*47)0*.*21 Practitioners162 0*.*07(0*.*81)0*.*10(0*.*52) −0*.*05 Scientific letters162 0*.*03(0*.*40) −0*.*03(0*.*68)0*.*11 Parishes162 61 101 *Notes:* Table compares the change in each pre-treatment characteristic between the 1600s–1610s and the 1630s–1640s, for London parishes that received a coffeehouse and parishes that never did. Entries are mean changes with standard deviations in parentheses. Characteristics that are fixed or recorded once, reported in TableC1, have no change to measure. Apothecaries are omitted because the source begins in 1617. Normalized differences are the difference between the treatment and control mean changes divided by the square root of the average sample variance of the changes. [Return to pages22,OA-22,OA-55]
OA-44
Table C3—Covariate adjustment on the full sample and on common support
| All parishes | Common support | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Practitioners | Shops | Practitioners | Shops | |
| Unadjusted0.68 | (0.22) [0.99] | 1.24 (0.31) [0.29] | 0.46 (0.22) [0.29] | 0.85 (0.29) [0.45] |
| Weighted0.56 | (0.25) [0.89] | 0.99 (0.37) [0.45] | 0.34 (0.24) [0.63] | 0.60 (0.37) [0.46] |
| Score by decade0.31 | (0.24) [0.46] | 0.64 (0.30) [0.58] | 0.33 (0.24) [0.62] | 0.59 (0.31) [0.53] |
| Pre-entry mean0.62 | 0.33 | 0.56 | 0.29 | |
| Treated parishes61 | 61 | 48 | 48 | |
| Control parishes101 | 101 | 101 | 101 |
*Notes:* Table reports the equal-weighted average of the event study estimates from entry through four decades after, from equation (1) with never-treated controls. Unadjusted is the baseline. Weighted reweights control parishes by the odds of treatment from a probit propensity score for ever being treated on pre-1652 taverns, tradesmen’s tokens (1648–1651), booksellers, and an indicator for the City of London, so that the estimate refers to the treated parishes; weights are not trimmed. Score by decade interacts the propensity score with decade fixed effects. Common support drops the treated parishes whose propensity score exceeds that of every control parish; no control parish falls below the smallest treated score. Pre-entry means are the mean of the outcome among treated parishes one decade before treatment, in the sample of the column. Outcomes are the decadal number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops in a parish. Sample includes the 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s, less those a column drops. Unit of observation is parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish in parentheses; *𝑝*-values of the joint test that the estimates two to five decades before entry are zero in brackets. [Return to pages22,OA-22]
OA-45
Table C4—Correlation between coffeehouses and taverns
| Coffeehouses (standardized) | Coffeehouses | > 0 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| (1) | (2) | (3) | (4) | (5) | (6) | (7) | (8) | |
| Taverns (standardized) | 0.408 (0. 067) (0 | 0.264. 094) (0 | 0.412. 068) (0 | 0.251. 103) | ||||
| Taverns > 0 | 0. 169 (0. 025) (0 | 0. 073. 035) (0 | 0. 154. 024) (0 | 0. 017. 032) | ||||
| Mean dep. var. | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0.107 | 0.107 | 0.107 | 0.107 |
| Observations | 1620 | 1620 | 1620 | 1620 | 1620 | 1620 | 1620 | 1620 |
| Parish FE✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | |||||
| Decade FE✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
*Notes:* Table shows the relationship between coffeehouses and taverns. Columns 1–4 show effect sizes from regressions of the number of coffeehouses on the number of taverns, standardized to mean 0 and standard deviation 1. Beginning with the raw correlation in Column 1, the specifications add parish fixed effects, decade fixed effects, and both parish and decade fixed effects. Columns 5–8 show the corresponding extensive-margin regressions of indicators for coffeehouses and taverns with the same sequence of fixed effects. The sample includes all 162 parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. The unit of observation is the parish-decade. Standard errors clustered by parish. [Return to page24]
OA-46
Table C5—Coffeehouse cities relative to comparison cities, alternative samples
Pre-entry mean Post-entry difference
Titles Makers Titles Makers
| Baseline5.95 | 3.73 | 4.97 | 4.89 |
|---|---|---|---|
| (2.30) | (2.97) | ||
| Country-by-decade fixed effects5.95 | 3.73 | 4.25 (2.38) | 3.15 (3.21) |
| Without London5.22 | 2.42 | 1.67 (1.29) | 0.98 (0.49) |
| Without London, first two decades5.22 | 2.42 | 2.29 (1.29) | 0.91 (0.53) |
| Country-by-decade fixed effects, without London5.22 | 2.42 | 2.23 (1.48) | 1.55 (0.69) |
| Without Paris5.56 | 3.17 | 4.26 (2.26) | 4.73 (3.05) |
| Without any capital3.56 | 1.56 | 1.26 (0.93) | 0.23 (0.33) |
| Only France, Germany, the Netherlands, and the UK6.96 | 4.67 | 5.18 (1.42) | 5.92 (0.38) |
*Notes:* Table reports the equal-weighted post-entry difference from entry through three decades after, from equation (1) estimated at the city level with never-treated controls and log population in 1600 and growth from 1500 to 1600 by decade, the average of the estimates inFigure 13. The row marked first two decades averages from entry through two decades after instead, since the third decade rests on the seven coffeehouse cities other than London that opened by the 1660s. Without any capital drops the ten coffeehouse cities and eleven comparison cities that were seats of government. Pre-entry means are the mean of the outcome among coffeehouse cities in the decade before entry, in the sample of the row. Titles are applied mathematics titles; makers are scientific instrument makers. Sample includes all 200 cities from the 1600s to the 1690s, less those a row drops. Unit of observation is city-decade. Standard errors clustered by city in parentheses. [Return to pages34,OA-27,OA-48]
OA-47
Table C6—Coffeehouse cities relative to comparison cities, alternative entry decades
| Pre-entry mean | Post-entry difference | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Titles | Makers | Titles | Makers | |
| Baseline5.95 | 3.73 | 4.97 (2.30) | 4.89 (2.97) | |
| Earliest admissible decade5.74 | 3.56 | 4.75 (2.24) | 4.76 (2.92) | |
| Latest admissible decade6.47 | 3.79 | 4.59 (1.42) | 6.09 (0.53) | |
| Without the recoded cities5.76 | 3.76 | 5.45 (1.58) | 6.69 (0.61) |
*Notes:* Table reports post-entry differences as inTable C5under alternative entry decades. The sources admit more than one entry decade for Rome (1650s–1690s), Venice (1680s or dropped), Utrecht (1670s or 1680s), Nuremberg (1680s or 1690s), Bremen (1660s or 1670s), Haarlem (1680s or never), Alkmaar (1680s or 1690s), and Antwerp (1680s or 1690s); the earliest and latest rows assign every one of them to the end of its interval, and the last row drops them together with The Hague and Leiden, whose dates were recoded on source grounds. Haarlem and Alkmaar are comparison cities in the baseline. Pre-entry means are the mean of the outcome among coffeehouse cities in the decade before entry, in the sample of the row. Titles are applied mathematics titles; makers are scientific instrument makers. Sample includes all 200 cities from the 1600s to the 1690s, less those the last row drops. Unit of observation is city-decade. Standard errors clustered by city in parentheses. [Return to pages33,OA-27]
OA-48
D.DATA APPENDIX
D.1.Summary Statistics
Table D1—Summary statistics, London
<u>Distribution Units</u> Non-Non- Mean SD p25 p75 Max N missing zero
| SD | p25 | p75 | Max | N | missing | zero | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Panel A. Main outcomes | |||||||
| Mathematical practitioners0.43 | 1.16 | 0 | 0 | 12 | 1,620 | 162 | 69 |
| Scientific instrument shops0.30 | 1.05 | 0 | 0 | 13 | 1,620 | 162 | 68 |
| Guild-linked0.23 | 0.87 | 0 | 0 | 11 | 1,620 | 162 | 54 |
| Applied scientists0.65 Panel B. Mechanism outcomes | 1.61 | 0 | 1 | 19 | 1,620 | 162 | 91 |
| Below-median practitioners0.21 | 0.63 | 0 | 0 | 6 | 1,620 | 162 | 53 |
| Above-median practitioners0.23 | 0.71 | 0 | 0 | 7 | 1,620 | 162 | 48 |
| All connections1.26 | 4.29 | 0 | 0 | 55 | 1,620 | 162 | 58 |
| Between makers and theorists0.58 | 2.12 | 0 | 0 | 33 | 1,620 | 162 | 52 |
| Among makers0.20 | 0.86 | 0 | 0 | 12 | 1,620 | 162 | 38 |
| Among theorists0.48 | 1.98 | 0 | 0 | 19 | 1,620 | 162 | 36 |
| Experimental instrument shops0.12 | 0.58 | 0 | 0 | 9 | 1,620 | 162 | 43 |
| Practical instrument shops0.17 | 0.65 | 0 | 0 | 9 | 1,620 | 162 | 53 |
| Teachers and instrument masters0.25 | 0.75 | 0 | 0 | 7 | 1,620 | 162 | 61 |
| Instrument masters’ apprentices0.17 | 0.89 | 0 | 0 | 13 | 1,620 | 162 | 37 |
| Senior-to-junior practitioner connections0.57 | 1.99 | 0 | 0 | 19 | 1,620 | 162 | 51 |
| Dated works0.53 | 2.47 | 0 | 0 | 32 | 1,620 | 162 | 43 |
| Distinct instrument classes0.17 | 0.46 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 1,620 | 162 | 65 |
| Royal Society fellows0.21 | 1.12 | 0 | 0 | 20 | 1,620 | 162 | 45 |
| Booksellers0.83 Panel C. Treatment and placebo outcomes | 2.50 | 0 | 1 | 27 | 1,620 | 162 | 99 |
| Coffeehouses open0.28 | 1.23 | 0 | 0 | 16 | 1,620 | 162 | 61 |
| Baptisms per km² | 566 447 | 289 | 747 3,972 | 910 | 130 | 130 | |
| Deaths per km² | 810 616 | 464 1,010 | 4,618 | 963 | 119 | 119 | |
| Luxury shops0.15 | 0.60 | 0 | 0 | 7 | 1,620 | 162 | 45 |
| Non-scientific letters0.75 | 4.53 | 0 | 0 | 81 | 1,620 | 162 | 67 |
| Taverns1.82 | 3.92 | 0 | 2 | 47 | 1,620 | 162 | 108 |
| Commercial premises0.96 Panel D. Parishes | 3.54 | 0 | 0 | 38 | 1,620 | 162 | 78 |
| Coffeehouse by the 1690s0.38 | 0.49 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 162 | 162 | 61 |
| City of London0.70 | 0.46 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 162 | 162 | 113 |
| Inside the London Wall0.60 | 0.49 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 162 | 162 | 97 |
| Exposed to the Great Fire0.59 | 0.49 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 162 | 162 | 95 |
| Area (km²)1.17 unit of observation is the parish-decade in Panels A to C and the parish in Panel D. Columns p25 and p75 report the 25th and 75th percentiles, and N the number of observations. Baptisms and deaths are recorded for fewer than the 1,620 parish-decades of the panel. The nonmissing and nonzero columns count the parishes with at least one recorded value and with at least one value above zero. Rows without units are counts, except the indicators of Panel D, which take the value 0 or 1. Below- and above-median practitioners split the practitioners at the median of 𝑧(𝑠) in equation (4). Applied scientists are the practitioners and makers ofSection 7, with a person in both rosters counted once.Appendix Ddefines each variable. | 4.31 | 0.03 | 0.18 32.27 | 162 | 162 | 162 |
Notes:Table reports summary statistics for the 162 London parishes from the 1600s to the 1690s. The
OA-49
Table D2—Summary statistics, European cities
<u>Distribution Units</u> Non-Non-
| SD p25 | p75 | Max | N missing | zero | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Panel A. Outcomes | ||||||
| Applied mathematics titles1.71 | 6.70 | 0 1 | 128 | 2,000 | 200 | 120 |
| Scientific instrument makers1.11 Panel B. Other | 6.78 | 0 0 | 144 | 2,000 | 200 | 84 |
| Coffeehouse by the 1690s0.18 | 0.39 | 0 0 | 1 | 200 | 200 | 37 |
| Population, 1600 (thousands)30.02 | 37.09 | 12 32 | 300 | 200 | 200 | 200 |
| Population growth, 1500 to 1600 (log points)0.32 | 0.42 0.09 | 0.56 | 1.61 | 200 | 200 | 193 |
| Seat of government0.10 | 0.31 | 0 0 | 1 | 200 | 200 | 21 |
| Copy ofDe revolutionibus, 16200.09 | 0.28 | 0 0 | 1 | 200 | 200 | 17 |
| Distance to the nearest coffee port (km)448 1690s. The unit of observation is the city-decade in Panel A and the city in Panel B. Columns p25 and p75 report the 25th and 75th percentiles, and N the number of observations. The nonmissing and nonzero columns count the cities with at least one recorded value and with at least one value above zero. Rows without units are counts, except the indicators of Panel B, which take the value 0 or 1.Appendix D defines each variable. [Return to page17] | 327 174 | 666 | 1,317 | 200 | 200 | 200 |
Notes:Table reports summary statistics for the 200 European cities ofSection 6from the 1600s to the
Mean SD p25 p75 Max N missing zero
Table D3—Summary statistics, Hooke’s diary
<u>Distribution</u> Mean
| SD | p25 | p75 | Max | N | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coffeehouse day0.65 | 0.48 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 3,464 |
| Other public house day0.10 | 0.30 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 3,464 |
| People recorded4.71 | 3.81 | 2 | 7 | 24 | 3,464 |
| In the network1.86 | 1.77 | 0 | 3 | 11 | 3,464 |
| Outside it2.85 1683. The unit of observation is the day. Columns p25 and p75 report the 25th and 75th percentiles, and N the number of days. Coffeehouse and other public house days are indicators, which take the value 0 or 1, and people recorded are counts. People in the network sent at least one letter from London in the seventeenth century recorded inEarly Modern Letters Online.Appendix Ddefines each variable. [Return to page17] | 2.67 | 1 | 4 | 21 | 3,464 |
Notes:Table reports summary statistics for the 3,464 days of Hooke’s diary from 10 March 1672 to 15 May
D.2.Treatment Variable
*Coffeehouses, 1652–1699 (Lillywhite,1963,1972).*Defined as the number of coffee- houses established between 1652 and 1699 in a given parish, based on public houses identified as coffeehouses, excluding entries explicitly marked as duplicates. When the source is uncertain whether two mentions refer to the same establishment, both are retained as separate entries. The source data contain 287 coffeehouses first recorded before 1700. Don Saltero’s coffeehouse in Chelsea, first recorded in 1695, lies outside the 162-parish study area and is therefore excluded, which leaves 286.Appendix Table D6 summarizes the historical sources that record them. For any year *𝑡*, the count includes all coffeehouses whose recorded years of activity encompass*𝑡*, as determined by their earliest and latest mentions. Of the 286, 107 are mentioned in a single year and count as open in that year only. Where only a decade is known (9 of the 286 coffeehouses), activity years are set to the full decade range (e.g., 1660s as 1660–1669). The count also
OA-50
includes chocolate houses, which the source treats as one subject with coffeehouses and at times cannot separate, typing a house “Chocolate or Coffee-house?” Five of the 286 are recorded as chocolate houses, four of them in St. James Westminster, a parish treated from 1659 on Harper’s Coffee House. The fifth, in Queen’s Head Alley, is the earliest record in St. Botolph Bishopsgate, at 1657; without it that parish enters in the 1660s. Appendix D.11assesses the completeness of these counts against independent records.
D.3.Outcome Variables
The two main outcomes are mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops. They measure applied scientific activity in a parish and decade. The remaining outcome variables support the mechanism analyses ofSection 5and the European comparison ofSection 6.
*Mathematical Practitioners, 1600–1699 (Taylor,1954).*Defined as the number of mathematical practitioners in a given parish and decade. This count encompasses all practitioners who have at least one workplace in London and whose recorded flourishing overlaps 1600–1699. Each practitioner contributes a record for every decade from the decade containing the first year of flourishing to the decade containing the last, and is assigned in each decade to the parish of each workplace recorded for that decade. Each workplace carries the yearsTaylor(1954) gives for it, and where she dates no move, the period of flourishing is split at its midpoint. Practitioners therefore count in two parishes only in the decade of a move or while two addresses overlap, in 28 of 670 practitioner-decades. In a given parish-decade, a practitioner is counted once, independently of how many workplaces the source records.
##### Connections Between Mathematical Practitioners, 1600–1699 (Taylor,1954;Warren
*etal.,2016).*Definedasthenumberofconnectionsbetweenmathematicalpractitioners in a given parish and decade. It counts the undirected pairs with *𝐴𝑖𝑗𝑡*=1 defined in Appendix D.4, each counted once in every parish where practitioner *𝑖* or *𝑗* works, so that a connection between a practitioner in one parish and a practitioner in another parish counts in both, and a connection between two practitioners in the same parish counts once. Connections are further split by whether each endpoint is a maker or a theorist, defined as any practitioner who is not a maker.
*Scientific Instrument Shops, 1600–1699 (Clifton,1995;Hay et al.,2025).*Defined as the number of scientific instrument shops in a given parish and decade. Each shop is one maker at one recorded address over the years the source gives for it, so makers who move open a new shop, and the 252 makers in the panel operate 345 shops. In a given parish-decade, each shop is counted once, and a maker counts twice only where the source records two of their addresses in the same parish and decade, in 31 of 447 maker-parish-decades.
*Practical Instrument Shops, 1600–1699 (Clifton,1995;Hay et al.,2025).*Defined as scientific instrument shops whose makers are recorded as producing mathematical, navigational, or surveying instruments, counted as above. This category includes the
OA-51
tools used for measuring, calculating, and setting out, such as sectors, dividers, and slide rules. It also includes the tools of navigators, such as quadrants, nocturnals, and compasses, and those of surveyors, such as theodolites, circumferentors, levels, and waywisers.
*Experimental Instrument Shops, 1600–1699 (Clifton,1995;Hay et al.,2025).*Defined as scientific instrument shops whose makers are recorded as producing optical or philosophical instruments, counted as above. This category includes optical instru- ments (microscopes, refracting and reflecting telescopes, and lenses) and philosophical instruments (air pumps, barometers, and thermometers).
*Guild-LinkedInstrumentShops,1600–1699(Clifton,1995;Hayetal.,2025).*Definedas scientific instrument shops restricted to makers with a recorded London guild, counted as above. Of the 252 makers active in the panel, 175 have a recorded guild. None of the London guilds were specifically dedicated to instrument making, so instrument makers could only join an existing guild, and most London makers did (Cormack,2017, p. 79). Hence, the restriction keeps the makers who joined a guild and whose membership survives in the record.
*Royal Society Fellows, 1660–1699 (The Royal Society,2024).*Defined as the number of Fellows of the Royal Society associated with a parish in a given decade, restricted to fellows whose recorded place of death or burial lies in London. This variable assigns fellows to their parish of death, or to their burial site when the parish of death is unknown. The variable counts each fellow for every decade from the decade of election through the last decade of recorded fellowship. That is, a fellow is placed where their life ended, not at their workplaces, and the variable is a long-run outcome that records where the membership eventually lived. Note that since the Royal Society was founded in 1660, this variable is by definition 0 before 1660.
*Instrument Makers’ Apprentices, 1600–1699 (Clifton,1995).*Defined as the number of apprentice bindings recorded to scientific instrument masters in a parish and decade. The source records each master’s apprentices as a free-text list of names and years, which we transcribe. Apprentices with no recorded name or year are dropped, so the count is a lower bound. Apprentices named in two years, for instance at binding and again at turnover (when the apprentice is transferred to a new master), enter twice. That is, the variable counts binding-years rather than distinct individuals. Moreover, as the source records only the location of the master, the apprentice is assigned to each workplace the master had in the year of binding, so from 1600 to 1699 parish totals sum to 279 rather than to the 251 distinct binding-years recorded.
*Teachers and Instrument Masters, 1600–1699 (Clifton,1995;Taylor,1954).*Defined as the number of mathematical teachers recorded byTaylor(1954) and of scientific instrument makers who have bound at least one apprentice, in a given parish and decade. The makers share their records with the apprentices variable above.
OA-52
*DatedWorks, 1600–1699(Taylor,1954).*DefinedasthenumberoftitleslistedbyTaylor (1954) together with the distinct editions in the*English Short Title Catalogue*recorded under the same author authority string, placed at the workplace of the author rather than at the imprint, which gives the address of the bookseller.
*Instrument Classes, 1600–1699 (Clifton,1995;Hay et al.,2025).*Defined as the number of distinct trades, mathematical, optical, or philosophical, recorded for the scientific instrument makers with a shop in a parish and decade.
*Booksellers, 1600–1699 (Isaac et al.,2024).*Defined as the number of members of the London book trades recorded at an address in a parish and decade, from the*British* *Book Trade Index*. Addresses are geocoded and assigned to parishes as described in Appendix D.12. A trader recorded more than once within the same parish is counted once, since repeated entries reflect alternative descriptions of a single address, and each trader contributes a record for every decade between the first and last recorded trading dates.
*Senior-to-Junior Connections, 1600–1699 (Taylor,1954;Warren et al.,2016).*Defined as the connections above, restricted to those in which the practitioner assigned to the parish began flourishing in a later decade than the practitioner they are connected to, so each connection between a senior and a junior practitioner counts in the parish of the junior.
*Applied Scientists, 1600–1699 (Clifton,1995;Hay et al.,2025;Taylor,1954).*Defined as the number of mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument makers in a given parish and decade, with a person who appears in both sources counted once. Of the 252 makers, 93 are already among the 244 practitioners, so the roster holds 403 applied scientists. Matched people enter once, with the earlier first year and the later last year of the two sources and the addresses of both. Everyone is counted once in a parish and decade, so a scientist recorded in two parishes in a decade counts in each. This is the count of applied scientists inSection 7andAppendix E.
##### Applied Mathematics Titles, European Cities, 1600–1699 (Kelly and Ó Gráda,2022;
*Universal Short Title Catalogue [USTC],2026).*Defined as the number of applied mathematics titles printed in a city and decade, counted in the USTC and classified by the fourteen subject headings of the*English Short Title Catalogue*thatKelly and Ó Gráda (2022, p. 849) use to measure English practical mathematics. We apply the headings as keyword rules, in seven languages (English, Latin, French, German, Dutch, Italian, and Spanish), to every title the USTC classes as Science or Mathematics, which yields 3,415 titles printed in the 200 cities between 1600 and 1699: arithmetic (1,223), astronomical instruments (461), bookkeeping (55), compasses (148), geometry (882), gunnery (69), logarithms (155), mathematics (1,215), mathematical instruments (243), measuring (199), navigation (82), shipbuilding (4), surveying (101), and trigonometry (238). Of these, 996 satisfy more than one heading.
OA-53
##### Scientific Instrument Makers, European Cities, 1600–1699 (Webster and Webster,2007).
Defined as the number of scientific instrument makers active in a city and decade. The sourceisacatalogofmakerswhosignedinstrumentsnowheldincollectionsworldwide. In other words, counts are of recorded makers with a located signature rather than of all instrument makers. Thus, there is measurement error, and coverage reflects which instruments survive and which collectionsWebster and Webster(2007) went through. Restricting to signatures whose recorded years of activity overlap 1600–1699 and that report an identifiable European city leaves 1,201 makers, of whom 309 worked in London, ahead of Paris (101), Nuremberg (89), Augsburg (55), and Amsterdam (45); nine further located records name a city outside Europe. Restricted to the British Isles instead, the source places 309 of 437 makers in London, or 71 percent, in the range of the share of about three-quarters thatAppendix Figure D17reports from an independent compilation. In London the source serves only as context and enters none of the parish estimates.
D.4.Practitioner Connections
Connections recorded byTaylor(1954) take various forms, including “friends,” “mas- ter,” “received advice from,” “associated with,” “visited,” “employed or consulted,” “corresponded with,” and “mentioned by.” Practitioners are recorded as connected whenever historical evidence indicates a social or intellectual association. To extend this network, we turn to the*Six Degrees of Francis Bacon*(SDFB) database of Warren et al.(2016), which uses machine learning to infer influence or interaction among early modern individuals from mentions in*Oxford Dictionary of National Biography* (ODNB) biographies (Oxford Dictionary of National Biography,2025). We identify ODNB entries for 75 of the 244 practitioners in our sample, all of whom are recorded in the SDFB. 62
Together, the two sources record 1,200 directed ties among 293 individuals. Collaps- ing reciprocated pairs leaves 631 undirected connections, of which 475 are between two of the 244 practitioners in the panel (involving 204 of them).Taylor(1954) alone records 326 of the 475, the SDFB alone 83, and both sources 66. Both distributions are skewed: the most connected practitioner has 54 connections, and 18 percent of active practitioner-decades carry none. Fifty of the 475 pairs are never active in the same decade and so never enter *𝐴𝑖𝑗𝑡*, among them the father-and-son pairsTaylor(1954) records. The remaining 425 pairs are jointly active in 1,053 pair-decades across the panel, against 670 practitioner-decades of activity. Note that the data do not record when individuals became connected, and the direction of influence is uncertain. Thus, we treat all connections as undirected. In other words, we take a connection only as evidence that two individuals were socially or intellectually associated at some point. Formally, we set *𝐴𝑖𝑗*=1 if practitioners *𝑖* and *𝑗*are ever connected in this sense, and0otherwise. To capture variation over time, we define *𝐴𝑖𝑗𝑡*=1 if *𝐴𝑖𝑗*=1 and both *𝑖* and *𝑗* are active in period *𝑡*, and 0 otherwise. This measure represents the maximum possible connectivity under the assumption that connections require both individuals to be active. 63
62 We identify ODNB entries by linking practitioners to Wikidata items that carry an ODNB index number. Of the 244 practitioners, 90 are linked to a Wikidata item and 75 of those items carry the identifier, so 75 is a lower bound on ODNB coverage in our sample. The set of practitioner dyads (*𝑖,𝑗*) for which *𝐴𝑖𝑗*=1 includes biological ties such as “father” and
OA-54
D.5.Covariates
The covariates are pre-treatment parish characteristics. They enter the balance com- parisons inTables C1andC2, the propensity score ofAppendix C.1, and, for several of them, the placebo outcomes reported in the appendix figures.Table D5gives the source for each. Counts recorded as an interval of activity are assigned to every decade the interval spans, and addresses are geocoded and assigned to parishes as described inAppendix D.12.
*Households and Baptisms and Deaths (Cummins et al.,2016).*Defined as parish counts of households in 1638 and of baptisms and deaths by decade, taken from the parish register data. Densities divide each count by parish area in square kilometers. Baptisms and deaths are observed for 130 and 119 of the 162 parishes, respectively.
*Median Tax Paid, 1582 (Cummins et al.,2016).*Defined as the parish median assess- ment in the lay subsidy of 1582.
*Substantial Households, 1638 (Cummins et al.,2016).*Defined as the share of house- holds living in properties with an annual rent of at least £20 in 1638.
*Tradesmen’s Tokens, 1648–1651 (Burn,1855).*Defined as the number of tradesmen’s tokens issued in a parish between 1648 and 1651. Tokens were issued by individual traders as small change and are used here as a measure of the density of retail commerce immediately before the first coffeehouse opened.
*Goldsmiths, 1600–1651 (Lillywhite,1972).*Defined as the number of goldsmiths recorded at an address in a parish before 1652.
*Commercial Premises (Lillywhite,1972).*Defined as the number of signed premises recorded in a parish and decade, excluding taverns, inns, other pubs, and coffeehouses. From the 1600s to the 1690s the measure records 1,560 premises-decades. Booksellers account for 452 of them, goldsmiths for 200, grocers for 85, printers for 37, and mealmen for 29; the remaining 757 are spread over 226 other trades.
*Taverns (Lillywhite,1972).*Defined as the number of taverns active in a parish and decade, counted in every decade between the first and last recorded mention. Houses count as taverns only if the source never records them as coffeehouses or under another type. We also count the taverns newly recorded in each decade, but the placebo figures and the balance tables use the active count. The tavern placebo treatment is the decade of the first seventeenth-century tavern recorded in a parish, so taverns first recorded before 1600 do not count as openings.
“son” recorded byTaylor(1954). Restricting the analysis to within-time connectivity, as defined by *𝐴𝑖𝑗𝑡*, implicitly excludes such ties, since *𝐴𝑖𝑗*=1 does not necessarily imply *𝐴𝑖𝑗𝑡*=1 for some *𝑡*, and the fathers and sons in our dataset are not active in the same period. Hence, we restrict attention to non-familial connections.
OA-55
*Booksellers(Isaacetal.,2024).*Definedamongtheoutcomesabove, wherebooksellers also appear inSection 5.
*Dissenting Meetings (Hine,1976).*Defined as the number of dissenting meeting places first recorded in a parish and decade, from a manuscript index of dissenting chapels in the City of London held at the Guildhall Library under shelfmark SL 18. The index is closed access and was transcribed on site. Each meeting place is dated by its earliest known date, which the source records either to the year or to the decade. As end dates are not recorded, the variable only counts the meeting places that are newly recorded in a decade. That is, it is a flow and not a stock.
*Clay-Pipe Finds (Museum of London,2013).*Defined as the number of excavated clay tobacco pipes assigned to a parish and decade. Each find is dated by the typological interval given in its record and is counted in every decade of that interval. Some records carry the interval 1580–1910, which says nothing about when the pipe was made. We exclude these records, as they would otherwise be counted in every decade of the panel.
*Luxury Shops (Lillywhite,1972).*Defined as the number of shops in luxury trades recorded in a parish and decade, active in every decade between the first and last recorded mention, with trades read from the description the source records for each sign. It is used here as a measure of shops selling imported and fashionable goods, of which coffee itself was one. It counts grocers, comfit makers, confectioners, tobacconists, and pastry cooks; the silk trades (silk weavers, silk dyers, silk mercers, silkmen, and throwsters); mercers, lacemen and lace shops, milliners, and perfumers; cabinet makers and upholsterers; musical instrument makers and music sellers; and toy shops, wax chandlers, and glass sellers. It leaves out drinking and sociability venues, which lie too close to treatment; the book, print, map, instrument, and clock trades, which overlap the outcomes; goldsmith-bankers, which are financial rather than retail; and, as borderline, goldsmiths and silversmiths, apothecaries and druggists, hatters, glovers, calico printers, cheesemongers, and fruiterers. From the 1600s to the 1690s it records 246 premises-decades: grocers 128, mercers 32, confectioners and comfit makers 20, tobacconists 19, and milliners 12, with the remaining 35 spread over 13 other trades.
*Apothecaries, 1617–1640s (Wallis and Webb,2000).*Defined as the number of distinct masters named in geocoded binding records of the Apothecaries’ Company in a parish and decade. Note that the source records apprenticeship bindings, not all practicing apothecaries. Hence, the variable counts the masters who took an apprentice in the decade, and an apothecary without one in that decade is not counted. It begins in 1617, so the pre-treatment average excludes the 1600s.
*Theaters (Wikipedia,2024).*Defined as the number of playhouses whose operating interval overlaps a given decade. The venue list is ours, built from the index of English Renaissance theatres on Wikipedia and the venue pages it links, with the first and second Blackfriars separated and omitted venues added. Each playhouse is dated by the end of ordinary or legal performance rather than by demolition. The list holds 19 venues, 18 inside the parish geography of the panel; the Hope, on Bankside, geocodes
OA-56
just outside it. Eleven had closed before the Civil War, from the Red Lion in 1568 to the Swan around 1632, and the other eight are dated to the order of 2 September 1642 by which the Long Parliament suppressed stage plays. Illicit playing after it and the Restoration revival do not count, so no venue reaches the 1650s.
*Scientific and Non-Scientific Letters (Hotson and Lewis,2024).*Defined as the number of letters sent from or received at an address in a parish in a given decade, recorded in *Early Modern Letters Online*, counting only letters whose location is recorded directly rather than interpolated. A letter is scientific when the description of its author or recipient contains one of ten strings, matched in lower case anywhere in the field: “cartographer”, “meteorologist”, “pharmacist”, and the stems “astro”, “natur”, “experim”, “math”, “physic”, “chem”, and “botan”, cut short to catch astronomer and astrologer, natural philosopher and naturalist, and the like. All other letters are non-scientific. Note that the classification is based on who wrote or received a letter and not on what it says. In other words, a scientific letter is one involving someone described in scientific terms, whatever its subject. The 1,220 non-scientific letter- author pairs recorded from the 1600s to the 1690s fall under clergy and religious (310); scholarship, letters, and education (266); nobility, royalty, and court (166); government and administration (154); law (93); five other occupations (126); and no recorded occupation (105).
*Mathematical Practitioners and Scientific Instrument Shops Before 1652.*Defined among the outcomes above, measured over the decades preceding the first coffeehouse.
*City of London and London Wall (Cummins et al.,2016).*Defined as indicators for location in the City and inside the London Wall. The City of London indicator covers all 113 parishes within the City. The Inside the London Wall indicator covers the 97 of these parishes located within the historic London Wall.
*Distances and Area.*Defined as the great-circle distance in kilometers from the parish centroid to the Royal Exchange, Gresham College, and Paternoster Row, and the parish area in square kilometers. Centroids and areas are taken from the parish geography of Cummins et al.(2016).
*Exposure to the Great Fire.*Defined as an indicator, constructed by hand for each parish, of whether the parish lay in the area destroyed by the Great Fire of 1666. We read the burnt area from the map of the fire’s extent inSchofield(1984, pp. 172–173).
D.6.Hooke’s Diary
Robert Hooke kept a memorandum book from 10 March 1672 to May 1683, now Guildhall Library MS 1758.Robinson and Adams(1935) print the entries from August 1672 to December 1680, andHenderson(2007) the months they omit, March to July 1672 and January 1681 to May 1683. We transcribe both editions by hand, with one row per printed entry, and check each row against the text of its printed page. Of the 2,950 rows from the first edition, 2,944 closely match a passage on the page, and so do 438
OA-57
of the 509 rows from the second. When an entry covers several days, we assign it to each of them. Dates keep the Old Style calendar, but with the year starting on 1 January. This gives 3,464 dated days. Coffeehouse days are those whose entry names a coffeehouse or mentions coffee. We match each entry and its notes against regular expressions built from the spelling variants in the indexes of both editions and from the establishments thatBrown et al. (2021) identify in the diary. On 2,193 days the entry names one of 57 coffeehouses, 3,097 times when each coffeehouse counts once a day. On 51 further days it mentions coffee or a coffeehouse outside the 57, and on six of these Hooke records no visit, as when he made coffee at home. Drinking houses, mostly taverns, are named on 337 days. We compare our counts with those ofBrown et al.(2021). For the Intoxicating Spaces project, they compiled Hooke’s use of coffee, alcohol, and other intoxicants from the same two editions, 2,637 coffeehouse visits in all. Their data have no entries for 1679, so the 535 mentions we find in that year are only in ours. In all other years our count of coffeehouse mentions is within 15 percent of their count of visits, and across years the two series correlate at 0.996. Garraway’s, for instance, has 1,283 mentions in our data outside 1679 and 1,276 visits in theirs, and Jonathan’s has 535 and 545. Including 1679, the two coffeehouses have 1,425 and 798 mentions (seeAppendix Figure B6). 65
We annotated all 3,464 days with coding agents built on large language models, run in Codex, in 55 batches of 16 to 100 days. Every person an entry names gets one row in the annotation (the name as written, whether Hooke met the person, the matching person in the index of the printed editions, and the passage behind each of these decisions). Before this, we merged the two indexes. The 397 people in the index of Henderson(2007) were linked to the 2,043 in the index ofRobinson and Adams(1935) by first searching for candidates with the help of a language model and then checking every link by hand. Of the 22,132 mentions, 17,341 record a meeting, and in 16,435 of these the index identifies the person. If the entry for a day records more than one meeting with the same person, we count only one. This leaves 16,325 meetings with 1,426 distinct people on 3,045 days. By script, we confirm that each identified person appears in the printed indexes. For 172 days, or 5 percent, the annotations are still flagged for manual review. Their 1,101 certain meetings are kept. Encounters we are unsure of, and people we could not identify, are left out throughout. On the 2,166 coffeehouse days with a recorded meeting, a second model, GPT-5.4 mini (OpenAI, version of 17 March 2026), reads the whole entry and places each of the 12,767 meetings at the coffeehouse (2,896) or elsewhere (9,331), or leaves it uncertain (540). For 152 days, the output failed our checks, and a coding agent repaired it, changing 22 placements and adding 12 meetings the model had omitted. The 3,558 meetings on other days count as elsewhere. People are in the Republic of Letters if the index links them to a writer of at least one letter sent from London in the seventeenth century in*Early Modern Letters Online* (Hotson and Lewis,2024). Candidate links to the 1,581 such writers come from a search 64 We search the machine-read page for long runs of identical words. Each match confirms the passage, not every character in it, and the 1935 edition is itself “corrupt in places, where words have been mistranscribed or left out” (Henderson,2007, p. 133). 65 Appendix Figure B6places our mentions at the 32 coffeehouses thatBrown et al.(2021) locate: 2,915 mentions, 2,233 of them within 400 meters of Hooke’s lodgings at Gresham College in Bishopsgate. Using the data ofBrown et al.(2021) directly instead of ours, we find 2,497 located visits to coffeehouses and a share within 1 kilometer of 77 percent, against 78 percent for our data.
OA-58
on names, their variants, and life dates: 198 people in the index are linked to 199 writers, and 155 of the 1,426 people Hooke records meeting are among them. We group the people Hooke records meeting by occupation from the notes in the index. Mathematical practitioners are the 55 people matched by name toTaylor(1954) or to SIMON, 29 of them instrument makers; each match was adjudicated individually, and a bare surname never suffices. The match is partly circular, since Taylor cites the diary in 58 entries. The index records no occupation for 902 of the 1,426 people. Coding by an independent language model agrees with these groups for 85 percent of people, and on whether an occupation lies in science for 94 percent.
D.7.First Coffeehouses in European Cities
To the best of our knowledge, no previous work attempts a comprehensive listing of the first coffeehouse of every European city.Table D4reports the year, the decade, and the source for each of the 37 cities in which we find a first coffeehouse before 1700, when the panel ends. The search made four passes over the 200 cities. The first was a systematic review of the historical scholarship on coffeehouses at the National Library of Sweden and Stockholm University Library, which have the major works in English, French, and German. The second was a systematic search on the web, focusing on the Internet Archive, in the language of each country: national and city histories of coffee and of sociability, municipal and guild records in print, digitized archival finding aids, and the secondary literature on coffeehouses. The third was algorithmic. Using regular expressions, we identified each record in the*Universal Short Title Catalogue*whose title mentions coffee in any of the catalog languages, which surfaced, among other things, ordinances regulating the premises, excise documents, and polemics naming a coffeehouse (which, for example, is what dates Middelburg to 1686). The fourth pass used Claude Code and Codex to search our candidate list for false positives, checking each candidate against the cited text and rejecting dates that record the arrival, sale, or first mention of coffee rather than a coffeehouse. Claude Code and Codex flagged candidates, which we used as a list for hand-coding. This fourth approach never supplied a date by itself: every date inTable D4rests on a later-identified source, which is cited beside the entry. For example, Barcelona, where coffee is recorded in 1627 but no coffeehouse, is the kind of candidate we were able to reject. Cities without a dated coffeehouse enter the data as never having had one in the seventeenth century, but an absent record is not an absent coffeehouse. Relatedly, Withington(2020) shows that in provincial England coffee was often sold in inns that left no coffeehouse record. Two empirical checks support the dates. First, coffee entered Europe through Venice, Livorno, Marseille, London, and Amsterdam, and among the 33 cities whose source gives a year, the first coffeehouse opens 3.3 years later for every 100 kilometers of distance from the nearest of them (s.e. 0.8). See Panel A ofFigure D1for this check. Second, as can be seen in Panel B ofFigure D1, across all 200 cities, the nearest third by that distance open coffeehouses first, the middle third overtake them in the 1690s, and the farthest third hardly open any before 1700. Seventeen of the 37 also printed a title on coffee before 1700, against 13 of the 163 comparison cities, and in 14 of the 17 the
OA-59
<u>first such title follows the first coffeehouse.</u>
The three exceptions are academic: a Frankfurt dissertation of 1666, a Lübeck tea tract of 1694, and Daniel Wencker’s Strasbourg dissertation*De potu café*of 1693, two years before the Magistrat’s ordinance on the*maisons de café*.
OA-60
Table D4—First coffeehouses by city in Europe
| Country | City | Year | Decade Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Austria | Vienna | 1685 | 1680sAlbrecht(1989) |
| Belgium | Antwerp Kortrijk | 1690 1690 | 1690sVan Aert(2009) 1690sP. D. B.(1934) |
| Denmark | Copenhagen | 1690sHoff(2016) | |
| France | Angers Lyon Marseille Paris Strasbourg | 1693 1671 1671 1695 | 1690sBertoldi(2013) 1670sGrand-Carteret(1902);Van Damme(2005) 1670sEllis(2004a) 1670sEllis(2004a);Leclant(1951) (1672) 1690sPerry(2011) |
| Germany | Bremen Frankfurt am Main Hamburg Leipzig Lübeck Munich Nuremberg Regensburg Würzburg | 1669 1689 1677 1694 1695 1699 1686 1686 1697 | 1660sEllis(2004a) 1680sCowan(2014) 1670sAlbrecht(1989);Robilliard(2024) 1690sEllis(2004a) 1690sMeyer(2011) 1690sMonacensia Literaturarchiv und Bibliothek(2019) 1680sCowan(2014) 1680sCowan(2014) 1690sDenzinger(1848) |
| Italy Netherlands Amsterdam | Genoa Rome Venice Groningen Leiden Middelburg Rotterdam The Hague Utrecht | 1661 1683 1665 1686 1685 1686 1666 1670 1678 | 1660sBelgrano(1875) 1650sLombardo(2016) 1680sEllis(2004a) 1660sStadsarchief Amsterdam(2019);Hell(2017) 1680sKuiken(1982) 1680svan Oostrum(2006) 1680sCity of Middelburg(1686) 1660sHeise(1987) 1670svan Oostrum(2006);Betz(1900) 1670svan Oostrum(2006) |
| Poland Switzerland Basel | Gdańsk Geneva | by 1697 c. 1690 | 1690sGedanopedia(2020) 1690sMeier(1973) 1690sEncyclopédie de Genève(1992) |
| UK | Bristol Edinburgh London Newcastle upon Tyne Norwich York | 1666 1673 1652 1692 1676 1669 | 1660sPincus(1995) 1670sPincus(1995) 1650sEllis(2004a) 1690sStory(1692) 1670sWithington(2020) 1660sPincus(1995) |
*Notes:* Table lists every city recorded with a first coffeehouse in the seventeenth century, as inferred from our systematic literature review. Year is the year the source establishes and is left blank where the source fixes only a decade, as for Rome, Copenhagen, Basel, and Lyon. Decade is the decade the source establishes. Cities are dated only from sources that name or regulate a coffeehouse, as against recording the arrival or sale of coffee. Cities whose entry decade could not be established on that rule are coded as never having had a coffeehouse in the seventeenth century. [Return to pagesOA-59,OA-62,OA-63]
OA-61
Year of the first coffeehouse
(A)
(B)Share of cities with a coffeehouse
0.3
| 1690 | 0.2 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1680 | |||||
| 1670 1660 | 0.1 | ||||
| 1650 | 0 Distance to the nearest coffee port (km) | 250 | 0 1640s | 1660s Decade | 1670s |
| CityLinear fit95 percent interval | Nearest thirdMiddle thirdFarthest third |
500 750 1,000 1650s 1680s 1690s
The spread of coffeehouses from the coffee ports Figure D1.
*Notes:* Figure plots the spread of coffeehouses against the distance from each city to the nearest of the five ports through which coffee entered Europe, Venice (1624), Livorno (1632), Marseille (1644), London (1650), and Amsterdam (1661), with the year coffee is first recorded there. Panel A plots the year of the first coffeehouse against distance for the 33 of the 37 coffeehouse cities whose source gives a year, with a linear fit of 3.3 years per 100 kilometers and its 95 percent confidence interval, from a robust standard error of 0.8. Panel B splits the 200 cities into thirds by that distance, within 223 kilometers, 224 to 555 kilometers, and more than 555 kilometers, and plots for each third the share of its cities with a coffeehouse by each decade, from the decades ofTable D4; the thirds hold 15, 20, and 2 of the 37 coffeehouse cities. [Return to pages17,OA-59]
D.8.Data Sources
Level Source ParishLillywhite(1963) Lillywhite(1972)
Mackie(2013) Taylor(1954)
*English Short Title* *Catalogue* Warren et al.(2016)
Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (2025) Wikidata
Clifton(1995)
Hay et al.(2025)
The Royal Society(2024) Fischer et al.(2020)
Isaac et al.(2024)
Table D5—Data sources
Variables Online CoffeehousesInternet Archive Coffeehouses, Taverns, Inns, Goldsmiths, Internet Archive Luxury Shops, Commercial Premises Recorded Uses of CoffeehousesAcademia.edu Mathematical Practitioners, Their Internet Archive Connections, Dated Works Dated WorksBritish Library
Connections Between PractitionersSix Degrees of Francis Bacon Practitioners’ EntriesOxford University Press
Links from Practitioners to the ODNB, Wikidata Paternal Occupations Scientific Instrument Shops, Makers’ Trades, Internet Archive Apprentices Scientific Instrument Shops, Guilds, National Instruments Known to Have Been Sold Museums Scotland Fellows of the Royal SocietyThe Royal Society Practitioners Named in the*Philosophical* CLARIN-D *Transactions* BooksellersUniversity of Oxford *Continued on the next page*
OA-62
Table D5—Data sources, continued
Level Source Variables Online Clark and Cummins Surname Counts Among Alumni of Human Nature (2014) Cambridge and Oxford FamilySearch(2025) Surname Counts Among English Couples FamilySearch Married 1538–1649 Cummins et al.(2016) Median Tax 1582, Substantial Households Economic History 1638, Baptisms, Deaths, Parish Boundaries, Review City of London, London Wall Schofield(1984) Exposure to the Great FireInternet Archive Burn(1855) Tradesmen’s Tokens 1648–1651Internet Archive Wallis and Webb(2000) ApothecariesLSE Research Online Hine(1976) Dissenting Meeting PlacesGuildhall Library Museum of London Clay-Pipe FindsMuseum of (2013) London Wikipedia(2024) TheatersWikipedia Hotson and Lewis(2024) Scientific and Non-Scientific Letters, Early Modern Republic of Letters in Hooke’s Diary Letters Online DiaryRobinson and Adams Diary Entries, 1672–1680: Coffeehouse Days, Internet Archive (1935) Recorded Meetings Henderson(2007) Diary Entries, 1672 and 1681–1683: Notes and Records Coffeehouse Days, Recorded Meetings of the Royal Society Brown et al.(2021) Establishments Named in the Diary and Intoxicating Their Locations Spaces CityBosker et al.(2013) Cities and Their PopulationsReview of Economics and Statistics Sources of Appendix First Coffeehouses Listed in the table TableD4 Universal Short Title Applied Mathematics TitlesUniversity of St Catalogue [USTC](2026) Andrews Webster and Webster Scientific Instrument MakersAdler Planetarium (2007) Gingerich(2002) Surviving Copies of Copernicus’s*De* Brill *revolutionibus*
England Kelly and Ó Gráda(2022) Applied Mathematics Titles, Subject openICPSR Headings for the European Titles Almelhem et al.(2026) Average Progress ScoreQuarterly Journal of Economics
*Notes:* Table lists the data sources used to construct the variables and exhibits, grouped by the level at which each enters the analysis: Parish covers London parishes and finer units such as addresses, shops, and practitioners; Diary the days of Robert Hooke’s diary; City the European cities; and England the country as a whole. Online links go to the relevant catalogue, database, or publication. Sources used only to validate the coffeehouse records (AppendixD.11) or to geocode addresses (AppendixD.12) are cited there. [Return to pageOA-55]
OA-63
D.9.Pages of Original Historical Data
Figure D2.Coffeehouses in London (Lillywhite,1963, pp. 304–305)
*Notes:* Excerpt fromLillywhite(1963), showing London coffeehouse entries and their historical references. Entry 656 is Jonathan’s Coffee House in Exchange Alley, Cornhill, first mentioned in 1680–1684. Entry 649 shows how the book links the names one coffeehouse went by: John Shipton’s Coffee House is “also mentioned as Shipston’s,” with cross-references to John’s Coffee House (entries 635 and 636) and to Shipton’s (entry 1202). [Return to page14]
OA-64
Figure D3.Signs in London (Lillywhite,1972, pp. 480–481)
*Notes:* Excerpt fromLillywhite(1972), showing information about London signs. Numbers up to 2,034 are those ofLillywhite(1963), so entry 1163, Santry’s Coffee House in Borough High Street, is in both, while entry 13056, the Sandford Coffee House on Lawrence Lane in Cheapside, recorded in 1673–1674, is a seventeenth-century coffeehouse the earlier book does not list. [Return to page14]
OA-65
Figure D4.Mathematical practitioners in England (Taylor,1954, pp. 240–241)
*Notes:* Excerpt fromTaylor(1954), showing biographical entries of mathematical practitioners. Entry 260 is Christopher Wren, whomTaylor(1954) describes as “fertile in designing and making mathematical instruments” andClifton(1995) does not list as a maker. [Return to pages15,16]
OA-66
Figure D5.Scientific instrument makers in the British Isles (Clifton,1995, p. 6)
*Notes:* Excerpt fromClifton(1995), showing entries on scientific instrument makers in the British Isles, among them Elias Allen (c. 1588–1653) at “Blacke Horse-ally, neere Fleetbridge, London” from 1606 to
1611. [Return to page16]
#### D.10.Primary and Secondary Sources for Main Variables
The works byLillywhite(1963,1972) draw on a wide range of primary sources. For 1652 to 1672, these mainly include catalogs of tokens issued by London coffeehouses (Appendix Figure D6). For the period between 1660 and 1669, another key source is the diary of Samuel Pepys. More broadly, Lillywhite also relies extensively on contemporary advertisements (seeAppendix Figure D7for a prominent example) and on a wide range of archival materials on London history held in the Guildhall Library in London.Appendix Table D6more systematically groups the 617 sources cited for the 286 coffeehouses of our London panel by type of source and reports how many coffeehouses each type documents.
OA-67
Taylor(1954) is based on a broad set of primary and secondary sources, detailed in Appendix Figure D8. The 628 works on applied mathematics from about 1400 to 1715 are not listed here, as they are already cataloged in her study. The underlying bibliography for the data on scientific instrument shops and makers inHay et al.(2025) is available athttps://toolsofknowledge.org/sources/. It covers 441 primary and secondary sources, withClifton(1995) and its cited bibliographies serving as key references. Examples include trade cards, such asAppendix Figure D9, and signed instruments, such as those inAppendix Figure D10. These are often supplemented by later identification in guild records, since most scientific instrument makers belonged to a guild, although none was dedicated specifically to instrument making (Cormack,2017, p. 79).
Figure D6.The Turk’s Head coffeehouse token, 1669
*Notes:* Copper alloy trade token issued by Nicholas Strange in 1669 for his coffeehouse in St. Ann’s Lane, now part of Gresham Street, Aldersgate Ward, City of London. The obverse bears the inscrip- tion “NICH. STRAINGE. AT. YE. COFFEE” surrounding a Turk’s head device. The reverse reads “HOVSE.IN.ST.ANNS.LANE.69” and shows a hand pouring coffee into a cup.London Museum, object ID NN18344. [Return to pageOA-67]
OA-68
Figure D7.The Vertue of the COFFEE Drink, 1652
*Notes:* This handbill byRosée(1652), “The Vertue of the COFFEE Drink,” is the earliest known advertisement for coffee in England. The final lines identify the coffeehouse as Pasqua Rosée’s Coffee House, located in St. Michael’s Alley in Cornhill. Reproduced byWilliams(1936) from the original held at the British Museum. [Return to pageOA-67]
OA-69
Figure D8.Primary and secondary sources used byTaylor(1954)
*Notes:* Selection of primary and secondary sources cited inTaylor(1954). [Return to pageOA-68]
OA-70
Figure D9.Trade card of John Yarwell, London, 1683
*Notes:* Trade card of the optical instrument maker John Yarwell, St. Paul’s Churchyard, London, 1683. Science Museum Group Collection, object no. 1951-687/45. [Return to pageOA-68]
(A)Gunter sector, 1623 (B)Compendium, 1630–1653
(C)Compound microscope, c. 1665 (D)Portable barometer, 1695–1705
Figure D10.Practical and experimental scientific instruments
*Notes:* Panels A and B show practical instruments and Panels C and D experimental ones, the two groups defined inAppendix D.3. Panel A: brass Gunter sector signed “Elias Allen fecit 1623,” London,Science Museum Group Collection, object no. 1976-638. Panel B: compendium of sundial, compass, and calendar indices inscribed “Elias Allen fecit,” London, 1630–1653,Science Museum Group Collection, object no. 1883-135. Panel C: compound microscope of Robert Hooke’s design made by Christopher Cock, London,Billings Microscope Collection, National Museum of Health and Medicine, no. M-030.00276. Panel D: portable barometer by Daniel Quare, Exchange Alley, London, 1695–1705,Science Museum Group Collection, object no. 1948-227. [Return to pageOA-68]
OA-71
D.11.Data Validation
*Coffeehouses.*First, we assess the completeness of the coffeehouse dataset by bench- marking it against counts from theCity of London Magistrates(1663) survey and the 1692–1698 poll tax returns reported byCowan(2005). Both count coffeehouses in wards of the City of London only, so we compare them with the records in the same wards. The 1663 survey lists 82 coffeehouses in 20 wards, whereLillywhite(1963,1972) records 24 in 1663. 67 The 1692–1698 poll tax lists 90 coffeehouses in 13 of 26 wards for which data are available, while 1701 administrative records note 34 more in 7 of the 13 previously missing wards, giving about 124 coffeehouses in 20 wards, whereLillywhite(1963,1972) records75over1692–1698, three-fifthsofthecount. ThispatternsuggeststhatLillywhite (1963,1972) covers late seventeenth-century coffeehouses more comprehensively than those from mid-century, likely reflecting the loss of records associated with the 1666 Great Fire. Observation delays also contribute. “Henry Willington” in “Dowgate” is listed in the 1663 survey, with “H. Wellington” in “Dowgate” first noted in a 1665 token byLillywhite(1963,1972). Similarly,Lillywhite(1963,1972) may have ceased observing a coffeehouse before 1663. To facilitate a broader 1663 comparison, we consider a margin of error: allowing a margin of ±1 year around 1663 results in 28 coffeehouses recorded byLillywhite(1963,1972) in the survey’s wards, ±2 years in 31, and ±3 years in 43, between a third and a half of the survey’s count. 68
Second,Mackie(2013) attempts to extendLillywhite(1963) using modern searchable databases, including Electronic Enlightenment, Old Bailey Online, and British Periodi- cals. 69 This effort yields only a small number of additional and often ambiguous cases. We conduct a parallel search using two Gale resources, the*Seventeenth and Eighteenth* *Century Nichols Newspapers Collection*and the*Seventeenth and Eighteenth Century Burney* *Newspapers Collection*, focusing on mentions of “coffee” and its variants. These sources referencecoffeehouseslessfrequentlythanwouldbeexpectedbasedonLillywhite(1963,
1972). Furthermore, when “coffee” turns up beside a place that Lillywhite does not list, it is often unclear whether the venue was a coffeehouse, a tavern, or an inn. Moreover, claims that thousands of coffeehouses operated in London by the late seventeenth or early eighteenth century (e.g.,Iliffe,1995) rest mostly on secondary sources, not on primary documents. In fact, the first systematic count dates from 1739, when William Maitland recorded 551 coffeehouses for his*History of London*, a count that took him eleven months (Ellis,2006b, pp. xxix–xxx). Third,Appendix Figure D11plots the number of coffeehouses in seventeenth-century London in the dataset. The series exhibits discrete shifts that align with major historical events. The first coffeehouse is recorded in 1652. The count then jumps from 12 in 1659 to 27 in 1660, the year of the Stuart Restoration. The Great Fire destroyed nearly all of London within the walls in 1666. Yet that year the recorded count rises from 35 to 51, and in 1667 it falls back to 45. Of the 19 coffeehouses first recorded in 1666, at least six are on trade tokens dated that year, and seven are recorded in that year only. That is, the spike seems to reflect when coffeehouses were documented, not when they opened 67 Lillywhite(1963,1972) does not mentionCity of London Magistrates(1663), likely because the survey lists coffeehouses only by owner and ward, without names or specific addresses. 68 The sharp increase under the ±3 margin comes from 1666, when the number of recorded coffeehouses spikes because many are documented that year, often on dated trade tokens, rather than because they opened (Appendix Figure D11). Mackie(2013) does not draw onLillywhite(1972).
OA-72
or closed. The number of new coffeehouses increases sharply following the Rebuilding Acts of 1666 and 1670, and the upward trend persists through the end of the century. Fourth,Appendix Figure D12plots the frequency of coffeehouse-related terms in the British English corpus from the Google Books Ngram Viewer. Because most coffeehouses in the British Isles were located in London (Cowan,2005), movements in the corpus likely reflect developments in London. The close alignment between the two series suggests thatLillywhite(1963,1972) provides a reasonably representative account of the historically observed universe of coffeehouses. Mentions in the early seventeenth century, prior to the first London coffeehouse opening in 1652, likely reflect the emergence of discourse about coffee and coffeehouses rather than physical establishments (Smith,2001).
*Mathematical Practitioners.*To our knowledge, no independent source exists to cross-verify the set of so-called mathematical practitioners compiled byTaylor(1954). A simple internal validity exercise nonetheless lends credibility to the dataset.Appendix Figure D13reports, by decade, the number of connections held by the most connected practitioner. The names that come up are the ones that accounts of seventeenth-century London science would lead us to expect. Before the prominence of the polymath Robert Hooke, known for his frequent coffeehouse visits and his sociable way with other scientists, the leading instrument maker Elias Allen ranks among the most connected practitioners decade after decade. Allen had an extensive clientele, including Kings James I and Charles I, and maintained ties with prominent mathematicians such as Edmund Gunter (1581–1626) and William Oughtred (1574–1660), inventor of the slide rule and the multiplication sign. Alongside these practitioners appears William Leybourne (1626–1716), an active mathematician, land surveyor, author, printer, and bookseller.
OA-73
Pre-existing New
0 1650 1655 1660 1665 1670 1675 1680 1685 1690 1695 1700
Figure D11.Coffeehouses in London over time
*Notes:* Figure plots the annual number of coffeehouses in London from 1652, when the first opened, to 1699, distinguishing between those already established and those newly opened. Data fromLillywhite (1963,1972). [Return to pageOA-72]
) 7 10 × 4
2 Relative frequency (
0 1600 1610 1620 1630 1640 1650 1660 1670 1680 1690 1700
Figure D12.Frequency of n-grams containing coffeehouse terms over time
*Notes:* Figure plots the annual relative case-insensitive frequency of n-grams containing the terms “coffee house” and “coffeehouse” from 1600 to 1699. Data from Google Books Ngram Viewer, British English corpus, accessed November 5, 2025. [Return to pageOA-73]
OA-74
HOOKE Robert
40HOOKE Robert
HOOKE Robert
30 HOOKE Robert HOOKE Robert
Connections
20 LEYBOURNE William
OUGHTRED William ALLEN Elias ALLEN Elias ALLEN Elias 10ALLEN Elias 1600 1620 1640 1660 1680 1700
Figure D13.Most connected mathematical practitioner over time
*Notes:* Figure shows, for each decade, the number of connections of the most connected mathematical practitioner. In the 1620s, William Oughtred and Elias Allen are tied with 13 connections each. [Return to pages17,OA-73]
D.12.Geocoding
##### D.12.1Procedure
Eachhistoricaladdressisassignedageographiccoordinatethroughatwo-step,manually performed process aided by digital tools:
1.The address is located on a historical map of London.
- Digitized historical maps of London are available on the Grub Street Project website (https://www.grubstreetproject.net/). Several of these maps support searchable places. SeeFigure D14.
70
- If the address cannot be found on a historical map of London, we use con- textual information from the source or additional resources (e.g., Wikipedia, historical gazetteers, historical works on London) to identify either a nearby address that can be located on a historical map of London or, failing that, the smallest containing geography that can be so located, typically the street.
- 2. The geographic coordinate of the location identified in Step 1 is estimated by visuallyoverlayingthehistoricalmapontoacontemporaryGooglemapofLondon, aligning key geographic features (e.g., rivers, streets, and churches) that survive in both. Note that the earliest topographic survey of London precise enough A digital gazetteer of locations from the Woodcut Map of London (early 1560s) has been created
- on the Map of Early Modern London website (https://mapoflondon.uvic.ca/index.htm), which was occasionally used for hard-to-geocode addresses.
OA-75
to be georeferenced comprehensively against modern maps is John Rocque’s map of 1746. Hence, for the seventeenth century, we align single features whose present-day position we know independently, and the alignment is bound to be imperfect. 71
We also use two other sources.Taylor(1954) maps about 100 London workplaces, and we transfer her plotted points to coordinates with the overlay described in Step 2. For roughly 600 addresses, the*Early Modern Letters Online*project (Hotson and Lewis,
2024) already supplies coordinates directly. All coordinates are manually verified.
##### D.12.2Worked Examples
Below we geocode four historical addresses, ordered from the most to the least straightforward, to demonstrate the procedure.
*Direct match, no modern name.*Geocode “Jewen St,” recorded as the address of a scientific instrument maker active in 1671.
1. Strype’s 1720 survey and accompanying map, reproduced inFigure D14, record Jewen (Jewin) Street running east from Aldersgate Street to Redcross Street, immediately north of the churchyard of St. Giles-without-Cripplegate.
72
2. Unlike the cases below, the street has no modern counterpart that can be matched by name: Jewin Street and the neighboring Redcross Street were demolished in the twentieth century for the construction of the Barbican Estate.
73 The coordinate is therefore obtained by overlaying the historical map onto a contemporary Google map and aligning two features whose present-day position is known, the church of St. Giles-without-Cripplegate and the line of Aldersgate Street. The midpoint of the street yields the coordinate(51*.*51955*,*−0*.*09577).
*Direct match, surviving name.*Geocode “St. Katharine’s Stairs.” 74
1. The Grub Street Project provides points on digitized maps of London from 1553 to 1736 indicating the location of “St. Katherine’s Stairs.”
75
2.The 1736 map shows that the location lies just southeast of the Tower of London, next to the Thames. Because the name survives, the corresponding modern location is identified directly on Google Maps as “St. Katharine Docks,” and the overlay of Step 2 serves only to confirm the match against the Tower and the river <u>frontage. This yields the coordinate</u>(51*.*50640*,*−0*.*07187). 71 Cf.*Locating London’s Past: Recreating Rocque, London 1746*, available athttps://locatinglondonspast.
wordpress.com/2011/06/22/recreating-rocque-london-1746, accessed September 5, 2025. 72 Strype describes the yard of the Castle Inn on Aldersgate Street as having “a passage into Jewen street” (Strype,1720). See*The Grub Street Project :: Places :: Castle and Falcon*, available athttps: //www.grubstreetproject.net/places/945/, accessed July 27, 2026. 73 *Jewin Street*, London Picture Archive, The London Archives,available online, accessed July 27, 2026. 74 Spelling varies across sources between “Katharine” and “Katherine”; we retain each source’s form when quoting it. *The Grub Street Project :: Places :: St. Katherine’s Stairs*, available athttps://www.grubstreetproject.net/ places/4318/, accessed September 4, 2025.
OA-76
*Nearby landmark.*Geocode “Pasqua Rosée’s Coffee House” in “St. Michael’s Alley, Cornhill.”
1. The location refers to a medieval alley next to St. Michael’s Church in Cornhill. The original church, destroyed in the Great Fire of London (1666), was replaced in 1670 by the present church on the same site.
77
2. The exact position of the coffeehouse within the alley cannot be recovered, so we substitute the adjacent church, which Google Maps locates directly. This yields the coordinate(51*.*51325*,*−0*.*08556).
78
##### Containing street.Geocode “Pilkington Court.”
1. ThelocationreferstoacourtinLittleBritain, accordingtoacontemporaryobituary register kept by the London book collector and antiquary Richard Smyth.
79
2. We are unable to identify the exact location of Pilkington Court within Little Britain, and no nearby address is recoverable, so we fall back on the containing street. LittleBritainisasufficientlyprecisereference,beingashortandwell-known street in seventeenth-century London, and its Wikipedia entry directly provides the coordinate(51*.*51699*,*−0*.*09780).
80
76 *The Grub Street Project :: Places :: St. Michael’s Alley*, available athttps://www.grubstreetproject.net/ places/4421/, accessed August 5, 2025. 77 *St Michael, Cornhill*, Wikipedia, available athttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St_Michael,_Cornhill, accessed August 5, 2025. 78 *St Michael Cornhill Saint Michael’s Alley, London*on Google Maps, available athttps://maps.app.goo.g l/9DJKJm9cwTVkz1fN7, accessed August 5, 2025. 79 Smyth’s 1661 entry records “Mr. Franck, a juryman in Pilkington Court in Little Brittain” (Smyth, 1849, p. 53). The register was published posthumously in 1849. 80 *Little Britain, London*, Wikipedia, available athttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Britain,_London, accessed September 5, 2025.
OA-77
Figure D14.London in 1720 (Strype,1720)
*Notes:* Digitized 1720 map of London with a geocoded layer of streets, roads, thoroughfares, public markets, bodies of water, and places, from theGrub Street Projectat the University of Saskatchewan, based on*A New Plan of the City of London, Westminster, and Southwark*inStrype(1720). [Return to pages OA-75,OA-76]
OA-78
D.13.Figures
(A)First coffeehouses
1
Parish
162 1600161016201630164016501660167016801690
Never treatedNot yet treatedTreated
(B)Coffeehouse presence
1
Parish
162 1600161016201630164016501660167016801690
ControlTreated
Figure D15.Treatment rollout
*Notes:* Panel A shows the decades in which the first coffeehouse opened across all 162 parishes, and Panel B the decades in which a coffeehouse is open. Parishes are grouped by decade of first opening and ordered from earliest to latest, followed by those with no coffeehouse openings. [Return to pages19, OA-25]
OA-79
0 0 1 2 3 4 Decades since first coffeehouse
Figure D16.Coffeehouses by decades since first opening
*Notes:* Figureshowsajitteredstripplotofthenumberofcoffeehousesbydecadessincethefirstcoffeehouse opened. Sample includes the 61 parishes that ever have a coffeehouse from the 1600s to the 1690s. [Return to page19]
| (A)Mathematical practitioners | (B)Scientific instrument makers | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 150 | Unknown | 150 | British Isles |
| England London | London | ||
| 100 | 100 |
50 50
0 0 1600 1620 1640 1660 1680 1700 1600 1620 1640 1660 1680 1700
Figure D17.Science in London relative to England and the British Isles over time
*Notes:* Panel A plots the annual number of mathematical practitioners in seventeenth-century England, separated by whether they were ever active in London or only outside it. Unknowns were active in England, but their London activity is unknown. Panel B plots the annual number of scientific instrument makers in the seventeenth-century British Isles and London. Data fromClifton(1995);Hay et al.(2025); Taylor(1954). [Return to pages16,25,OA-54]
OA-80
0 1600 1620 1640 1660 1680 1700
UnknownExperimentalPractical
Figure D18.Scientific instrument makers in London over time by type
*Notes:* Figure plots the annual number of scientific instrument makers in seventeenth-century London by type. Experimental makers produced optical (e.g., telescopes, microscopes) and philosophical (e.g., air pumps, barometers, thermometers) instruments. Practical makers produced mathematical (e.g., dividers, sectors, scales), navigational (e.g., compasses, astrolabes), and surveying (e.g., theodolites, circumferentors) instruments. Data fromClifton(1995);Hay et al.(2025). [Return to page16]
150 30 Coffeehouses Mathematical practitioners Scientific instrument shops Applied mathematics titles
Average Progress Score 100 20 (Percentile, right axis)
50 10
0 0 1600 1620 1640 1660 1680 1700
Figure D19.Coffeehouses, science, mathematical titles, and belief in progress
*Notes:* Figure repeats the three series ofFigure 1and overlays two national series from published work. AppliedmathematicstitlescountthebooksinEnglishpublishedineachdecade, excludingreprints, inthe replication files ofKelly and Ó Gráda(2022). These are decade totals, so their level is not comparable to the annual counts plotted beside them. The average progress score follows the construction ofAlmelhem et al.(2026): the score of each volume on their main progress dictionary is converted to its percentile rank across the 264,433 English-language volumes in their replication data, and the line plots, for each year, the mean percentile among volumes published within ten years of it. Data fromAlmelhem et al. (2026);Clifton(1995);Hay et al.(2025);Kelly and Ó Gráda(2022);Lillywhite(1963,1972);Taylor(1954). [Return to page2]
OA-81
W. Gilbert T. Harriot J. Speidell Practitioner Practitioner Teacher
1600–19 fl. 1561–1603 fl. 1581–1621 fl. 1600–1634
J. Pell M. Dary J. Aspley Teacher Practitioner Practitioner
1620–39 fl. 1632–1685 fl. 1634–1679 fl. 1624–1624
C. Wren W. Flower J. Eyre Maker Maker Practitioner
1640–59 fl. 1653–1723 fl. 1646–1646 fl. 1654–1654
E. Halley P. Lea P. Perkins Practitioner Maker Teacher
1660–79 fl. 1677–1742 fl. 1666–1700 fl. 1677–1680
G. Graham E. Pagitt R. Williams Maker Practitioner Teacher
1680–99 fl. 1694–1751 fl. 1682–1695 fl. 1682–1703
Figure D20.Examples of mathematical practitioners (Taylor,1954)
*Notes:* Figure shows three mathematical practitioners for each twenty-year cohort of first flourishing in the London sample described inSection 3, labeled by the years the cohort spans. Portrait slots go to practitioners matched to an entry in theOxford Dictionary of National Biography(2025) and use images from Wikipedia; their number rounds the cohort’s matched share to thirds, and the remaining slots name a practitioner and show a silhouette. Beneath each practitioner is a facsimile of the opening lines of their entry inTaylor(1954), and Christopher Wren’s entry is boxed on the page reproduced at left. Orange marks instrument makers. [Return to page15]
OA-82
(A)Connections by decade
1600s 1630s 1660s 1690s
Taylor (1954) *Six Degrees of Francis Bacon*(Warren et al., 2016)
(B)Connections of Thomas Tompion
Theorists Makers Robert Hooke Christopher Cock *paid him £10 for a quadrant* *supplied the sights for his quadrant* Edmund Halley George Graham *praised the sextant he made* *succeeded him in the shop* Jonas Moore Humphrey Adamson *ordered a Greenwich clock from him* *dined with him, Hooke, and Moore* James Hodgson Daniel Quare *owned a clock he made for Greenwich* Richard Norris Robert Morden *saw him time falling-ball experiments* Samuel Morland John Conyers
Charles Scarburgh John Rowley *made an astronomical clock for him, ordered by Hooke*
Taylor (1954) *Six Degrees of Francis Bacon*(Warren et al., 2016) Figure D21.Connections among mathematical practitioners
*Notes:* Panel A draws the mathematical practitioners active in London in four decades and the connections among them (seeSection 3), with the clockmaker Thomas Tompion highlighted as the large red node and his connections in each decade in pink. Panel B shows his 14 connections, divided into theorists and makers. Glosses paraphrase passages ofTaylor(1954) on nine of the connections. The*Six Degrees of* *Francis Bacon*database records no such text and gives only the connections. [Return to page16]
OA-83
barrister (*𝑛*=1) baronet (*𝑛*=2) physician (*𝑛*=1) printer (*𝑛*=2) husbandman (*𝑛*=1) optical instrument maker (*𝑛*=2) ship captain (*𝑛*=1) labourer (*𝑛*=1) gentleman (*𝑛*=5) rector (*𝑛*=4) clergyman (*𝑛*=5) scientific instruments maker (*𝑛*=6) cordwainer (*𝑛*=2) cutler (*𝑛*=1) surveyor (*𝑛*=1) mathematical instrument maker (*𝑛*=1) minister (*𝑛*=1) compass maker (*𝑛*=1) farmer (*𝑛*=3) magistrate (*𝑛*=1) sword cutler (*𝑛*=1) yeoman (*𝑛*=3) merchant (*𝑛*=2) lieutenant, army (*𝑛*=1) page (*𝑛*=1) beadle (*𝑛*=1) joiner (*𝑛*=1) blacksmith (*𝑛*=1) estate worker (*𝑛*=1) innkeeper (*𝑛*=1) scientist (*𝑛*=1)
N/A (*𝑛*=188) 34
0 1 2 5 10 20 50 Relative representation at Oxbridge,*𝑧*(*𝑠*)(arsinh scale)
Figure D22.Relative Oxbridge representation by father’s occupation
*Notes:* Figure plots relative Oxbridge representation by father’s occupation for the 244 mathematical practitioners in the London sample described inSection 3. The horizontal axis shows relative surname representation among pre-1650 Oxbridge alumni, *𝑧*(*𝑠*), on an inverse hyperbolic sine (arsinh) scale. Each circle is one value of *𝑧*(*𝑠*) within a category, with area proportional to the number of practitioners sharing that value, and counts are printed inside circles drawn large enough to hold them. Blue circles have *𝑧*(*𝑠*)*>*1 and red circles *𝑧*(*𝑠*)≤1, with the dashed line at *𝑧*(*𝑠*)=1. Numbers in parentheses give the number of practitioners in each category, and the 31 observed occupations are ordered by their median *𝑧*(*𝑠*). The bottom row holds the 188 practitioners whose paternal occupation is unobserved, 34 of whom carry a surname that never appears among pre-1650 Oxbridge alumni. The median *𝑧*(*𝑠*) in that row is
1.14, against a median of 1.51 across the observed occupation medians. Occupations are coded from fathers’ occupational titles using the PST system developed byWrigley(2010). Data from the authors’ dataset. [Return to page26]
OA-84
D.14.Tables
Table D6—Coffeehouse source categories
| Any source | Only source | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Panel A. Source categories | ||||
| Published and private | 158 | 0.55 | 67 | 0.23 |
| Printed books, pamphlets, and literary works | 47 | 0.16 | 9 | 0.03 |
| Newspapers and periodicals | 44 | 0.15 | 7 | 0.02 |
| Secondary histories and reference works | 40 | 0.14 | 8 | 0.03 |
| Manuscripts and private papers | 36 | 0.13 | 13 | 0.05 |
| Diaries, memoirs, and personal writings | 32 | 0.11 | 6 | 0.02 |
| Advertisements, notices, and ephemera | 31 | 0.11 | 9 | 0.03 |
| Catalogues, sales, and auctions | 8 | 0.03 | 2 | 0.01 |
| Material and visual | 98 | 0.34 | 44 | 0.15 |
| Trade tokens | 65 | 0.23 | 34 | 0.12 |
| Maps, views, inscriptions, and topographical evidence | 36 | 0.13 | 10 | 0.03 |
| Administrative and official | 90 | 0.31 | 27 | 0.09 |
| Parish, civic, and local records | 44 | 0.15 | 13 | 0.05 |
| Company, commercial, and financial records | 34 | 0.12 | 7 | 0.02 |
| State, legal, and court records | 33 | 0.12 | 6 | 0.02 |
| Unknown | 52 | 0.18 | 50 | 0.17 |
| No source, unidentified, or unclear | 52 | 0.18 | 50 | 0.17 |
| Panel B. Summary statisticsTotal | Per coffeehouse | |||
| Coffeehouses | 286 | 1 | ||
| Sources | 617 | 2.16 | ||
| Sources by finer categories | 502 | 1.76 | ||
| Sources by broader categories first column counts the coffeehouses with at least one source in the category, and the second divides that count by the number of distinct coffeehouses. Only source does the same for coffeehouses whose sources all fall in the category. For broad rows, this means no source in another broad category, and for indented rows no source in another finer category. Fine rows need not sum to broad rows because a coffeehouse can appear in multiple finer categories. Panel B reports summary totals and averages per coffeehouse. [Return to pages14,OA-50,OA-67] | 398 | 1.39 |
Notes:Panel A reports source-category coverage for distinct coffeehouses. Under Any source, the
Coffeehouses Per coffeehouse Coffeehouses Per coffeehouse
Table D7—Detailed types of mathematical practitioners
Occupation Distinct practitioners
*All practitioners*244 *Mathematical practitioners (proper)*69 Mathematical practitioner
Continued on next page
OA-85
Table D7 continued Distinct practitioners
| Occupation | |
|---|---|
| Surveyor | 10 |
| Hydrographer | 4 |
| Land surveyor | 4 |
| Mathematician | 4 |
| Astrologer | 3 |
| Amateur mathematician | 2 |
| Engineer | 2 |
| Applied mathematics student | 1 |
| Astronomer | 1 |
| Bookseller | 1 |
| Cartographer | 1 |
| Magnetism researcher | 1 |
| Marine hydrographer | 1 |
| Marine surveyor | 1 |
| Master of the mint | 1 |
| Master printer | 1 |
| Mathematical bookseller | 1 |
| Mathematics promoter | 1 |
| Mathematics student | 1 |
| Navigational instrument seller | 1 |
| Navigator | 1 |
| Operator to the Royal Society | 1 |
| Physician | 1 |
| Professional surveyor | 1 |
| Teachers | 54 |
| Mathematics teacher | 24 |
| Mathematics professor | 6 |
| Mathematics schoolmaster | 6 |
| Navigation teacher | 4 |
| Practical mathematics teacher | 3 |
| Astronomy professor | 2 |
| Geometry professor | 2 |
| Mathematics lecturer | 2 |
| Applied mathematics teacher | 1 |
| Mathematics school founder | 1 |
| Mathematics teacher or lecturer | 1 |
| Mathematics tutor | 1 |
| Practical mathematics and navigation teacher | 1 |
| Makers | 130 |
| Instrument maker | 46 |
| Mathematical instrument maker | 28 |
| Optical instrument maker | 19 |
| Dial maker | 6 |
| Globe maker | 6 |
| Chart maker | 5 |
| Clockmaker | 5 |
Continued on next page
OA-86
Table D7 continued Distinct practitioners
| Occupation | |
|---|---|
| Compass maker | 4 |
| Engraver | 3 |
| Glass grinder | 3 |
| Almanac maker | 2 |
| Astronomical instrument maker | 1 |
| Calendar maker | 1 |
| Craftsman | 1 |
| Instrument designer | 1 |
| Instrument repairer | 1 |
| Master craftsman | 1 |
| Mechanic | 1 |
| Nautical instrument maker | 1 |
| Smith | 1 |
*Notes:* Counts are distinct mathematical practitioners in the London sample described in Section3, by the occupational titles thatTaylor(1954) records for them. Indented rows are titles, harmonized from the raw occupation strings, and headers group them. A practitioner with several titles is counted under each, so the rows of a group can sum to more than its header, and the headers to more than the 244 practitioners. [Return to page15]
OA-87
E.MODEL APPENDIX
E.1.Environment
Decades are indexed by *𝑡* and parishes by *𝑝*=1*,...,𝑁* with *𝑁*≥2, and *𝑑𝑝𝑞*≥0 is
| 81 | 𝑝𝑡 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝜙𝐷𝑝𝑡 | 82 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 𝑡 𝑡 |
the distance in kilometers between parishes *𝑝* and *𝑞*. 81 *𝑆 >*0, *𝑆* for scientists, is the number of applied scientists in parish *𝑝* in decade *𝑡*, in the model an expected count Í whoserealizationistheobservedcount. *𝑆* = *𝑆* isLondon’stotaland *𝜎* =*𝑆* /*𝑆* parish *𝑝*’s share of it. A pool of *𝐿>*0 potential entrants into science makes *𝜋* =*𝑆* /*𝐿* the science share of the pool. Treatment *𝐷* ∈{0*,*1} indicates a coffeehouse in parish *𝑝* in decade *𝑡*, and *𝑚𝑝𝑡*=*𝑒* is the factor by which it scales meetings between applied scientists. The parameters are *𝜙 >*0, *𝛿 >*0, *𝜂 >*0, *𝛾*≥0, and the Fréchet shapes *𝜀𝑃,𝜀𝑆*of Assumption E.2: *𝜙* is the coffeehouse effect on meetings, *𝛿* the decay of meetings with distance, *𝜂* the return to access, and *𝛾* the dispersion force. The fundamentals, taken as given, are *𝜓𝑝𝑡>*0 and *𝑢>*0: *𝜓𝑝𝑡*is what makes parish *𝑝* attractive apart from access and *𝑢*the payoff of the trade outside science.
Definition E.1(Access).The access in count form of parish*𝑝*in decade*𝑡*is Õ
| 𝑝𝑡 | −𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞 | 𝑞𝑡 𝑞𝑡 |
|---|---|---|
| 𝑞 |
*𝐾𝑝𝑡*=*𝑚 𝑒 𝑚 𝑆.*(E.1)
The access in share form of parish*𝑝*in decade*𝑡*is Õ
| 𝜅 (𝝈 )=𝑚 | 𝑒 𝑚 | 𝜎 ,(E.2) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑝𝑡 𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 | −𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞 | 𝑞𝑡 𝑞𝑡 |
| 𝑞 | 𝑝𝑡 |
with *𝝈𝑡*=(*𝜎₁𝑡,...,𝜎𝑁𝑡*) the vector of shares, written *𝜅* when the argument is clear.
Access, *𝐾* for the knowledge within an applied scientist’s reach, is the agglomeration force of the quantitative urban model (Redding,2025, §4). There productivity rises with the employment nearby, discounted by travel time, through production externalities such as knowledge spillovers (Redding,2025, §4.2, eq. (9)). Here the externality is the meeting rate: access is the distance-discounted sum of applied scientists, with the coffeehouse as the shifter*𝑚𝑝𝑡*at each end.
Lemma E.1(The aggregate factors out of access).*𝐾𝑝𝑡*=*𝑆𝑡𝜅𝑝𝑡*(*𝝈𝑡*)*.*
81 Distances *𝑑* run between the centroids of parishes *𝑝* and *𝑞*. For *𝑞*=*𝑝*, *𝑑 >*0 is instead two thirds *𝑝𝑞 𝑝𝑝* of the radius of a disk of its area, which is equal to the average distance from the center of such a disk to the points in it. 82 A parish with no applied scientist in a decade is the limit of the model as its fundamental *𝜓𝑝𝑡*goes to zero. By (E.9) its share is then zero in the observed equilibrium and in every counterfactual, and by (E.1) it adds nothing to the access of others, soProcedure E.4keeps it at zero.
OA-88
*Proof.*Using*𝑆𝑞𝑡*=*𝜎𝑞𝑡𝑆𝑡*, we have Õ *𝐾𝑝𝑡*=*𝑚𝑝𝑡𝑒* −*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞* *𝑚𝑞𝑡𝑆𝑞𝑡* *𝑞* Õ =*𝑚𝑝𝑡𝑒* −*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞* *𝑚𝑞𝑡𝜎𝑞𝑡𝑆𝑡* *𝑞* Õ =*𝑆𝑡𝑚𝑝𝑡𝑒* −*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞* *𝑚𝑞𝑡𝜎𝑞𝑡* *𝑞* =*𝑆𝑡𝜅𝑝𝑡*(*𝝈𝑡*)*.*
Definition E.2(Return).The return to practicing science in parish*𝑝*in decade*𝑡*is
*𝜂* −*𝛾* *𝑅𝑝𝑡*=*𝜓𝑝𝑡𝐾* *𝑝𝑡* *𝑆* *𝑝𝑡*
*.*(E.3)
The dispersion force *𝛾* is, inRedding(2025, §4), an inelastic supply of land: the applied scientists of a parish compete for its premises, whose supply is fixed, so the price of floor space rises with *𝑆𝑝𝑡*and the return net of that price falls at elasticity *𝛾*, the share of income spent on premises.
Definition E.3(Composite coefficient).The composite coefficient at elasticity*𝜀*is
<u>𝜀𝜂</u> *𝛽*(*𝜀*)=*.*(E.4) 1+*𝛾𝜀*
##### Furthermore, set𝛽𝑃=𝛽(𝜀𝑃)and𝛽𝑆=𝛽(𝜀𝑆).
Lemma E.2(*𝛽*is increasing).*If*0*< 𝜀₁* ≤*𝜀₂ then*0*< 𝛽*(*𝜀₁*)≤*𝛽*(*𝜀₂*)*.*
*Proof.*Positivity follows from*𝜀𝜂 >*0and1+*𝛾𝜀 >*0. Now,
*𝛽*(*𝜀₁*)≤*𝛽*(*𝜀₂*) ⇐⇒*𝜀₁𝜂*(1+*𝛾𝜀₂*)≤*𝜀₂𝜂*(1+*𝛾𝜀₁*) ⇐⇒*𝜀₁𝜂*+*𝛾𝜂𝜀₁𝜀₂* ≤*𝜀₂𝜂*+*𝛾𝜂𝜀₁𝜀₂* ⇐⇒*𝜂*(*𝜀₂* −*𝜀₁*)≥0*,*
##### which holds because𝜂 >0and𝜀₁ ≤𝜀₂.
E.2.Meetings and Gravity
Assumption E.1(Meetings).Each applied scientist in *𝑝* meets each applied scientist in*𝑞*at Poisson rate *𝜆𝑝𝑞𝑡*=*𝜒𝑚𝑝𝑡𝑒* −*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞* *𝑚𝑞𝑡,*(E.5)
with *𝜒 >*0, independently across pairs. Each meeting is documented with probabil- ity*𝜌𝑡*∈(0*,*1], independently of everything else.
Assumption E.1is the gravity equation of quantitative urban models applied to meetings (Redding,2025, §2.4, §5.2). The flow between two parishes rises with the mass at either end, as interaction rises with the mass of people nearby in the classical account
OA-89
(e.g.,Glaeser et al.,1992), and falls with distance. In our application, the added part is the coffeehouse, which raises the rate given that mass and enters as the shifter *𝑚𝑝𝑡*at each end of a pair.
Lemma E.3(Superposition).*If 𝑋₁,...,𝑋𝑁are independent Poisson counts with rates* *𝑟₁,...,𝑟𝑁, then𝑋₁* +···+*𝑋𝑁is a Poisson count with rate𝑟₁* +···+*𝑟𝑁.*
*Proof.*See the Superposition Theorem inKingman(1993, p. 16, §2.2).
Lemma E.4(Thinning).*If the number of events is Poisson with rate 𝑟, and each event* *is kept with probability 𝜌, independently of the other events and of their number, then the* *number of events kept is Poisson with rate𝜌𝑟.*
*Proof.*See the Colouring Theorem inKingman(1993, p. 53, §5.1).
Theorem E.1(Gravity).*UnderAssumption E.1the number of documented connections* *𝑇𝑝𝑞𝑡between parishes𝑝*≠*𝑞in decade𝑡is Poisson with mean*
E[*𝑇𝑝𝑞𝑡*]=(*𝜒𝜌𝑡*)(*𝑚𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑝𝑡*)*𝑒* −*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞* (*𝑚𝑞𝑡𝑆𝑞𝑡*)*.*(E.6)
*Proof.* Since the *𝑆𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑞𝑡*pairs of an applied scientist in *𝑝* and one in *𝑞* meet independently, Lemma E.3gives that the total number of meetings is Poisson with rate*𝜆𝑝𝑞𝑡𝑆𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑞𝑡*. By Lemma E.4, documentation with probability *𝜌𝑡*thins it to a Poisson count with rate *𝜌𝑡𝜆𝑝𝑞𝑡𝑆𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑞𝑡*, which is the display once (E.5) is substituted.
E.3.The Fréchet Distribution
The choice model of the next subsection rests on three standard properties of the Fréchet distribution. We found no textbook that proves them in the forms in which we use them, so we prove them here.
Definition E.4(Fréchet distribution).A random draw *𝑧* is Fréchet with shape *𝜀 >*0 and scale*𝐴>*0if
P[*𝑧*≤*𝑥*]=*𝐹𝜀,𝐴*(*𝑥*)=exp(−*𝐴𝑥* −*𝜀* )*, 𝑥>*0*,*
with density −*𝜀*−1 −*𝐴𝑥* −*𝜀* *𝑓* *𝜀,𝐴*(*𝑥*)=*𝐴𝜀𝑥 𝑒, 𝑥>*0*.*
Definition E.5(Unit Fréchet distribution).A random draw *𝑧* is unit Fréchet with shape*𝜀*if it is Fréchet with shape*𝜀*and scale*𝐴*=1.
Lemma E.5(Scaling).*If 𝑧 is unit Fréchet with shape 𝜀, then 𝑅𝑧 with 𝑅>*0 *is Fréchet* *with shape𝜀and scale𝑅* *𝜀* *.*
OA-90
*Proof.*For*𝑥>*0,
P[*𝑅𝑧*≤*𝑥*]=P[*𝑧*≤*𝑥*/*𝑅*] =exp −(*𝑥*/*𝑅*) −*𝜀*
=exp −*𝑅* *𝜀* *𝑥* −*𝜀* =*𝐹𝜀,𝑅𝜀* (*𝑥*)*.*
Lemma E.6(Max-stability).*If 𝑢₁,...,𝑢𝑁are independent Fréchet draws with common* Í *𝑁* *shape𝜀and scales𝐴₁,...,𝐴𝑁, then*max*𝑝𝑢𝑝is Fréchet with shape𝜀and scale* *𝑝*=1 *𝐴𝑝.*
*Proof.*For*𝑥>*0,
P max*𝑢𝑝*≤*𝑥* =P *𝑢₁* ≤*𝑥,...,𝑢𝑁*≤*𝑥* *𝑝* Ö *𝑁* = P[*𝑢𝑝*≤*𝑥*](independence) *𝑝*=1 Ö *𝑁* = exp −*𝐴𝑝𝑥* −*𝜀*
*𝑝*=1 Õ *𝑁* =exp − *𝐴𝑝𝑥* −*𝜀* =*𝐹𝜀,* Í *𝑝𝐴𝑝*
(*𝑥*)*.*
*𝑝*=1
Lemma E.7(Choice probability).*Let 𝑢₁,...,𝑢𝑁be independent Fréchet with common* Í *shape𝜀and scales𝐴₁,...,𝐴𝑁, and𝑆*=*𝑘𝐴𝑘. Then*
P[*𝑢𝑝*=max*𝑢𝑘*]=*𝐴𝑝*/*𝑆.* *𝑘*
*Proof.* Let *𝑀*=max*𝑘*≠*𝑝𝑢𝑘*. *𝑀* is a function of draws independent of *𝑢𝑝*, so *𝑀* and *𝑢𝑝* are independent. ByLemma E.6, the distribution function of*𝑀*is*𝐹𝜀,𝑆*−*𝐴* *𝑝*. Thus,
P[*𝑢𝑝*=max*𝑢𝑘*]=P[*𝑀*≤*𝑢𝑝*]=E 1{*𝑀*≤*𝑢𝑝*} *𝑘* h i =E E 1{*𝑀*≤*𝑢𝑝*} *𝑢𝑝* (iterated expectations)
=E *𝐹𝜀,𝑆*−*𝐴* *𝑝* (*𝑢𝑝*) (*𝑀*independent of*𝑢𝑝*) ∫ ∞ = *𝐹𝜀,𝑆*−*𝐴* *𝑝*
(*𝑥*)*𝑓𝜀,𝐴* *𝑝*
(*𝑥*)*𝑑𝑥*
∫ 0 ∞ −(*𝑆*−*𝐴𝑝*)*𝑥* −*𝜀* −*𝜀*−1 −*𝐴𝑝𝑥* −*𝜀* = *𝑒* ·*𝐴𝑝𝜀𝑥 𝑒 𝑑𝑥* 0 ∫ ∞ <u>𝐴𝑝</u> −*𝜀* = *𝑆𝜀𝑥* −*𝜀*−1 *𝑒* −*𝑆𝑥* *𝑑𝑥* *𝑆*0 ∫ ∞ <u>𝐴𝑝</u> = *𝑓𝜀,𝑆*(*𝑥*)*𝑑𝑥* *𝑆*0 | {z} =1 <u>𝐴𝑝</u> =*.* *𝑆*
OA-91
E.4.Choice
Assumption E.2(Choice model).In decade *𝑡* each of *𝐿* potential entrants *𝜈* makes two choices in sequence.
1. *Whether to practice.*The outside trade yields entrant *𝜈* the payoff *𝑢𝜁₀𝜈*and practicing the payoff *𝑉𝑡𝜁₁𝜈*, where (*𝜁₀𝜈,𝜁₁𝜈*) are independent unit Fréchet draws with shape*𝜀𝑆 𝑡 𝜈 𝜈*
| . The entrant practices if𝑉 | 𝜁₁ > 𝑢𝜁₀ | . | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑆 𝑝 𝑝𝜈 | 𝑡 𝜈 | 𝜈 𝑝𝜈 𝜈 | 𝑝𝑡 𝑁𝜈 | 𝑝𝜈 | 𝑆 𝑃 |
2. *Wheretopractice.*Practicinginparish *𝑝* yieldsthepayoff*𝑢* =*𝑅 𝜉*,theparish’s return scaled by an idiosyncratic draw, where (*𝜉₁,...,𝜉*) are independent unit Fréchet draws with shape *𝜀𝑃*. The entrant picks the parish with the largest payoff,arg max *𝑢*. Draws are independent across entrants and across the two choices, and 0*< 𝜀* ≤*𝜀*. Assumption E.2is the Fréchet choice model of quantitative urban models (Redding,
2025, §4.1), in which a worker chooses where to live and work. Here the entrant makes twochoices,whethertopracticeandwhere,eachwithitsowndispersionparameter. The restriction 0*< 𝜀𝑆*≤*𝜀𝑃*is the consistency condition of a nested choice (McFadden,1978; Train,2009): the two choices together are one nested maximization with inclusive-value coefficient *𝜀𝑆*/*𝜀𝑃*, which must lie in the unit interval for the probabilities to come from utility maximization. This means that entering science is no easier than moving parish. WithLemma E.2, the restriction gives0*< 𝛽𝑆*≤*𝛽𝑃*.
Theorem E.2(Shares and total).*UnderAssumption E.2,*
| 𝜀𝑃 | 1/𝜀𝑃 | 𝜀𝑆 | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑝𝑡 | 𝜀𝑃 | 𝑡 | 𝑡 | |
| 𝜀𝑃 | 𝑘𝑡 | 𝜀𝑆𝜀𝑆 | ||
| 𝑘 𝑘𝑡 | 𝑘 | 𝑡 | 𝑡 |
*𝑅* Õ *𝑉* *𝜕*ln*𝑆* *𝜎𝑝𝑡*= Í*, 𝑉𝑡*= *𝑅, 𝑆𝑡*= *𝐿,* =*𝜀𝑆*(1−*𝜋𝑡*)*.* *𝑅 𝑢* +*𝑉 𝜕*ln*𝑉*
*Proof.* ByLemma E.5the payoffs *𝑢𝑝𝜈*=*𝑅𝑝𝑡𝜉𝑝𝜈*are independent Fréchet with shape *𝜀𝑃* *𝜀* *𝑃* and scales *𝑅* *𝑝𝑡*. An entrant who practices picks the parish with the largest payoff, so by Lemma E.7parish*𝑝*is chosen with probability
*𝜀* *𝑃* *𝑅* <u>𝑝𝑡</u>
| 𝜎 = Í | .(E.7) | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑝𝑡 | 𝜀𝑃 𝑘 𝑘𝑡 | ||
| 𝑝 𝑝𝜈 | 𝑘 𝜀 𝑘𝑡𝑃 | 𝑡 𝜀𝑃 | |
| 𝑡 𝜈 𝜀𝑆 𝑡 | 𝜈 𝜀𝑆 |
*𝑝𝑡 𝜀𝑃* *𝑅*
Í ByLemma E.6the best payoff max *𝑢* is Fréchet with shape *𝜀𝑃*and scale *𝑅* =*𝑉*, that is, byLemma E.5read backwards, distributed as *𝑉𝑡𝑧*˜ with *𝑧*˜ unit Fréchet with shape *𝜀𝑃*. The entrant practices when *𝑉 𝜁₁ > 𝑢𝜁₀*. ByLemma E.5these two are independent Fréchet with shape *𝜀𝑆*and scales *𝑉* and *𝑢*, so byLemma E.7with two alternatives the entrant practices with probability
*𝜀* *𝑆* <u>𝑉</u> <u>𝑡</u> *𝜋𝑡*= *𝜀* *𝑆𝜀𝑆*
*.*(E.8)
*𝑢* +*𝑉* *𝑡*
Each of the *𝐿* entrants practices with probability *𝜋𝑡*, so the expected number who practice is *𝑆𝑡*= *𝐿𝜋𝑡*, and by the independence of the two choices each practices in parish
OA-92
*𝑝* with probability *𝜎𝑝𝑡𝜋𝑡*, so the expected number there is *𝑆𝑝𝑡*=*𝜎𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑡*. Finally, taking logarithms of*𝑆𝑡*and differentiating with respect toln*𝑉𝑡*,
*𝜀* *𝑆𝜀𝑆* ln*𝑆𝑡*=ln*𝐿*+*𝜀𝑆*ln*𝑉𝑡*−ln *𝑢* +*𝑉* *𝑡* *𝜀* *𝑆* <u>𝜕ln𝑆𝑡𝜀𝑆𝑉𝑡</u> =⇒ =*𝜀𝑆*− *𝜀* *𝑆𝜀𝑆* =*𝜀𝑆*(1−*𝜋𝑡*)*.* *𝜕*ln*𝑉𝑡 𝑢* +*𝑉* *𝑡*
E.5.Block Recursion
##### Theorem E.3(Block recursion).
ln*𝜎𝑝𝑡*=*𝛽𝑃*ln*𝜅𝑝𝑡*(*𝝈𝑡*)+ln*𝜓*˜*𝑝𝑡*+*𝑐𝑡,*(E.9)
| ln𝑉 | =(𝜂−𝛾)ln𝑆 | +ln𝑊 | ,(E.10) | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑝𝑡 | 𝜀𝑃/(1+𝛾𝜀 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑡 𝑃) | 𝑆 𝑡 | 𝜀𝑆 | 𝑡 𝜀𝑆 | |||
| 𝑃 | 𝑡 𝑃 | 𝑡 | 𝜀𝑃 | 𝜀𝑃 | 𝜂 −𝛾 | 𝜀𝑃1/𝜀𝑃 | ||
| 𝑡 | 𝑃 | 𝑡 𝑘 | 𝑘𝑡 | 𝑡 𝑘 | 𝑘𝑡 𝑘𝑡 𝑘𝑡 |
*𝑡 𝑡 𝑡* *𝜀* *𝑆𝜀𝑆* ln*𝑆* =ln*𝐿*+*𝜀* ln*𝑉* −ln *𝑢* +*𝑉,*(E.11)
˜ *where 𝜓* =*𝜓 and*
<u>𝜀 (𝜂−𝛾)ln𝑆 −𝜀 ln𝑉</u> Õ Õ *𝑐* =*, 𝑉* = *𝑅, 𝑊* = *𝜓 𝜅 𝜎.* 1+*𝛾𝜀*
*Proof.*ByLemma E.1and*𝑆𝑝𝑡*=*𝜎𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑡*,
*𝜂* −*𝛾* *𝑅𝑝𝑡*=*𝜓𝑝𝑡𝐾* *𝑝𝑡* *𝑆* *𝑝𝑡* *𝜂* −*𝛾* =*𝜓𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑡𝜅𝑝𝑡*(*𝝈𝑡*) *𝜎𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑡* *𝜂* −*𝛾 𝜂*−*𝛾* =*𝜓𝑝𝑡𝜅* *𝑝𝑡* *𝜎* *𝑝𝑡* *𝑆* *𝑡* *.*
*𝜀* *𝑃* Í*𝜀* *𝑃* Taking logarithms of the share equation ofTheorem E.2, with *𝑉* *𝑡* =*𝑘𝑅* *𝑘𝑡*, and collecting theln*𝜎𝑝𝑡*terms,
*𝜀* *𝑃* *𝑅* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> *𝜎𝑝𝑡*= *𝜀* *𝑃* *𝑉* *𝑡* =⇒ln*𝜎𝑝𝑡*=*𝜀𝑃*ln*𝑅𝑝𝑡*−*𝜀𝑃*ln*𝑉𝑡* =*𝜀𝑃*ln*𝜓𝑝𝑡*+*𝜂*ln*𝜅𝑝𝑡*−*𝛾*ln*𝜎𝑝𝑡*+(*𝜂*−*𝛾*)ln*𝑆𝑡*−*𝜀𝑃*ln*𝑉𝑡* =⇒ (1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃*)ln*𝜎𝑝𝑡*=*𝜀𝑃𝜂*ln*𝜅𝑝𝑡*+*𝜀𝑃*ln*𝜓𝑝𝑡*+ *𝜀𝑃*(*𝜂*−*𝛾*)ln*𝑆𝑡*−*𝜀𝑃*ln*𝑉𝑡* <u>𝜀𝑃𝜂 𝜀𝑃</u> =⇒ln*𝜎𝑝𝑡*= ln*𝜅𝑝𝑡*+ ln*𝜓𝑝𝑡*+*𝑐𝑡,*(*𝜀𝑃𝜂*/(1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃*)=*𝛽𝑃*) 1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃*1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃*
| 𝜀 (𝜂−𝛾)ln𝑆 | −𝜀 ln𝑉 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑃 | 𝑡 | 𝑃 | 𝑡 | ||||
| 𝑡 | |||||||
| 𝑃 |
*𝑐* =*,* 1+*𝛾𝜀*
OA-93
<u>𝜀</u> <u>𝑃</u>˜ which is (E.9), as 1+*𝛾𝜀* ln*𝜓𝑝𝑡*=ln*𝜓𝑝𝑡*. For (E.10), by the same factoring, *𝑃* Õ *𝜀* *𝑃𝜀𝑃* *𝑉* *𝑡* = *𝑅* *𝑘𝑡* *𝑘* Õ *𝜂* −*𝛾 𝜀𝑃*(*𝜂*−*𝛾*)*𝜀𝑃* = *𝜓𝑘𝑡𝜅* *𝑘𝑡* *𝜎* *𝑘𝑡* *𝑆* *𝑡* *𝑘* (*𝜂*−*𝛾*)*𝜀𝑃 𝜀𝑃* =*𝑆* *𝑡* *𝑊* *𝑡* =⇒ln*𝑉𝑡*=(*𝜂*−*𝛾*)ln*𝑆𝑡*+ln*𝑊𝑡.*
Equation (E.11) is the total ofTheorem E.2in logs.
Í*𝛽* *𝑃*1/*𝛽𝑃* Corollary E.1(The total in levels).*Let 𝜅𝑡*=*𝑘𝜓*˜*𝑘𝑡𝜅* *𝑘𝑡* *, and 𝐾𝑡*=*𝑆𝑡𝜅𝑡, London’s* *𝜂* *average access. In equilibrium𝑊𝑡*= *𝜅* *𝑡* *, so that*
<u>ln𝐿−𝜀𝑆ln𝑢+ln(1−𝜋𝑡)</u> ln*𝑉𝑡*=*𝜂*ln*𝐾𝑡*−*𝛾*ln*𝑆𝑡,*ln*𝑆𝑡*=*𝛽𝑆*ln*𝐾𝑡*+ *𝑐𝑡, 𝑐𝑡*=*,* 1+*𝛾𝜀𝑆*
*and 𝑐𝑡is fixed by 𝐿 and 𝑢 as 𝜋𝑡*→0*. If a counterfactual holds the fundamentals fixed, then* ′Í′ *𝛽𝑃*1/*𝛽𝑃* *𝜅𝑡*/*𝜅𝑡*=*𝑘𝜎𝑘𝑡*(*𝜅* *𝑘𝑡* /*𝜅𝑘𝑡*)*.*
˜ *𝛽* *𝑃𝑐𝑡𝑐𝑡* Í ˜ *𝛽* *𝑃* *Proof.* By (E.9), *𝜎𝑘𝑡*= *𝜓𝑘𝑡𝜅* *𝑘𝑡* *𝑒*, and since the shares sum to one, *𝑒* =1/*𝑘𝜓𝑘𝑡𝜅* *𝑘𝑡* = −*𝛽𝑃* *𝜅* *𝑡*. Since*𝛽𝑃*(1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃*)=*𝜀𝑃𝜂*,
*𝜀* *𝑃𝜂𝜀𝑃*˜*𝛽𝑃*1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃𝛽𝑃*1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃* *𝜓* *𝑘𝑡* *𝜅* *𝑘𝑡* = *𝜓𝑘𝑡𝜅* *𝑘𝑡* = *𝜎𝑘𝑡𝜅* *𝑡* Õ Õ *𝜀* *𝑃𝜀𝑃𝜂𝜀𝑃*−*𝛾𝜀𝑃𝜂𝜀𝑃𝜂𝜀𝑃* =⇒*𝑊* *𝑡* = *𝜓* *𝑘𝑡* *𝜅* *𝑘𝑡* *𝜎* *𝑘𝑡* = *𝜅* *𝑡* *𝜎𝑘𝑡*= *𝜅* *𝑡* *,* *𝑘 𝑘*
so (E.10) reads ln*𝑉𝑡*=(*𝜂*−*𝛾*)ln*𝑆𝑡*+*𝜂*ln*𝜅𝑡*=*𝜂*ln*𝐾𝑡*−*𝛾*ln*𝑆𝑡*. ByTheorem E.2, *𝜀* *𝑆𝜀𝑆𝜀𝑆* 1−*𝜋𝑡*= *𝑢* /(*𝑢* +*𝑉* *𝑡* ), so (E.11) reads
ln*𝑆𝑡*=ln*𝐿*−*𝜀𝑆*ln*𝑢*+ln(1−*𝜋𝑡*)+*𝜀𝑆*ln*𝑉𝑡*
=ln*𝐿*−*𝜀𝑆*ln*𝑢*+ln(1−*𝜋𝑡*)+*𝜀𝑆𝜂*ln*𝐾𝑡*−*𝜀𝑆𝛾*ln*𝑆𝑡,*
and solving for ln*𝑆𝑡*gives the second display equation, with *𝜀𝑆𝜂*/(1+*𝛾𝜀𝑆*)=*𝛽𝑆*. Last, ˜ ˜ *𝛽* *𝑃𝛽𝑃* with *𝜓𝑘𝑡*fixed and*𝜎𝑘𝑡*= *𝜓𝑘𝑡𝜅* *𝑘𝑡* /*𝜅* *𝑡*,
′ *𝛽* *𝑃* Õ *𝜓*˜ *𝜅* *𝛽* *𝑃* *𝜅* ′ *𝛽* *𝑃* Õ *𝜅*′ *𝛽* *𝑃* *𝜅𝑡 𝑘𝑡 𝑘𝑡 𝑘𝑡 𝑘𝑡* = = *𝜎𝑘𝑡.* *𝜅𝑡* *𝜅* *𝛽* *𝑃𝜅* *𝑘𝑡𝜅𝑘𝑡* *𝑘 𝑡 𝑘*
Theorem E.4(The aggregate fixed point).*If 𝛽𝑃<*1*, then for given shares 𝝈𝑡equations* (E.9)*–*(E.11)*give exactly one solution in*ln*𝑆𝑡.*
OA-94
*Proof.*Write*𝑧*=ln*𝑆𝑡*. Substituting (E.10),ln*𝑉𝑡*=(*𝜂*−*𝛾*)*𝑧*+ln*𝑊𝑡*, into (E.11),
*𝜀* *𝑆 𝜀𝑆*(*𝜂*−*𝛾*)*𝑧 𝜀𝑆* *𝑧*=ln*𝐿*+*𝜀𝑆*(*𝜂*−*𝛾*)*𝑧*+ln*𝑊𝑡*
| −ln 𝑢 | +𝑒 | 𝑊 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑡 𝑎𝑧 | 𝑡 |
*𝑡* ⇐⇒0=(1−*𝑎*)*𝑧*−*𝑏*+ln *𝑐*+*𝑑𝑒* =: *ℎ*(*𝑧*)*,*
with constants
*𝜀* *𝑆𝜀𝑆* *𝑎*=*𝜀𝑆*(*𝜂*−*𝛾*)*, 𝑏*=ln*𝐿*+*𝜀𝑆*ln*𝑊𝑡, 𝑐*= *𝑢, 𝑑*=*𝑊* *𝑡* *,*
so the solutions are the zeros of *ℎ*. Suppose first that *𝑎<*1. With *𝑤*=*𝑑𝑒* *𝑎𝑧* /(*𝑐*+*𝑑𝑒* *𝑎𝑧* )∈ (0*,*1),
′ <u>𝑎𝑑𝑒</u> *𝑎𝑧* *ℎ* (*𝑧*)=(1−*𝑎*)+ *𝑎𝑧* =1−*𝑎*(1−*𝑤*)*>*0*,* *𝑐*+*𝑑𝑒*
so *ℎ* is strictly increasing. Since *ℎ*(*𝑧*)≥*𝑧*+min(ln*𝑐,*ln*𝑑*)−*𝑏* for *𝑧*≥0, which tends to +∞ as *𝑧*→+∞, and *ℎ*(*𝑧*)≤min(1*,*1−*𝑎*)*𝑧*+ln(*𝑐*+*𝑑*)−*𝑏* for *𝑧*≤0, which tends to −∞ as *𝑧*→−∞, the intermediate value theorem gives a zero and strict monotonicity its uniqueness. It remains to see that*𝛽𝑃<*1gives*𝑎<*1. Since*𝛽𝑆*=*𝜀𝑆𝜂*/(1+*𝛾𝜀𝑆*),
*𝛽𝑆<*1⇐⇒*𝜀𝑆𝜂 <*1+*𝛾𝜀𝑆*⇐⇒*𝜀𝑆*(*𝜂*−*𝛾*)*<*1⇐⇒*𝑎<*1*,*
and*𝛽𝑆*≤*𝛽𝑃<*1.
E.6.Equilibrium in Levels
Write*𝜿𝑡*=(*𝜅₁𝑡,...,𝜅𝑁𝑡*)for the vector of access in share form, beside*𝝈𝑡*.
Lemma E.8(The fixed point in*𝜿𝑡*).*The share block*(E.9)*is*
| 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 𝑡 𝛽𝑃 | 𝑡 | 𝑐𝑡 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑡 𝑡 | 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑞𝑡 | 𝛽𝑃 𝑞𝑡 | 𝑡 𝑝𝑞𝑡 | −𝛿𝑑 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑞 𝑞𝑡 | 𝑞𝑡 |
| 𝑞 |
*𝜎* =*𝐶 𝜓*˜ *𝜅* (*𝝈*)*, 𝐶* =*𝑒,*(E.12)
*and𝜿* =*𝜿* (*𝝈*)*then solves a fixed point in𝜿 alone,* Õ ˜ *𝜅* = *𝑄 𝜅, 𝑄* =*𝐶 𝑚 𝑒 𝑚 𝜓 >*0*.*(E.13)
*Proof.* Exponentiating (E.9) gives (E.12). Substituting it into the access in share form (E.2), Õ
| 𝜅 (𝝈 )=𝑚 | 𝑒 𝑚 | 𝜎 | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑝𝑡 𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 | −𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞 | 𝑞𝑡 𝑞𝑡 | |
| 𝑞 𝑝𝑡 | −𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞 | 𝑞𝑡 𝑡 | 𝑞𝑡 𝛽 𝑞𝑡𝑃 | |
| 𝑞 𝑝𝑞𝑡 | 𝛽𝑃 𝑞𝑡 | |||
| 𝑞 |
Õ ˜ =*𝑚 𝑒 𝑚 𝐶 𝜓 𝜅* (by (E.12))
Õ = *𝑄 𝜅.*
Theorem E.5(Existence and uniqueness).*Let 𝑄𝑝𝑞𝑡> and* 0≤*𝛽𝑃<. Then* (E.13) *has exactly one strictly positive solution, and iterating the system in log coordinates from any*
OA-95
| after 𝑘 iterations. The constant 𝐶 | is pinned by Í | 𝜎 =1: |
|---|---|---|
| 𝑃 𝑘 | 𝑡 1/(1−𝛽𝑃) | 𝑝 𝑝𝑡 |
*start converges to it at rate 𝛽* *scaling 𝑄 by 𝑐 scales the solution and the shares by 𝑐, so exactly one 𝑐> normalizes* *them.*
*Proof. The fixed point and the rate.*In log coordinates *𝑥𝑝*=ln*𝜅𝑝𝑡*the system is *𝒙*=*𝑇*(*𝒙*) Í *𝛽 𝑥* with*𝑇*(*𝒙*)*𝑝*=ln*𝑞𝑄𝑝𝑞𝑡𝑒* *𝑃 𝑞*. If*𝑥𝑞*≤*𝑦𝑞*+*𝑑*for all*𝑞*, then Õ *𝑇*(*𝒙*)*𝑝*=ln *𝑄𝑝𝑞𝑡𝑒* *𝛽* *𝑃𝑥𝑞* *𝑞* Õ ≤ln *𝑄𝑝𝑞𝑡𝑒* *𝛽* *𝑃* (*𝑦𝑞*+*𝑑*) (*𝛽𝑃*≥0,lnincreasing) *𝑞* Õ
| 𝛽 | 𝑑 𝑝𝑞𝑡 | 𝛽𝑃𝑦𝑞 | (𝑒𝛽 𝑑common to every term) | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑃 | 𝑞 𝑝𝑞𝑡 | 𝛽𝑃𝑦𝑞 | 𝑝 𝑃 | ||||
| 𝑞 | |||||||
| 𝑃 | |||||||
| 𝑁 | |||||||
| 𝒙∗ | 𝑘 | ∗ 𝑘 | |||||
| 𝑡 | 𝑃 |
=ln *𝑒* *𝑃* *𝑄 𝑒𝑃*
Õ =*𝛽 𝑑*+ln *𝑄 𝑒* =*𝑇*(*𝒚*) +*𝛽 𝑑,*
and with the roles exchanged, *𝑇* is *𝛽*-Lipschitz for the sup metric, so a contraction on the complete space R since *𝛽𝑃<*1. Banach’s theorem gives a unique fixed point *𝒙* ∗, so ∗ *𝜿* =*𝑒* is the only strictly positive solution, anddist(*𝑇 𝒙₀,𝒙*)≤*𝛽* dist(*𝒙₀,𝒙*). *The constant.*For*𝑐>*0,
| 1/(1−𝛽 | 𝑃) 𝛽𝑃 | 𝛽𝑃/(1−𝛽𝑃 | ) 𝛽𝑃 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑝𝑞𝑡 | 1/(1−𝛽 | 𝑞𝑡 𝑃) 𝛽𝑃 𝑞𝑡 | 𝛽𝑃/(1−𝛽 | 𝑞𝑡 𝑃) | 𝛽𝑃 𝑝𝑞𝑡 𝑞𝑡 | 𝑃) 𝑝𝑡 | |
| 𝑞 | |||||||
| 𝑃) 𝑡 | 𝑡 | ||||||
| 𝑝𝑡 1/(1−𝛽 | 𝑃) 𝑝𝑡 | 𝛽𝑃 | 1/(1−𝛽𝑃 | 𝑝 𝑝𝑡 𝛽 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑃 |
*𝑐 𝜅* =*𝑐 𝜅* Õ Õ 1/(1−*𝛽* =⇒ (*𝑐𝑄*) *𝑐 𝜅* =*𝑐*·*𝑐 𝑄 𝜅* =*𝑐 𝜅,* *𝑞*
so *𝑐* 1/(1−*𝛽* *𝜿* solves the system with kernel *𝑐𝑄*, and, with *𝐶* absorbed into *𝑐*, the ) Í shares *𝑐𝜓*˜ (*𝑐 𝜅*) sum to *𝑐 𝜓*˜ *𝜅*, which equals one for exactly one *𝑐>*0. Í Theorem E.6(Inversion).*For any strictly positive data* (*𝑆𝑝𝑡,𝐾𝑝𝑡*) *with 𝑆𝑡*=*𝑝𝑆𝑝𝑡and* *any constant𝑐𝑡,* <u>1+𝛾𝜀𝑃</u> ln*𝜓𝑝𝑡*= ln*𝑆𝑝𝑡*−*𝜂*ln*𝐾𝑝𝑡*+*𝑐𝑡*(E.14) *𝜀𝑃* *defines a strictly positive 𝜓𝑝𝑡that satisfies the share equation ofTheorem E.2exactly, and* *every 𝜓𝑝𝑡that satisfies it is of this form. The constant scales every 𝜓𝑝𝑡of the decade by the* *same factor𝑒* *𝑐* *𝑡* *, so the fundamentals are recovered up to a scale per decade.*
*Proof. The formula works.*The *𝜓𝑝𝑡*it defines is positive, being an exponential. Exponenti-
| 𝑐𝑡(1+𝛾𝜀 | 𝑃)/𝜀𝑃−𝜂 | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 𝜂 | −𝛾 | |
| 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 𝑝𝑡 𝑐𝑡(1+𝛾𝜀 𝑝𝑡 𝑐𝑡(1+𝛾𝜀 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 𝑃)/𝜀𝑃−𝜂 𝑝𝑡 𝑃)/𝜀𝑃−𝛾 | 𝜂 −𝛾 𝑝𝑡 𝑝𝑡 𝑐𝑡1/𝜀𝑃 𝑝𝑡 |
*𝑐* *𝑡* (1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃*)/*𝜀𝑃*−*𝜂* ating (E.14) gives*𝜓𝑝𝑡*=*𝑒 𝑆 𝐾*, so in the return (E.3) the access cancels,
##### 𝑅 =𝜓 𝐾 𝑆
=*𝑒 𝑆 𝐾 𝐾 𝑆* (by (E.14))
##### =𝑒 𝑆 =𝑒 𝑆.
OA-96
Hence, *𝜀* *𝑃 𝜀𝑃𝑐𝑡* *𝑅* *𝑝𝑡* =*𝑒 𝑆𝑝𝑡* *𝜀* *𝑃𝜀 𝑐* *𝑅* *𝑝𝑡𝑒* *𝑃 𝑡𝑆* *𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑝𝑡* Í =⇒ Í *𝜀* *𝑃* = *𝜀 𝑐* Í = =*𝜎𝑝𝑡,*(*𝑘𝑆𝑘𝑡*=*𝑆𝑡*) *𝑅 𝑒* *𝑃 𝑡* *𝑘𝑆𝑘𝑡𝑆𝑡* *𝑘 𝑘𝑡*
which is the share equation ofTheorem E.2, whatever the value of*𝑐𝑡*. *Nothing else works.*Conversely, let *𝜓𝑝𝑡>*0 satisfy that share equation. Then *𝜀* *𝑃* Í*𝜀* *𝑃* Í*𝜀* *𝑃* *𝑅* *𝑝𝑡* =*𝜎𝑝𝑡 𝑘𝑅* *𝑘𝑡* =(*𝑆𝑝𝑡*/*𝑆𝑡*)*𝑘𝑅* *𝑘𝑡*, and solving (E.3) for the fundamental in logarithms,
ln*𝜓𝑝𝑡*=ln*𝑅𝑝𝑡*−*𝜂*ln*𝐾𝑝𝑡*+*𝛾*ln*𝑆𝑝𝑡* (by (E.3)) <u>𝑆𝑝𝑡</u>Õ *𝜀* = *𝜀* <u>1</u> ln *𝑅* *𝑘𝑡* *𝑃* −*𝜂*ln*𝐾𝑝𝑡*+*𝛾*ln*𝑆𝑝𝑡* (the share equation) *𝑃𝑆* *𝑡* *𝑘* <u>1+𝛾𝜀𝑃</u> <u>1</u> Õ *𝜀* *𝑃* = ln*𝑆𝑝𝑡*−*𝜂*ln*𝐾𝑝𝑡*+ *𝜀* ln *𝑅* *𝑘𝑡* /*𝑆𝑡,* *𝜀𝑃𝑃* *𝑘* <u>1</u> Í*𝜀* *𝑃* which is (E.14) with *𝑐𝑡*= *𝜀* ln*𝑘𝑅* *𝑘𝑡* /*𝑆𝑡*, the same number for every parish of the *𝑃* ′ decade. Two constants thus give fundamentals differing by the common factor *𝑒* *𝑐* *𝑡* −*𝑐* *𝑡*, which is the scale per decade.
The fit of the model in levels thus tests nothing. What identifies *𝛽𝑃*is how a parish’s share moves when a coffeehouse arrives and its neighbors’ do not, the fundamentals held fixed.
Corollary E.2(Inversion in *𝛽𝑃*).*In terms of 𝜓*˜*𝑝𝑡, the shares, and access in share form,* *Theorem E.6reads* <u>𝜀𝑃𝑐𝑡</u> ln*𝜓*˜*𝑝𝑡*=ln*𝜎𝑝𝑡*−*𝛽𝑃*ln*𝜅𝑝𝑡*(*𝝈𝑡*)+ *𝑐*˜*𝑡, 𝑐*˜*𝑡*=(1−*𝛽𝑃*)ln*𝑆𝑡*+*,* 1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃*
##### with 𝑐˜𝑡common to all parishes.
*Proof.*ByTheorem E.6, with*𝑆𝑝𝑡*=*𝜎𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑡*and*𝐾𝑝𝑡*=*𝑆𝑡𝜅𝑝𝑡*(*𝝈𝑡*)fromLemma E.1,
<u>𝜀𝑃</u> ln*𝜓*˜*𝑝𝑡*= ln*𝜓𝑝𝑡* 1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃* <u>𝜀𝑃𝜂 𝜀𝑃𝑐𝑡</u> =ln*𝑆𝑝𝑡*− ln*𝐾𝑝𝑡*+ 1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃*1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃* <u>𝜀𝑃𝑐𝑡</u> =ln*𝜎𝑝𝑡*+ln*𝑆𝑡*−*𝛽𝑃*ln*𝑆𝑡*+ln*𝜅𝑝𝑡*(*𝝈𝑡*) + 1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃* <u>𝜀𝑃𝑐𝑡</u> =ln*𝜎𝑝𝑡*−*𝛽𝑃*ln*𝜅𝑝𝑡*(*𝝈𝑡*)+(1−*𝛽𝑃*)ln*𝑆𝑡*+ 1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃* =ln*𝜎𝑝𝑡*−*𝛽𝑃*ln*𝜅𝑝𝑡*(*𝝈𝑡*)+ *𝑐*˜*𝑡.*
E.7.Equilibrium in Changes
A counterfactual is a second geography *𝑫* ′ =(*𝐷* *𝑝𝑡* ′ ) with the same fundamentals *𝜓𝑝𝑡*
and *𝑢* and the same pool *𝐿*. When *𝛽𝑃<*1 its equilibrium exists and is unique, the
OA-97
shares byTheorem E.5and the total byTheorem E.4, so we can introduce the following notation: b*𝑥*=*𝑥* ′ /*𝑥*is the ratio of a counterfactual value to its observed value.
Definition E.6(Baseline access shares).Given (*𝜙,𝛿*) and an observed equilibrium, we define the baseline access share of parish*𝑞*in the access of parish*𝑝*as
*𝑒* −*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞* *𝑚𝑞𝑡𝑆𝑞𝑡* *𝜔𝑝𝑞𝑡*= Í*.*(E.15) *𝑒* −*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑘* *𝑚 𝑆* *𝑘 𝑘𝑡 𝑘𝑡*
Í Theorem E.7(Access in changes). *𝐾*b*𝑝𝑡*= *𝑚*b*𝑝𝑡 𝑞𝜔𝑝𝑞𝑡𝑚*b*𝑞𝑡𝑆*b*𝑞𝑡.*
*Proof.*We have
′ ′ Í −*𝛿𝑑* ′ ′ *𝐾* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> *𝑚* <u>𝑝𝑡 𝑞</u> *𝑒* *𝑝𝑞* *𝑚* <u>𝑞𝑡</u> *𝑆* <u>𝑞𝑡</u> *𝐾* b *𝑝𝑡*= = Í *𝐾𝑝𝑡 𝑚* *𝑝𝑡 𝑘𝑒* −*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑘* *𝑚𝑘𝑡𝑆𝑘𝑡*
*𝑚* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> ′ Õ *𝑒* −*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞* *𝑚* *𝑞𝑡* ′ *𝑆* ′ *𝑞𝑡* = Í *𝑚𝑝𝑡* *𝑘𝑒* −*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑘* *𝑚𝑘𝑡𝑆𝑘𝑡* *𝑞* *𝑚* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> ′ Õ *𝑒*−*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑞𝑚* *𝑞𝑡𝑆𝑞𝑡* *𝑚* <u>𝑞𝑡</u> ′ *𝑆* ′ <u>𝑞𝑡</u> = Í · *𝑚𝑝𝑡* *𝑘𝑒* −*𝛿𝑑𝑝𝑘* *𝑚𝑘𝑡𝑆𝑘𝑡𝑚𝑞𝑡𝑆𝑞𝑡* *𝑞* Õ = *𝑚*b*𝑝𝑡𝜔𝑝𝑞𝑡𝑚*b*𝑞𝑡𝑆*b*𝑞𝑡.* *𝑞*
Theorem E.8(Exact hat and sufficiency).*In a counterfactual,*
b *𝜀* *𝑃* Õ *𝑅* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> *𝐾* b *𝑝𝑡*= *𝑚*b*𝑝𝑡𝜔𝑝𝑞𝑡𝑚*b*𝑞𝑡𝑆* b *𝑞𝑡, 𝑅* b *𝑝𝑡*= *𝐾* b *𝑝𝑡* *𝑆* b *𝑝𝑡* *,* b*𝜎𝑝𝑡*= Í*,* *𝜂* −*𝛾* *𝜎𝑘𝑡𝑅*b *𝜀* *𝑃* *𝑞 𝑘 𝑘𝑡*
<u>𝑉</u> b <u>𝑡</u> *𝑆* *𝜀* *𝑆* b *𝑡*=*, 𝑆* b *𝑝𝑡*= b*𝜎𝑝𝑡𝑆* b *𝑡* *,* b *𝜀* *𝑆* (1−*𝜋𝑡*)+*𝜋𝑡𝑉* *𝑡*
b *𝜀* *𝑃* Í b *𝜀* *𝑃* *with 𝑉* *𝑡* =*𝑘𝜎𝑘𝑡𝑅* *𝑘𝑡* *. No level of 𝜓 or 𝑢 is needed, and 𝐿 enters only through 𝜋𝑡. The* *fundamental is absent from 𝑅*b*𝑝𝑡because it is held fixed and enters the return multiplicatively,*
′*𝜂* ′−*𝛾* *𝜓𝑝𝑡𝐾* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> *𝑆* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> *𝑅* b *𝑝𝑡*=*𝜂* −*𝛾*= *𝐾* b *𝑝𝑡* *𝑆* b *𝑝𝑡* *.* *𝜂* −*𝛾* *𝜓𝑝𝑡𝐾* *𝑝𝑡* *𝑆* *𝑝𝑡*
*Moreover, whatever the value of𝜋𝑡, the counterfactual shares solve*
*𝛽* *𝑃* b*𝜅* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> Õ b*𝜎𝑝𝑡*= Í *,* b*𝜅𝑝𝑡*= *𝑚*b*𝑝𝑡𝜔𝑝𝑞𝑡𝑚*b*𝑞𝑡*b*𝜎𝑞𝑡,* *𝛽* *𝑃* *𝑘𝜎𝑘𝑡*b*𝜅𝑘𝑡 𝑞*
##### in which(𝜂,𝛾,𝜀𝑃)appear only through𝛽𝑃.
OA-98
*Proof.* Access isTheorem E.7, and the return ratio is the display. For the shares, dividing the two Fréchet share equations ofTheorem E.2,
′ ′*𝜀𝑃* Í′*𝜀* *𝑃* *𝜎* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> *𝑅* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> /<u>𝑘</u>*𝑅* <u>𝑘𝑡</u> b*𝜎𝑝𝑡*= = *𝜀* *𝑃* Í*𝜀* *𝑃* *𝜎𝑝𝑡 𝑅* / *𝑘𝑅* *𝑝𝑡 𝑘𝑡* *𝑅* b *𝑝𝑡* *𝑃* *𝜀* = Í ′*𝜀𝑃*Í*𝜀𝑃* *𝑘𝑅𝑘𝑡*/*𝑘𝑅𝑘𝑡* *𝑅* b *𝑝𝑡* *𝑃* *𝑅* b <u>𝑝𝑡</u> *𝑃* *𝜀 𝜀* = Í Í = Í*,* *𝜀* *𝑃𝜀𝑃*b*𝜀𝑃*b*𝜀𝑃* *𝑘𝑅𝑘𝑡*/*𝑞𝑅𝑞𝑡𝑅𝑘𝑡 𝑘𝜎𝑘𝑡𝑅𝑘𝑡*
b *𝜀* *𝑃*′*𝜀𝑃𝜀𝑃* Í′*𝜀* *𝑃* Í*𝜀* *𝑃* and the denominator is *𝑉* *𝑡* =*𝑉* <u>𝑡</u> /*𝑉* *𝑡* =*𝑘𝑅* *𝑘𝑡* /*𝑘𝑅* *𝑘𝑡*. For the total, with *𝜋𝑡*= *𝜀* *𝑆𝜀𝑆𝜀𝑆* *𝑉* *𝑡* /(*𝑢* +*𝑉* *𝑡* )from (E.8) and *𝑢, 𝐿*unchanged,
′ ′*𝜀𝑆𝜀𝑆*′*𝜀𝑆* <u>𝑆</u> <u>𝑡</u> <u>𝐿𝑉</u> <u>𝑡</u> <u>/(𝑢 +𝑉</u> <u>𝑡</u> <u>)</u> *𝑆* b *𝑡*= = *𝑆𝑡𝐿𝑉𝜀𝑆*/(*𝑢𝜀𝑆*+*𝑉𝜀𝑆*) *𝑡 𝑡* *𝜀* *𝑆𝜀𝑆* b *𝜀* *𝑆* *𝑢* +*𝑉* *𝑡* = *𝑉* *𝑡 𝜀𝑆𝜀𝑆* b *𝜀* *𝑆* *𝑢* +*𝑉* *𝑡* *𝑉* *𝑡* *𝑉* b *𝑡* *𝑆* *𝜀* =*.* b *𝜀* *𝑆* (1−*𝜋𝑡*)+*𝜋𝑡𝑉* *𝑡*
For sufficiency, byLemma E.1 *𝐾*b*𝑝𝑡*= *𝑆*b*𝑡*b*𝜅𝑝𝑡*with Õ b*𝜅𝑝𝑡*=*𝜅𝑝𝑡*(*𝝈* *𝑡* ′ )/*𝜅𝑝𝑡*(*𝝈𝑡*)= *𝑚*b*𝑝𝑡𝜔𝑝𝑞𝑡𝑚*b*𝑞𝑡*b*𝜎𝑞𝑡* *𝑞*
(the computation ofTheorem E.7with*𝜎*in place of*𝑆*), and *𝑆*b*𝑝𝑡*= b*𝜎𝑝𝑡𝑆*b*𝑡*, so
*𝑅* b *𝑝𝑡*= *𝑆* b *𝑡* b*𝜅𝑝𝑡*b*𝜎𝑝𝑡𝑆*b*𝑡*= b*𝜅* *𝑝𝑡* b*𝜎* *𝑝𝑡* *𝑆* b *𝑡* *𝜂* −*𝛾 𝜂* −*𝛾 𝜂*−*𝛾*
*𝜂𝜀𝑃*−*𝛾𝜀𝑃* b (*𝜂*−*𝛾*)*𝜀𝑃𝜂𝜀𝑃*−*𝛾𝜀𝑃* b*𝜅* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> b*𝜎* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> *𝑆* <u>𝑡</u> b*𝜅* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> b*𝜎* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> Õ *𝜂𝜀𝑃*−*𝛾𝜀𝑃* =⇒ b*𝜎𝑝𝑡*= Í =*, 𝐵𝑡*= *𝜎𝑘𝑡*b*𝜅* *𝑘𝑡* b*𝜎* *𝑘𝑡* *𝜂𝜀𝑃*−*𝛾𝜀𝑃* b (*𝜂*−*𝛾*)*𝜀𝑃 𝐵* *𝑡* *𝑘𝜎𝑘𝑡*b*𝜅𝑘𝑡*b*𝜎𝑘𝑡𝑆𝑡 𝑘* *𝜂𝜀𝑃* b*𝜅* <u>𝑝𝑡</u> 1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃* =⇒ b*𝜎* *𝑝𝑡* = *𝐵𝑡* *𝛽* *𝑃*−1/(1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃*) =⇒ b*𝜎𝑝𝑡*=*𝐴* b*𝜅* *𝑝𝑡* *, 𝐴*=*𝐵* *𝑡* *.*(*𝜂𝜀𝑃*/(1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃*)=*𝛽𝑃*)
Thus, using that the shares sum to one in both worlds,
##### Õ Õ
<u>1</u> *𝛽* *𝑃* 1= *𝜎𝑘𝑡*b*𝜎𝑘𝑡*=*𝐴 𝜎𝑘𝑡*b*𝜅* *𝑘𝑡* =⇒*𝐴*= Í *.* *𝛽* *𝑃* *𝑘 𝑘 𝑘𝜎𝑘𝑡*b*𝜅𝑘𝑡*
The system ofTheorem E.8is solved by iterating it from b*𝝈𝑡*=. Its share equation in Í*𝛽* *𝑃* Í logs isln b*𝜎𝑝𝑡*=*𝛽𝑃*lnb*𝜅𝑝𝑡*−ln*𝑘𝜎𝑘𝑡*b*𝜅* *𝑘𝑡*, so substituting b*𝜅𝑝𝑡*= *𝑚*b*𝑝𝑡 𝑞𝜔𝑝𝑞𝑡𝑚*b*𝑞𝑡*b*𝜎𝑞𝑡*, a pass
OA-99
##### in log shares𝑥𝑝=ln b𝜎𝑝𝑡is
##### Õ Õ
| 𝑥 | 𝑞 | 𝛽𝑃 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑝 | 𝑃 𝑝𝑞 | 𝑝𝑞 𝑞 | 𝑝𝑞 𝑝𝑞 | 𝑝𝑡 𝑝𝑞𝑡 | 𝑞𝑡 𝑝 | 𝑃 𝑞 | 𝑘𝑡 𝑘𝑡 𝑘 𝑥𝑞𝑝 | |
| 𝑁 | 𝑁 | 𝑃 | 𝑝 𝑝 | 𝑝 𝑝 | ||||
| 𝑁 |
*𝑥* ↦−→*𝛽* ln *𝑎 𝑒* +*𝑐, 𝑎* = *𝑚*b *𝜔 𝑚*b*, 𝑐*=−ln *𝜎* b*𝜅.*
The weights*𝑎 >*0are fixed, and*𝑐*, the normalization, is the same for every parish.
Í Theorem E.9(Rate of convergence).*Let 𝑎 >*0*, let 𝑇*(*𝒙*) =*𝛽* ln *𝑎𝑝𝑞𝑒* +*𝑐 for* *𝒙*∈R *and constants 𝑐₁,...,𝑐, with 𝛽* ≥0*, and let* sp(*𝒛*)=max *𝑧* −min *𝑧 be the* *span seminorm of𝒛*∈R*. Then*
sp(*𝑇*(*𝒙*)−*𝑇*(*𝒚*))≤*𝛽𝑃*sp(*𝒙*−*𝒚*)*.*
*Proof.* Let *𝒗*=*𝒙*−*𝒚*, *𝑣*=max*𝑞𝑣𝑞*, and <u>𝑣</u> =min*𝑞𝑣𝑞*. Since *𝑒* *𝑥* *𝑞* =*𝑒* *𝑦* *𝑞* *𝑒* *𝑣* *𝑞* and *𝑒* <u>𝑣</u> ≤*𝑒* *𝑣* *𝑞* ≤*𝑒* *𝑣*, Õ Õ Õ <u>𝑣</u> +ln *𝑎𝑝𝑞𝑒* *𝑦* *𝑞* ≤ln *𝑎𝑝𝑞𝑒* *𝑥* *𝑞* ≤ *𝑣*+ln *𝑎𝑝𝑞𝑒* *𝑦* *𝑞* *𝑞 𝑞 𝑞*
| Õ | Õ | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑃 | 𝑝𝑞 𝑥𝑞 | 𝑝𝑞 | 𝑦𝑞 | 𝑃 𝑃 | |||
| 𝑞 | 𝑞 | 𝑃 | 𝑃 |
=⇒*𝑇*(*𝒙*)*𝑝*−*𝑇*(*𝒚*)*𝑝*=*𝛽* ln *𝑎 𝑒* −ln *𝑎 𝑒* ∈[*𝛽* <u>𝑣</u>*,𝛽 𝑣*]
##### =⇒sp 𝑇(𝒙)−𝑇(𝒚) ≤𝛽 (𝑣−<u>𝑣</u>)=𝛽 sp(𝒙−𝒚).
Theorem E.10(The aggregate multiplier).*Take the hat system ofTheorem E.8with* Í*𝛽* *𝑃*1/*𝛽𝑃* *𝛽𝑃<*1*, and let 𝐿*→∞*, so that 𝜋𝑡*→0*. Let 𝑀𝑡*=*𝑘𝜎𝑘𝑡*b*𝜅* *𝑘𝑡* *be the access change* *averaged over London with the observed shares as weights. Then*
ln*𝑉*b*𝑡*=*𝜂*ln(*𝑆*b*𝑡𝑀𝑡*)−*𝛾*ln*𝑆*b*𝑡,*
b b b b *so the aggregate block in changes reads*ln*𝑆𝑡*=*𝛽𝑆*ln*𝐾𝑡with 𝐾𝑡*= *𝑆𝑡𝑀𝑡, and*
<u>𝛽𝑆</u>
| = | ln𝑀 | , | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑡 | 𝑡 | ||
| 𝑆 |
ln*𝑆*b*𝑡 𝑡* 1−*𝛽*
##### with a positive multiplier.
*Proof.* Corollary E.1holds in both equilibria, with the same *𝜓*˜*𝑘𝑡*since the fundamentals ′ b b are fixed. Its last display is *𝜅𝑡*/*𝜅𝑡*=*𝑀𝑡*, so *𝐾𝑡*= *𝑆𝑡𝑀𝑡*, and its first display in ratios is
b b b b b ln*𝑉𝑡*=*𝜂*ln*𝐾𝑡*−*𝛾*ln*𝑆𝑡*=*𝜂*ln(*𝑆𝑡𝑀𝑡*)−*𝛾*ln*𝑆𝑡,*
which is the first display. As *𝐿*→ ∞, *𝜋𝑡*→0 and the total ofTheorem E.8is
OA-100
ln*𝑆*b*𝑡*=*𝜀𝑆*ln*𝑉*b*𝑡*, so
ln*𝑆*b*𝑡*=*𝜀𝑆𝜂*ln(*𝑆*b*𝑡𝑀𝑡*)−*𝜀𝑆𝛾*ln*𝑆*b*𝑡*
b b =⇒ (1+*𝛾𝜀𝑆*)ln*𝑆𝑡*=*𝜀𝑆𝜂*ln*𝐾𝑡*
b b b =⇒ln*𝑆𝑡*=*𝛽𝑆*ln*𝐾𝑡*=*𝛽𝑆*ln*𝑆𝑡*+ln*𝑀𝑡*
=⇒ (1−*𝛽𝑆*)ln*𝑆*b*𝑡*=*𝛽𝑆*ln*𝑀𝑡* <u>𝛽𝑆</u> =⇒ln*𝑆*b*𝑡*= ln*𝑀𝑡.* 1−*𝛽𝑆*
The division by 1−*𝛽𝑆*is legitimate and the multiplier positive because *𝛽𝑆*≤*𝛽𝑃<*1.
E.8.Relocation and Creation
The change in a parish’s count from a counterfactual to the observed equilibrium, *𝑆𝑝𝑡*−*𝑆* ′ *𝑝𝑡*, splits, as in the decomposition ofBennet(1920, p. 457), into relocation, the change in its share at the average total, and creation, its average share of the change in the total.
Theorem E.11(Relocation and creation).*Let 𝑆*
| = (𝑆 | +𝑆 ) and 𝜎 | = | (𝜎 +𝜎 | ). | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑡 | 12 𝑡 | 𝑡′ | 𝑝𝑡 21 | 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 ′ | |
| 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 relocation | 𝑝𝑡 ′ | 𝑝𝑡 𝑡 creation 𝑡 | 𝑡′ 𝑡′ |
*Then* *𝑆𝑝𝑡*−*𝑆* ′ *𝑝𝑡* = *𝑆* (*𝜎* −*𝜎*) +*𝜎* (*𝑆* −*𝑆*)*,*(E.16) | {z} | {z}
*the first term summing to zero over𝑝and the second to𝑆* −*𝑆.*
*Proof.*Expanding the products,
| 𝑆 (𝜎 | −𝜎 )+ 𝜎 | (𝑆 −𝑆 | (𝑆 +𝑆 | )(𝜎 −𝜎 | )+ (𝜎 | +𝜎 | )(𝑆 −𝑆 | ) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 ′ | 𝑝𝑡 𝑡 | 12 𝑡 12 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 𝑝𝑡 𝑡 | 𝑡′ 𝑝𝑡 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 ′ 𝑝𝑡 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 ′ 𝑡′ | 𝑝𝑡 ′ 21 𝑡′ 𝑝𝑡 𝑝𝑡 𝑡′ 𝑝𝑡 ′ 𝑝𝑡 ′𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 𝑝𝑡 ′ 𝑡′ 𝑝𝑡 ′ 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 ′ | 𝑡 𝑡′ | 𝑡′ |
*𝑡* ′ )=
= *𝑆 𝜎* −*𝑆 𝜎* +*𝑆 𝜎* −*𝑆 𝜎*
+*𝜎 𝑆* −*𝜎 𝑆* +*𝜎 𝑆* −*𝜎 𝑆*
=*𝜎 𝑆* −*𝜎 𝑆* =*𝑆* −*𝑆,*
and Õ
| 𝑆 (𝜎 | )= 𝑆 −𝜎 | (1−1)=0, | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 𝑝 | 𝑝𝑡 ′ | 𝑡 | ||
| 𝑝𝑡 𝑝 | 𝑡 𝑡′ | 21 | 𝑡 𝑡′ | 𝑡 𝑡′ |
Õ *𝜎* (*𝑆* −*𝑆*)= (1+1)(*𝑆* −*𝑆*)=*𝑆* −*𝑆.*
E.9.Estimation, Simulation, and the Aggregate Effect
Procedure E.1uses the 244 mathematical practitioners ofTaylor(1954) and the connec- tions among them documented there and in the Six Degrees of Francis Bacon database (Warren et al.,2016). FromProcedure E.2on,*𝑆𝑝𝑡*counts those244completed with the scientific instrument makers found by later research, the 252 ofClifton(1995) andHay et al.(2025), 93 of whom are already among the practitioners, so 403 applied scientists
OA-101
in all (Appendix D.3). They make 797 scientist-decades in 1650–1690, each scientist counted in every decade they were active, 458 of them in parishes that had a coffeehouse by then.
Procedure E.1(Access,(*𝜙,𝛿*)).ByTheorem E.1, in logs,
E[*𝑇𝑝𝑞*+ln*𝑆𝑝𝑡*+ln*𝑆𝑞𝑡,*(E.17)
| ]=exp ln𝜒𝜌 | +𝜙(𝐷 | +𝐷 )−𝛿𝑑 |
|---|---|---|
| 𝑝𝑞𝑡 | 𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 𝑞𝑡 |
| 𝑡 | 𝑡 |
which is (5) with *𝜇* =ln*𝜒𝜌*. The parameters of this conditional mean are con- sistently estimated by Poisson pseudo-maximum likelihood. The documented connections are undated, so in estimation the mean is summed over the decades in which both practitioners are active, in the parishes where each works in that decade, and the likelihood is evaluated on person dyads, which puts the decade terms inside that sum, one free term per decade. Practitioners with two parishes in a decade count in both, as in the outcomes, and pairs within a parish enter at *𝑑𝑝𝑝*. The sample is the 14*,*686 pairs of practitioners active in a London parish in a common decade, 423 of them connected, and standard errors come from 200 bootstrap samples that redraw practitioners, so that pairs sharing a practitioner are drawn together.
Procedure E.2(The share elasticity,*𝛽𝑃*).Indirect inference, in three steps.
1. Run the event study on the observed counts. This gives the post-treatment
coefficients b*𝝉*=(b₀*𝜏,*b₁*𝜏,...,*b₄*𝜏*) and their standard errors se(b₀*𝜏*)*,...,*se(b₄*𝜏*). The
pre-treatment coefficients are not matched, as they are checks on the design.
2. For a trial *𝛽𝑃*, build the panel the model implies at the observed geography and run step 1 on it:
(a) *Fundamentals.*The fundamentals are taken as time-invariant, *𝜓*˜*𝑝𝑡*= *𝜓*˜*𝑝*. For the trial *𝛽𝑃*, recover *𝜓*˜*𝑝*from the pre-coffeehouse decades 1600–1640
˜ pre pre pre byCorollary E.2, ln*𝜓𝑝*=ln*𝜎𝑝*−*𝛽𝑃*ln*𝜅𝑝*+ *𝑐*˜ with *𝑐*˜=0, where *𝜎𝑝*= Í Í <u>1</u> *𝜆𝑝*/*𝑘𝜆𝑘*is the pre-period share, *𝜆𝑝*=*𝑡*≤1640*𝑆𝑝𝑡*+ 2 /5 the count per decade smoothed by one half, which keeps the parishes with nobody recorded before 1650 from being held at a zero share by construction, and pre 83 *𝜅𝑝*the access these shares imply without coffeehouses (*𝑚𝑝𝑡*=1).
(b) *Counts.*For each decade *𝑡*=1600*,...,*1690, with the observed indi- cators *𝐷*
| , the fixed 𝜓˜ | , and the trial 𝛽 | , solve the share block: with | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝 | 𝑃 | |||||
| 𝑝𝑡 −𝛿𝑑 | 𝑝𝑞𝑞𝑡 | 𝑞 𝑝𝑡 𝑃 | 𝑡 𝑝𝑡 𝑃 𝑡 | 𝑡 𝛽𝑃 𝑝 𝑝𝑡 𝛽𝑃 𝑘 𝑘 𝑘𝑡 𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 𝑡 | 𝑞 𝑝𝑞𝑡 | 𝛽 𝑞𝑡𝑃 |
| 𝑃 | |||||||
| 𝑝𝑡 𝑃 | 𝑡 |
Í *𝑄𝑝𝑞𝑡*=*𝑚 𝑒 𝑚 𝜓*˜, that is, (E.13) at *𝐶* =1, iterate *𝜅* ← *𝑄 𝜅* in logarithms from any start until it stops changing (Theorem E.5). The shares are (E.12), and since solving at *𝐶* =1 only rescales *𝜿* (Theorem E.5), they are *𝜓* ˜ *𝜅* *𝜎* (*𝛽*)= Í *.* *𝜓* ˜ *𝜅*
The model’s count is*𝜎* (*𝛽*)*𝑆* with*𝑆* the observed London total.
(c) *Coefficients.*Let *𝝉*(*𝛽*) denote the post-treatment coefficients of step 1 on the panel*𝜎* (*𝛽*)*𝑆*.
OA-102
3.Estimate
| 4 | 2 | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| ℓ | ℓ 𝑃 | ||
| 𝛽𝑃∈[0,0.999] | ℓ=0 | ℓ | |
| 𝑃 |
Õ <u>b𝜏 −𝜏 (𝛽)</u> *𝛽* c *𝑃*=arg min*,*(E.18) se(b*𝜏*)
by running step 2 once per trial value of *𝛽*.Figure E1shows the estimated coefficients and the model’s at the estimate. The weighting is diagonal so that the estimate fits the five coefficients themselves rather than the contrasts between them that the inverse covariance weights.
*𝛽𝑆*is not identified within London. ByTheorem E.3it enters the model only through the total *𝑆𝑡*, and *𝑆𝑡*enters the share block only through *𝑐𝑡*, which is common to all parishes, so no within-London contrast depends on it. It is bounded,0*< 𝛽𝑆*≤*𝛽𝑃*. Yet, it can be calibrated to the aggregate margin, in two designs, each resting on one of the following lemmas.
Lemma E.9(The aggregate margin).*Let 𝜃*=*𝛽𝑆*/(1−*𝛽𝑆*)*, so that* ln*𝑆*b*𝑡*=*𝜃*ln*𝑀𝑡by* *Theorem E.10.*
| 𝑘𝑡 𝜙 | 𝑡 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑘 𝑘𝑡 | 𝑘𝑡 𝜙𝛽𝑃1/𝛽𝑃 | 𝑘 𝑘𝑡 𝑘 𝜙 | 𝑡 | 𝑘 𝑘 𝜙 | |
| 𝑘𝑡 𝑘 | 𝑡 | ||||
| 𝑡 𝛽 1𝑃 | 𝑘 𝑘𝑡 𝛽𝑃𝑢𝑘 | 𝑘𝑡 | |||
| 𝛽𝑃Í𝑘𝜎𝑘𝑡𝑢𝑘 | 𝑘𝑡 𝛽𝑃 𝑘 | 𝑢𝑘𝛽𝑃max | 𝑘𝑢𝑘 𝑘 | 𝑘𝑡 𝛽𝑃max | 𝑘𝑢𝑘 |
*(a)*A uniform shock.*If* b*𝜅* =*𝑒² for every parish𝑘, then*ln*𝑆*b =2*𝜙𝜃.*
Í
*(b)*The bracket.*With𝑢𝑘*=lnb*𝜅, 𝜎 𝑢* ≤ln*𝑀* ≤max *𝑢.*
Í *Proof.*(a) Since *𝜎* =1,
Õ *𝑀𝑡*= *𝜎 𝑒²* =*𝑒²* =⇒ln*𝑆*b =*𝜃*ln*𝑒²* =2*𝜙𝜃.*
Í
(b) Writeln*𝑀* = ln *𝜎 𝑒*. Since the weights*𝜎* sum to one,
##### Õ Õ
*𝑒* ≤ *𝜎 𝑒* ≤*𝑒 𝜎* =*𝑒,*
where the lower-end inequality follows from Jensen’s inequality for the convex function *𝑒* *𝑧* and the upper-end one from *𝑒* *𝛽* *𝑃* *𝑢𝑘* ≤*𝑒* *𝛽* *𝑃*max*𝑞𝑢𝑞* for every *𝑘*. Taking logarithms and dividing by*𝛽𝑃>*0gives the bracket.
Lemma E.10(The aggregate margin against a control).*Let 𝑆* *𝑡* ′ *be the total with the* *coffeehouses of decade 𝑡 removed, so that 𝑆*b*𝑡*=*𝑆* *𝑡* ′ /*𝑆𝑡, and let 𝑎𝑡*=−ln*𝑀𝑡be the access* *lost. Let 𝑆𝑅𝑡be a control series that moves with the same fundamentals up to a linear trend,* −ln*𝑆𝑅𝑡 𝑡 𝑡 𝑡 𝑡*−1
| ln𝑆 | =𝜇₀ +𝜇₁𝑡+𝑒 | , with𝑡counted in decades. Then, withΔ𝑥 | =𝑥 −𝑥 | , | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑡′ | 𝑅𝑡 | 𝑡 | 𝑡 | 𝑡 | 𝑡−1 | |||||
| 83The weight of one half matters for 𝛽 and 1, but hardly for the aggregate effect ofProcedure E.4, 242 to 246 of the 797 scientist-decades at 𝛽𝑆=0.39, with 173 to 189 of them in the parishes that had a coffeehouse by the decade. At weight 0, 𝛽 | 𝑡 | 𝑘 𝑘𝑡 | 𝑘𝑡 | 𝑡 𝑅𝑡 𝑃, which is 0.390, 0.485, 0.560, and 0.670 at weights 0, 1/4, 1/2, | 𝑡 | 𝑡 𝑘𝑡 | ||||
| also falls below the instrument makers’𝛽 | 𝑆=0.43ofProcedure E.3, which𝜀 | 𝑆≤𝜀𝑃rules out. |
<u>𝑆</u> Δln =*𝜃*Δ*𝑎* +*𝜇₁* +Δ*𝑒,* *𝑆* Í *and*0≤*𝑎* ≤− *𝜎* lnb*𝜅 when no parish gains access,* b*𝜅* ≤1*for every𝑘.*
*𝑃*
OA-103
*Proof.*ByLemma E.9,ln*𝑆* *𝑡* ′ −ln*𝑆𝑡*=*𝜃*ln*𝑀𝑡*=−*𝜃𝑎𝑡*, so
ln*𝑆𝑡*−ln*𝑆𝑅𝑡*=ln*𝑆* *𝑡* ′ +*𝜃𝑎𝑡*−ln*𝑆𝑅𝑡*=*𝜇₀* +*𝜇₁𝑡*+*𝜃𝑎𝑡*+*𝑒𝑡,* <u>𝑆𝑡</u> Δln =*𝜃*Δ*𝑎𝑡*+*𝜇₁*(*𝑡*−(*𝑡*−1))+Δ*𝑒𝑡*=*𝜃*Δ*𝑎𝑡*+*𝜇₁* +Δ*𝑒𝑡.* *𝑆𝑅𝑡*
For the bounds, with *𝑢𝑘*=lnb*𝜅𝑘𝑡*as inLemma E.9(b), every *𝑢𝑘*≤0 when no parish gains access. Multiplying the bracket ofLemma E.9(b) by −1 reverses its inequalities, and −max*𝑘𝑢𝑘*≥0because every*𝑢𝑘*≤0, so Õ 0≤−max*𝑢𝑘*≤*𝑎𝑡*≤− *𝜎𝑘𝑡𝑢𝑘.* *𝑘* *𝑘*
Procedure E.3(The aggregate margin, *𝛽𝑆*).Both designs read the aggregate response off the European panel ofSection 6, 200 cities of 10*,*000 or more inhabitants in 1600 over 1600–1690, 37 of them with a coffeehouse before 1700, the outcome the count of applied mathematics titles printed in the city (the Universal Short Title Catalogue) or of scientific instrument makers active there (Webster and Webster,2007).
1. *Cities.*A city whose applied scientists do not move to other cities is the economy ofTheorem E.10. Its first coffeehouse, read as reaching the whole city, is *𝑚*b*𝑘𝑡*=*𝑒*
*𝜙*
in every parish, so byTheorem E.8 b*𝜅𝑘𝑡*=*𝑒²* *𝜙* for every *𝑘* and the shares do not move, and byLemma E.9(a) it raises the city’s log count by 2*𝜙𝜃*. We estimate this rise inSection 6as ln(1+*𝑏*/base), with *𝑏* the mean post-entry effect over event times 0 to 3 and base the treated cities’ mean count in the decade before entry, so *𝜃*=ln(1+*𝑏*/base)/(2*𝜙*) and *𝛽𝑆*=*𝜃*/(1+*𝜃*). Titles give *𝛽𝑆*=0*.*35 (s.e. 0*.*12) and instrument makers *𝛽𝑆*=0*.*43 (0*.*15), with parametric-bootstrap standard errors over*𝑏*and *𝜙*b. 84
2. *London against the other European cities.*Removing London’s coffeehouses in
| 𝑝𝑡 | −𝜙𝐷𝑝𝑡 | 𝑝𝑡 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝑡 | ||||||
| 𝑃 | ||||||
| 𝑅𝑡 | 𝑡 | |||||
| 𝐿𝑡 | 𝑅𝑡 | 𝐿𝑡 | 𝑡 | |||
| 𝑆 | 𝑆 | 𝑆 |
decade *𝑡* is *𝑚*b =*𝑒*. The share system ofTheorem E.8then gives b*𝜅*, which is below one in every parish and decade, and *𝑎* follows at the observed counts and shares, (*𝜙*b*,* b*𝛿*), and *𝛽*. With the sum over the other 199 cities as the control *𝑆*,Lemma E.10makes *𝜃* the coefficient of Δ*𝑎* in the least-squares regression of Δln(*𝑆* /*𝑆*), with *𝑆* London’s count in the panel, on Δ*𝑎* and a constant over 1600–1690, nine differences. Titles: *𝜃*=0*.*43 (s.e. 1*.*37), *𝛽* =0*.*30. Instrument makers: *𝜃*=0*.*23 (0*.*67), *𝛽* =0*.*18. In a parametric bootstrap over *𝜃*, *𝛽* has upper ends of 0*.*76 and 0*.*61 and no lower end, since *𝜃*=−1, where *𝜃*/(1+*𝜃*) is unbounded, lies within two standard errors of both estimates. The remaining parameters are not estimated. *𝛾* and *𝜀𝑃*are not identified, since the
data speak to *𝛽𝑃*alone (Corollary E.2). Both can be set from the quantitative urban literature, which measures them in other places and centuries: modern Berlin and
84 The standard error is half the distance between the 16th and 84th percentiles of 20*,*000 draws of *𝑏* and *𝜙* b from normal distributions at their estimates and standard errors, which matches the standard deviation when the draws are normal. The standard deviation itself is not informative here: *𝛽𝑆*=*𝜃*/(1+*𝜃*) is unbounded as *𝜃* approaches −1, and the few draws that come close dominate it. The draws also have heavier tails than a normal distribution, with 2.5th and 97.5th percentiles of 0*.*06 and 0*.*67 for titles and −0*.*20and0*.*75for instrument makers.
OA-104
London give the premises share *𝛾*=0*.*225 and the commuting dispersion *𝜀𝑃*=5 (Ahlfeldt et al.,2015;Heblich et al.,2020), so that *𝜂*=*𝛽𝑃*(1+*𝛾𝜀𝑃*)/*𝜀𝑃*=0*.*238 by (E.4), and postwar American occupational choice gives *𝜀𝑆*between 1*.*5 and 2*.*7, with 2 the base case (Burstein et al.,2019;Galle et al.,2023;Hsieh et al.,2019;Lagakos and Waugh,
2013). The implied *𝛽𝑆*=*𝛽*(2)=0*.*33, and 0*.*27 to 0*.*40 over that range, is a check on the values calibrated inProcedure E.3,0*.*18to0*.*43, not a measurement of*𝛽𝑆*. Procedure E.4(The aggregate effect).With (*𝜙,𝛿*), *𝛽𝑃*, and *𝛽𝑆*in hand, the no- coffeehouse counterfactual is computed decade by decade for 1650–1690, in ratios andfromtheobserveddecadealone,withthefundamentalsheldfixed(TheoremE.8). For one decade:
1.*Baseline.*From the observed counts and geography, the shares*𝜎𝑝𝑡*=*𝑆𝑝𝑡*/*𝑆𝑡*, the
*𝜙*(*𝐷* *𝑝𝑡* ′ −*𝐷𝑝𝑡*) access shares *𝜔𝑝𝑞𝑡*ofDefinition E.6, and the treatment ratios *𝑚*b*𝑝𝑡*=*𝑒*, here *𝑚*b*𝑝𝑡*=*𝑒* −*𝜙𝐷𝑝𝑡* since every coffeehouse is removed (*𝐷* *𝑝𝑡* ′ =0). Parishes with *𝑆𝑝𝑡*=0stay at zero.
2. *Shares.*Solve the share system ofTheorem E.8for b*𝜎𝑝𝑡*and b*𝜅𝑝𝑡*by iterating it from b*𝝈𝑡*=1 until nothing changes. ByTheorem E.9each pass contracts the error by *𝛽𝑃*, and the solution is the unique one ofTheorem E.5applied to the kernel *𝑚*b*𝑝𝑡𝜔𝑝𝑞𝑡𝑚*b*𝑞𝑡*.
b <u>𝛽</u> <u>𝑆</u>
3.*Total.*ln*𝑆𝑡*=
1−*𝛽* ln*𝑀𝑡*byTheorem E.10. *𝑆*
4. *Counts.*The counterfactual count is the observed count times its ratio, *𝑆*
′ *𝑝𝑡* =
*𝑆* b *𝑝𝑡𝑆𝑝𝑡*with *𝑆* b *𝑝𝑡*= b*𝜎𝑝𝑡𝑆* b *𝑡*(Theorem E.8), and the decade’s aggregate effect is Í ′ *𝑝*(*𝑆𝑝𝑡*−*𝑆𝑝𝑡*).Theorem E.11splits each parish’s change into relocation and creation.
Procedure E.1gives *𝜙*=0*.*554 (s.e. 0*.*20) and *𝛿*=0*.*277 (0*.*12),Procedure E.2 *𝛽𝑃*=0*.*560, andProcedure E.4turns each value of *𝛽𝑆*fromProcedure E.3into the aggregate effect ofTable E1, with *𝛽𝑆*=0 and the bound *𝛽𝑆*=*𝛽𝑃*alongside. We prefer the city estimates for their statistical power: they compare 37 treated cities with 163 never treated, whereas London against the other cities is one series of nine differences, which leaves *𝛽𝑆*without a lower end. Their average, *𝛽𝑆*=0*.*39, is the preferred value. At it the parishes that had a coffeehouse by the decade lose 182 of the 243 scientist-decades and the others a net 61, and coffeehouses account for 46 percent of the rise in the number of applied scientists from the 1640s to the 1690s (40to52at the two city estimates).
OA-105
E.10.Figures
Model at*𝛽𝑃*= 0.560 6
0 (.84)
−5 −4 −3 −2 −1 0 1 2 3 4 Decades since first coffeehouse
Figure E1.The event study and the model at the estimated*𝛽𝑃*
*Notes:* Dots with bars: the coefficients b*ℓ𝜏* of the event study on the observed counts of the combined roster, step 1 ofProcedure E.2, with 95 percent intervals, the decade before entry normalized to zero, drawn as inFigure 4(blue before entry, red after, the treated parishes’ mean count in the decade before entry beside the zero tick). Line with hollow markers: the post-treatment coefficients *𝝉*(*𝛽*c*𝑃*) of the same event
| study on the panel the model implies, step 2, at the estimate 𝛽 | c𝑃=0.560 of (E.18). Only the post-treatment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| coefficients are matched. [Return to pages36,OA-103] |
study on the panel the model implies, step 2, at the estimate *𝛽*c =0*.*560 of (E.18). Only the post-treatment
OA-106
E.11.Tables
Table E1—The aggregate effect of removing every coffeehouse, 1650–1690
| Cities, titles | 0.35 | 212 | 27 | 26 | 74 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cities, makers | 0.43 | 276 | 35 | 21 | 79 |
| Average of the two city estimates | 0.39 | 243 | 31 | 23 | 77 |
| Aggregate effect | Gain of the treated parishes | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 𝛽𝑆 | Count | Percent | Relocation, % | Creation, % | |
| No aggregate response | 0.00 | 0 | 0 | 100 | 0 |
| London against Europe, titles | 0.30 | 172 | 22 | 31 | 69 |
| London against Europe, makers | 0.18 | 96 | 12 | 46 | 54 |
Upper bound,*𝛽𝑆*=*𝛽𝑃*0.56 405 51 14 86
*Notes:* Procedure E.4, the five decades summed, on the combined roster of applied scientists. Count in scientist-decades, percent of the 797 observed. The last two columns take the gain of the parishes that had a coffeehouse by the decade, *𝑆𝑝𝑡*−*𝑆* ′ *𝑝𝑡* summed over those parishes and the five decades, and split it into the relocation and creation terms ofTheorem E.11, summed the same way, each in percent of the gain. Relocation is the part that the counterfactual places in other London parishes, and creation the part it places outside science. *𝛽𝑆*fromProcedure E.3: titles are the applied mathematics titles printed in a city and makers its scientific instrument makers. Light shading marks the two city estimates and dark shading their average, the preferred value. [Return to pages37,OA-105]
OA-107
APPENDIX REFERENCES
Ager, Philipp, Maja U. Pedersen, Paul Sharp, and Xanthi Tsoukli(2025) “Urban Resilience and Reorganization: The Economic Impact of the Great Fire of London,”
10.2139/ssrn.5244098, SSRN Working Paper 5244098. [Referenced on pageOA-24]
Ahlfeldt, Gabriel M., Stephen J. Redding, Daniel M. Sturm, and Nikolaus Wolf(2015) “The Economics of Density: Evidence from the Berlin Wall,”*Econometrica*, 83 (6), 2127–2189. [Referenced on pageOA-105] Albrecht, Peter(1989) “Coffee-Drinking as a Symbol of Social Change in Continental Europe in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,”*Studies in Eighteenth-Century* *Culture*, 18, 91–103. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Almelhem, Ali, Murat Iyigun, Austin Kennedy, and Jared Rubin(2026) “Enlightenment Ideals and Belief in Progress in the Run-up to the Industrial Revolution: A Textual Analysis,”*The Quarterly Journal of Economics*, 141 (1), 263–314, 10.1093/qje/qjaf054. [Referenced on pagesOA-63,OA-81] Baer, William C(2010) “Stuart London’s Standard of Living: Re-Examining the Settlement of Tithes of 1638 for Rents, Income, and Poverty,”*The Economic History* *Review*, 63 (3), 612–637. [Referenced on pageOA-24] Belgrano, Luigi Tommaso(1875)*Della vita privata dei genovesi*, 2nd edition, Genoa: Tipografia del R. Istituto Sordo-Muti. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Bennet, T. L.(1920) “The Theory of Measurement of Changes in Cost of Living,”*Journal* *of the Royal Statistical Society*, 83 (3), 455–462. [Referenced on pageOA-101] Bertoldi, Sylvain(2013) “Le premier café,” Chroniques historiques, Archives munici- pales d’Angers;*Vivre à Angers*, no. 375, https://archives.angers.fr/chronique s-historiques/les-chroniques-par-annees/octobre-2010-decembre-2019/le -premier-cafe. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Betz, G. H.(1900)*Het Haagsche leven in de tweede helft der zeventiende eeuw*, 2nd edition, The Hague: Nijhoff. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Bosker, Maarten, Eltjo Buringh, and Jan Luiten Van Zanden(2013) “From Baghdad to London: Unraveling Urban Development in Europe, the Middle East, and North Africa, 800–1800,”*Review of Economics and Statistics*, 95 (4), 1418–1437. [Referenced on pageOA-63] Brown, James, Connor Plunkett, and Agatha Yates(2021) “Hooked: Robert Hooke’s World of Intoxicants, 1672–83,” https://intoxicatingspaces.org/hooke/, Ac- cessed 27 February 2026. [Referenced on pagesOA-13,OA-58,OA-63] Burn, Jacob Henry(1855)*A Descriptive Catalogue of the London Traders, Tavern, and Coffee-* *House Tokens Current in the Seventeenth Century*, 2nd edition, London: Corporation of the City of London. [Referenced on pagesOA-55,OA-63] Burstein, Ariel, Eduardo Morales, and Jonathan Vogel(2019) “Changes in Between- Group Inequality: Computers, Occupations, and International Trade,”*American* *Economic Journal: Macroeconomics*, 11 (2), 348–400, 10.1257/mac.20170291. [Refer- enced on pageOA-105] Butts, Kyle(2023) “Difference-in-Differences with Spatial Spillovers,” https://arxiv. org/abs/2105.03737, arXiv preprint 2105.03737. [Referenced on pagesOA-8,OA-9, OA-11] Callaway, Brantly, Andrew Goodman-Bacon, and Pedro H. C. Sant’Anna(2026) “Difference-in-Differences with a Continuous Treatment,”*American Economic Review*,
10.1257/aer.20240137, Forthcoming. [Referenced on pageOA-20]
OA-108
Callaway, Brantly and Pedro H. C. Sant’Anna(2021) “Difference-in-Differences with Multiple Time Periods,”*Journal of Econometrics*, 225 (2), 200–230. [Referenced on pagesOA-26,OA-38] deChaisemartin,ClémentandXavierD’Haultfoeuille(2026)“Difference-in-Differences Estimators of Intertemporal Treatment Effects,”*Review of Economics and Statistics*, 108
(4), 863–880,10.1162/rest_a_01414. [Referenced on pagesOA-25,OA-39]
City of London Magistrates(1663) “An accompt of Coffee Houses in the severall wards taken in May 1663,” https://layersoflondon.humap.site/map/records/acco unts-of-coffee-houses-in-several-wards-taken-in-may-1663, Accessed 2 February, 2026. [Referenced on pageOA-72] City of Middelburg(1686) “Placaet, betreffende openingstijden van coffy en brandewi- jnshuysen,” https://www.ustc.ac.uk/editions/1520423, Municipal ordinance of 4 November 1686 setting opening hours for coffee and brandy houses. Universal Short Title Catalogue sn 1520423. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Clark, Gregory and Neil Cummins(2014) “Surnames and Social Mobility in England, 1170–2012,”*Human Nature*, 25, 517–537. [Referenced on pageOA-63] Clark, Peter(2000)*British Clubs and Societies 1580–1800: The Origins of an Associational* *World*, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Referenced on pageOA-5] Clifton,Gloria(1995)*DirectoryofBritishScientificInstrumentMakers,1550–1851*,London: Zwemmer in association with the National Maritime Museum. [Referenced on pages OA-51,OA-52,OA-53,OA-62,OA-66,OA-67,OA-68,OA-80,OA-81,OA-101] Conley, Timothy G(1999) “GMM Estimation with Cross Sectional Dependence,”*Journal* *of Econometrics*, 92 (1), 1–45. [Referenced on pagesOA-9,OA-26,OA-42] Cormack,LesleyB(2017)“MathematicsforSale: MathematicalPractitioners,Instrument Makers, and Communities of Scholars in Sixteenth-Century London,” in Lesley B Cormack, Steven A Walton, and John A Schuster eds.*Mathematical Practitioners and* *the Transformation of Natural Knowledge in Early Modern Europe*, 69–85, Cham: Springer. [Referenced on pagesOA-24,OA-52,OA-68] Cowan, Brian(2004a) “Garraway, Thomas (d. 1692?),” in*Oxford Dictionary of National* *Biography*, Oxford: OxfordUniversityPress, Accessed12September, 2025. [Referenced on pageOA-1] (2004b) “The Rise of the Coffeehouse Reconsidered,”*The Historical Journal*, 47
(1), 21–46. [Referenced on pageOA-2] (2004c) “Urwin, William [Will] (d. 1695),” in*Oxford Dictionary of National* *Biography*, Oxford: OxfordUniversityPress, Accessed12September, 2025. [Referenced on pageOA-1] (2005)*The Social Life of Coffee: The Emergence of the British Coffeehouse*, Yale University Press. [Referenced on pagesOA-2,OA-5,OA-6,OA-72,OA-73] (2014) “Café or Coffeehouse? Transnational Histories of Coffee and Sociability,” in Susanne Schmid and Barbara Schmidt-Haberkamp eds.*Drink in the Eighteenth and* *Nineteenth Centuries*, 35–46, London: Pickering & Chatto. [Referenced on pageOA-61] (2017) “Rosee, Pasqua (*fl.*1651–1656),” in*Oxford Dictionary of National Biography*, Oxford: Oxford University Press, Online edition, first published 2006. Accessed 12 September, 2025. [Referenced on pageOA-1]
Cummins, Neil, Morgan Kelly, and Cormac Ó Gráda(2016) “Living Standards and Plague in London, 1560–1665,”*The Economic History Review*, 69 (1), 3–34. [Referenced on pagesOA-55,OA-57,OA-63]
OA-109
Dasanaike, Noah(2026) “Pre-Trained Language Models as Zero-Shot Tools for Social Science Research,” 10.48550/arXiv.2610.19048, arXiv preprint 2610.19048, which supersedes arXiv:2601.21138. [Referenced on pageOA-25] Denzinger, J.(1848) “Erste Kaffee-Schenke in Würzburg,”*Archiv des historischen Vereines* *von Unterfranken und Aschaffenburg*, 9, 161–162, https://archive.org/details/bu b_gb_q-opAAAAYAAJ. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Ellis, Markman(2004a)*The Coffee-House: A Cultural History*, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson. [Referenced on pagesOA-2,OA-61] (2004b) “Pasqua Rosée’s Coffee-House, 1652–1666,”*The London Journal*, 29 (1), 1–24. [Referenced on pageOA-1] ed. (2006a)*Eighteenth-Century Coffee-House Culture*, Vol. 4, London: Pickering & Chatto. [Referenced on pageOA-5] ed. (2006b)*Eighteenth-Century Coffee-House Culture*, Vol. 1, London: Pickering & Chatto. [Referenced on pageOA-72] Encyclopédie de Genève(1992) “La vie quotidienne,” In*L’art de vivre*, Encyclopédie de Genève; online edition, https://encycloge.org/la-vie-quotidiennejean-pie rre-arn-francoise-blaser-christian-lalive-depinaymaryvonne-maitre-ann e-marie-piuzcatherine-santschi-jean.html. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Evans, Jeremy Lancelotte(2008) “Tompion, Thomas (bap. 1639, d. 1713),” in*Oxford* *Dictionary of National Biography*, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 10.1093/ref: odnb/27527, Online edition, first published 2004. Accessed 29 September, 2026. [Referenced on pageOA-3] FamilySearch(2025) “England Marriages, 1538–1973,” https://www.familysearch.o rg/en/search/collection/1473015, Accessed 2 June, 2025. [Referenced on page OA-63] Fischer, Stefan, Jörg Knappen, Katrin Menzel, and Elke Teich(2020) “The Royal Society Corpus 6.0: Providing 300+ Years of Scientific Writing for Humanistic Study,” in*Proceedings of the Twelfth Language Resources and Evaluation Conference*, 794–802, Marseille: European Language Resources Association. [Referenced on pagesOA-16, OA-62] Galle, Simon, Andrés Rodríguez-Clare, and Moises Yi(2023) “Slicing the Pie: Quanti- fying the Aggregate and Distributional Effects of Trade,”*Review of Economic Studies*, 90 (1), 331–375,10.1093/restud/rdac020. [Referenced on pageOA-105] Gedanopedia(2020) “Kawiarnia Mombera,” https://gdansk.gedanopedia.pl/gdan sk/?title=KAWIARNIA_MOMBERA. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Gingerich, Owen(2002)*An Annotated Census of Copernicus’ De revolutionibus (Nuremberg,* *1543 and Basel, 1566)*, Leiden: Brill. [Referenced on pagesOA-20,OA-21,OA-63] Glaeser, Edward L., Hedi D. Kallal, José A. Scheinkman, and Andrei Shleifer(1992) “Growth in Cities,”*Journal of Political Economy*, 100 (6), 1126–1152. [Referenced on pageOA-90] Goodman-Bacon, Andrew(2021) “Difference-in-Differences with Variation in Treatment Timing,”*Journal of Econometrics*, 225 (2), 254–277. [Referenced on pagesOA-15,OA-19, OA-26,OA-40] Grand-Carteret, John(1902)*L’enseigne: son histoire, sa philosophie, ses particularités,* *les boutiques, les maisons, la rue, la réclame commerciale à Lyon*, Grenoble: Librairie Dauphinoise (H. Falque et F. Perrin). [Referenced on pageOA-61] Harris, Jonathan(2000) “The Grecian Coffee House and Political Debate in London, 1688–1714,”*The London Journal*, 25 (1), 1–13. [Referenced on pageOA-1]
OA-110
Hay, Duncan, Sarah Middle, Alex Butterworth et al.(2025) “Tools of Knowledge Database,” 10.34908/vkmq-hk45. [Referenced on pagesOA-51,OA-52,OA-53,OA-62, OA-68,OA-80,OA-81,OA-101] Heblich, Stephan, Stephen J. Redding, and Daniel M. Sturm(2020) “The Making of the Modern Metropolis: Evidence from London,”*Quarterly Journal of Economics*, 135 (4), 2059–2133. [Referenced on pageOA-105] Heise, Ulla(1987)*Kaffee und Kaffeehaus: Eine Kulturgeschichte*, Hildesheim: Olms. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Hell, Maarten(2017)*DeAmsterdamseherberg1450–1800*, Nijmegen: Vantilt. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Henderson, Felicity(2007) “Unpublished Material from the Memorandum Book of Robert Hooke, Guildhall Library MS 1758,”*Notes and Records of the Royal Society*, 61
(2), 129–175, 10.1098/rsnr.2006.0173. [Referenced on pagesOA-57,OA-58,OA-63]
Hine, Margaret(1976) “Dissenting Chapels in the City of London,” Manuscript, 281 leaves. Guildhall Library, London, shelfmark SL 18. [Referenced on pagesOA-56, OA-63] Hoff, Annette(2016) “Den danske kaffehistorie, 1665–,” danmarkshistorien.dk, Aarhus Universitet; now in Lex: Danmarks Nationalleksikon, https://lex.dk/Den_dansk e_kaffehistorie%2C_1665-. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Hotson, Howard and Miranda Lewis(2024) “Early Modern Letters Online,” http: //emlo.bodleian.ox.ac.uk, Accessed 15 October, 2024. [Referenced on pages OA-57,OA-58,OA-63,OA-76] Houghton, John(1699) “A Discourse of Coffee, Read at a Meeting of the Royal Society,” *Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London*, 21 (256), 311–317. [Referenced on pageOA-5] (1701) “A Collection for the Improvement of Husbandry and Trade,” No. 461, 23 May 1701. [Referenced on pageOA-5] Hsieh, Chang-Tai, Erik Hurst, Charles I. Jones, and Peter J. Klenow(2019) “The Allocation of Talent and U.S. Economic Growth,”*Econometrica*, 87 (5), 1439–1474. [Referenced on pageOA-105] Hunter, Michael(1989)*Establishing the New Science: The Experience of the Early Royal* *Society*, Woodbridge: The Boydell Press. [Referenced on pageOA-4] Iliffe, Rob(1995) “Material Doubts: Hooke, Artisan Culture and the Exchange of Information in 1670s London,”*The British Journal for the History of Science*, 28 (3), 285–318. [Referenced on pageOA-72] Imbens, Guido W and Donald B Rubin(2015)*Causal Inference for Statistics, Social, and* *Biomedical Sciences: An Introduction*, Cambridge University Press. [Referenced on pagesOA-22,OA-28] Isaac, P. C. G., Maureen Bell, and John Hinks(2024) “British Book Trade Index Database,”University of Oxford, Accessed 14 August, 2025. [Referenced on pages OA-53,OA-56,OA-62] Kelly, Morgan and Cormac Ó Gráda(2022) “Connecting the Scientific and Industrial Revolutions: The Role of Practical Mathematics,”*The Journal of Economic History*, 82
(3), 841–873. [Referenced on pagesOA-53,OA-63,OA-81]
Kingman, J. F. C.(1993)*Poisson Processes*, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Referenced on pageOA-90] Kuiken, D. F.(1982) “De koffiehuizen in Groningen, 1686–1808,”*Groningse Volksalmanak*, 1982/83, 21–41. [Referenced on pageOA-61]
OA-111
Lagakos, David and Michael E. Waugh(2013) “Selection, Agriculture, and Cross- Country Productivity Differences,”*American Economic Review*, 103 (2), 948–980. [Referenced on pageOA-105] Leclant, Jean(1951) “Le café et les cafés à Paris (1644–1693),”*Annales. Économies, sociétés,* *civilisations*, 6 (1), 1–14,10.3406/ahess.1951.1900. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Lillywhite, Bryant(1963)*London Coffee Houses: A Reference Book of Coffee Houses of the* *Seventeenth, Eighteenth, and Nineteenth Centuries*, London: George Allen and Unwin. [Referenced on pagesOA-1,OA-3,OA-5,OA-50,OA-62,OA-64,OA-65,OA-67,OA-72, OA-73,OA-74,OA-81] (1972)*London Signs: A Reference Book of London Signs from Earliest Times to About* *the Mid-Nineteenth Century*, London: George Allen and Unwin. [Referenced on pages OA-50,OA-55,OA-56,OA-62,OA-65,OA-67,OA-72,OA-73,OA-74,OA-81] Lombardo, Maria Luisa(2016) “I caffè romani tra storia e cultura,”*Ludica. Annali di* *storia e civiltà del gioco*, 21–22, 63–84,10.23744/1919. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Mackie, Brendan(2013) “One Last Cup of Coffee? The Decline of the London Cof- feehouse,” Master’s Thesis, The University of Chicago. [Referenced on pagesOA-3, OA-62,OA-72] McFadden, Daniel(1978) “Modelling the Choice of Residential Location,” in Anders Karlqvist,LarsLundqvist,FolkeSnickars,andJörgenW.Weibulleds.*SpatialInteraction* *Theory and Planning Models*, 75–96, Amsterdam: North-Holland. [Referenced on page OA-92] Meier, Eugen A.(1973) “Leckerli, Hypokras und Burgermeisterli,” in*Das süsse Basel*, 11–15, Basel: Birkhäuser, 10.1007/978-3-0348-6484-8_3. [Referenced on page OA-61] Meyer, Hans(2011) “Bau- und Architekturgeschichte, Stadtentwicklung in Lübeck. Literatur-Nachweise und Zitate. B.03 Profanbauten Vorstädte: Lachswehr bis Ruh- leben,”https://www.luebeck.de/file/b03.pdf. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Monacensia Literaturarchiv und Bibliothek(2019) “Münchner Kaffeehaustradition,” https://www.literaturportal-bayern.de/themen?id=172&task=lpbtheme.def ault. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Mount, Toni(2021)*The World of Isaac Newton*, Stroud: Amberley Publishing. [Referenced on pageOA-5] Museum of London(2013) “Clay Tobacco Pipe Makers’ Marks from London,” Database of stamped makers’ marks from London excavations, c. 1580–1710, compiled in association with the City of London Archaeological Trust; archived May 2013. [Referenced on pagesOA-56,OA-63] Oxford Dictionary of National Biography(2025) “Oxford Dictionary of National Biography,” https://www.oxforddnb.com/, Online edition, first published 2004. Accessed 12 September 2025. [Referenced on pagesOA-54,OA-62,OA-82]
P. D. B.(1934) “Den Oven te Kortrijk,”*Biekorf*, 40, 46–47, https://www.dbnl.org/tek st/_bie001193401_01/_bie001193401_01_0020.php. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Palmer, Sarah(2007) “Lloyd, Edward (c. 1648–1713),” in*Oxford Dictionary of National* *Biography*, Oxford: Oxford University Press, Online edition, first published 2004. Accessed 12 September, 2025. [Referenced on pageOA-1] Pepys, Samuel(1660–1669) “The Diary of Samuel Pepys, 1660–1669,” https://www.pe pysdiary.com/, Wheatley edition, retrieved via the Pepys Diary API. Accessed 16 July, 2026. [Referenced on pageOA-5]
OA-112
Perry, Laurence(2011) “Les boissons de “salon”: thé, café, chocolat,”*Revue d’Alsace*, 137, 291–305,10.4000/alsace.1262. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Pincus, Steve(1995) ““Coffee Politicians Does Create”: Coffeehouses and Restoration Political Culture,”*The Journal of Modern History*, 67 (4), 807–834. [Referenced on pages OA-2,OA-61] Rambachan, Ashesh and Jonathan Roth(2023) “A More Credible Approach to Parallel Trends,”*The Review of Economic Studies*, 90 (5), 2555–2591. [Referenced on pages OA-26,OA-41] Redding, Stephen J.(2025) “Quantitative Urban Economics,” in*Handbook of Regional and* *Urban Economics*, Vol. 6, Chap. 2, 73–141, Amsterdam: Elsevier. [Referenced on pages OA-88,OA-89,OA-92] Riley, Margaret(2006) “The Club at the Temple Coffee House Revisited,”*Archives of* *Natural History*, 33 (1), 90–100. [Referenced on pageOA-5] Robilliard, Gabrielle(2024) “Novel, Popular, Fashionable and Partisan: Making Coffeehouses ‘Burgherly’ Spaces in Early Modern Hamburg,”*Urban History*, 51 (1), 146–170. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Robinson, Henry W. and Walter Adamseds. (1935)*The Diary of Robert Hooke, M.A.,*
*M.D., F.R.S., 1672–1680*, London: Taylor & Francis. [Referenced on pagesOA-3,OA-5, OA-57,OA-58,OA-63]
Rosée, Pasqua(1652) “The Vertue of the Coffee Drink: First Publiquely Made and Sold in England, by Pasqua Rosée,” Broadside handbill, London. [Referenced on pages OA-1,OA-69] Schofield, John(1984)*The Building of London: From the Conquest to the Great Fire*, London: British Museum Publications. [Referenced on pagesOA-57,OA-63] Shapin, Steven and Simon Schaffer(1985)*Leviathan and the Air-Pump: Hobbes, Boyle,* *and the Experimental Life*, Princeton: Princeton University Press. [Referenced on page OA-5] Smith, S. D.(2001) “The Early Diffusion of Coffee Drinking in England,” in Michel Tuchscherer ed.*Le Commerce du Café avant l’ère des plantations coloniales : Espaces,* *réseaux, sociétés (XVe–XIXe siècle)*, 245–268, Cairo: Institut français d’archéologie orientale. [Referenced on pagesOA-6,OA-73] Smyth, Richard(1849)*The Obituary of Richard Smyth, Secondary of the Poultry Compter,* *London: Being a Catalogue of All Such Persons as He Knew in Their Life: Extending from*
*A.D. 1627 to A.D. 1674*, Vol. 44 of Camden Old Series, Camden Old Series, London: Camden Society, Edited by Henry Ellis. [Referenced on pageOA-77]
Stadsarchief Amsterdam(2019) “Eerste koffiehuis,” https://www.amsterdam.nl/sta dsarchief/stukken/uitgaan/eerste-koffiehuis/. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Stewart, Larry(1999) “Other Centres of Calculation, or, Where the Royal Society Didn’t Count: Commerce, Coffee-Houses and Natural Philosophy in Early Modern London,” *The British Journal for the History of Science*, 32 (2), 133–153. [Referenced on pageOA-2] Story, John(1692) “A catalogue of excellent books English, Latine &c. in divinity, law, physick, mathematicks, history, poetry, romances, travels, navigation, &c. which will be sold by auction at Mr. George Headlam’s Coffee-House on the Sand-Hill, in Newcastle upon Tine on [9] July 1692,” Book-auction catalogue. Wing C1325A; ESTC R173589. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Strype, John(1720)*A Survey of the Cities of London and Westminster: Containing the* *Original, Antiquity, Increase, Modern Estate and Government of Those Cities*, London: Printed for A. Churchill, J. Knapton, R. Knaplock, J. Walthoe, E. Horne, B. Tooke, D.
OA-113
Midwinter, B. Cowse, R. Robinson, and T. Ward, A revised edition of John Stow’s *A Survay of London: Contayning the Originall, Antiquity, Increase, Moderne Estate, and* *Description of That Citie*, first published in 1598. [Referenced on pagesOA-76,OA-78] Taylor, Eva Germaine Rimington(1954)*The Mathematical Practitioners of Tudor and Stuart* *England*, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Referenced on pagesOA-15, OA-16,OA-17,OA-24,OA-37,OA-38,OA-51,OA-52,OA-53,OA-54,OA-55,OA-59, OA-62,OA-66,OA-67,OA-70,OA-73,OA-76,OA-80,OA-81,OA-82,OA-83,OA-87, OA-101] The Royal Society(2024) “The Royal Society Collections Catalogues,” https://catalo gues.royalsociety.org/CalmView, Accessed 21 November, 2024. [Referenced on pagesOA-16,OA-52,OA-62] Train, KennethE.(2009)*DiscreteChoiceMethodswithSimulation*, 2ndedition, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. [Referenced on pageOA-92] Universal Short Title Catalogue [USTC](2026) “Universal Short Title Catalogue,” University of St Andrews, Database of books printed in early modern Europe, https://www.ustc.ac.uk/, accessed 3 August 2026. [Referenced on pagesOA-53, OA-63] Van Aert, Laura(2009) “Buurtwinkels en winkelstraten. De evolutie van het Antwerpse winkelbedrijf in de nieuwe tijd,”*Stadsgeschiedenis*, 4 (1), 21–44. [Referenced on page OA-61] Van Damme, Stéphane(2005)*Paris, capitale philosophique: de la Fronde à la Révolution*, Paris: Odile Jacob. [Referenced on pageOA-61] van Oostrum, Pim(2006) “Trammelant rond de theestoof: over de sekse van thee (en koffie),”*Mededelingen van de Stichting Jacob Campo Weyerman*, 29, 49–66. [Referenced on pageOA-61] Wallis, Patrick and Cliff Webb(2000)*Apothecaries’ Company, 1617–1669*, Vol. 32 of London Livery Company Apprenticeship Registers, London Livery Company ApprenticeshipRegisters,London: SocietyofGenealogists,DepositedatLSEResearch Online, eprint 6778. [Referenced on pagesOA-56,OA-63] Warren, Christopher N., Daniel Shore, Jessica Otis, Lawrence Wang, Mike Finegold, and Cosma Shalizi(2016) “Six Degrees of Francis Bacon: A Statistical Method for Reconstructing Large Historical Social Networks,”*DHQ: Digital Humanities Quarterly*, 10 (3). [Referenced on pagesOA-16,OA-51,OA-53,OA-54,OA-62,OA-101] Webster, Roderick S. and Marjorie K. Webster(2007) “Webster Signature Database,” Adler Planetarium and Astronomy Museum, Chicago, Database of makers who signed scientific instruments held in collections worldwide. Archived at https: //web.archive.org/web/20260513013557/https://historydb.adlerplanetari um.org/signatures/about.html, accessed 30 August, 2026. [Referenced on pages OA-54,OA-63,OA-104] Wikipedia(2024) “List of English Renaissance Theatres,” Used as the starting venue list, extended with venue-level dates and coordinates. [Referenced on pagesOA-56, OA-63] Williams, James(1936)*The London Coffee-Houses and Their Literary Associations, Down to* *the Death of Anne*, M.Litt. dissertation, University of Oxford, Bodleian Libraries, MS.
M.Litt. d.276. [Referenced on pageOA-69]
Withington, Phil(2020) “Where Was the Coffee in Early Modern England?,”*The Journal* *of Modern History*, 92 (1), 40–75. [Referenced on pagesOA-59,OA-61]
OA-114
Wrigley, E. A.(2010) “The PST System of Classifying Occupations,” Unpublished. [Referenced on pageOA-84]
OA-115